R.W. Hut
Please Note
20 records found
1
This study aims to quantify the relative influence of human water use and climate variability on the Aral Sea water balance using a fully reproducible modelling workflow implemented within the eWaterCycle environment. A reproducible model chain was designed and implemented using the eWaterCycle platform, which promotes FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) computational hydrology. New workflow components were developed for forcing generation, spatial regridding and downscaling, bias correction, and regional model calibration, and integrated as reusable tools within eWaterCycle.
Meteorological forcing was derived from ERA5 reanalysis data (1940–2020) for historical reconstruction and CMIP6 global climate models for future scenarios (2025–2100). Catchment hydrology was simulated using PCR-GLOBWB2 (PCRaster GLOBal Water Balance model, version 2) following regional calibration against observed discharge data. Simulated discharges were subsequently used as input as inflow to an Aral Volume Balance model developed for this study.
Methodologically, the study delivers a modular and reproducible workflow enabling consistent preparation and use of climate forcing data within eWaterCycle. The developed reprocessing tools allowed CMIP6 datasets to be directly applied in PCR-GLOBWB2 simulations, while bias correction substantially reduced temperature and precipitation biases. Regional calibration improved discharge simulations from double digit negative KGE to positive values.
Hydrologically, the coupled modelling framework successfully reproduced the observed desiccation trend of the Aral Sea, and showed the effect of different models and pathways on the future of the Aral Sea. The study demonstrates that the eWaterCycle platform can be used as a robust, transparent, and reusable workflow environment. The developed tools extend the capabilities of the eWaterCycle ecosystem and enable transparent, reusable hydrological experimentation for endorheic basins and other large-scale water systems. ...
This study aims to quantify the relative influence of human water use and climate variability on the Aral Sea water balance using a fully reproducible modelling workflow implemented within the eWaterCycle environment. A reproducible model chain was designed and implemented using the eWaterCycle platform, which promotes FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) computational hydrology. New workflow components were developed for forcing generation, spatial regridding and downscaling, bias correction, and regional model calibration, and integrated as reusable tools within eWaterCycle.
Meteorological forcing was derived from ERA5 reanalysis data (1940–2020) for historical reconstruction and CMIP6 global climate models for future scenarios (2025–2100). Catchment hydrology was simulated using PCR-GLOBWB2 (PCRaster GLOBal Water Balance model, version 2) following regional calibration against observed discharge data. Simulated discharges were subsequently used as input as inflow to an Aral Volume Balance model developed for this study.
Methodologically, the study delivers a modular and reproducible workflow enabling consistent preparation and use of climate forcing data within eWaterCycle. The developed reprocessing tools allowed CMIP6 datasets to be directly applied in PCR-GLOBWB2 simulations, while bias correction substantially reduced temperature and precipitation biases. Regional calibration improved discharge simulations from double digit negative KGE to positive values.
Hydrologically, the coupled modelling framework successfully reproduced the observed desiccation trend of the Aral Sea, and showed the effect of different models and pathways on the future of the Aral Sea. The study demonstrates that the eWaterCycle platform can be used as a robust, transparent, and reusable workflow environment. The developed tools extend the capabilities of the eWaterCycle ecosystem and enable transparent, reusable hydrological experimentation for endorheic basins and other large-scale water systems.
eWaterCycle in Practice
Reproducible and Diagnostic Approaches for Large-Sample Catchment Based Hydrological Model Evaluation
Central to this work are the development and application of the eWaterCycle platform: a modular, community-driven system that promotes reproducible modeling\\ through standardized interfaces and containerized environments. By building on existing models through the Basic Model Interface (BMI) and deploying experiments at scale, eWaterCycle enables model intercomparison and refinement with fewer technical barriers. Although it does not eliminate all integration complexity, the platform provides a practical foundation for reproducible, FAIR-compliant workflows and has already enabled new forms of collaborative experimentation.
Using this platform, the thesis evaluates the effects of spatial resolution on hydrological model performance. Results from 454 CAMELS-US catchments show that a finer spatial resolution (down to 200~m) does not universally improve streamflow predictions at catchment outlets. Although resolution matters in some contexts, particularly where topography or land cover is complex, the overall gains are limited and often fall within uncertainty bounds. These findings suggest that investing in higher spatial resolution without a corresponding investment in observational density is a questionable allocation of research effort. ``Hyper-resolution'' modeling, though technically feasible, must be approached with clear use cases and a realistic assessment of whether the available data can actually support it.
Expanding the scope of model diagnostics, the research applies machine learning (specifically, a random forest) to link catchment attributes to model performance across 617 CAMELS-GB catchments. The analysis shows that model suitability often varies with catchment scale and physical characteristics, with different models (wflow\_sbm and PCR-GLOBWB) excelling under different conditions. This underscores the ``reality of locality'' in hydrology: every catchment presents a unique combination of dominant processes, making the pursuit of a universal model impractical. Although the results expose structural model limitations, they also demonstrate the potential of machine learning as a diagnostic tool, an application that deserves greater emphasis alongside its more common use in prediction.
