V. Grewe
Please Note
20 records found
1
The Climate Impact of Stratospheric Water Vapour Caused by Aviation Emissions
A Simplified Climate Response Modelling Framework Implemented in OpenAirClim
This thesis develops and evaluates a method to represent aviation-induced changes in stratospheric water vapour within the OpenAirClim (OAC) response model. The novelty of this work lies in the quantification of SWV changes due to methane oxidation within a reduced-form climate response model, enabling fast yet process-consistent scenario analysis. Other potential SWV pathways are assessed but not explicitly implemented due to methodological limitations, overlap with existing OAC modules, or negligible expected impact.
The implementation is verified through consistency checks on fractional release factors, age-of-air distributions, spatial SWV patterns, and mass conservation, and validated against published results. A sensitivity and uncertainty analysis is performed to assess the robustness of the calculated radiative forcing, followed by scenario analyses illustrating the relative magnitude of SWV forcing compared to methane-related effects for different future aviation scenarios. The results demonstrate that aviation-induced reductions in methane lead to a net decrease in SWV and associated radiative forcing, highlighting the importance of including SWV effects for a more complete assessment of aviation's climate impact within simplified climate models. ...
This thesis develops and evaluates a method to represent aviation-induced changes in stratospheric water vapour within the OpenAirClim (OAC) response model. The novelty of this work lies in the quantification of SWV changes due to methane oxidation within a reduced-form climate response model, enabling fast yet process-consistent scenario analysis. Other potential SWV pathways are assessed but not explicitly implemented due to methodological limitations, overlap with existing OAC modules, or negligible expected impact.
The implementation is verified through consistency checks on fractional release factors, age-of-air distributions, spatial SWV patterns, and mass conservation, and validated against published results. A sensitivity and uncertainty analysis is performed to assess the robustness of the calculated radiative forcing, followed by scenario analyses illustrating the relative magnitude of SWV forcing compared to methane-related effects for different future aviation scenarios. The results demonstrate that aviation-induced reductions in methane lead to a net decrease in SWV and associated radiative forcing, highlighting the importance of including SWV effects for a more complete assessment of aviation's climate impact within simplified climate models.
In this thesis, a double-box aircraft exhaust plume model is developed by extending the framework of the well-established MADE3 single-box model, incorporating additional parametrisation to capture the spatial and temporal evolution of aerosol dynamics within the aircraft exhaust plume. The plume model is designed to explicitly simulate the aerosol microphysics inside a gradually dispersing aircraft exhaust plume, together with a simplified representation of the vortex regime (starting ∼10 s behind the aircraft) which simulates the interaction of aerosols with short-lived contrail ice particles. This thesis primarily focuses on sulfate (SO4) and soot aerosols, together with the total number concentration of aerosols emitted in the exhaust plume of an aircraft. The model is specifically designed to provide a more accurate representation of the microphysical processes occurring within an aircraft exhaust plume which alters the aerosol dynamics at the plume scale. The plume model is initialised at the end of the jet phase, approximately 10 seconds after the emission, using measured initial size distribution parameters for standard aircraft operating conditions together with other aircraft operational and emission parameters such as fuel consumption, speed, and emission factors of emitted species. In order to ensure the validity of the double-box plume model, I performed different numerical and parametric tests. The numerical tests confirmed the correct implementation of the extension from single- to double-box plume model. The parametric study in combination with the tendency diagnostics showed that the model reliably captures the expected sensitivity of aerosol number and size to several physical parameters, in line with theory and with previous global applications of MADE3.
The plume model is used to quantify the aviation-induced particle number concentration at the end of the dispersion regime (∼46 h) by comparing the results from the plume approach with the results obtained by the instantaneous dispersion approach commonly applied by the global models. The difference between the plume approach and the instantaneous dispersion approach allows to define a plume correction: for typical cruise conditions over the North Atlantic and typical aviation emission parameters, the plume correction for aviation-induced particle number concentration ranges between –15% and –4% as quantified for the first time in this study, depending on the presence or absence of the short-lived contrail ice in the vortex regime, respectively. These negative corrections indicate that the plume approach simulates a lower aviation induced particle number concentration than the instantaneous dispersion.
In order to understand the influence of the microphysical processes and diffusion dynamics on the aerosol evolution inside an aircraft plume, tendency diagnostics are implemented in the plume model to track the impact of the individual processes on the aerosol properties. This analysis shows that the negative value of the plume correction is due to the higher efficiency of the coagulation in the plume model, partly counteracted by nucleation, leading to a lower number concentration of aviation-induced particles in the plume approach. Sensitivity studies performed over different regions highlight a large variability in the plume correction between –12% for Europe and –43% for China, thus signifying the importance of background conditions for the plume microphysics. Parametric studies performed on various aviation emission parameters used to initialise the plume model further demonstrate the high relevance of short-lived contrail ice in the vortex regime, which accounts for the aerosol-ice interaction. These interactions lead to a considerable reduction in aviation-induced aerosol number concentrations, particularly in the early stages of plume evolution. Moreover, the parametric studies show a large sensitivity towards aviation fuel sulfur content (FSC), driving sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions and gas-phase sulfuric acid (H2SO4) formation, which in turn is a primary driver for the nucleation process.
