J.H. den Besten
Please Note
26 records found
1
Design for Production
A Decision-Support Framework for Early-Stage Cost Reduction in One-Off Steel Superyacht Hull Structures
To address the research objectives, a mixed-methods research approach was adopted, consisting of a qualitative phase and a quantitative phase. The qualitative phase focused on the evaluation, elimination, and prioritisation of DfP guidelines identified in the literature. This was achieved through an expertbased multi-criteria analysis, in which guidelines were assessed with respect to their importance, applicability, and expected cost reduction (IAR). This step enabled a context-specific filtering of broadly formulated DfP knowledge, reducing fragmentation and focusing the analysis on guidelines considered most relevant for one-off superyacht hull construction.
Production cost reduction was found to be primarily governed by a limited number of dominant production-oriented KPIs, of which part count emerged as the most influential due to its direct effect on welding effort, assembly time, and with that labour intensity, and production lead time. Coordinated increases in plate thickness and stiffener spacing reduced part count and resulted in panel-level production cost reductions of up to 23%, which translate to estimated overall production cost reductions of approximately 10–15% for hull stiffening. These reductions were achieved without compromising structural integrity or quality, confirming that the primary value of Design for Production lies in supporting informed early-stage design decision-making rather than identifying a single optimal solution. ...
To address the research objectives, a mixed-methods research approach was adopted, consisting of a qualitative phase and a quantitative phase. The qualitative phase focused on the evaluation, elimination, and prioritisation of DfP guidelines identified in the literature. This was achieved through an expertbased multi-criteria analysis, in which guidelines were assessed with respect to their importance, applicability, and expected cost reduction (IAR). This step enabled a context-specific filtering of broadly formulated DfP knowledge, reducing fragmentation and focusing the analysis on guidelines considered most relevant for one-off superyacht hull construction.
Production cost reduction was found to be primarily governed by a limited number of dominant production-oriented KPIs, of which part count emerged as the most influential due to its direct effect on welding effort, assembly time, and with that labour intensity, and production lead time. Coordinated increases in plate thickness and stiffener spacing reduced part count and resulted in panel-level production cost reductions of up to 23%, which translate to estimated overall production cost reductions of approximately 10–15% for hull stiffening. These reductions were achieved without compromising structural integrity or quality, confirming that the primary value of Design for Production lies in supporting informed early-stage design decision-making rather than identifying a single optimal solution.
Real-Time Stress State Estimation for Steel Bridges
A Proof-of-Concept Approach to Stress State Estimation of Steel Bridges using FBG Sensor Data and Image Recognition
Experiments were conducted on multiple specimens under different loading conditions, and both time-domain and frequency-domain AE parameters were analyzed. The study found that parameters like energy rate and rise angle were particularly effective in detecting specific stages of fatigue crack growth, while count rate and amplitude provided consistent indicators of crack initiation and progression. However, the study also highlighted limitations in the use of filtering techniques, such as SNR and amplitude filters, which can inadvertently remove crucial AE signals.
The findings suggest that while AE methods have potential for accurately monitoring fatigue crack growth, their effectiveness is influenced by the choice of AE parameters and the management of noise. To improve accuracy, the study recommends further research that includes a broader range of specimens, explores additional AE parameters, integrates complementary techniques such as Digital Image Correlation (DIC), and applies advanced analytical methods like machine learning. Future research should also consider the impact of environmental factors, such as corrosion fatigue, particularly in marine environments where realistic AE data is critical.
Overall, this study contributes to the broader understanding of AE monitoring for fatigue damage, laying a foundation for future research and practical applications, while acknowledging the need for further refinement and validation of AE techniques across diverse materials and conditions. ...
Experiments were conducted on multiple specimens under different loading conditions, and both time-domain and frequency-domain AE parameters were analyzed. The study found that parameters like energy rate and rise angle were particularly effective in detecting specific stages of fatigue crack growth, while count rate and amplitude provided consistent indicators of crack initiation and progression. However, the study also highlighted limitations in the use of filtering techniques, such as SNR and amplitude filters, which can inadvertently remove crucial AE signals.
The findings suggest that while AE methods have potential for accurately monitoring fatigue crack growth, their effectiveness is influenced by the choice of AE parameters and the management of noise. To improve accuracy, the study recommends further research that includes a broader range of specimens, explores additional AE parameters, integrates complementary techniques such as Digital Image Correlation (DIC), and applies advanced analytical methods like machine learning. Future research should also consider the impact of environmental factors, such as corrosion fatigue, particularly in marine environments where realistic AE data is critical.
Overall, this study contributes to the broader understanding of AE monitoring for fatigue damage, laying a foundation for future research and practical applications, while acknowledging the need for further refinement and validation of AE techniques across diverse materials and conditions.
Electron beam welding for the C1 Wedge Connection
Study into the feasibility of electron beam welding of thick structural steel sections
The UF is currently manufactured using submerged arc welding to join its three components: the crown (CR), inner web (IW), and outer web (OW). This research investigates the feasibility of electron beam welding (EBW) as an alternative technique. EBW offers increased production speed by utilizing higher power density, allowing the weld to be made in a single pass. However, its full-scale (long-term) performance is unproven. This study explores its feasibility through small-scale experimental tests. The thesis also examines an alternative weld location in the C1-WC UF, comparing the current and alternative weld positions in terms of fatigue and ultimate limit state (ULS) by using finite element analyses.
The main research question is:
To what extent is the welding technique 'Electron Beam Welding' feasible for application in the C1 Wedge Connection™ upper flange manufacturing?