A key contribution of the dissertation is the integration of uncertainty in discharge observations into model evaluation. Using quantified uncertainty estimates from 299 CAMELS-GB catchments, the analysis shows that a significant share of perceived performance improvements, whether achieved through parameter tuning or arising from structural differences, may fall within the uncertainty bounds of the observations. Notably, no clear relationship was found between model complexity and model performance, challenging the assumption that more complex models are inherently more capable. Together, these findings call into question how model results are interpreted and underline the need to report and account for uncertainty more systematically.
The concluding chapters synthesize these results, arguing for a more critical yet constructive modeling practice: one that embraces reproducibility and large-sample evaluation while recognizing the limits of model resolution, structural complexity, and observational quality. They make the case that advancing hydrology depends as much on investing in new and better observations---from rehabilitating existing gauging networks to deploying novel sensing technologies and satellite products---as it does on improving models. By embedding uncertainty diagnostics into the evaluation process and facilitating open, repeatable workflows, this work contributes to a more robust and realistic foundation for model improvement and application.
Looking ahead, the thesis outlines clear directions for future research: expanding eWaterCycle to include more models and domains; exploiting underutilized satellite missions and opportunistic data sources; and bridging the cultural divide between modelers and field scientists so that data collection and model experimentation become two sides of the same scientific process. Although challenges remain, particularly in the community-wide adoption of reproducible practices, the tools and insights developed here offer a tangible step forward.
In summary, this dissertation contributes to hydrological science by combining reproducible modeling tools with diagnostic depth. It promotes a more transparent and critical modeling practice, one that acknowledges uncertainty, challenges complacency about data scarcity, and encourages the responsible use of models. Rather than seeking breakthroughs, the work focuses on enabling more reproducible, interpretable, and broadly applicable hydrological modeling, thereby helping build a stronger foundation for both scientific progress and practical decision-making. The path forward is not to accept the limitations we have inherited, but to systematically reduce them. ...
Central to this work are the development and application of the eWaterCycle platform: a modular, community-driven system that promotes reproducible modeling\\ through standardized interfaces and containerized environments. By building on existing models through the Basic Model Interface (BMI) and deploying experiments at scale, eWaterCycle enables model intercomparison and refinement with fewer technical barriers. Although it does not eliminate all integration complexity, the platform provides a practical foundation for reproducible, FAIR-compliant workflows and has already enabled new forms of collaborative experimentation.
Using this platform, the thesis evaluates the effects of spatial resolution on hydrological model performance. Results from 454 CAMELS-US catchments show that a finer spatial resolution (down to 200~m) does not universally improve streamflow predictions at catchment outlets. Although resolution matters in some contexts, particularly where topography or land cover is complex, the overall gains are limited and often fall within uncertainty bounds. These findings suggest that investing in higher spatial resolution without a corresponding investment in observational density is a questionable allocation of research effort. ``Hyper-resolution'' modeling, though technically feasible, must be approached with clear use cases and a realistic assessment of whether the available data can actually support it.
Expanding the scope of model diagnostics, the research applies machine learning (specifically, a random forest) to link catchment attributes to model performance across 617 CAMELS-GB catchments. The analysis shows that model suitability often varies with catchment scale and physical characteristics, with different models (wflow\_sbm and PCR-GLOBWB) excelling under different conditions. This underscores the ``reality of locality'' in hydrology: every catchment presents a unique combination of dominant processes, making the pursuit of a universal model impractical. Although the results expose structural model limitations, they also demonstrate the potential of machine learning as a diagnostic tool, an application that deserves greater emphasis alongside its more common use in prediction.
A key contribution of the dissertation is the integration of uncertainty in discharge observations into model evaluation. Using quantified uncertainty estimates from 299 CAMELS-GB catchments, the analysis shows that a significant share of perceived performance improvements, whether achieved through parameter tuning or arising from structural differences, may fall within the uncertainty bounds of the observations. Notably, no clear relationship was found between model complexity and model performance, challenging the assumption that more complex models are inherently more capable. Together, these findings call into question how model results are interpreted and underline the need to report and account for uncertainty more systematically.
The concluding chapters synthesize these results, arguing for a more critical yet constructive modeling practice: one that embraces reproducibility and large-sample evaluation while recognizing the limits of model resolution, structural complexity, and observational quality. They make the case that advancing hydrology depends as much on investing in new and better observations---from rehabilitating existing gauging networks to deploying novel sensing technologies and satellite products---as it does on improving models. By embedding uncertainty diagnostics into the evaluation process and facilitating open, repeatable workflows, this work contributes to a more robust and realistic foundation for model improvement and application.