The double-box aircraft exhaust plumemodelMADE3 (v4.0) presented in this thesis is ready for application in global model studies. The model configuration is highly flexible with low computational costs which means that it can be effectively implemented for both online and offline parametrisation. The results from the plume model can be used to better initialise the aviation emissions in global model simulations and can contribute to a refined quantification of the climate impact of aviation-induced aerosol particles on clouds.
...
In this thesis, a double-box aircraft exhaust plume model is developed by extending the framework of the well-established MADE3 single-box model, incorporating additional parametrisation to capture the spatial and temporal evolution of aerosol dynamics within the aircraft exhaust plume. The plume model is designed to explicitly simulate the aerosol microphysics inside a gradually dispersing aircraft exhaust plume, together with a simplified representation of the vortex regime (starting ∼10 s behind the aircraft) which simulates the interaction of aerosols with short-lived contrail ice particles. This thesis primarily focuses on sulfate (SO4) and soot aerosols, together with the total number concentration of aerosols emitted in the exhaust plume of an aircraft. The model is specifically designed to provide a more accurate representation of the microphysical processes occurring within an aircraft exhaust plume which alters the aerosol dynamics at the plume scale. The plume model is initialised at the end of the jet phase, approximately 10 seconds after the emission, using measured initial size distribution parameters for standard aircraft operating conditions together with other aircraft operational and emission parameters such as fuel consumption, speed, and emission factors of emitted species. In order to ensure the validity of the double-box plume model, I performed different numerical and parametric tests. The numerical tests confirmed the correct implementation of the extension from single- to double-box plume model. The parametric study in combination with the tendency diagnostics showed that the model reliably captures the expected sensitivity of aerosol number and size to several physical parameters, in line with theory and with previous global applications of MADE3.
The plume model is used to quantify the aviation-induced particle number concentration at the end of the dispersion regime (∼46 h) by comparing the results from the plume approach with the results obtained by the instantaneous dispersion approach commonly applied by the global models. The difference between the plume approach and the instantaneous dispersion approach allows to define a plume correction: for typical cruise conditions over the North Atlantic and typical aviation emission parameters, the plume correction for aviation-induced particle number concentration ranges between –15% and –4% as quantified for the first time in this study, depending on the presence or absence of the short-lived contrail ice in the vortex regime, respectively. These negative corrections indicate that the plume approach simulates a lower aviation induced particle number concentration than the instantaneous dispersion.
In order to understand the influence of the microphysical processes and diffusion dynamics on the aerosol evolution inside an aircraft plume, tendency diagnostics are implemented in the plume model to track the impact of the individual processes on the aerosol properties. This analysis shows that the negative value of the plume correction is due to the higher efficiency of the coagulation in the plume model, partly counteracted by nucleation, leading to a lower number concentration of aviation-induced particles in the plume approach. Sensitivity studies performed over different regions highlight a large variability in the plume correction between –12% for Europe and –43% for China, thus signifying the importance of background conditions for the plume microphysics. Parametric studies performed on various aviation emission parameters used to initialise the plume model further demonstrate the high relevance of short-lived contrail ice in the vortex regime, which accounts for the aerosol-ice interaction. These interactions lead to a considerable reduction in aviation-induced aerosol number concentrations, particularly in the early stages of plume evolution. Moreover, the parametric studies show a large sensitivity towards aviation fuel sulfur content (FSC), driving sulfur dioxide (SO2) emissions and gas-phase sulfuric acid (H2SO4) formation, which in turn is a primary driver for the nucleation process.
The double-box aircraft exhaust plumemodelMADE3 (v4.0) presented in this thesis is ready for application in global model studies. The model configuration is highly flexible with low computational costs which means that it can be effectively implemented for both online and offline parametrisation. The results from the plume model can be used to better initialise the aviation emissions in global model simulations and can contribute to a refined quantification of the climate impact of aviation-induced aerosol particles on clouds.
The Climate Impact of Hydrogen Leakage in Aviation
A Machine Learning Approach to Long-Term Scenario Forecasting
State-of-the-art Earth system models are used for simulations, and results calculated with the EMAC model are subsequently compared with simulations performed elsewhere with the LMDZ-INCA model. The comparison to a third model, i.e. WACCM, with a very similar – but independent – model setup allows even further clarification. For model validation satellite measurements (ozone, water vapor) and aircraft measurements (ozone, water vapor, temperature) are taken into account.
