M. Snellen
Please Note
41 records found
1
This thesis develops a framework to evaluate broadband noise prediction models for (electrically driven) propellers in hover and forward flight. Two model are assessed: the classical Brooks, Pope, and Marcolini (BPM) model and the data-driven Gill and Lee (GL) model. Both are verified against literature and validated and compared using scaled hover experiments and full-scale flyover measurements.
Results show that the GL model performs well in hover but overpredicts noise in forward flight. The BPM model provides more consistent predictions across operating conditions. ...
This thesis develops a framework to evaluate broadband noise prediction models for (electrically driven) propellers in hover and forward flight. Two model are assessed: the classical Brooks, Pope, and Marcolini (BPM) model and the data-driven Gill and Lee (GL) model. Both are verified against literature and validated and compared using scaled hover experiments and full-scale flyover measurements.
Results show that the GL model performs well in hover but overpredicts noise in forward flight. The BPM model provides more consistent predictions across operating conditions.
Thrust and weight estimation for Doc. 29 noise models
Using ACMS data to more accurately predict noise levels at Amsterdam Airport Schiphol
...
Multi-frequency Acoustic Mapping of Marine Benthos
Data-driven Multibeam Classification in the Dutch North Sea
Nevertheless, MBES-based benthic habitat mapping remains challenging. Limited seabed ground truth hinders model construction and evaluation. Lack of absolute calibration poses challenges when comparing or combining MBES backscatter across surveys. Backscatter angular dependency and large volume of multi-frequency measurements further complicate data processing. This thesis addresses these challenges by exploiting the multi-spectral MBES, making optimal use of limited ground truth, and improving the MBES data processing workflow.... ...
Nevertheless, MBES-based benthic habitat mapping remains challenging. Limited seabed ground truth hinders model construction and evaluation. Lack of absolute calibration poses challenges when comparing or combining MBES backscatter across surveys. Backscatter angular dependency and large volume of multi-frequency measurements further complicate data processing. This thesis addresses these challenges by exploiting the multi-spectral MBES, making optimal use of limited ground truth, and improving the MBES data processing workflow....
Aeroacoustic testing in acoustically disturbed environments
Improvements to closed test section wind tunnel experiments
The investigation of wall cavities for microphone placement was done with Computational Fluid Dynamics simulations, which in turn were validated experimentally. Cavities covered with a mesh cover were investigated, since previous literature shows that these reduce hydrodynamic noise while allowing for the transmission of waves to the microphones. The numerical simulations show that covering microphone cavities with a mesh cover results in a stagnant flow inside the cavities. As consequence, the only source of pressure fluctuations at the cavity bottoms are acoustic waves. The hydrodynamic pressure fluctuations from the wallβs boundary layer still propagate acoustically to the cavity bottoms. The findings show that increasing cavity size, by increasing the cavity opening diameter with respect to the length of the eddies in the turbulent boundary layer, leads to a lower propagation of spurious pressure fluctuations to the cavity bottoms. This in turn leads to an increased signal to noise ratio of acoustic measurements recorded at closed test section wind tunnels.
Wind tunnel wall liners have been characterized based on their viscous resistivity, inertial resistivity and roughness. Several porous liners have been tested experimentally. The aim was to analyze their impact on the aerodynamic properties of the wind tunnel boundary layer, on the generation of spurious noise, and on the absorption of acoustic reflections. The results show that the ideal choice of liner consists of a liner: with high viscous resistivity, which leads to high acoustic absorption; with low roughness, to reduce the impact on the wind tunnel wallβs boundary layer; and with low inertial resistivity, to reduce the generation of spurious noise. The best lining material tested was melamine foam.
The acoustic propagation and acoustic interference in a closed wind tunnel test section were predicted with a FEM acoustic solver. The propagation was modelled on a baseline test section, with fully reflective walls, and on test sections with lined walls. The numerical results were found to give a very accurate prediction of the acoustic experimental tests. It was possible to use the numerical results to improve the postβprocessing of experimental data. The Greenβs function used to process experimental microphone data with beamforming was corrected, using the numerical results. Beamforming with the Greenβs function corrected for the acoustically disturbed environment led to a higher beamforming spatial resolution. In addition, the estimated noise levels are more accurate when the correction is used. This improved approach was shown to work for postβprocessing experimental measurements of a monopole sound source placed at the center of the test section, with and without freeβstream flow.
...