Looking ahead, the thesis outlines clear directions for future research: expanding eWaterCycle to include more models and domains; exploiting underutilized satellite missions and opportunistic data sources; and bridging the cultural divide between modelers and field scientists so that data collection and model experimentation become two sides of the same scientific process. Although challenges remain, particularly in the community-wide adoption of reproducible practices, the tools and insights developed here offer a tangible step forward.
In summary, this dissertation contributes to hydrological science by combining reproducible modeling tools with diagnostic depth. It promotes a more transparent and critical modeling practice, one that acknowledges uncertainty, challenges complacency about data scarcity, and encourages the responsible use of models. Rather than seeking breakthroughs, the work focuses on enabling more reproducible, interpretable, and broadly applicable hydrological modeling, thereby helping build a stronger foundation for both scientific progress and practical decision-making. The path forward is not to accept the limitations we have inherited, but to systematically reduce them.
In this study, experimental measurements of the plastic particles wave-induced transport in intermediate to shallow water depths are presented. The focus is put on the influence of wave steepness as a key parameter affecting the transport of marine plastic debris in the transition from deep water to the shoreline. Its potential as a predictive parameter is investigated through controlled laboratory experiments involving the generation of seven regular breaking wave conditions, characterised by varying offshore steepness, propagating in shallow water depth over a sloped bathymetry.
The results reveal a consistent increase in particle drift speed with increasing offshore wave steepness. While the exact functional nature of the observed positive relationship could not be definitively concluded, the trend appears more likely linear than quadratic, aligning with previous findings for particles deviating from perfect tracers undergoing deep water breaking conditions. Furthermore, wave breaking was observed to play an important role in enhancing particle drift speed. Finally, particle drift speeds were consistently underestimated by the Stokes drift and only partially captured by the wave crest speed estimates, progressively diverging from the former and approaching the latter as offshore steepness increased, though remaining consistently lower than crest speeds. This trend was most recognisable in the breaking zone across all the tested wave conditions.
Overall, the findings suggest offshore wave steepness as a robust predictor for marine plastic debris transport in the nearshore environment, proving its value as a classification parameter for future modelling efforts. By investigating how plastic particles respond to changing wave conditions in the nearshore environment, this study aims to contribute to a better understanding of their dynamics. ...
In this study, experimental measurements of the plastic particles wave-induced transport in intermediate to shallow water depths are presented. The focus is put on the influence of wave steepness as a key parameter affecting the transport of marine plastic debris in the transition from deep water to the shoreline. Its potential as a predictive parameter is investigated through controlled laboratory experiments involving the generation of seven regular breaking wave conditions, characterised by varying offshore steepness, propagating in shallow water depth over a sloped bathymetry.
The results reveal a consistent increase in particle drift speed with increasing offshore wave steepness. While the exact functional nature of the observed positive relationship could not be definitively concluded, the trend appears more likely linear than quadratic, aligning with previous findings for particles deviating from perfect tracers undergoing deep water breaking conditions. Furthermore, wave breaking was observed to play an important role in enhancing particle drift speed. Finally, particle drift speeds were consistently underestimated by the Stokes drift and only partially captured by the wave crest speed estimates, progressively diverging from the former and approaching the latter as offshore steepness increased, though remaining consistently lower than crest speeds. This trend was most recognisable in the breaking zone across all the tested wave conditions.
Overall, the findings suggest offshore wave steepness as a robust predictor for marine plastic debris transport in the nearshore environment, proving its value as a classification parameter for future modelling efforts. By investigating how plastic particles respond to changing wave conditions in the nearshore environment, this study aims to contribute to a better understanding of their dynamics.
In this thesis, a data assimilation framework was developed for the eWaterCycle platform. This framework takes care of the intricacies of data assimilation for the user. Any model implemented with the Basic Model Interface can make use of this, models within eWaterCycle are focused on FAIR hydrology. The framework was implemented in such a way that any data assimilation scheme can be used, following the FAIR principles. The framework was verified to work with synthetic observations for both the HBV (Hydrologiska Byråns Vattenbalansavdelning) and the Lorenz model. The framework also makes applying data assimilation within eWaterCycle easier and scalable.
To answer the research question, the five-year hydrological response of 671 catchments in the United States of America was modeled. These catchments are from the CAMELS dataset, which is a collection of hydrological data with characteristics for catchments across the United States of America. The data assimilation scheme particle filtering was applied to the conceptual hydrological model HBV using eWaterCycle. The parameters and states of each experiment were stored and analysed. The data assimilation scheme requires hyperparameters. These hyperparameters were optimised using the first 26 catchments in the dataset. This single combination of hyperparameters was used across the 671 catchments.
Taking the best prediction of stream flow at every time step, the data assimilation experiment outperformed the calibrated model in 461 of these catchments. Part of this is due to the bias introduced through the use of one set of hyperparameters. Analysis shows that catchments of the same characteristics perform similarly. Catchments with a low mean stream flow, have a high spread of predicted observations causing very good predictions when selecting the best. Due to this bias, no real correlations can be drawn about the relation of background characteristics and model deficiency. Analysing three catchments on a catchment scale showed that step changes in parameters often occur around flood peaks. The data assimilation scheme adjusts the working of the model to better capture the observed streamflow.