After the introduction in the first chapter, the second chapter is a general description of the Earth system including anthropogenic perturbations, in particular perturbations from subsonic, supersonic and hypersonic aircraft emissions followed by a detailed explanation of methods and the EMAC model setup in the third chapter. A new research finding in the context of middle atmospheric chemistry is the increased methane and nitric acid oxidation following hypersonic emissions. This effect results in a (photo-)chemical net production of water vapor and eventually increases water vapor perturbations further, which is described in detail in chapter 4. In chapter 5 an analysis of atmospheric dynamics and transport of emitted trace gases in the middle atmosphere underlines the importance of the Brewer-Dobson circulation and shows the impact of polar stratospheric clouds on water vapor perturbations during polar winter. The evaluation of multiple hypersonic aircraft designed for different cruise altitudes shows that their climate impact increases with cruise altitude and can be approximately 10-20 times as much as a conventional aircraft (chapter 6). Emissions at different hypersonic cruise altitude and latitude regions show that the climate impact can vary more with latitude of emission than with altitude of emission (chapter 7). With rf_of_hypersonic_trajectories() a software was developed to estimate the climate impact of aircraft design and flight trajectory/network options in seconds based on robust results from Earth system modelling. Using the software it is shown that a cruise altitude optimization loop can reduce the overall climate impact of a state-of-the-art aircraft design (chapter 8).
There are two methodological highlights to mention in the context of the EMAC model. The first is a new MESSy submodel H2OEMIS, which was created as part of this thesis. H2OEMIS is an interface to include water vapor emissions in EMAC model simulations, which was not possible before. This submodel will generally be of interest for future evaluations of e.g. any vehicles emitting water vapor and the impact of volcanic eruptions with EMAC. The secondmethodological highlight is the application of a novel speed-up technique during simulation runs, which reduces the simulated years by twothirds. To conclude the summary, the four following points are important to take away. This thesis brought
• A new research finding on middle atmospheric chemistry: The identification of a chemical feedback that enhances the water vapor perturbation lifetime albeit an increasing chemical water vapor destruction
• A robust estimate of the climate impact of hypersonic aircraft for both specific aircraft designs and general atmospheric and radiative sensitivities showing a large altitude and latitude dependence
• An easily accessible tool for researchers and companies to estimate the climate impact of new hypersonic aircraft designs with low cost and low time
• An estimate how the development of hypersonic aircraft would contribute to a road map to a climate optimal aircraft industry compared to conventional aircraft
...
State-of-the-art Earth system models are used for simulations, and results calculated with the EMAC model are subsequently compared with simulations performed elsewhere with the LMDZ-INCA model. The comparison to a third model, i.e. WACCM, with a very similar – but independent – model setup allows even further clarification. For model validation satellite measurements (ozone, water vapor) and aircraft measurements (ozone, water vapor, temperature) are taken into account.
After the introduction in the first chapter, the second chapter is a general description of the Earth system including anthropogenic perturbations, in particular perturbations from subsonic, supersonic and hypersonic aircraft emissions followed by a detailed explanation of methods and the EMAC model setup in the third chapter. A new research finding in the context of middle atmospheric chemistry is the increased methane and nitric acid oxidation following hypersonic emissions. This effect results in a (photo-)chemical net production of water vapor and eventually increases water vapor perturbations further, which is described in detail in chapter 4. In chapter 5 an analysis of atmospheric dynamics and transport of emitted trace gases in the middle atmosphere underlines the importance of the Brewer-Dobson circulation and shows the impact of polar stratospheric clouds on water vapor perturbations during polar winter. The evaluation of multiple hypersonic aircraft designed for different cruise altitudes shows that their climate impact increases with cruise altitude and can be approximately 10-20 times as much as a conventional aircraft (chapter 6). Emissions at different hypersonic cruise altitude and latitude regions show that the climate impact can vary more with latitude of emission than with altitude of emission (chapter 7). With rf_of_hypersonic_trajectories() a software was developed to estimate the climate impact of aircraft design and flight trajectory/network options in seconds based on robust results from Earth system modelling. Using the software it is shown that a cruise altitude optimization loop can reduce the overall climate impact of a state-of-the-art aircraft design (chapter 8).