The investigation of wall cavities for microphone placement was done with Computational Fluid Dynamics simulations, which in turn were validated experimentally. Cavities covered with a mesh cover were investigated, since previous literature shows that these reduce hydrodynamic noise while allowing for the transmission of waves to the microphones. The numerical simulations show that covering microphone cavities with a mesh cover results in a stagnant flow inside the cavities. As consequence, the only source of pressure fluctuations at the cavity bottoms are acoustic waves. The hydrodynamic pressure fluctuations from the wallβs boundary layer still propagate acoustically to the cavity bottoms. The findings show that increasing cavity size, by increasing the cavity opening diameter with respect to the length of the eddies in the turbulent boundary layer, leads to a lower propagation of spurious pressure fluctuations to the cavity bottoms. This in turn leads to an increased signal to noise ratio of acoustic measurements recorded at closed test section wind tunnels.
Wind tunnel wall liners have been characterized based on their viscous resistivity, inertial resistivity and roughness. Several porous liners have been tested experimentally. The aim was to analyze their impact on the aerodynamic properties of the wind tunnel boundary layer, on the generation of spurious noise, and on the absorption of acoustic reflections. The results show that the ideal choice of liner consists of a liner: with high viscous resistivity, which leads to high acoustic absorption; with low roughness, to reduce the impact on the wind tunnel wallβs boundary layer; and with low inertial resistivity, to reduce the generation of spurious noise. The best lining material tested was melamine foam.
The acoustic propagation and acoustic interference in a closed wind tunnel test section were predicted with a FEM acoustic solver. The propagation was modelled on a baseline test section, with fully reflective walls, and on test sections with lined walls. The numerical results were found to give a very accurate prediction of the acoustic experimental tests. It was possible to use the numerical results to improve the postβprocessing of experimental data. The Greenβs function used to process experimental microphone data with beamforming was corrected, using the numerical results. Beamforming with the Greenβs function corrected for the acoustically disturbed environment led to a higher beamforming spatial resolution. In addition, the estimated noise levels are more accurate when the correction is used. This improved approach was shown to work for postβprocessing experimental measurements of a monopole sound source placed at the center of the test section, with and without freeβstream flow.
The Rhine River plume
Unravelling its dynamics and sea-level contributions
Chapter 2 investigates the variability of the wind-driven response of the Rhine River plume using numerical model simulations of a spring-neap cycle forced by idealized wind conditions. The difference in wind-driven response between spring and neap tide shows how the competition between straining and mixing, both induced by tides and winds, determines the structure and evolution of the Rhine River plume.
Chapter 3 examines the plumeβs effect on sea-level variability along the Dutch coast by comparing barotropic and baroclinic model simulations. The Rhine plume induces a positive steric height anomaly, elevating the mean sea level along the coast and modulating the tidal signal near the river mouth. This highlights the need to include river plumes in sea-level studies.
In Chapters 4 and 5, an innovative method is developed for estimating sound speed profiles from multibeam echosounder measurements. The inversion method is based on minimizing the discrepancies between overlapping swaths and exploits empirical orthogonal functions to describe sound speed profiles using a limited number of unknowns. Since sound speed is influenced by depth, temperature, and salinity, this proof-of-concept provides a way to offer valuable insights into the vertical structure of the water column using routinely collected data.
Overall, this thesis advances our understanding of the Rhine River plume and its contribution to sea-level variability. In addition, the development of a proof-of-concept for retrieving sound speed profiles from multibeam echosounder measurements offers a promising approach to provide valuable information on stratification in river plumes. Together, these contributions support improved modelling and understanding of coastal oceans, particularly river plumes, which will become more and more important, especially in the face of climate change and its impact on coastal regions. ...
Chapter 2 investigates the variability of the wind-driven response of the Rhine River plume using numerical model simulations of a spring-neap cycle forced by idealized wind conditions. The difference in wind-driven response between spring and neap tide shows how the competition between straining and mixing, both induced by tides and winds, determines the structure and evolution of the Rhine River plume.
Chapter 3 examines the plumeβs effect on sea-level variability along the Dutch coast by comparing barotropic and baroclinic model simulations. The Rhine plume induces a positive steric height anomaly, elevating the mean sea level along the coast and modulating the tidal signal near the river mouth. This highlights the need to include river plumes in sea-level studies.
In Chapters 4 and 5, an innovative method is developed for estimating sound speed profiles from multibeam echosounder measurements. The inversion method is based on minimizing the discrepancies between overlapping swaths and exploits empirical orthogonal functions to describe sound speed profiles using a limited number of unknowns. Since sound speed is influenced by depth, temperature, and salinity, this proof-of-concept provides a way to offer valuable insights into the vertical structure of the water column using routinely collected data.