To further incorporate the framework in eWaterCycle more testing should be done on 2D models. Deficiencies in the HBV model can be further analysed by optimising hyperparameters per catchment type or flow regime.
...
In this thesis, a data assimilation framework was developed for the eWaterCycle platform. This framework takes care of the intricacies of data assimilation for the user. Any model implemented with the Basic Model Interface can make use of this, models within eWaterCycle are focused on FAIR hydrology. The framework was implemented in such a way that any data assimilation scheme can be used, following the FAIR principles. The framework was verified to work with synthetic observations for both the HBV (Hydrologiska Byråns Vattenbalansavdelning) and the Lorenz model. The framework also makes applying data assimilation within eWaterCycle easier and scalable.
To answer the research question, the five-year hydrological response of 671 catchments in the United States of America was modeled. These catchments are from the CAMELS dataset, which is a collection of hydrological data with characteristics for catchments across the United States of America. The data assimilation scheme particle filtering was applied to the conceptual hydrological model HBV using eWaterCycle. The parameters and states of each experiment were stored and analysed. The data assimilation scheme requires hyperparameters. These hyperparameters were optimised using the first 26 catchments in the dataset. This single combination of hyperparameters was used across the 671 catchments.
Taking the best prediction of stream flow at every time step, the data assimilation experiment outperformed the calibrated model in 461 of these catchments. Part of this is due to the bias introduced through the use of one set of hyperparameters. Analysis shows that catchments of the same characteristics perform similarly. Catchments with a low mean stream flow, have a high spread of predicted observations causing very good predictions when selecting the best. Due to this bias, no real correlations can be drawn about the relation of background characteristics and model deficiency. Analysing three catchments on a catchment scale showed that step changes in parameters often occur around flood peaks. The data assimilation scheme adjusts the working of the model to better capture the observed streamflow.
To further incorporate the framework in eWaterCycle more testing should be done on 2D models. Deficiencies in the HBV model can be further analysed by optimising hyperparameters per catchment type or flow regime.
Temperature profiles through the soil-vegetation-atmosphere continuum
Taking an unprecedented look into the canopy
A broader goal in the field of atmospheric science is to study a way to unify internal canopy dynamics with the dynamics above the canopy to yield temperature profiles that are valid from the surface, through the canopy, up into the atmosphere. In working towards these goals, a key element still lacks; precise, high resolution temperature measurements through the canopy-atmosphere interface. Novel measurement techniques such as distributed temperature sensing (DTS) have advanced the quality of datasets significantly, yielding temperature profiles with a resolution and accuracy on the order of centimeters. However, it has thus far not yielded sufficient accuracy for conclusive model comparison and for studying internal canopy temperature profiles. Therefore, there is a need for a more accurate, high-resolution dataset.
To this end, an experiment was designed to gain detailed insight into these regimes. A helical frame structure was designed, built and combined with the method of distributed temperature sensing (DTS) to attain a high resolution temperature profile along the vertical. The setup was installed at Cabauw where several weeks of data were acquired. Preliminary data analysis shows that the resulting data is well suited for the aforementioned purposes. Strong gradients near the surface can be identified as a result of the high measurement resolution on the millimeter scale. Furthermore, close to 80 data points are located within the 10cm canopy, allowing for the investigation of internal canopy transport dynamics. Finally, the data may be used in the future to validate any future models that aim to combine the canopy and atmospheric regimes. ...
A broader goal in the field of atmospheric science is to study a way to unify internal canopy dynamics with the dynamics above the canopy to yield temperature profiles that are valid from the surface, through the canopy, up into the atmosphere. In working towards these goals, a key element still lacks; precise, high resolution temperature measurements through the canopy-atmosphere interface. Novel measurement techniques such as distributed temperature sensing (DTS) have advanced the quality of datasets significantly, yielding temperature profiles with a resolution and accuracy on the order of centimeters. However, it has thus far not yielded sufficient accuracy for conclusive model comparison and for studying internal canopy temperature profiles. Therefore, there is a need for a more accurate, high-resolution dataset.
To this end, an experiment was designed to gain detailed insight into these regimes. A helical frame structure was designed, built and combined with the method of distributed temperature sensing (DTS) to attain a high resolution temperature profile along the vertical. The setup was installed at Cabauw where several weeks of data were acquired. Preliminary data analysis shows that the resulting data is well suited for the aforementioned purposes. Strong gradients near the surface can be identified as a result of the high measurement resolution on the millimeter scale. Furthermore, close to 80 data points are located within the 10cm canopy, allowing for the investigation of internal canopy transport dynamics. Finally, the data may be used in the future to validate any future models that aim to combine the canopy and atmospheric regimes.
Safely Building New Houses in the Geul Catchment
How to mitigate the impact on flooding?