There are two methodological highlights to mention in the context of the EMAC model. The first is a new MESSy submodel H2OEMIS, which was created as part of this thesis. H2OEMIS is an interface to include water vapor emissions in EMAC model simulations, which was not possible before. This submodel will generally be of interest for future evaluations of e.g. any vehicles emitting water vapor and the impact of volcanic eruptions with EMAC. The secondmethodological highlight is the application of a novel speed-up technique during simulation runs, which reduces the simulated years by twothirds. To conclude the summary, the four following points are important to take away. This thesis brought
• A new research finding on middle atmospheric chemistry: The identification of a chemical feedback that enhances the water vapor perturbation lifetime albeit an increasing chemical water vapor destruction
• A robust estimate of the climate impact of hypersonic aircraft for both specific aircraft designs and general atmospheric and radiative sensitivities showing a large altitude and latitude dependence
• An easily accessible tool for researchers and companies to estimate the climate impact of new hypersonic aircraft designs with low cost and low time
• An estimate how the development of hypersonic aircraft would contribute to a road map to a climate optimal aircraft industry compared to conventional aircraft
To address these issues, this thesis first analyses algorithmic climate change functions (aCCFs), a simple surrogate model obtained by regressing the CCFs against local atmospheric variables. The aCCFs are computationally inexpensive to run since they only use few meteorological inputs to estimate climate impact, enabling real-time flight trajectory optimisation on arbitrary days. However, aCCFs are applicable only in parts of the Northern Hemisphere and require thorough verification before implementation. The focus is narrowed down on local aviation NOx effects on climate change, which largely causes warming via short-term increase in tropospheric ozone (O3) and is characterised by large variability. This necessitates a detailed investigation of NOx-O3 effects in isolation and its mitigation, which is a previously unexplored area. After verifying the O3 aCCFs through complex climate-chemistry model simulations, it is concluded that while it enables a reasonable first estimate, there are a few discrepancies.
TheO3 aCCFs are replaced by using a more comprehensive dataset comprising global NOx-O3 impacts, identifying additional physical variables that influence this impact, and using this information to train stochastic surrogates based on homoscedastic and heteroscedastic Gaussian processes. These models provide mean and uncertainty estimates for the climate impact of NOx on O3, for the first time. The heteroscedastic model more accurately reproduces the data distribution and its ease of use in predicting the climate impact of individual flights is demonstrated. Defined as probabilistic aCCFs (paCCFs), these models demonstrate superior accuracy over aCCFs, provide valuable insights for aviation’s non-CO2 effects, and offer broader implications for climateoptimised flight planning. The thesis concludes with limitations and recommendations to furthermitigate aviation’s environmental impact. ...
To address these issues, this thesis first analyses algorithmic climate change functions (aCCFs), a simple surrogate model obtained by regressing the CCFs against local atmospheric variables. The aCCFs are computationally inexpensive to run since they only use few meteorological inputs to estimate climate impact, enabling real-time flight trajectory optimisation on arbitrary days. However, aCCFs are applicable only in parts of the Northern Hemisphere and require thorough verification before implementation. The focus is narrowed down on local aviation NOx effects on climate change, which largely causes warming via short-term increase in tropospheric ozone (O3) and is characterised by large variability. This necessitates a detailed investigation of NOx-O3 effects in isolation and its mitigation, which is a previously unexplored area. After verifying the O3 aCCFs through complex climate-chemistry model simulations, it is concluded that while it enables a reasonable first estimate, there are a few discrepancies.
TheO3 aCCFs are replaced by using a more comprehensive dataset comprising global NOx-O3 impacts, identifying additional physical variables that influence this impact, and using this information to train stochastic surrogates based on homoscedastic and heteroscedastic Gaussian processes. These models provide mean and uncertainty estimates for the climate impact of NOx on O3, for the first time. The heteroscedastic model more accurately reproduces the data distribution and its ease of use in predicting the climate impact of individual flights is demonstrated. Defined as probabilistic aCCFs (paCCFs), these models demonstrate superior accuracy over aCCFs, provide valuable insights for aviation’s non-CO2 effects, and offer broader implications for climateoptimised flight planning. The thesis concludes with limitations and recommendations to furthermitigate aviation’s environmental impact.
The mass of liquid water contained in an SLD is several orders of magnitude higher than the mass contained in a typical small cloud droplet. However, the number concentration of SLDs is much lower than that of small cloud droplets, consequently, it is challenging to detect SLDs with instruments. As of now, no instruments for the detection of SLD icing conditions are in use on commercial aircraft.