Overall, this thesis advances our understanding of the Rhine River plume and its contribution to sea-level variability. In addition, the development of a proof-of-concept for retrieving sound speed profiles from multibeam echosounder measurements offers a promising approach to provide valuable information on stratification in river plumes. Together, these contributions support improved modelling and understanding of coastal oceans, particularly river plumes, which will become more and more important, especially in the face of climate change and its impact on coastal regions.
Noise emissions and annoyance of sustainable aviation systems
Identifying noise sources and validating noise prediction models
Reducing the noise emissions and annoyance is only possible when the noise sources of an aircraft are known and can be predicted accurately during the design process. The objective of this dissertation is therefore to improve aircraft noise prediction models that can be used for reducing noise emissions and noise annoyance in the design process. This is specifically applied to currently operational sustainable aviation systems. ...
Reducing the noise emissions and annoyance is only possible when the noise sources of an aircraft are known and can be predicted accurately during the design process. The objective of this dissertation is therefore to improve aircraft noise prediction models that can be used for reducing noise emissions and noise annoyance in the design process. This is specifically applied to currently operational sustainable aviation systems.
On Understanding Environmental Inefficiencies in Air Traffic Management
A Causal Inference Approach
The research findings indicate that the ammonia-fueled sector generally exhibits higher air quality and human health impacts compared to conventional transport. We estimate that the implementation of various ammonia engine configurations into the road transportation fleet in the USA in 2011 could lead to approximately 23 000 to 250 000 premature mortalities.
However, there is potential for mitigating air quality impacts of ammonia emissions through the use of post-combustion treatment methods or the adoption of ammonia-fueled heavy-duty vehicles. These approaches could help achieve air pollution levels comparable to those of fossil fuel vehicles while reducing the carbon footprint, offering future possibilities for an ammonia-fueled road transportation sector. ...
The research findings indicate that the ammonia-fueled sector generally exhibits higher air quality and human health impacts compared to conventional transport. We estimate that the implementation of various ammonia engine configurations into the road transportation fleet in the USA in 2011 could lead to approximately 23 000 to 250 000 premature mortalities.
However, there is potential for mitigating air quality impacts of ammonia emissions through the use of post-combustion treatment methods or the adoption of ammonia-fueled heavy-duty vehicles. These approaches could help achieve air pollution levels comparable to those of fossil fuel vehicles while reducing the carbon footprint, offering future possibilities for an ammonia-fueled road transportation sector.
Using a hemisphere noise model to obtain a single event based ground noise prediction for the Apache helicopter
Prediction ground exposure noise for the Apache
For this research a set of flights has been selected, carefully keeping the limitations of both HELENA as well as Casper in mind. The most ideal flights would be steady, straight, symmetric and repeatable flights. Transit flights departing to or returning from a northeast positioned low-level flying area, encompass most of these requirements. These flights pass three NMTs. For a full year, all Apache flights passing these three NMTs were collected. The formation flights and flights with a maximum πΏπ΄,πππ₯ππ΅(π΄) relatively close to the background πΏπ΄,πππ₯ β€ 70ππ΅(π΄) were removed. In total 108 noise events were selected for the model-calculation comparison. In general, the noise events were underestimated by HELENA. The error, measurement minus calculation, showed a large difference with a mean ofπ = 4.9ππ΅(π΄) and variance of π = 2.9ππ΅(π΄). Upon closer inspection, the performance varied amongst the NMTs. One NMT (58) had the least noise events after selection but produced the largest difference between measurement and calculation (π = 8.8ππ΅(π΄) and variance π = 3.3ππ΅(π΄)). The NMT with the most (70) noise events produced the smallest error with a mean (π = 4.2ππ΅(π΄)) and variance (π = 2.4ππ΅(π΄)). The underestimation could be due to certain circumstances that influence the measurement but are not included in the calculation. No correlation could be found for the presence of wind, deviation in speed relative to the speed of the corresponding hemisphere, distance or addition of ground effect. ...