Therefore, the goal of this research is to investigate the best suitable subcatchment for the construction of new residential houses within the Geul catchment, in terms of flooding. The July 2021 flood event is used as a reference. The first step was to investigate the hydrological response of the Geul catchment. Secondly, this hydrological response was modelled by the semi-distributed hydrological models HBV coupled to D-RR and by the distributed model Wflow_sbm. HBV and D-RR are set up in this research, while Wflow_sbm is adopted from Klein (2022) and Bouaziz (2022). The hydrological models are coupled to the Geul hydrodynamic model D-HYDRO of Hulsman, Weijers, Verstegen, and Goedbloed (2023). The building plans in the Geul catchment were investigated and scenarios were constructed. These scenarios were simulated in the hydrological models. This method resulted in a workflow that can be found in Idsinga (2024). The workflow can be applied on analyses of different land cover types.
The modelled hydrographs showed differences between the hydrological models. Each model better describes one part of the hydrological response compared to the other. HBV and D-RR better represent the subsurface flow and describe the hydrological response during consecutive precipitation events. Wflow_sbm represents the overland flow flux better and therefore describes the hydrological response during the July 2021 flood event. The modelled flood extents during the July 2021 flood event are also compared to the estimated extent by Slager, de Moel, and de Jong (2021). Wflow_sbm showed better similarity to the measured flood extent than HBV and D-RR. The Province of Limburg wants to build 18,730 new houses in the South of Limburg. This results in an increase of 6 km2 paved area. In this research, this increase is applied to different locations in the Geul catchment. Next, the impact of completely paved subcatchments was investigated. The relatively small 6 km2 increase in paved area did not result in different discharge behaviour and the total area of the flood extent showed a small difference. However, it impacted the flooded paved area. Building far from the river on the hills resulted in no increase in the flooded paved area. New houses in the valleys, close to the river, are more exposed to flooding. In the Meerssen subcatchment, the added paved area was responsible for 95% of the total increase in the flooded paved area. This was also the case in the Gulp subcatchment, where about 90% of the increase in flooded paved area came from the added paved area.
The Meerssen subcatchment is the most vulnerable to flooding. This subcatchment contains the most paved area and more runoff will result in a more flooded paved area. A completely paved Gulp subcatchment results in a less flooded paved area than building 6 km2 close to the Geul in the Meerssen subcatchment. When the Belgians build new houses in the Sippenaeken subcatchment, the Netherlands will receive more water during an extreme event such as in July 2021.
The letter Water en Bodem Sturend states that new houses must be built in sensible locations. In this research, the location of new houses is found to be important for the hydrological response. Building close to the river results in a more flooded paved area than building far from the river. The Gulp subcatchment is the least vulnerable to flooding and can be considered the best building location for new houses among the three investigated subcatchments. ...
Therefore, the goal of this research is to investigate the best suitable subcatchment for the construction of new residential houses within the Geul catchment, in terms of flooding. The July 2021 flood event is used as a reference. The first step was to investigate the hydrological response of the Geul catchment. Secondly, this hydrological response was modelled by the semi-distributed hydrological models HBV coupled to D-RR and by the distributed model Wflow_sbm. HBV and D-RR are set up in this research, while Wflow_sbm is adopted from Klein (2022) and Bouaziz (2022). The hydrological models are coupled to the Geul hydrodynamic model D-HYDRO of Hulsman, Weijers, Verstegen, and Goedbloed (2023). The building plans in the Geul catchment were investigated and scenarios were constructed. These scenarios were simulated in the hydrological models. This method resulted in a workflow that can be found in Idsinga (2024). The workflow can be applied on analyses of different land cover types.
The modelled hydrographs showed differences between the hydrological models. Each model better describes one part of the hydrological response compared to the other. HBV and D-RR better represent the subsurface flow and describe the hydrological response during consecutive precipitation events. Wflow_sbm represents the overland flow flux better and therefore describes the hydrological response during the July 2021 flood event. The modelled flood extents during the July 2021 flood event are also compared to the estimated extent by Slager, de Moel, and de Jong (2021). Wflow_sbm showed better similarity to the measured flood extent than HBV and D-RR. The Province of Limburg wants to build 18,730 new houses in the South of Limburg. This results in an increase of 6 km2 paved area. In this research, this increase is applied to different locations in the Geul catchment. Next, the impact of completely paved subcatchments was investigated. The relatively small 6 km2 increase in paved area did not result in different discharge behaviour and the total area of the flood extent showed a small difference. However, it impacted the flooded paved area. Building far from the river on the hills resulted in no increase in the flooded paved area. New houses in the valleys, close to the river, are more exposed to flooding. In the Meerssen subcatchment, the added paved area was responsible for 95% of the total increase in the flooded paved area. This was also the case in the Gulp subcatchment, where about 90% of the increase in flooded paved area came from the added paved area.