Numerical analyses offer insights into fatigue performance and the use of increased strength in the net cross-section. Although the alternative design, with the weld located in the gross cross-section, demonstrates acceptable fatigue performance under preloaded conditions, it does not outperform the base-case design in service life. Moreover, the increase in net cross-sectional yield strength of the alternative design remains unutilized in the ULS. This suggests that the UF geometry could be designed more efficiently: by reducing the thickness of the inner and outer webs with 19%, an UF mass reduction of 13%, 3.3 tonnes of steel, is achieved.
Experimental tests presented challenges, particularly regarding the precision required for EBW. A slight misalignment in the weld led to incomplete fusion at the weld’s root. Hardness testing revealed a significant increase in hardness in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and fusion zone (FZ). Charpy impact tests failed to meet the minimum requirement of 31 Joules at -40°C, while tensile tests showed that failure occurred outside the weld. This raised concerns about the weld’s ductility.
Overall, EBW is not yet a feasible option for full-scale production of the C1-WC, mainly due to the needed stringent tolerance requirements and thereby in achieving a consistent welds along the full OWT circumference. Submerged arc welding remains the most reliable method for assembling the UF. Future research should focus on improving EBW’s robustness and reliability, particularly in understanding its fatigue performance and how to account for geometric imperfections.
...
The UF is currently manufactured using submerged arc welding to join its three components: the crown (CR), inner web (IW), and outer web (OW). This research investigates the feasibility of electron beam welding (EBW) as an alternative technique. EBW offers increased production speed by utilizing higher power density, allowing the weld to be made in a single pass. However, its full-scale (long-term) performance is unproven. This study explores its feasibility through small-scale experimental tests. The thesis also examines an alternative weld location in the C1-WC UF, comparing the current and alternative weld positions in terms of fatigue and ultimate limit state (ULS) by using finite element analyses.
The main research question is:
To what extent is the welding technique 'Electron Beam Welding' feasible for application in the C1 Wedge Connection™ upper flange manufacturing?
Numerical analyses offer insights into fatigue performance and the use of increased strength in the net cross-section. Although the alternative design, with the weld located in the gross cross-section, demonstrates acceptable fatigue performance under preloaded conditions, it does not outperform the base-case design in service life. Moreover, the increase in net cross-sectional yield strength of the alternative design remains unutilized in the ULS. This suggests that the UF geometry could be designed more efficiently: by reducing the thickness of the inner and outer webs with 19%, an UF mass reduction of 13%, 3.3 tonnes of steel, is achieved.
Experimental tests presented challenges, particularly regarding the precision required for EBW. A slight misalignment in the weld led to incomplete fusion at the weld’s root. Hardness testing revealed a significant increase in hardness in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and fusion zone (FZ). Charpy impact tests failed to meet the minimum requirement of 31 Joules at -40°C, while tensile tests showed that failure occurred outside the weld. This raised concerns about the weld’s ductility.
Overall, EBW is not yet a feasible option for full-scale production of the C1-WC, mainly due to the needed stringent tolerance requirements and thereby in achieving a consistent welds along the full OWT circumference. Submerged arc welding remains the most reliable method for assembling the UF. Future research should focus on improving EBW’s robustness and reliability, particularly in understanding its fatigue performance and how to account for geometric imperfections.
production of larger vessels of complex geometries. These vessels are subjected to unique
loading conditions that have not been investigated extensively. Such a case is presented
in wet deck slamming of large catamaran vessels. These vessels have been designed and
produced to conduct offshore platform installation operations and are expected to operate
in severe conditions where wet deck submergence becomes a threat.
Wet deck slamming is a water entry impact phenomenon that can induce extreme loads
when a part of the floating structure pierces the water surface during severe waves. This
event can trigger a transient dynamic response at both local and global levels. The event has
multiple influencing factors that can contribute to the severity and probability of occurrence.
Although the examination of slamming started over a century ago, the criteria concerning
the incident definition, identification and prediction are applied from different perspectives.
Modern methods identify slamming events based on the structural responses, while the sta-
tistical analysis considers correlation between the events, as opposed to older approaches
treating the incidents as independent.
Progress in understanding slamming is achieved through full-scale measurements, exper-
imental tests, and numerical simulations. Each method presents unique advantages and
drawbacks,and all three are used for knowledge development but also verification and vali-
dation. As numerical capabilities increase, it is also important for the experimental method
to evolve and explore new ways of representation of the complex events.
This project aims to investigate wet deck slamming using a rarely used form of model
that could closely mimic real life responses. This research can enhance the experimental
method capabilities and serve as stepping stone for further evolution of similar research.
The experimental test runs for the needs of the project were conducted in the Ship and
Hydromechanics laboratory facilities of TU Delft. ...
production of larger vessels of complex geometries. These vessels are subjected to unique
loading conditions that have not been investigated extensively. Such a case is presented
in wet deck slamming of large catamaran vessels. These vessels have been designed and
produced to conduct offshore platform installation operations and are expected to operate
in severe conditions where wet deck submergence becomes a threat.
Wet deck slamming is a water entry impact phenomenon that can induce extreme loads
when a part of the floating structure pierces the water surface during severe waves. This
event can trigger a transient dynamic response at both local and global levels. The event has
multiple influencing factors that can contribute to the severity and probability of occurrence.
Although the examination of slamming started over a century ago, the criteria concerning
the incident definition, identification and prediction are applied from different perspectives.
Modern methods identify slamming events based on the structural responses, while the sta-
tistical analysis considers correlation between the events, as opposed to older approaches
treating the incidents as independent.
Progress in understanding slamming is achieved through full-scale measurements, exper-
imental tests, and numerical simulations. Each method presents unique advantages and
drawbacks,and all three are used for knowledge development but also verification and vali-
dation. As numerical capabilities increase, it is also important for the experimental method
to evolve and explore new ways of representation of the complex events.