For this research a set of flights has been selected, carefully keeping the limitations of both HELENA as well as Casper in mind. The most ideal flights would be steady, straight, symmetric and repeatable flights. Transit flights departing to or returning from a northeast positioned low-level flying area, encompass most of these requirements. These flights pass three NMTs. For a full year, all Apache flights passing these three NMTs were collected. The formation flights and flights with a maximum πΏπ΄,πππ₯ππ΅(π΄) relatively close to the background πΏπ΄,πππ₯ β€ 70ππ΅(π΄) were removed. In total 108 noise events were selected for the model-calculation comparison. In general, the noise events were underestimated by HELENA. The error, measurement minus calculation, showed a large difference with a mean ofπ = 4.9ππ΅(π΄) and variance of π = 2.9ππ΅(π΄). Upon closer inspection, the performance varied amongst the NMTs. One NMT (58) had the least noise events after selection but produced the largest difference between measurement and calculation (π = 8.8ππ΅(π΄) and variance π = 3.3ππ΅(π΄)). The NMT with the most (70) noise events produced the smallest error with a mean (π = 4.2ππ΅(π΄)) and variance (π = 2.4ππ΅(π΄)). The underestimation could be due to certain circumstances that influence the measurement but are not included in the calculation. No correlation could be found for the presence of wind, deviation in speed relative to the speed of the corresponding hemisphere, distance or addition of ground effect.
Aerodynamic noise produced by aircraft, wind turbines, and other objects subjected to airflow contribute to environmental noise pollution, which adversely affects human and animal health. Consequently, governments impose restrictions on aircraft and wind turbine noise levels. These restrictions can have an economic impact by limiting aircraft traffic and reducing wind turbine energy production. Accordingly, improving the design of aerodynamic surfaces to reduce their noise levels benefits health while enabling improved operational efficiency. Therefore, aeroacoustic research focuses on identifying and understanding the physical mechanisms behind aerodynamic noise to improve noise mitigation technologies. This research relies on acoustic wind tunnel measurements to validate simulations, theories, and design improvements.
Closed test section wind tunnels are widely used for aerodynamic testing but are less suitable for acoustic measurements because microphones must be installed in the wall. This location subjects the microphones to pressure fluctuations from the turbulent boundary layer (TBL), which contaminates acoustic measurements and reduces the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). The impact of the TBL can be mitigated by recessing microphones within cavities and covering them with an acoustically transparent material. Modifying existing wind tunnel walls by installing cavity--mounted microphones is a straightforward and cost-effective improvement that enables combined aerodynamic and acoustic measurement campaigns.
The cavity geometry, i.e., depth, aperture size, wall angle, and presence of a covering determines the amount of TBL attenuation and consequently the improvement to SNR. While several studies have shown empirically that these parameters have an effect, few studies focus on identifying the physical mechanisms that explain the relationship between geometry and the reduction in TBL pressure fluctuations at the microphone. Thus, this thesis aims to identify these physical mechanisms through experiments and different modeling approaches to better explain the relationship between cavity geometry, the amount of TBL attenuation, and the subsequent impact on the measured acoustic signal.
Experimental data were collected to develop an empirical model to quantify how varying cavity geometry affects the measured pressure spectra. Moreover, experiments were also performed to validate simulation results and to quantify the SNR improvement when applying a beamforming algorithm to microphone array data. The modeling and simulation efforts focus on explaining the trends and phenomena identified in the experimental data. Initially, a physical model was developed that assumed acoustic propagation into an axisymmetric cavity with a constant cross-section. This model decomposes a pressure field, resulting from a TBL, into circular duct modes and was used to evaluate the relationship between cavity geometry and the propagation of these acoustic modes into the cavity. This model was followed up with a finite element method (FEM) simulation to study the influence of different cavity geometric parameters and wall materials on the acoustic response of the cavity when subjected to an acoustic wave.
The FEM simulation showed that the cavity's acoustic response is determined by the presence of standing waves in the form of acoustic depth modes. This simulation showed that cavities with angled walls have depth modes with lower amplitude waves and thus distort the acoustic signal less. Furthermore, it is shown that the acoustic responses of cavities formed out of sound-absorbing foam are driven by the shape of the foam holder and not the cavity shapes within the foam. Thus, the holder can be optimized to minimize the acoustic response, while the cavity itself can be optimized to reduce the influence of the TBL. Building upon these simulations, a Lattice Boltzmann based computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method was used to simulate the pressure and flow fields within three uncovered cavities and covered cavities resulting from the presence of a turbulent boundary layer.
The CFD simulations confirmed a significant finding of the physical model, that the amount of TBL attenuation increases as the cavity aperture size increases relative to the TBL streamwise coherence length. This is due to the resulting modal decomposition of the pressure field above larger cavities having more energy distributed across higher-order modes than for smaller cavities. These higher-order modes decay exponentially into the cavity, resulting in increased attenuation of the TBL. Smaller cavities have most of their energy in their first mode, which does not decay with increasing cavity depth. Furthermore, these simulations showed that the pressure field within covered cavities is primarily acoustic and can be decomposed into acoustic circular duct modes. Since the propagation of TBL pressure fluctuations into covered cavities is primarily acoustic, the shape of future cavities can be efficiently optimized using FEM simulations.