The Meerssen subcatchment is the most vulnerable to flooding. This subcatchment contains the most paved area and more runoff will result in a more flooded paved area. A completely paved Gulp subcatchment results in a less flooded paved area than building 6 km2 close to the Geul in the Meerssen subcatchment. When the Belgians build new houses in the Sippenaeken subcatchment, the Netherlands will receive more water during an extreme event such as in July 2021.
The letter Water en Bodem Sturend states that new houses must be built in sensible locations. In this research, the location of new houses is found to be important for the hydrological response. Building close to the river results in a more flooded paved area than building far from the river. The Gulp subcatchment is the least vulnerable to flooding and can be considered the best building location for new houses among the three investigated subcatchments.
To address this objective, eight LSMs were evaluated: CESM2, CMCC-ESM2, E3SM-1-1, EC-Earth3-Veg, HadGEM3-GC31-LL, IPSL-CM6A-LR, MIROC6, and UKESM1-0-LL. Two reference evaporation datasets (DOLCE V3 and an ensemble of FLUXCOM-RS, BESS and PML) and a reference soil moisture dataset (SoMo.ml) were utilized for the evaluation. After a global analysis of LSM evaporation characteristics, six climatically diverse study areas were selected for further investigation.
A long-term analysis was performed by examining the water balance and implementing the LSMs into the Budyko framework. Subsequently, soil moisture deficits were calculated for the driest periods in time, and the resulting accumulated deficits were compared with the reference evaporation data. The timing and progression of the deficits were evaluated using the reference soil moisture data. Finally, the sensitivity of the models was evaluated by examining the response of evaporation anomalies to precipitation anomalies and comparing this with the reference evaporation data.
The results showed that there was a large spread in output and performance among the LSMs across all parts of the evaluation. The greatest contrasts among the LSMs were found in the dry-to-wet transition zones within the tropics. In this latitudinal range, the worst-performing LSMs overestimated the accumulation of soil moisture deficits and the severity of droughts, while the opposite was found for the extratropical regions. Additionally, the models showed, in general, that they were overly sensitive to precipitation anomalies.
When ranking the implemented model bases in the LSMs based on their performance during droughts, the findings showed that the Community Land Model (implemented in CMCC-ESM2, E3SM-1-1 and CESM2) was predominantly the best performing, followed by ORCHIDEE (IPSL-CM6A-LR) and HTESSEL (EC-Earth3-Veg). MATSIRO (MIROC6) and JULES (HadGEM3-GC31-LL and UKESM1-0-LL) were the least performing model bases.
From a hydrological perspective, the findings of this research could be linked to some known limitations of LSMs. Oversimplified soil and vegetation dynamics could contribute to LSMs being overly sensitive to precipitation anomalies, while the contrasts between tropical and extratropical regions could be attributed to the representation of soil moisture–evaporation coupling, which plays a greater role in the tropical study areas.
Ultimately, this research could contribute to LS3MIP and the land surface modeling community, as the results highlight the strengths and weaknesses of LSMs in simulating soil moisture droughts. From there, this research could contribute to improving LSMs, understanding drought mechanisms, and addressing climate change impacts, especially in drought-prone regions. ...
To address this objective, eight LSMs were evaluated: CESM2, CMCC-ESM2, E3SM-1-1, EC-Earth3-Veg, HadGEM3-GC31-LL, IPSL-CM6A-LR, MIROC6, and UKESM1-0-LL. Two reference evaporation datasets (DOLCE V3 and an ensemble of FLUXCOM-RS, BESS and PML) and a reference soil moisture dataset (SoMo.ml) were utilized for the evaluation. After a global analysis of LSM evaporation characteristics, six climatically diverse study areas were selected for further investigation.
A long-term analysis was performed by examining the water balance and implementing the LSMs into the Budyko framework. Subsequently, soil moisture deficits were calculated for the driest periods in time, and the resulting accumulated deficits were compared with the reference evaporation data. The timing and progression of the deficits were evaluated using the reference soil moisture data. Finally, the sensitivity of the models was evaluated by examining the response of evaporation anomalies to precipitation anomalies and comparing this with the reference evaporation data.
The results showed that there was a large spread in output and performance among the LSMs across all parts of the evaluation. The greatest contrasts among the LSMs were found in the dry-to-wet transition zones within the tropics. In this latitudinal range, the worst-performing LSMs overestimated the accumulation of soil moisture deficits and the severity of droughts, while the opposite was found for the extratropical regions. Additionally, the models showed, in general, that they were overly sensitive to precipitation anomalies.
When ranking the implemented model bases in the LSMs based on their performance during droughts, the findings showed that the Community Land Model (implemented in CMCC-ESM2, E3SM-1-1 and CESM2) was predominantly the best performing, followed by ORCHIDEE (IPSL-CM6A-LR) and HTESSEL (EC-Earth3-Veg). MATSIRO (MIROC6) and JULES (HadGEM3-GC31-LL and UKESM1-0-LL) were the least performing model bases.