This project aims to investigate wet deck slamming using a rarely used form of model
that could closely mimic real life responses. This research can enhance the experimental
method capabilities and serve as stepping stone for further evolution of similar research.
The experimental test runs for the needs of the project were conducted in the Ship and
Hydromechanics laboratory facilities of TU Delft.
In this thesis, the feasibility of a digital twin (DT) concept is tested to make lifetime predictions of a highly-loaded low-speed roller bearing. The developed DT uses a combination of the Paris model and an AE-based model presenting the current state of the bearing. In the remaining useful life (RUL) prediction, the final crack size and total number of load cycles are determined based on an integrated form of the Paris model. Three different forms were tested for the RUL prediction.
The Paris model and the AE-based model showed good agreement in a benchmark case, based on which the two models were combined. The AE-based prediction was tested for hits and counts, with the counts yielding into better results due to a better fitting of the model constants. The linear RUL based on the number of load cycles resulted in the best prediction. The developed DT showed good potential in making lifetime predictions of highly-loaded low-speed roller bearings and enrichment of future DTs with prognostic information.
...
In this thesis, the feasibility of a digital twin (DT) concept is tested to make lifetime predictions of a highly-loaded low-speed roller bearing. The developed DT uses a combination of the Paris model and an AE-based model presenting the current state of the bearing. In the remaining useful life (RUL) prediction, the final crack size and total number of load cycles are determined based on an integrated form of the Paris model. Three different forms were tested for the RUL prediction.
The Paris model and the AE-based model showed good agreement in a benchmark case, based on which the two models were combined. The AE-based prediction was tested for hits and counts, with the counts yielding into better results due to a better fitting of the model constants. The linear RUL based on the number of load cycles resulted in the best prediction. The developed DT showed good potential in making lifetime predictions of highly-loaded low-speed roller bearings and enrichment of future DTs with prognostic information.
Fatigue Assessment of Complex Riveted Connections
A study on old steel bridges using Advanced Finite Element Analysis
While fatigue phenomena have been extensively investigated throughout the years, studies pertaining to the fatigue of riveted connections are relatively limited. The Eurocode on fatigue, EN-1993-1-9 includes only two detail categories. Additional guidelines, like RBK Steel expand upon these detail categories, but focus primarily on built-up beam cross-sections in riveted structures, rather than riveted connections. In order to attempt to more accurately assess the complex joints present in ancient steel bridges, this thesis attempts to answer the following question: What would be a suitable approach to model complex riveted joints and assess their fatigue life considering a balance between the level of complexity and applicability in design practice?
A literature study is performed to identify the different factors that affect the fatigue resistance of riveted connections, as well as to highlight several of the available methods to perform a fatigue assessment. Through the investigation of experimental studies complemented with Finite Element (FE) Analyses, a design methodology for a full scale riveted model is drawn up, and finally a FE model of a joint of the John S. Thompsonbridge is constructed. A critical location within the joint is identified. On this critical locations, several stress- and strain-based fatigue life analyses are performed, namely the use of Stress Concentration Factors (SCF), Smith-Watson-Topper’s (SWT) strain-life equation, and the multiaxial shear strain criterion (MSSC) method, to investigate the effects of incorporating mean stress effects and multiaxiality.
From these analyses, it is concluded that SCF appears to provide overly conservative fatigue life estimates, whereas SWT and MSSC provide more probable results. The increased life estimate through MSSC suggests a limited degree of multiaxiality present in the critical location. All three methods require a detailed FE model, complicating the fatigue assessment of the joint. While the SCF method is slightly simpler to use than SWT and MSSC, it does not weigh up to the conservativity of its life estimation. SWT is deemed the most suitable approach for the fatigue assessment of riveted joints, given that it is more widely applicable and relevant than MSSC. ...
While fatigue phenomena have been extensively investigated throughout the years, studies pertaining to the fatigue of riveted connections are relatively limited. The Eurocode on fatigue, EN-1993-1-9 includes only two detail categories. Additional guidelines, like RBK Steel expand upon these detail categories, but focus primarily on built-up beam cross-sections in riveted structures, rather than riveted connections. In order to attempt to more accurately assess the complex joints present in ancient steel bridges, this thesis attempts to answer the following question: What would be a suitable approach to model complex riveted joints and assess their fatigue life considering a balance between the level of complexity and applicability in design practice?
A literature study is performed to identify the different factors that affect the fatigue resistance of riveted connections, as well as to highlight several of the available methods to perform a fatigue assessment. Through the investigation of experimental studies complemented with Finite Element (FE) Analyses, a design methodology for a full scale riveted model is drawn up, and finally a FE model of a joint of the John S. Thompsonbridge is constructed. A critical location within the joint is identified. On this critical locations, several stress- and strain-based fatigue life analyses are performed, namely the use of Stress Concentration Factors (SCF), Smith-Watson-Topper’s (SWT) strain-life equation, and the multiaxial shear strain criterion (MSSC) method, to investigate the effects of incorporating mean stress effects and multiaxiality.
From these analyses, it is concluded that SCF appears to provide overly conservative fatigue life estimates, whereas SWT and MSSC provide more probable results. The increased life estimate through MSSC suggests a limited degree of multiaxiality present in the critical location. All three methods require a detailed FE model, complicating the fatigue assessment of the joint. While the SCF method is slightly simpler to use than SWT and MSSC, it does not weigh up to the conservativity of its life estimation. SWT is deemed the most suitable approach for the fatigue assessment of riveted joints, given that it is more widely applicable and relevant than MSSC.
crucial to determine how the composite blade will respond to a wide variety of environmental and loading conditions that it will experience over its life. Basically one needs to determine what effects fatigue will have on the material properties of the blade. The main objective of this thesis is to estimate the fatigue lifetime of composite marine propellers subjected to a pressure distribution determined by a Fluid-Structure Interaction
(FSI)model with the use of a progressive damage model integrated into a Finite
Element Model (FEM). The fluid structure interaction model to determine the pressure distribution has already been created Maljaars (2019). Currently the mostly used and most reliable approach is to use an experimental approach in order to estimate the fatigue life. However, for custom designs such as marine propellers this is a long and costly process. Modelling fatigue the fatigue performance in an earlier stage of the design cycle will result in significant cost and time savings.