This thesis investigates a combination of two instruments for the detection of SLD icing conditions. The first instrument is the Nevzorov probe for the measurement of liquid and total water content and the second instrument is the Backscatter Cloud Probe with Polarization Detection (BCPD), a non-invasive laser backscatter probe that measures the size and shape of cloud particles between 2 and 42 µm. The Nevzorov probe used in this work carried a new, 12 mm diameter total water content sensor that was added to the instrument specifically for the measurement of SLD icing conditions. Both instruments, the Nevzorov probe and the BCPD, are first analyzed individually in icing wind tunnel tests. The findings from the tests show that the new 12 mm sensor of the Nevzorov probe captures SLDs effectively. No indication was found of SLD being incompletely evaporated due to splashing or of water being swept out of the cone. The collision efficiency of small droplets with the sensor is low and can be compensated with a correction derived in this work. Intensive atmospheric testing ensued the icing wind tunnel measurements. During measurements in Arctic clouds, it could be shown that the fraction of liquid and glaciated particles can be estimated from the BCPD. Measurements in the South of France were able to demonstrate that the detection and discrimination of SLD icing conditions is possible with the Nevzorov probe and the BCPD for SLD icing encounters that are sufficiently long and contain a high number of SLDs.
The results of this work allow future flight campaigns to use the 12 mm sensor of the Nevzorov probe and benefit from its capture efficiency and better sampling statistics. The comparisons of the Nevzorov probe to other instruments can help scientists choose suitable instrumentation for future icing wind tunnel and flight campaigns. Concerning the BCPD, a new method developed in this thesis to estimate the number of ice and water particles could, with small modifications, also be employed for other instruments that use polarization filters. For the detection and discrimination of SLD conditions, future work should focus on extending the sample area of the BCPD further outward from the aircraft skin to measure particle size distributions that are unaffected by the aircraft boundary layer. Furthermore, the false alarm rate of the system could be reduced by incorporating an instrument similar to the BCPD but with a larger size range and larger sample area for the direct detection of SLDs. ...
The mass of liquid water contained in an SLD is several orders of magnitude higher than the mass contained in a typical small cloud droplet. However, the number concentration of SLDs is much lower than that of small cloud droplets, consequently, it is challenging to detect SLDs with instruments. As of now, no instruments for the detection of SLD icing conditions are in use on commercial aircraft.
This thesis investigates a combination of two instruments for the detection of SLD icing conditions. The first instrument is the Nevzorov probe for the measurement of liquid and total water content and the second instrument is the Backscatter Cloud Probe with Polarization Detection (BCPD), a non-invasive laser backscatter probe that measures the size and shape of cloud particles between 2 and 42 µm. The Nevzorov probe used in this work carried a new, 12 mm diameter total water content sensor that was added to the instrument specifically for the measurement of SLD icing conditions. Both instruments, the Nevzorov probe and the BCPD, are first analyzed individually in icing wind tunnel tests. The findings from the tests show that the new 12 mm sensor of the Nevzorov probe captures SLDs effectively. No indication was found of SLD being incompletely evaporated due to splashing or of water being swept out of the cone. The collision efficiency of small droplets with the sensor is low and can be compensated with a correction derived in this work. Intensive atmospheric testing ensued the icing wind tunnel measurements. During measurements in Arctic clouds, it could be shown that the fraction of liquid and glaciated particles can be estimated from the BCPD. Measurements in the South of France were able to demonstrate that the detection and discrimination of SLD icing conditions is possible with the Nevzorov probe and the BCPD for SLD icing encounters that are sufficiently long and contain a high number of SLDs.
The results of this work allow future flight campaigns to use the 12 mm sensor of the Nevzorov probe and benefit from its capture efficiency and better sampling statistics. The comparisons of the Nevzorov probe to other instruments can help scientists choose suitable instrumentation for future icing wind tunnel and flight campaigns. Concerning the BCPD, a new method developed in this thesis to estimate the number of ice and water particles could, with small modifications, also be employed for other instruments that use polarization filters. For the detection and discrimination of SLD conditions, future work should focus on extending the sample area of the BCPD further outward from the aircraft skin to measure particle size distributions that are unaffected by the aircraft boundary layer. Furthermore, the false alarm rate of the system could be reduced by incorporating an instrument similar to the BCPD but with a larger size range and larger sample area for the direct detection of SLDs.