From a hydrological perspective, the findings of this research could be linked to some known limitations of LSMs. Oversimplified soil and vegetation dynamics could contribute to LSMs being overly sensitive to precipitation anomalies, while the contrasts between tropical and extratropical regions could be attributed to the representation of soil moisture–evaporation coupling, which plays a greater role in the tropical study areas.
Ultimately, this research could contribute to LS3MIP and the land surface modeling community, as the results highlight the strengths and weaknesses of LSMs in simulating soil moisture droughts. From there, this research could contribute to improving LSMs, understanding drought mechanisms, and addressing climate change impacts, especially in drought-prone regions.
Sustainably scaling up the operations of Kelp Blue in Lüderitz, Namibia
A consultancy report
The study with observed data shows both increasing and decreasing trends in coefficients for several degrees of deforestation. Literature shows that landcover type after deforestation is a major factor in the interpretation of these results. However, a lack of quality annual landcover data prevents better research in the non-masked impact of deforestation on discharge. The results of the simple model study show no significant relation between deforestation and recession coefficient $\alpha$. The simplicity of this self-made conceptual model is the weak and strong point of this sub-study. The simplicity makes the results less suitable for analyzing the exact impact of deforestation on discharge, but it is useful for observing general signals and is easily scalable to different catchments. The simulated discharge by WFLOW show a steep overestimation of discharge during peak flow in comparison to observed discharge by CAMELS-BR. Therefore it is not possible to analyze how WFLOW reacts to deforestation. Instead, an in-depth analysis on the cause of this poor performance is conducted by analyzing timeseries for hydrological factors like unsaturated zone depth. The results of this analysis indicate the overestimation of discharge is caused by a lack of outflow from soil layers. In addition, the difference between the Budyko framework of different data sets used in this research, show that uncertainty in quality of input data is a plausible factor on the output of WFLOW.
In conclusion it is observed that deforestation does not necessarily lead to higher runoff coefficients and recession coefficients for measured data in this study area. In addition, the conclusion of the simple model study is that no significant relation between deforestation and recession coefficient $\alpha$ is observed for this conceptual model. Finally, the performance of WFLOW is considered too poor to analyze the impact of deforestation on discharge. The root of this poor performance is considered to be a combination between lack of groundwater modelling and uncertainty on the quality of input-data. ...
The study with observed data shows both increasing and decreasing trends in coefficients for several degrees of deforestation. Literature shows that landcover type after deforestation is a major factor in the interpretation of these results. However, a lack of quality annual landcover data prevents better research in the non-masked impact of deforestation on discharge. The results of the simple model study show no significant relation between deforestation and recession coefficient $\alpha$. The simplicity of this self-made conceptual model is the weak and strong point of this sub-study. The simplicity makes the results less suitable for analyzing the exact impact of deforestation on discharge, but it is useful for observing general signals and is easily scalable to different catchments. The simulated discharge by WFLOW show a steep overestimation of discharge during peak flow in comparison to observed discharge by CAMELS-BR. Therefore it is not possible to analyze how WFLOW reacts to deforestation. Instead, an in-depth analysis on the cause of this poor performance is conducted by analyzing timeseries for hydrological factors like unsaturated zone depth. The results of this analysis indicate the overestimation of discharge is caused by a lack of outflow from soil layers. In addition, the difference between the Budyko framework of different data sets used in this research, show that uncertainty in quality of input data is a plausible factor on the output of WFLOW.
In conclusion it is observed that deforestation does not necessarily lead to higher runoff coefficients and recession coefficients for measured data in this study area. In addition, the conclusion of the simple model study is that no significant relation between deforestation and recession coefficient $\alpha$ is observed for this conceptual model. Finally, the performance of WFLOW is considered too poor to analyze the impact of deforestation on discharge. The root of this poor performance is considered to be a combination between lack of groundwater modelling and uncertainty on the quality of input-data.
The remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir area was used to come up with Level-Area-Storage(LAS) relationships for the five main reservoirs in the Oum Er Rbia basin. These curves were able to approximate the present set of LAS curves well. Hence, were used in place of the local LAS curves in a water allocation decision model called RIBASIM. Thus, we had two scenarios one where the local LAS curves were used to optimize reservoir operations and the other where remotely sensed LAS curves were used instead of the local LAS curves.
The operating rule curves in the water allocation decision model were then optimized for the two scenarios. The optimization was done to maximize the performance of the system across three objectives: a)public water supply, b)irrigation and c)hydroelectricity generation. A trade-off between the three objective functions was then shown using parallel and scatter plots. It was observed that for the same set of LAS curves the performance across all three objectives improved post-optimization of the operating rule curves. This showed that there were rooms for improvement in the existing reservoir operating rule curves. The operating rule curves for the water allocation decision model with remotely sensed LAS curves were then optimized. The best set of operating rule curves that we got from the second optimization were then used with the local LAS curves to see how the system would perform with these operating rule curves. This gave us an idea of the feasibility of using remotely sensed data to come up with water management decisions and also to assess the benefits of using remotely sensed time-series data. Though the performance over the three objectives was not as good as the results we got by optimizing the system with local LAS curves, it was better than the system performance across the three objectives with the existing set of operating rules and local LAS curves. Thus, it can be used when there is a dearth of proper LAS curves.