The expected fatigue lifetime of the composite marine propeller is concluded to be at least 1012 cycles under the considered loading condition. If the propeller would rotate at 600 rpm for 24 hours per day this would translate to over 3000 years. The reason behind this large number is that the combination of the applied pressure load and the strength of the carbon fiber propeller is such that the stresses in each ply are very low. These low stresses create almost no damage throughout the propeller blade even for ultra high cycles. ...
crucial to determine how the composite blade will respond to a wide variety of environmental and loading conditions that it will experience over its life. Basically one needs to determine what effects fatigue will have on the material properties of the blade. The main objective of this thesis is to estimate the fatigue lifetime of composite marine propellers subjected to a pressure distribution determined by a Fluid-Structure Interaction
(FSI)model with the use of a progressive damage model integrated into a Finite
Element Model (FEM). The fluid structure interaction model to determine the pressure distribution has already been created Maljaars (2019). Currently the mostly used and most reliable approach is to use an experimental approach in order to estimate the fatigue life. However, for custom designs such as marine propellers this is a long and costly process. Modelling fatigue the fatigue performance in an earlier stage of the design cycle will result in significant cost and time savings.
The expected fatigue lifetime of the composite marine propeller is concluded to be at least 1012 cycles under the considered loading condition. If the propeller would rotate at 600 rpm for 24 hours per day this would translate to over 3000 years. The reason behind this large number is that the combination of the applied pressure load and the strength of the carbon fiber propeller is such that the stresses in each ply are very low. These low stresses create almost no damage throughout the propeller blade even for ultra high cycles.
Fatigue design investigation of the main- to cross-girder connection in steel railway bridges
A study on the beam railway bridges of the Oostertoegang in Amsterdam
The main- to cross-girder connection can be designed for fatigue using different design principles. Designing the connection with a certain rotational stiffness leads to higher fatigue stresses at this location. Meeting the fatigue requirements at the connection can often be achieved by local adjustments, such as welding extra steel plates to the fatigue-induced location to evenly distribute stresses from the cross-girder to the main girder. This can be a costly solution. Designing a connection that is flexible could reduce stresses at the main- to cross-girder connection. Solving fatigue issues can be done by making global adaptations to the structure. The question arises: which aspects can be adjusted such that slight changes can notably improve fatigue resistance in a cost-effective manner?
A literature study and a finite element investigation of the main- to cross-girder connection are performed. A reference model is made after which parameters are altered to investigate their impact on the fatigue response of the connection. The reference model is based on the design of the bridges from project Oostertoegang. However, instead of considering a connection with a certain rotational stiffness, the design is made more flexible for this study. Ansys 2022 R2 is used to create a finite element model of the bridge with shell elements. The hot spot stress method is used to conduct the fatigue assessment. In total four critical fatigue locations are researched for six parameters. The parameters researched are: the center-to-center distance between the cross-girders, the height of the cross-girder and main girder, the thickness of the inner web plate of the main girder, the diaphragm, and the steel deck plate.
From the analysis, it can be concluded that for one detail (M3) local measures should be applied to meet fatigue criteria. The three other details can satisfy requirements within feasible limits. The most cost-effective and realistic way is to increase the thickness of the inner web of the main girder. Other cost-effective but less feasible solutions to optimize the flexible design for fatigue are: decreasing the thickness of the diaphragm and increasing the height of the cross-girder. These parameters show the best ratio between the costs needed to alter the parameter and the total fatigue damage change of the critical detail.
Furthermore, it is determined that the fatigue assessment using finite element analysis with shell elements can be optimized by using the hot spot stress method in combination with modeling the weld using an increased thickness.
...
The main- to cross-girder connection can be designed for fatigue using different design principles. Designing the connection with a certain rotational stiffness leads to higher fatigue stresses at this location. Meeting the fatigue requirements at the connection can often be achieved by local adjustments, such as welding extra steel plates to the fatigue-induced location to evenly distribute stresses from the cross-girder to the main girder. This can be a costly solution. Designing a connection that is flexible could reduce stresses at the main- to cross-girder connection. Solving fatigue issues can be done by making global adaptations to the structure. The question arises: which aspects can be adjusted such that slight changes can notably improve fatigue resistance in a cost-effective manner?
A literature study and a finite element investigation of the main- to cross-girder connection are performed. A reference model is made after which parameters are altered to investigate their impact on the fatigue response of the connection. The reference model is based on the design of the bridges from project Oostertoegang. However, instead of considering a connection with a certain rotational stiffness, the design is made more flexible for this study. Ansys 2022 R2 is used to create a finite element model of the bridge with shell elements. The hot spot stress method is used to conduct the fatigue assessment. In total four critical fatigue locations are researched for six parameters. The parameters researched are: the center-to-center distance between the cross-girders, the height of the cross-girder and main girder, the thickness of the inner web plate of the main girder, the diaphragm, and the steel deck plate.
From the analysis, it can be concluded that for one detail (M3) local measures should be applied to meet fatigue criteria. The three other details can satisfy requirements within feasible limits. The most cost-effective and realistic way is to increase the thickness of the inner web of the main girder. Other cost-effective but less feasible solutions to optimize the flexible design for fatigue are: decreasing the thickness of the diaphragm and increasing the height of the cross-girder. These parameters show the best ratio between the costs needed to alter the parameter and the total fatigue damage change of the critical detail.
