H.H.G. Savenije
Please Note
14 records found
1
Remote river rating in resource constricted river basins
Exploring opportunities for ungauged basins through low-cost technological advancements
The first three chapters of this thesis provide an introduction in the form of a literature review, justification for the study and a description of the study area. In chapter 4, a framework is developed through an intensive review of traditional river monitoring processes. Uniquely effective and low-cost individual components are selected and placed within a framework. The ideal outcome is an interconnected framework which clearly presents the steps which are necessary for river monitoring in remote locations. The manner in which each critical step is related to the other is explained. Furthermore, the method by which modern technologies are assimilated into the method is described. Within the framework, critical thresholds are set up in order to signal the to the water manager whether the proposed model in its current state continues to perform as required.
Chapter 5 investigates how low-cost technologies such as UAVs in combination with low-cost GNSS devices can be used to generate river geometry for the purposes of application in a hydraulic model. Furthermore, performance of the open-source photogrammetry software substantiated the claim that, free and open-source available packages are capable of producing results which are as good as proprietary alternatives as shown by the RMSE analyses. A novel approach to generate a seamless bathymetry through merging and volumization was successfully tested. Results presented in this chapter encourage future studies to investigate the impact of variations in the number of Ground Control Points (GCPs) on discharge estimations in a hydraulic model with different hydrodynamic boundary conditions. This follow up was instituted in Chapter 6.
In this sixth chapter we accept that uncertainties in the data acquisition may propagate into uncertainties in the relationships found between discharge and state variables. This uncertainty prompts the need to understand the impact of varying geometries on hydraulic models. Specific attention is placed on variations caused by differing GCP numbers since the task of GCP placement is time consuming, potential dangerous and resource intensive in certain location and instances. We are successfully able to determine the minimum number of control points required to reproduce geometry. Overall, we successfully develop and test a workable method for water resources authorities to estimate river flows accurately through the application of advanced, low-cost technologies with minimal contact with measured variables.
The development and application of low-cost technologies for river flow monitoring has led to the following important conclusions:
• For the purpose of flow estimation, there is no need to use more than seven GCPs to establish accurate UAV-based geometry. Rather, it is more crucial to distribute the available markers to be maximally representative of the terrain elevations. Furthermore, it may be necessary to place more markers in close proximity to locations where one may expect the largest challenge for photogrammetry software (e.g.: water, thick forest/vegetation)
• In order to limit the impact of the “doming” effect on terrain geometry measurements, one of the most effective, yet easily implementable mechanisms is to measure a river line using Real Time Kinematic (RTK) Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) equipment. This data can then be used to correct the terrain post photogrammetry processing.
...
The first three chapters of this thesis provide an introduction in the form of a literature review, justification for the study and a description of the study area. In chapter 4, a framework is developed through an intensive review of traditional river monitoring processes. Uniquely effective and low-cost individual components are selected and placed within a framework. The ideal outcome is an interconnected framework which clearly presents the steps which are necessary for river monitoring in remote locations. The manner in which each critical step is related to the other is explained. Furthermore, the method by which modern technologies are assimilated into the method is described. Within the framework, critical thresholds are set up in order to signal the to the water manager whether the proposed model in its current state continues to perform as required.
Chapter 5 investigates how low-cost technologies such as UAVs in combination with low-cost GNSS devices can be used to generate river geometry for the purposes of application in a hydraulic model. Furthermore, performance of the open-source photogrammetry software substantiated the claim that, free and open-source available packages are capable of producing results which are as good as proprietary alternatives as shown by the RMSE analyses. A novel approach to generate a seamless bathymetry through merging and volumization was successfully tested. Results presented in this chapter encourage future studies to investigate the impact of variations in the number of Ground Control Points (GCPs) on discharge estimations in a hydraulic model with different hydrodynamic boundary conditions. This follow up was instituted in Chapter 6.