Cirrus clouds play a crucial role in the Earth’s energy budget. They reflect incoming sunlight and absorb and re-emit terrestrial infrarred radiation. The magnitude of these components depends on the cirrus micro physical properties (e.g., ice crystal number and effective diameter), which can result in either net warming or cooling effects. This thesis investigates the differences in those properties of high- and mid-latitude cirrus, as well as their interactions with atmospheric aerosol and aviation-induced contrail cirrus. To explore these differences, cirrus clouds were measured with the German research aircraft HALO (High Altitude and LOng Range) during the CIRRUS-HL (CIRRUS at High Latitudes) campaign in June and July 2021. A total of 24 flights and 35 hours of in situ measurements of cirrus particle data were collected with the Cloud Droplet Probe (CDP), the Cloud Imaging Probe Grayscale (CIPG) and the Precipitation Imaging Probe (PIP). A comprehensive intercomparison among the instruments, along with a detailed uncertainty analysis, was performed, resulting in an accurate and quality-controlled data set. The results of these measurements show that high-latitude cirrus, compared to mid latitude cirrus, have lower median ice number concentration (0.001 and 0.0086 cm−3), higher median effective diameter (210 and 165 μm), and lower median extinction coefficient (0.042 and 0.072 m−1, respectively). In addition, high relative humidity over ice is observed, particularly at high latitudes, with median values around 125%. The influence of the formation region on cirrus properties was assessed by combining measurements with weather model data and backward trajectories starting at the flight tracks. The results show that a large part of the high-latitude cirrus were formed at mid-latitudes, leading to different properties compared to cirrus formed directly at high latitudes. Simulations from an aerosol-chemistry-climate model were combined with the backward trajectories and a strong contribution of heterogeneous nucleation was identified in the measured cirrus. Thus, the low concentrations of ice nucleating particles at high latitudes (from the model) combined with high ice supersaturation levels might explain the lower ice number concentration and larger effective diameter of cirrus measurements at high latitudes compared to mid-latitudes. Aviation emissions have a large local impact on the cirrus microphysical properties through contrail formation and their evolution to contrail cirrus. The CIRRUS-HL data set shows a higher occurrence of contrail cirrus at mid-latitudes, and a potential impact on natural cloudiness by reducing supersaturation levels at cirrus altitudes. The effect of contrails from future propulsion technologies may depend on background aerosol concentrations. Comparisons of measurements and model data for total aerosol number concentrations show good agreement for the larger particle size mode (> 250nm), but likely an underestimation above 300 hPa in the Aitken mode (> 12nm). By combining observations with model data, this study contributes to enhancing the understanding of the variability in cirrus properties due to different formation mechanisms and aerosol influences, as well as the interaction of natural and contrail cirrus. ...
Cirrus clouds play a crucial role in the Earth’s energy budget. They reflect incoming sunlight and absorb and re-emit terrestrial infrarred radiation. The magnitude of these components depends on the cirrus micro physical properties (e.g., ice crystal number and effective diameter), which can result in either net warming or cooling effects. This thesis investigates the differences in those properties of high- and mid-latitude cirrus, as well as their interactions with atmospheric aerosol and aviation-induced contrail cirrus. To explore these differences, cirrus clouds were measured with the German research aircraft HALO (High Altitude and LOng Range) during the CIRRUS-HL (CIRRUS at High Latitudes) campaign in June and July 2021. A total of 24 flights and 35 hours of in situ measurements of cirrus particle data were collected with the Cloud Droplet Probe (CDP), the Cloud Imaging Probe Grayscale (CIPG) and the Precipitation Imaging Probe (PIP). A comprehensive intercomparison among the instruments, along with a detailed uncertainty analysis, was performed, resulting in an accurate and quality-controlled data set. The results of these measurements show that high-latitude cirrus, compared to mid latitude cirrus, have lower median ice number concentration (0.001 and 0.0086 cm−3), higher median effective diameter (210 and 165 μm), and lower median extinction coefficient (0.042 and 0.072 m−1, respectively). In addition, high relative humidity over ice is observed, particularly at high latitudes, with median values around 125%. The influence of the formation region on cirrus properties was assessed by combining measurements with weather model data and backward trajectories starting at the flight tracks. The results show that a large part of the high-latitude cirrus were formed at mid-latitudes, leading to different properties compared to cirrus formed directly at high latitudes. Simulations from an aerosol-chemistry-climate model were combined with the backward trajectories and a strong contribution of heterogeneous nucleation was identified in the measured cirrus. Thus, the low concentrations of ice nucleating particles at high latitudes (from the model) combined with high ice supersaturation levels might explain the lower ice number concentration and larger effective diameter of cirrus measurements at high latitudes compared to mid-latitudes. Aviation emissions have a large local impact on the cirrus microphysical properties through contrail formation and their evolution to contrail cirrus. The CIRRUS-HL data set shows a higher occurrence of contrail cirrus at mid-latitudes, and a potential impact on natural cloudiness by reducing supersaturation levels at cirrus altitudes. The effect of contrails from future propulsion technologies may depend on background aerosol concentrations. Comparisons of measurements and model data for total aerosol number concentrations show good agreement for the larger particle size mode (> 250nm), but likely an underestimation above 300 hPa in the Aitken mode (> 12nm). By combining observations with model data, this study contributes to enhancing the understanding of the variability in cirrus properties due to different formation mechanisms and aerosol influences, as well as the interaction of natural and contrail cirrus.