Furthermore, it is determined that the fatigue assessment using finite element analysis with shell elements can be optimized by using the hot spot stress method in combination with modeling the weld using an increased thickness.
Experiments are still a vital part of these investigations, for validating ever-improving numerical techniques. An essential issue with experiments is the extent to which mode shapes and natural frequencies can be emulated in model scale. Traditional hydroelastic models are segmented and use either a flexible backbone or flexible joints to introduce stiffness. This often results in an excellent description of the 2-node bending mode, but an increasing error for higher modes leads to stress inaccuracies. In this investigation, a fully elastic model of a catamaran is designed and produced for hydroelastic experiments. The advantages and limitations of the concept are identified, and the verification against structural models is presented. ...
Experiments are still a vital part of these investigations, for validating ever-improving numerical techniques. An essential issue with experiments is the extent to which mode shapes and natural frequencies can be emulated in model scale. Traditional hydroelastic models are segmented and use either a flexible backbone or flexible joints to introduce stiffness. This often results in an excellent description of the 2-node bending mode, but an increasing error for higher modes leads to stress inaccuracies. In this investigation, a fully elastic model of a catamaran is designed and produced for hydroelastic experiments. The advantages and limitations of the concept are identified, and the verification against structural models is presented.
and distortions with experimental data from three specimens consisting of a 900x400mm deck plate, a 350mm deep trapezoidal stiffener and a 600x15mm crossbeam web with a Haibach cope hole. During the welding, temperatures were recorded by a FLIR© E96 thermal camera. Welding distortions were obtained by subtracting the geometry before welding from the geometry after welding. The 3D
geometry was obtained by the Artec© LEO scanner. The scans were post processed in Artec© studio software and data was extracted by the NumPy-stl package in Python. The predicted temperature distribution and deformations corresponded well to experimental results. The maximum deviation in the
temperature distribution 1.8s after welding was 67 °C and occurred at the last position of the welding torch. The maximum deviation between predicted and measured upward displacements of the deck plate 10mm from the edge was 0.2mm, with smaller deviations on average. Due to the good correspondence
of experimental and numerical results, residual stresses were presented. On the deck plate in longitudinal direction, tensile stresses of yield strength magnitude were obtained after unclamping. At the rib-to-crossbeam connection, the stress in the direction perpendicular to the weld toe at the location of the weld toe was equal to the yield strength after unclamping. The stresses quasi-linearly go to zero through the thickness of the rib. ...
and distortions with experimental data from three specimens consisting of a 900x400mm deck plate, a 350mm deep trapezoidal stiffener and a 600x15mm crossbeam web with a Haibach cope hole. During the welding, temperatures were recorded by a FLIR© E96 thermal camera. Welding distortions were obtained by subtracting the geometry before welding from the geometry after welding. The 3D
geometry was obtained by the Artec© LEO scanner. The scans were post processed in Artec© studio software and data was extracted by the NumPy-stl package in Python. The predicted temperature distribution and deformations corresponded well to experimental results. The maximum deviation in the
temperature distribution 1.8s after welding was 67 °C and occurred at the last position of the welding torch. The maximum deviation between predicted and measured upward displacements of the deck plate 10mm from the edge was 0.2mm, with smaller deviations on average. Due to the good correspondence
of experimental and numerical results, residual stresses were presented. On the deck plate in longitudinal direction, tensile stresses of yield strength magnitude were obtained after unclamping. At the rib-to-crossbeam connection, the stress in the direction perpendicular to the weld toe at the location of the weld toe was equal to the yield strength after unclamping. The stresses quasi-linearly go to zero through the thickness of the rib.
This research focuses on the feasibility of condition-based maintenance of bolts using ultrasonic waves. An energy attenuation method has been implemented for this feasibility research. The main objective is to establish a proper methodology and hypotheses for preload detection. Furthermore, along with preload detection, the feasibility of crack detection was investigated. Finally, the proposed methodology and hypotheses were validated by performing experiments and numerical simulations.
The experimental and numerical results verify the proposed methodology by showing an increasing trend in the energy and the power of the transmitted ultrasonic wave for increasing preload. Also, the feasibility of crack detection using the same setup has been positively evaluated.
The obtained results suggest that the ultrasonic waves can be employed to monitor bolts for condition-based maintenance. Additionally, a number of relevant research activities are recommended based on this study. ...
This research focuses on the feasibility of condition-based maintenance of bolts using ultrasonic waves. An energy attenuation method has been implemented for this feasibility research. The main objective is to establish a proper methodology and hypotheses for preload detection. Furthermore, along with preload detection, the feasibility of crack detection was investigated. Finally, the proposed methodology and hypotheses were validated by performing experiments and numerical simulations.
The experimental and numerical results verify the proposed methodology by showing an increasing trend in the energy and the power of the transmitted ultrasonic wave for increasing preload. Also, the feasibility of crack detection using the same setup has been positively evaluated.
The obtained results suggest that the ultrasonic waves can be employed to monitor bolts for condition-based maintenance. Additionally, a number of relevant research activities are recommended based on this study.