In this sixth chapter we accept that uncertainties in the data acquisition may propagate into uncertainties in the relationships found between discharge and state variables. This uncertainty prompts the need to understand the impact of varying geometries on hydraulic models. Specific attention is placed on variations caused by differing GCP numbers since the task of GCP placement is time consuming, potential dangerous and resource intensive in certain location and instances. We are successfully able to determine the minimum number of control points required to reproduce geometry. Overall, we successfully develop and test a workable method for water resources authorities to estimate river flows accurately through the application of advanced, low-cost technologies with minimal contact with measured variables.
The development and application of low-cost technologies for river flow monitoring has led to the following important conclusions:
• For the purpose of flow estimation, there is no need to use more than seven GCPs to establish accurate UAV-based geometry. Rather, it is more crucial to distribute the available markers to be maximally representative of the terrain elevations. Furthermore, it may be necessary to place more markers in close proximity to locations where one may expect the largest challenge for photogrammetry software (e.g.: water, thick forest/vegetation)
• In order to limit the impact of the “doming” effect on terrain geometry measurements, one of the most effective, yet easily implementable mechanisms is to measure a river line using Real Time Kinematic (RTK) Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) equipment. This data can then be used to correct the terrain post photogrammetry processing.
Satellite data in rainfall-runoff models
Exploring new opportunities for semi-arid, data-scarce river basins
Using River Geometry for Rating Curve Computation
A step towards Remote River Rating
Remote river rating in Zambia
A case study in the Luangwa river basin
A Physics-Based approach for Rating Curves to Reduce Uncertainties
A New Concept for Hydrological Model Calibration
In this research a physics-based rating curve is developed and evaluated that is more reliable and easy to update. By the use of a photogrammetry techtnique 3D surface maps of river banks are generated by pictures obtained from an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV). The topography of the main channel is determined by using an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) or it is approximated by the making use of expert judgement and the method developed by Lane (relates the water depth of the channel to the width and natural angle of repose). By knowing the geometric profile of a river reach, only the roughness coefficient and water surface slope are the unknown parameters to derive the rating curve, where the Manning’s formula acts as the basis of the rating curve. In this way, the rating curves can be made physically substantiated and the calibration parameter is the combination of roughness and water surface slope.
Instead of using the power law function as a approximate function of the rating curve, it is used as approximation of the conveyance-water level relationship. Therefore, the exponents in the power law function are physical substantiated and reduce uncertainties in the extrapolation zone of the traditional method, because the profile during high flow conditions is also known. Further more, the local invariabilities that are specific to single cross-section analyses are minimized by analysing river reaches. It is demonstrated that local invariabilities arises easily in natural rivers that are causing non-uniform flows, which make in general the the open-channel flow analysis much more complex. However, the average conveyance of a reach may led to the a valid assumption of a uniform flow (which is part of the assumption in the Manning’s formula), depending on how the local variabilities behave. The calibration of rating curves are much easier compared with the traditional way. Instead of collecting new discharge
measurements during dispersed flows, you just have to visit the area ones with a drone and surveying equipment. During this visit, the new new geometric profile can be captured and the rating curve can be updated, assuming that the roughness and water surface slope remains constant. ...
In this research a physics-based rating curve is developed and evaluated that is more reliable and easy to update. By the use of a photogrammetry techtnique 3D surface maps of river banks are generated by pictures obtained from an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV). The topography of the main channel is determined by using an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) or it is approximated by the making use of expert judgement and the method developed by Lane (relates the water depth of the channel to the width and natural angle of repose). By knowing the geometric profile of a river reach, only the roughness coefficient and water surface slope are the unknown parameters to derive the rating curve, where the Manning’s formula acts as the basis of the rating curve. In this way, the rating curves can be made physically substantiated and the calibration parameter is the combination of roughness and water surface slope.