As global air traffic has continued to grow overthe past two decades, it has effectively led to a sharp increase in the emissions and corresponding global warming through the 'greenhouse gas effect'. Apart from CO2 and H2O, NOx is the next major aviation-emitted species which significantly contributes to climatechange through its atmospheric chemistry leading to the formation of O3,which in itself is another major greenhouse gas.
Since global air traffic is a major source of tropospheric NOx,this thesis analyzed the contribution of aviation to tropospheric mixing ratiosof NOx and O3. The analyses were performed on 2 majoraspects: (A) to identify and understand the seasonal & zonal patterns with respect to aviation's contribution to tropospheric mixing ratio of NOx andO3, and (B) to comprehend the differences between 2 methodologies(called “Perturbation” & “Tagging”) in estimating aviation's contributionto tropospheric mixing ratio of NOx and O3. Inaddition to NOx and O3, background availability ofradicals OH and HO2 was also analyzed, since OH and HO2 arevital to the NOx-O3 chemistry.
The global climate-chemistry model EMAC (European Centre forMedium-Range Weather Forecasts – Hamburg (ECHAM)/MESSy Atmospheric Chemistry) was used, whereby the simulations were performed in quasi-chemistry transport model (QCTM) mode. The analyses presented an interesting overview of aviation's contribution to tropospheric NOx and O3. ...
As global air traffic has continued to grow overthe past two decades, it has effectively led to a sharp increase in the emissions and corresponding global warming through the 'greenhouse gas effect'. Apart from CO2 and H2O, NOx is the next major aviation-emitted species which significantly contributes to climatechange through its atmospheric chemistry leading to the formation of O3,which in itself is another major greenhouse gas.
Since global air traffic is a major source of tropospheric NOx,this thesis analyzed the contribution of aviation to tropospheric mixing ratiosof NOx and O3. The analyses were performed on 2 majoraspects: (A) to identify and understand the seasonal & zonal patterns with respect to aviation's contribution to tropospheric mixing ratio of NOx andO3, and (B) to comprehend the differences between 2 methodologies(called “Perturbation” & “Tagging”) in estimating aviation's contributionto tropospheric mixing ratio of NOx and O3. Inaddition to NOx and O3, background availability ofradicals OH and HO2 was also analyzed, since OH and HO2 arevital to the NOx-O3 chemistry.
The global climate-chemistry model EMAC (European Centre forMedium-Range Weather Forecasts – Hamburg (ECHAM)/MESSy Atmospheric Chemistry) was used, whereby the simulations were performed in quasi-chemistry transport model (QCTM) mode. The analyses presented an interesting overview of aviation's contribution to tropospheric NOx and O3.
An Assessment of the Future Climate Impact of Commercial Aviation Activity
A Scenario-Based Assessment Approach
during nighttime, THsunrise determines whether the contrail is formed sufficiently close to sunrise to be considered a daytime contrail. It is concluded that winter daytime mitigation of contrail climate impact is more eco-efficient than winter nighttime mitigation. Overall, daytime mitigation achieves a larger maximum reduction of contrail climate impact than nighttime mitigation. moreover, summer mitigation is more effective than winter mitigation and winter
mitigation has a larger reliance on the formation of extra cooling contrails. The thesis results are robust with respect to a varying THsunrise. However, overall results become biased to daytime results or nighttime results. Lastly, it is shown that differences between day and night contrail climate impact mitigation allow for the enhancement of mitigation results. ...
during nighttime, THsunrise determines whether the contrail is formed sufficiently close to sunrise to be considered a daytime contrail. It is concluded that winter daytime mitigation of contrail climate impact is more eco-efficient than winter nighttime mitigation. Overall, daytime mitigation achieves a larger maximum reduction of contrail climate impact than nighttime mitigation. moreover, summer mitigation is more effective than winter mitigation and winter
mitigation has a larger reliance on the formation of extra cooling contrails. The thesis results are robust with respect to a varying THsunrise. However, overall results become biased to daytime results or nighttime results. Lastly, it is shown that differences between day and night contrail climate impact mitigation allow for the enhancement of mitigation results.
Aircraft Trajectory Optimization for European Flights
Assessment of the trajectory variability considering a trade-off between operating costs and climate impact
A new method to assess the climate effect of mitigation strategies for road traffic
The fast chemistry-climate response model TransClim
In this thesis, the NOx chemistry, atmospheric transport processes and the model set-up of the REACT4C project is reviewed. The temporal development analysis of O3 is split-up into two parts, the O3 build-up and the O3 depletion. First, all data from the climate model are re-gridded and chemical production and loss rates are isolated from all other loss terms (i.e. diffusion). Certain characteristics of the temporal concentration changes of O3 are identified. A systematic analysis of the background chemical compounds and all important chemical reactions involved, provide insides to identify seasonal and emission altitude differences. With the help from literature and multiple statistical means, weather influences on those production and loss terms and thus the temporal development of O3 and CH4 , are identified. In a final step, inter-seasonal variations are analysed.