Besides, optimizing operating rule curves, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area was used to assess the effects of sedimentation in the reservoir storage. It was observed that for larger reservoirs the percentage change is not much as compared to the smaller reservoirs. Apart from the size of the reservoir, more study is required to make a detailed analysis of how factors like topography and soil texture influence the rate of sedimentation. Despite its limitations, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area can be used to perform a qualitative analysis of the rate of sedimentation and can give reservoir authorities an idea of the need for bathymetry. This can help in avoiding unnecessary bathymetries which are infeasible both economically and physically. ...
The remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir area was used to come up with Level-Area-Storage(LAS) relationships for the five main reservoirs in the Oum Er Rbia basin. These curves were able to approximate the present set of LAS curves well. Hence, were used in place of the local LAS curves in a water allocation decision model called RIBASIM. Thus, we had two scenarios one where the local LAS curves were used to optimize reservoir operations and the other where remotely sensed LAS curves were used instead of the local LAS curves.
The operating rule curves in the water allocation decision model were then optimized for the two scenarios. The optimization was done to maximize the performance of the system across three objectives: a)public water supply, b)irrigation and c)hydroelectricity generation. A trade-off between the three objective functions was then shown using parallel and scatter plots. It was observed that for the same set of LAS curves the performance across all three objectives improved post-optimization of the operating rule curves. This showed that there were rooms for improvement in the existing reservoir operating rule curves. The operating rule curves for the water allocation decision model with remotely sensed LAS curves were then optimized. The best set of operating rule curves that we got from the second optimization were then used with the local LAS curves to see how the system would perform with these operating rule curves. This gave us an idea of the feasibility of using remotely sensed data to come up with water management decisions and also to assess the benefits of using remotely sensed time-series data. Though the performance over the three objectives was not as good as the results we got by optimizing the system with local LAS curves, it was better than the system performance across the three objectives with the existing set of operating rules and local LAS curves. Thus, it can be used when there is a dearth of proper LAS curves.
Besides, optimizing operating rule curves, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area was used to assess the effects of sedimentation in the reservoir storage. It was observed that for larger reservoirs the percentage change is not much as compared to the smaller reservoirs. Apart from the size of the reservoir, more study is required to make a detailed analysis of how factors like topography and soil texture influence the rate of sedimentation. Despite its limitations, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area can be used to perform a qualitative analysis of the rate of sedimentation and can give reservoir authorities an idea of the need for bathymetry. This can help in avoiding unnecessary bathymetries which are infeasible both economically and physically.
Community mapped elevation through a low-cost, dual-frequency GNSS receiver
A performance study in Delft (the Netherlands) and Dar es Salaam (Tanzania)
Fog Water Collection Efficiency
The Influence of Collector Geometry
This research focuses on the need for a water level measuring instrument that is low cost, automatic, reliable and suitable for use in developing countries, specifically in Myanmar. In Myanmar, automated water level data collection remains challenging due to limited financial resources. This data collection limitation inhibits Myanmar's ability to optimize the distribution of water resources, potential consequences of poor water resource management include floods and droughts. Key requirements for a water level gauge to be considered suitable for use in developing countries include, simple to operate and repair, made from off the shelf components and operational in remote areas.
We developed an automatic water level gauge incorporating an acoustic distance sensor, which is the type of sensor used for parking assistance in modern cars. To validate the applicability of our instrument, field trials were undertaken in The Netherlands and Myanmar.
Our research objective was achieved and therefore we demonstrated it is possible to build a water level measuring instruments that is cost-efficient, automatic, reliable and suitable for use in developing countries. Although tests results from the Netherlands are promising, further optimization is needed for deployment in Myanmar. ...
This research focuses on the need for a water level measuring instrument that is low cost, automatic, reliable and suitable for use in developing countries, specifically in Myanmar. In Myanmar, automated water level data collection remains challenging due to limited financial resources. This data collection limitation inhibits Myanmar's ability to optimize the distribution of water resources, potential consequences of poor water resource management include floods and droughts. Key requirements for a water level gauge to be considered suitable for use in developing countries include, simple to operate and repair, made from off the shelf components and operational in remote areas.
We developed an automatic water level gauge incorporating an acoustic distance sensor, which is the type of sensor used for parking assistance in modern cars. To validate the applicability of our instrument, field trials were undertaken in The Netherlands and Myanmar.
Our research objective was achieved and therefore we demonstrated it is possible to build a water level measuring instruments that is cost-efficient, automatic, reliable and suitable for use in developing countries. Although tests results from the Netherlands are promising, further optimization is needed for deployment in Myanmar.