Instead of using the power law function as a approximate function of the rating curve, it is used as approximation of the conveyance-water level relationship. Therefore, the exponents in the power law function are physical substantiated and reduce uncertainties in the extrapolation zone of the traditional method, because the profile during high flow conditions is also known. Further more, the local invariabilities that are specific to single cross-section analyses are minimized by analysing river reaches. It is demonstrated that local invariabilities arises easily in natural rivers that are causing non-uniform flows, which make in general the the open-channel flow analysis much more complex. However, the average conveyance of a reach may led to the a valid assumption of a uniform flow (which is part of the assumption in the Manning’s formula), depending on how the local variabilities behave. The calibration of rating curves are much easier compared with the traditional way. Instead of collecting new discharge
measurements during dispersed flows, you just have to visit the area ones with a drone and surveying equipment. During this visit, the new new geometric profile can be captured and the rating curve can be updated, assuming that the roughness and water surface slope remains constant.
Genetic Programming in Hydrology
Using genetic programming in conceptual modelling
Most model experiments in this thesis are carried out in the Ourthe catchment, a subcatchment of the Meuse basin. This catchment has a strong seasonal behaviour, responds quickly to precipitation and has a large influence on peak flows in the Meuse. It has a variety of landscapes, among which steep forested slopes and flat agricultural fields.
This thesis proposes a new evaluation framework (Framework to Assess Realism of Model structures (FARM)), based on different characteristics of the hydrograph (hydrological signatures). Key element of this framework is that it evaluates both performance (good reproduction of signatures) and consistency (reproduction of multiple signatures with the same parameter set). This framework is used together with various other model evaluation tools to evaluate models at three levels: internal model behaviour, model performance and consistency, and predictive power.
The root zone storage capacity (Sr) of vegetation is an important parameter in conceptual rainfall-runoff models. It largely determines the partitioning of precipitation into evaporation and discharge. Distribution of a climate derived Sr-value (i.e., based on precipitation and evaporation) was compared with Sr-values derived from soil samples in 32 New Zealand catchments. The comparison is based on spatial patterns and a model experiment. It is concluded that climate is a better estimator for Sr than soil, especially in wet catchments. Within the Meuse basin, climate derived Sr -values have been estimated as well; applying these newly derived storage estimates improved model results.
Two types of distribution have been tested for the Ourthe catchment: the distribution of meteorological forcing and the distribution of model structure. The distribution of forcing was based on spatially variable precipitation and potential evaporation. These were averaged at different levels within in the model, thereby creating four levels of model state distribution. The model structure was distributed by using two hydrological response units (HRUs), representing wetlands and hillslopes. Eventually, a lumped and a distributed model structure were compared, each with four levels of model state (forcing) distribution. From this, it is concluded that distribution of model structure is more important than distribution of forcing. However, if the model structure is distributed, the forcing should be distributed as well.
Knowing that distribution of model structure is relevant, more detailed process conceptualisations have been tested for the Ourthe Orientale, a subcatchment of the Ourthe. An additional agricultural HRU was introduced for which Hortonian overland flow and frost in the topsoil are assumed to be relevant. In addition, a degree-day based snow module has been added to all HRUs. Adding these process conceptualisations improved the performance and consistency of the model on an event basis. However, the implemented processes and the related signatures are sensitive to errors in forcing and model outliers and should therefore be implemented carefully.
This thesis finishes with two explorative comparisons; one comparing the newly developed model of the Ourthe Orientale catchment with other catchments; the second between the newly developed model and other models, including the HBV configuration currently used for operational forecasting in the Meuse basin. These comparisons were carried out based on visual inspections of parts of the hydrograph. The results show that the newly developed model can be applied in neighbouring catchments with similar performance. The comparison with other models demonstrates that a very quick overland flow component and a parallel configuration of fast and slow runoff generating reservoirs is important to reproduce the dynamics of the hydrograph related to different time scales. Both aspects are included in the newly developed model. As a results, the newly developed model is better able to reproduce most of the dynamics of the hydrograph than the operational HBV configuration, used at the moment of writing.
Distribution and detailed process conceptualisation are very beneficial for rainfall-runoff modelling of the Ourthe catchment. However, they should be applied with care. Conceptual models are a strong simplification of reality. When confronting them only with discharge data, there is a risk of misinterpreting other hydrological processes.