In general, the chemical processes during the O3 build-up are dominated by the emitted NOx, whereas the chemical processes during the depletion of O3 are dominated by the high O3 concentration. Seasonal differences of the maximum O3 concentration and the total CH4 loss are caused by lower background concentrations of all chemicals involved during winter, which lead to lower production and loss rates of O3 and CH4 . At the same time altitude differences in the production and loss of O3 and CH4 are caused by altitude variations in all chemicals involved.
The vertical transport within the atmosphere defines the time when the O3 maximum is reached. If an air parcel containing the emitted NOx, is transported fast to a lower altitude, the O3 maximum occurs sooner. If however the same air parcel would stay for a longer time at a high altitude, a late O3 maximum occurs. It could be identified that this downward motion is caused by the subsidence within a high pressure system. Airparcel with an earlier O3 maxima, experience high subsidence, which leads to a higher chemical activity based on higher temperatures. During summer a high O3 maximum can only be reached, if the background concentration of NOx is low during the O3 build-up. If the background NOx concentration is high, only very low O3 maxima occur. During winter the maximum O3 concentration is limited by the background concentration of HO2 . Only high HO2 background concentrations lead to high O3 maxima. The temporal development of CH4 is mainly influenced by the maximum O3 concentration as well as specific humidity. High O3 and H2O concentrations lead to high OH productions, which lead to a high CH4 losses. A high CH4 loss only occurs, if the maximum O3 concentrations and the specific humidity are high.
This study shows that the weather situation each air parcel, containing NOx emissions, experiences has a direct influence on the resulting concentration changes of O3 and CH4 . Therefore, weather has a direct impact on the climate impact of NOx , since the concentration change of O3 and CH4 directly influences the resulting climate impact. The understanding of processes related to the climate impact of aviation attributed NOx emission is increased. This improved understanding shows great potential to improve possibilities to forecast local climate impact resulting from aviation NOx emissions, which is necessary for future re-routing mitigation strategies. ...
In this thesis, the NOx chemistry, atmospheric transport processes and the model set-up of the REACT4C project is reviewed. The temporal development analysis of O3 is split-up into two parts, the O3 build-up and the O3 depletion. First, all data from the climate model are re-gridded and chemical production and loss rates are isolated from all other loss terms (i.e. diffusion). Certain characteristics of the temporal concentration changes of O3 are identified. A systematic analysis of the background chemical compounds and all important chemical reactions involved, provide insides to identify seasonal and emission altitude differences. With the help from literature and multiple statistical means, weather influences on those production and loss terms and thus the temporal development of O3 and CH4 , are identified. In a final step, inter-seasonal variations are analysed.
In general, the chemical processes during the O3 build-up are dominated by the emitted NOx, whereas the chemical processes during the depletion of O3 are dominated by the high O3 concentration. Seasonal differences of the maximum O3 concentration and the total CH4 loss are caused by lower background concentrations of all chemicals involved during winter, which lead to lower production and loss rates of O3 and CH4 . At the same time altitude differences in the production and loss of O3 and CH4 are caused by altitude variations in all chemicals involved.
The vertical transport within the atmosphere defines the time when the O3 maximum is reached. If an air parcel containing the emitted NOx, is transported fast to a lower altitude, the O3 maximum occurs sooner. If however the same air parcel would stay for a longer time at a high altitude, a late O3 maximum occurs. It could be identified that this downward motion is caused by the subsidence within a high pressure system. Airparcel with an earlier O3 maxima, experience high subsidence, which leads to a higher chemical activity based on higher temperatures. During summer a high O3 maximum can only be reached, if the background concentration of NOx is low during the O3 build-up. If the background NOx concentration is high, only very low O3 maxima occur. During winter the maximum O3 concentration is limited by the background concentration of HO2 . Only high HO2 background concentrations lead to high O3 maxima. The temporal development of CH4 is mainly influenced by the maximum O3 concentration as well as specific humidity. High O3 and H2O concentrations lead to high OH productions, which lead to a high CH4 losses. A high CH4 loss only occurs, if the maximum O3 concentrations and the specific humidity are high.
This study shows that the weather situation each air parcel, containing NOx emissions, experiences has a direct influence on the resulting concentration changes of O3 and CH4 . Therefore, weather has a direct impact on the climate impact of NOx , since the concentration change of O3 and CH4 directly influences the resulting climate impact. The understanding of processes related to the climate impact of aviation attributed NOx emission is increased. This improved understanding shows great potential to improve possibilities to forecast local climate impact resulting from aviation NOx emissions, which is necessary for future re-routing mitigation strategies.