Finally, beamforming used with cavities improved the acoustic measurement SNR. Analysis shows that the improvements due to beamforming are independent of those attributed to the cavity geometry. Thus, combining the two approaches improves the SNR of acoustic measurements in closed test section wind tunnels.
...
Aerodynamic noise produced by aircraft, wind turbines, and other objects subjected to airflow contribute to environmental noise pollution, which adversely affects human and animal health. Consequently, governments impose restrictions on aircraft and wind turbine noise levels. These restrictions can have an economic impact by limiting aircraft traffic and reducing wind turbine energy production. Accordingly, improving the design of aerodynamic surfaces to reduce their noise levels benefits health while enabling improved operational efficiency. Therefore, aeroacoustic research focuses on identifying and understanding the physical mechanisms behind aerodynamic noise to improve noise mitigation technologies. This research relies on acoustic wind tunnel measurements to validate simulations, theories, and design improvements.
Closed test section wind tunnels are widely used for aerodynamic testing but are less suitable for acoustic measurements because microphones must be installed in the wall. This location subjects the microphones to pressure fluctuations from the turbulent boundary layer (TBL), which contaminates acoustic measurements and reduces the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). The impact of the TBL can be mitigated by recessing microphones within cavities and covering them with an acoustically transparent material. Modifying existing wind tunnel walls by installing cavity--mounted microphones is a straightforward and cost-effective improvement that enables combined aerodynamic and acoustic measurement campaigns.
The cavity geometry, i.e., depth, aperture size, wall angle, and presence of a covering determines the amount of TBL attenuation and consequently the improvement to SNR. While several studies have shown empirically that these parameters have an effect, few studies focus on identifying the physical mechanisms that explain the relationship between geometry and the reduction in TBL pressure fluctuations at the microphone. Thus, this thesis aims to identify these physical mechanisms through experiments and different modeling approaches to better explain the relationship between cavity geometry, the amount of TBL attenuation, and the subsequent impact on the measured acoustic signal.
Experimental data were collected to develop an empirical model to quantify how varying cavity geometry affects the measured pressure spectra. Moreover, experiments were also performed to validate simulation results and to quantify the SNR improvement when applying a beamforming algorithm to microphone array data. The modeling and simulation efforts focus on explaining the trends and phenomena identified in the experimental data. Initially, a physical model was developed that assumed acoustic propagation into an axisymmetric cavity with a constant cross-section. This model decomposes a pressure field, resulting from a TBL, into circular duct modes and was used to evaluate the relationship between cavity geometry and the propagation of these acoustic modes into the cavity. This model was followed up with a finite element method (FEM) simulation to study the influence of different cavity geometric parameters and wall materials on the acoustic response of the cavity when subjected to an acoustic wave.
The FEM simulation showed that the cavity's acoustic response is determined by the presence of standing waves in the form of acoustic depth modes. This simulation showed that cavities with angled walls have depth modes with lower amplitude waves and thus distort the acoustic signal less. Furthermore, it is shown that the acoustic responses of cavities formed out of sound-absorbing foam are driven by the shape of the foam holder and not the cavity shapes within the foam. Thus, the holder can be optimized to minimize the acoustic response, while the cavity itself can be optimized to reduce the influence of the TBL. Building upon these simulations, a Lattice Boltzmann based computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method was used to simulate the pressure and flow fields within three uncovered cavities and covered cavities resulting from the presence of a turbulent boundary layer.
The CFD simulations confirmed a significant finding of the physical model, that the amount of TBL attenuation increases as the cavity aperture size increases relative to the TBL streamwise coherence length. This is due to the resulting modal decomposition of the pressure field above larger cavities having more energy distributed across higher-order modes than for smaller cavities. These higher-order modes decay exponentially into the cavity, resulting in increased attenuation of the TBL. Smaller cavities have most of their energy in their first mode, which does not decay with increasing cavity depth. Furthermore, these simulations showed that the pressure field within covered cavities is primarily acoustic and can be decomposed into acoustic circular duct modes. Since the propagation of TBL pressure fluctuations into covered cavities is primarily acoustic, the shape of future cavities can be efficiently optimized using FEM simulations.
Finally, beamforming used with cavities improved the acoustic measurement SNR. Analysis shows that the improvements due to beamforming are independent of those attributed to the cavity geometry. Thus, combining the two approaches improves the SNR of acoustic measurements in closed test section wind tunnels.