This thesis suggests two possible opportunities to further improve conceptual models. First, catchment understanding could be increased by adding more physical meaning to the models, such as the climate derived root zone storage capacity. And second, remote sensing and plot scale data could be combined to link hydrological processes at different scales. In this way conceptual models can probably be used to get more insight into scaling issues, which occur when moving from hillslope to catchment scale.
...
Most model experiments in this thesis are carried out in the Ourthe catchment, a subcatchment of the Meuse basin. This catchment has a strong seasonal behaviour, responds quickly to precipitation and has a large influence on peak flows in the Meuse. It has a variety of landscapes, among which steep forested slopes and flat agricultural fields.
This thesis proposes a new evaluation framework (Framework to Assess Realism of Model structures (FARM)), based on different characteristics of the hydrograph (hydrological signatures). Key element of this framework is that it evaluates both performance (good reproduction of signatures) and consistency (reproduction of multiple signatures with the same parameter set). This framework is used together with various other model evaluation tools to evaluate models at three levels: internal model behaviour, model performance and consistency, and predictive power.
The root zone storage capacity (Sr) of vegetation is an important parameter in conceptual rainfall-runoff models. It largely determines the partitioning of precipitation into evaporation and discharge. Distribution of a climate derived Sr-value (i.e., based on precipitation and evaporation) was compared with Sr-values derived from soil samples in 32 New Zealand catchments. The comparison is based on spatial patterns and a model experiment. It is concluded that climate is a better estimator for Sr than soil, especially in wet catchments. Within the Meuse basin, climate derived Sr -values have been estimated as well; applying these newly derived storage estimates improved model results.
Two types of distribution have been tested for the Ourthe catchment: the distribution of meteorological forcing and the distribution of model structure. The distribution of forcing was based on spatially variable precipitation and potential evaporation. These were averaged at different levels within in the model, thereby creating four levels of model state distribution. The model structure was distributed by using two hydrological response units (HRUs), representing wetlands and hillslopes. Eventually, a lumped and a distributed model structure were compared, each with four levels of model state (forcing) distribution. From this, it is concluded that distribution of model structure is more important than distribution of forcing. However, if the model structure is distributed, the forcing should be distributed as well.
Knowing that distribution of model structure is relevant, more detailed process conceptualisations have been tested for the Ourthe Orientale, a subcatchment of the Ourthe. An additional agricultural HRU was introduced for which Hortonian overland flow and frost in the topsoil are assumed to be relevant. In addition, a degree-day based snow module has been added to all HRUs. Adding these process conceptualisations improved the performance and consistency of the model on an event basis. However, the implemented processes and the related signatures are sensitive to errors in forcing and model outliers and should therefore be implemented carefully.
This thesis finishes with two explorative comparisons; one comparing the newly developed model of the Ourthe Orientale catchment with other catchments; the second between the newly developed model and other models, including the HBV configuration currently used for operational forecasting in the Meuse basin. These comparisons were carried out based on visual inspections of parts of the hydrograph. The results show that the newly developed model can be applied in neighbouring catchments with similar performance. The comparison with other models demonstrates that a very quick overland flow component and a parallel configuration of fast and slow runoff generating reservoirs is important to reproduce the dynamics of the hydrograph related to different time scales. Both aspects are included in the newly developed model. As a results, the newly developed model is better able to reproduce most of the dynamics of the hydrograph than the operational HBV configuration, used at the moment of writing.
Distribution and detailed process conceptualisation are very beneficial for rainfall-runoff modelling of the Ourthe catchment. However, they should be applied with care. Conceptual models are a strong simplification of reality. When confronting them only with discharge data, there is a risk of misinterpreting other hydrological processes.
This thesis suggests two possible opportunities to further improve conceptual models. First, catchment understanding could be increased by adding more physical meaning to the models, such as the climate derived root zone storage capacity. And second, remote sensing and plot scale data could be combined to link hydrological processes at different scales. In this way conceptual models can probably be used to get more insight into scaling issues, which occur when moving from hillslope to catchment scale.