Semi-submersible structural design
Strength and fatigue assessment of a twin-pontoon semi-submersible with different bracing configurations
Fatigue of semi-submersibles remains a challenge in today’s practice, since service cracks are frequently found during inspections. Fatigue resistance is usually determined by S-N curves based on tested small-scale specimens (SSS). Large-scale specimen (LSS) and full-scale specimen (FSS) fatigue tests are performed less frequent. Semi-submersible tubular brace-column and brace brace fatigue resistance is typically determined by LSS tubular joint tests. The fatigue resistance similarity between SSS planar joints and LSS tubular joints was examined by the hot spot stress and averaged effective notch stress concepts. Five different LSS tubular joint fatigue tests, derived from literature, were studied by shell FEA and volume FEA. Weld geometry in tubular joint shell FEA can affect results significantly. When not present, bending stresses are overestimated up to 208%. For most LSS tubular joints, similarity with respect to SSS planar joints is increased for the average effective notch stress concept, compared to the hot spot stress concept. Most LSS tubular joints fit inside the average effective notch
stress SSS planar joint fatigue resistance data. Dissimilarity for divergent LSS tubular joints can be related to different modelling assumptions compared to actual conditions, where differences in boundary conditions and weld geometries is most likely. Fatigue resistance similarity, expressed as the strength scatter index and intercept log10(𝐶), of LSS tubular joints is increased compared to hot spot fatigue resistance. Differences in slope 𝑚 are similar. A SSS planar joint based design S-N curve is therefore applicable for tubular fatigue sensitive locations of semi-submersibles and other structures. Moreover, this study increases the applicability of the average effective notch stress as fatigue assessment concept. More LSS tubular joints should be studied to demonstrate similarity with higher confidence.
To accurately estimate fatigue lifetime, a detailed fatigue assessment is performed of a tubular brace-brace connection. Multi-axial loading was studied at global and local level, however at the critical saddle location, mode-I stress dominates. Therefore, multi-axial fatigue was not considered. The structural stress,𝑆𝑠, average effective notch stress,𝑆𝑒, and hot spot stress,𝑆ℎ, were applied as fatigue assessment concepts. The fatigue assessment of the simple tubular joint concluded insufficient fatigue lifetime. Stress intensities at the critical saddle location were reduced by implementing internal ring-stiffeners, classifying the connection as a complex tubular joint. Stress reduction factors of 3.9 and 4.1 were achieved, resulting in fatigue damages below 1, thus acceptable. Compared to common fatigue assessment concepts, the detailed 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒 fatigue assessments reduce the possibility of service cracks and maintenance and inspection work can be planned more precise. However, DNV-GL and IIW guidelines state a fatigue resistance slope change is present above 107 cycles (N), which is not accounted for in 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒. To study the presence of a slope change and to possibly establish a more accurate fatigue damage estimation for 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒. a recommendation for further research is to include
more fatigue tests for 𝑁 > 107, from which a design S-N curve can be derived. ...
Fatigue of semi-submersibles remains a challenge in today’s practice, since service cracks are frequently found during inspections. Fatigue resistance is usually determined by S-N curves based on tested small-scale specimens (SSS). Large-scale specimen (LSS) and full-scale specimen (FSS) fatigue tests are performed less frequent. Semi-submersible tubular brace-column and brace brace fatigue resistance is typically determined by LSS tubular joint tests. The fatigue resistance similarity between SSS planar joints and LSS tubular joints was examined by the hot spot stress and averaged effective notch stress concepts. Five different LSS tubular joint fatigue tests, derived from literature, were studied by shell FEA and volume FEA. Weld geometry in tubular joint shell FEA can affect results significantly. When not present, bending stresses are overestimated up to 208%. For most LSS tubular joints, similarity with respect to SSS planar joints is increased for the average effective notch stress concept, compared to the hot spot stress concept. Most LSS tubular joints fit inside the average effective notch
stress SSS planar joint fatigue resistance data. Dissimilarity for divergent LSS tubular joints can be related to different modelling assumptions compared to actual conditions, where differences in boundary conditions and weld geometries is most likely. Fatigue resistance similarity, expressed as the strength scatter index and intercept log10(𝐶), of LSS tubular joints is increased compared to hot spot fatigue resistance. Differences in slope 𝑚 are similar. A SSS planar joint based design S-N curve is therefore applicable for tubular fatigue sensitive locations of semi-submersibles and other structures. Moreover, this study increases the applicability of the average effective notch stress as fatigue assessment concept. More LSS tubular joints should be studied to demonstrate similarity with higher confidence.
To accurately estimate fatigue lifetime, a detailed fatigue assessment is performed of a tubular brace-brace connection. Multi-axial loading was studied at global and local level, however at the critical saddle location, mode-I stress dominates. Therefore, multi-axial fatigue was not considered. The structural stress,𝑆𝑠, average effective notch stress,𝑆𝑒, and hot spot stress,𝑆ℎ, were applied as fatigue assessment concepts. The fatigue assessment of the simple tubular joint concluded insufficient fatigue lifetime. Stress intensities at the critical saddle location were reduced by implementing internal ring-stiffeners, classifying the connection as a complex tubular joint. Stress reduction factors of 3.9 and 4.1 were achieved, resulting in fatigue damages below 1, thus acceptable. Compared to common fatigue assessment concepts, the detailed 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒 fatigue assessments reduce the possibility of service cracks and maintenance and inspection work can be planned more precise. However, DNV-GL and IIW guidelines state a fatigue resistance slope change is present above 107 cycles (N), which is not accounted for in 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒. To study the presence of a slope change and to possibly establish a more accurate fatigue damage estimation for 𝑆𝑠 and 𝑆𝑒. a recommendation for further research is to include
more fatigue tests for 𝑁 > 107, from which a design S-N curve can be derived.
Preventing Injuries of High Speed Marine Craft Operators
Incorporating Spinal Injury Models in the Analyses of Various Seat Suspension Principles
FEM is extensively used for analysing OSDs. In engineering applications, 2D shell elements are widely used instead of 3D solid elements for analysis due to less computational cost. The welds are generally not modelled with shell elements for fatigue assessment of welded structures. In this study, large difference of SHSS is obtained by shell and solid elements for both simple and complex fillet welded details and also for the OSD. This difference in structural hot-spot stress (SHSS) is reduced by the application of three weld modelling techniques with shell elements: (i) the IIW approach, (ii) the Eriksson’s approach and (iii) a combination of IIW and Eriksson’s approaches. All the three methods are based on increasing the thickness of shell elements at the weld region which are easy to be applied in practice. The dependence of SHSS on mesh size and element type is also investigated in this thesis.
A parametric study is performed first on simple and then on complex fillet welded details to check whether the weld modelling technique can be applied to different geometries, loading and boundary conditions. The solid element model of the complex detail is first validated with experimental strain measurements. Then, SHSS values from other numerical models are compared with the solid model. Representative load cases are investigated initially followed by load combinations. The weld modelling method with shell elements gives good consistency in the ratio of hot-spot stress compared to the solid element model for these details. The deformations are also investigated for all load cases and load combinations. The combined weld modelling technique (iii) with shell elements replicated the weld stiffness of the solid model for both in-plane and out-of-plane load cases.
As a final step in checking the consistency of SHSS ratios between shell elements with welds and solid elements in the application of OSD, a parametric investigation is performed. This study involved two geometric variants of OSD with different load positions. These two variants were based on the design of existing bridges in The Netherlands with relatively thin plate and newly designed ones with thicker plates. The parametric study is divided into two parts. The first part is based on representative load cases. The second part is based on SHSS influence lines for determination of critical loading positions having maximum and minimum hot-spot stress. For both these studies, the weld modelling approaches with shell elements gave a good match of SHSS compared to the solid models. The SHSS results from the shell model with weld are more consistent compared to the regular shell model without weld. From the preliminary parametric study on OSD, it is found that after weld modelling with shell elements using the combined approach of IIW and Eriksson, less scatter is observed in the SHSS ratios. The coefficient of variation (CV) in SHSS ratio for crossbeam is 6.8% and that for stiffener is around 5.1% which is low. The SHSS values are computed based on the stress perpendicular to weld toe. From the detailed parametric study, the mean value of SHSS ratio is 1.07 (range: 0.99-1.15) for the crossbeam and 1.02 (range: 0.98-1.10) for the stiffener. The CV of SHSS ratio is 5.4% for the crossbeam and 4% for the stiffener. The stress profiles are also investigated at the critical locations of OSD. The shell model with the combined weld modelling approach is in good agreement with not only SHSS but also with the stress at a distance far away from the stress concentration when compared to the solid model. The deformations are also very similar for both the numerical models. Thus, it is concluded that the combined weld modelling technique using the IIW and the Eriksson’s approach with shell elements could be used for accurate fatigue life assessment using hot-spot stress method where the measure of accuracy is with respect to the solid element model. ...
FEM is extensively used for analysing OSDs. In engineering applications, 2D shell elements are widely used instead of 3D solid elements for analysis due to less computational cost. The welds are generally not modelled with shell elements for fatigue assessment of welded structures. In this study, large difference of SHSS is obtained by shell and solid elements for both simple and complex fillet welded details and also for the OSD. This difference in structural hot-spot stress (SHSS) is reduced by the application of three weld modelling techniques with shell elements: (i) the IIW approach, (ii) the Eriksson’s approach and (iii) a combination of IIW and Eriksson’s approaches. All the three methods are based on increasing the thickness of shell elements at the weld region which are easy to be applied in practice. The dependence of SHSS on mesh size and element type is also investigated in this thesis.
A parametric study is performed first on simple and then on complex fillet welded details to check whether the weld modelling technique can be applied to different geometries, loading and boundary conditions. The solid element model of the complex detail is first validated with experimental strain measurements. Then, SHSS values from other numerical models are compared with the solid model. Representative load cases are investigated initially followed by load combinations. The weld modelling method with shell elements gives good consistency in the ratio of hot-spot stress compared to the solid element model for these details. The deformations are also investigated for all load cases and load combinations. The combined weld modelling technique (iii) with shell elements replicated the weld stiffness of the solid model for both in-plane and out-of-plane load cases.
As a final step in checking the consistency of SHSS ratios between shell elements with welds and solid elements in the application of OSD, a parametric investigation is performed. This study involved two geometric variants of OSD with different load positions. These two variants were based on the design of existing bridges in The Netherlands with relatively thin plate and newly designed ones with thicker plates. The parametric study is divided into two parts. The first part is based on representative load cases. The second part is based on SHSS influence lines for determination of critical loading positions having maximum and minimum hot-spot stress. For both these studies, the weld modelling approaches with shell elements gave a good match of SHSS compared to the solid models. The SHSS results from the shell model with weld are more consistent compared to the regular shell model without weld. From the preliminary parametric study on OSD, it is found that after weld modelling with shell elements using the combined approach of IIW and Eriksson, less scatter is observed in the SHSS ratios. The coefficient of variation (CV) in SHSS ratio for crossbeam is 6.8% and that for stiffener is around 5.1% which is low. The SHSS values are computed based on the stress perpendicular to weld toe. From the detailed parametric study, the mean value of SHSS ratio is 1.07 (range: 0.99-1.15) for the crossbeam and 1.02 (range: 0.98-1.10) for the stiffener. The CV of SHSS ratio is 5.4% for the crossbeam and 4% for the stiffener. The stress profiles are also investigated at the critical locations of OSD. The shell model with the combined weld modelling approach is in good agreement with not only SHSS but also with the stress at a distance far away from the stress concentration when compared to the solid model. The deformations are also very similar for both the numerical models. Thus, it is concluded that the combined weld modelling technique using the IIW and the Eriksson’s approach with shell elements could be used for accurate fatigue life assessment using hot-spot stress method where the measure of accuracy is with respect to the solid element model.
Wire and Arc Additive Manufacturing of Thin Structures Using Metal-Cored Wire Consumables
Microstructure, mechanical properties, and experiment-based thermal model
The current growth in WAAM applications will boost the WAAM consumable material development in the coming future. WAAM applications mostly refer to small batch production or prototypes, which often requires special wire compositions or can benefit from tailoring the consumable composition for the desired components. On one hand, solid wire production is only economically viable when large volumes are involved. On the other hand, metal-cored wires are particularly suitable to produce tailored or small-batch consumable compositions, which is very attractive for WAAM. However, only limited research has been carried out in the use of metal-cored wires in additive manufacturing. In this research, the focus is to explore the use of metal-cored wire in WAAM applications. Two chemical compositions, one ferrous, medium carbon low steel alloy (AM-XC-45), and one non-ferrous, Stellite 6 (cobalt-based superalloy), metal-cored wires were investigated based on industrial interests at RAMLAB.
The microstructure of the WAAM AM-XC-45 thin wall was characterized using optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Pearlite, ferrite, bainite, and martensite are present in the deposited wall. Columnar grains are found near the fusion line. The repeated thermal cycles cause the grains to become finer from the top to bottom layers. The mechanical properties including microhardness and tensile strength were tested and compared with the traditional processing methods like casting, milling, and forging. It showed a comparable or superior microhardness and tensile strength to the traditional process whereas the relative lower elongation of the deposited AM-XC-45 thin wall indicates that further post heat treatment is needed to improve the ductility of the part.
Stellite 6 is a cobalt-based superalloy, which has good wear and corrosion resistance and retains these properties at high temperatures. In this study, Stellite 6 metal-cored wire (WEARTECH® WT-6 GMAW-C, AWS A5.21 ERCCoCr-A) is selected and optimized to obtain results comparable to the commonly employed and more costly laser deposition, in terms of microstructure and mechanical properties. The optimal deposition parameters were developed using the S355 steel substrate, and then adopted on depositing on the AISI 420 stainless steel substrate. Characterization showed that Stellite 6 layer mainly contains Co-Cr-Fe solid solution with FCC crystal structure as the matrix and the Cr7C3 and Cr3C2 were identified in the microstructure through SEM, EDS, and XRD. These carbides can contribute to the strength. In addition, the identified Co4W2C carbides can contribute to the wear properties of the Stellite 6 WAAM deposits. The dilution and hardness of the WAAM deposit can reach the same level as laser deposition.
Additionally, a 3D temperature distribution model is developed by adopting the moving mesh technique to numerically study the WAAM process. The model helps to gain a better understanding of the physical phenomena (heat and mass transfer) during the WAAM deposition. The AM-XC-45 was used to validate the developed model. The simulated and experimental results were compared. The dilution and HAZ of WAAM deposited single bead was used as validation criteria. The A1 line (1100K) simulation is in a good agreement with the experimental result. The fusion line (1800K) shows some deviation. Compared with laser deposition, the main differences between the two processes lie on the heat source, the boundary conditions, and the material responses to the process. ...
The current growth in WAAM applications will boost the WAAM consumable material development in the coming future. WAAM applications mostly refer to small batch production or prototypes, which often requires special wire compositions or can benefit from tailoring the consumable composition for the desired components. On one hand, solid wire production is only economically viable when large volumes are involved. On the other hand, metal-cored wires are particularly suitable to produce tailored or small-batch consumable compositions, which is very attractive for WAAM. However, only limited research has been carried out in the use of metal-cored wires in additive manufacturing. In this research, the focus is to explore the use of metal-cored wire in WAAM applications. Two chemical compositions, one ferrous, medium carbon low steel alloy (AM-XC-45), and one non-ferrous, Stellite 6 (cobalt-based superalloy), metal-cored wires were investigated based on industrial interests at RAMLAB.
The microstructure of the WAAM AM-XC-45 thin wall was characterized using optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. Pearlite, ferrite, bainite, and martensite are present in the deposited wall. Columnar grains are found near the fusion line. The repeated thermal cycles cause the grains to become finer from the top to bottom layers. The mechanical properties including microhardness and tensile strength were tested and compared with the traditional processing methods like casting, milling, and forging. It showed a comparable or superior microhardness and tensile strength to the traditional process whereas the relative lower elongation of the deposited AM-XC-45 thin wall indicates that further post heat treatment is needed to improve the ductility of the part.
Stellite 6 is a cobalt-based superalloy, which has good wear and corrosion resistance and retains these properties at high temperatures. In this study, Stellite 6 metal-cored wire (WEARTECH® WT-6 GMAW-C, AWS A5.21 ERCCoCr-A) is selected and optimized to obtain results comparable to the commonly employed and more costly laser deposition, in terms of microstructure and mechanical properties. The optimal deposition parameters were developed using the S355 steel substrate, and then adopted on depositing on the AISI 420 stainless steel substrate. Characterization showed that Stellite 6 layer mainly contains Co-Cr-Fe solid solution with FCC crystal structure as the matrix and the Cr7C3 and Cr3C2 were identified in the microstructure through SEM, EDS, and XRD. These carbides can contribute to the strength. In addition, the identified Co4W2C carbides can contribute to the wear properties of the Stellite 6 WAAM deposits. The dilution and hardness of the WAAM deposit can reach the same level as laser deposition.
Additionally, a 3D temperature distribution model is developed by adopting the moving mesh technique to numerically study the WAAM process. The model helps to gain a better understanding of the physical phenomena (heat and mass transfer) during the WAAM deposition. The AM-XC-45 was used to validate the developed model. The simulated and experimental results were compared. The dilution and HAZ of WAAM deposited single bead was used as validation criteria. The A1 line (1100K) simulation is in a good agreement with the experimental result. The fusion line (1800K) shows some deviation. Compared with laser deposition, the main differences between the two processes lie on the heat source, the boundary conditions, and the material responses to the process.