Circular Image

E. Verbree

info

Please Note

57 records found

Incremental urban and community expansion in rural heritage landscapes often produces cumulative visual impacts, yet planning rarely specifies a clear endpoint for acceptable change. This paper proposes an integrated Visual Impact Assessment (VIA) framework, aligned with SDG 11, to determine “when to stop” using stage-comparable evidence across past, present, and future conditions. The framework is organized in three modules. First, a point cloud-enhanced GIS module quantifies visibility and spatial change across development stages. Second, an enhanced Key Observation Point (KOP) module derives matched eye-level evidence from multi-temporal street-level panoramas and scenario visualizations, for example using Street View Imagery (SVI) time series and 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) rendering. Third, a decision layer integrates structured public acceptability from a questionnaire covering different respondent groups with in-depth expert interviews and synthesis, with virtual reality (VR) eye- and head-tracking used as supportive behavioral evidence. Applied to the Middenbeemster expansion in the Beemster Polder, the Netherlands, the framework yields a case-calibrated reference package for decision support: KOP-based construction intensity serves as the primary reference line for review, perception indicators serve as supporting guardrails, spatial character metrics act as case-specific reference checks to protect the polder framework, and visibility diagnostics remain a necessary screening layer. More broadly, the framework provides a transparent and replicable procedure that can be transferred and locally recalibrated for heritage-sensitive rural-urban fringes where change is incremental and cumulative, supporting a stage-comparable VIA approach. ...

A workflow evaluation of 3D Gaussian splatting and LiDAR point cloud for modern architectural heritage

Journal article (2025) - Yingwen Yu, Edward Verbree, Peter van Oosterom, Uta Pottgiesser, Yuyang Peng, Florent Poux
This paper investigates the role of 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) within point cloud–dominated workflows for modern architectural heritage digitization. While 3DGS enables real-time, photorealistic visualization, its integration into LiDAR-based documentation pipelines remains underexplored. Using Bouwpub, a modern heritage building in the Netherlands, as a case study, the paper compares 3DGS and LiDAR across data acquisition and preservation, visualization, semantic segmentation, and dissemination. Results show that 3DGS offers superior visual expressiveness and user responsiveness, whereas LiDAR provides greater structural accuracy and segmentation reliability. Based on these findings, two integration strategies are proposed: a Blender-based multi-angle rendering workflow and a Level of Detail 3DGS (LOD3DGS) pipeline. Moving from isolated assessment to applied integration, the study positions 3DGS as a complementary visualization and dissemination module rather than a replacement. This hybrid approach supports immersive, scalable, and semantically enriched digital heritage systems, offering new directions for enhancing both expert documentation and public engagement. ...

Integrating Floor Plans and Nationwide Airborne LiDAR (AHN)

As urban environments become increasingly vertical, Land Administration Systems (LAS) must support complex 3D spatial representations. While Building Information Models (BIM) offer such capabilities, they are not always available. This paper investigates an alternative approach using point clouds for 3D LAS, focusing on the integration of scanned cadastral floor plans and airborne LiDAR from the Actueel Hoogtebestand Nederland (AHN). We present a semi-automated pipeline that extracts floorplan geometries, segments and enhances AHN data, and synthesizes room-level point clouds. Results from a case study in Rotterdam demonstrate the potential of this approach in the absence of BIM, supporting legal space definition and public visualization. However, challenges such as misalignment due to occlusion in AHN data and inconsistent quality in older floor plan drawings affect the accuracy and automation of the process. The synthetic point clouds include room-level attributes, enabling a seamless integration with AHN, offering a representation of real-world features such as building facades, walls, and fences, which often delineate cadastral boundaries. ...
This systematic literature review critically examines the application of digital technologies in architectural heritage risk management from 2014 to 2024, focusing exclusively on English-language publications. As the significance of architectural heritage continues to be recognized globally, there is an increasing shift towards integrating digital solutions to ensure its preservation and management. This paper explores the evolution and application of digital technologies such as Building Information Modeling (BIM), Geographic Information Systems (GIS), and advanced imaging techniques within the field. It highlights how these technologies have facilitated the non-destructive evaluation of heritage sites and enhanced accessibility and interaction through virtual and augmented reality applications. By synthesizing data from various case studies and scholarly articles, the review identifies current trends and the expanding scope of digital interventions in heritage conservation. It discusses the interplay between traditional conservation approaches and modern technological solutions, providing insights into their complementary roles. The analysis also addresses the challenges and limitations encountered in the digital preservation of architectural heritage, such as data integration, the compatibility of different technologies, and the need for more comprehensive frameworks to guide the implementation of digital tools in heritage conservation practices. Ultimately, this review underscores the transformative impact of digital technology in managing architectural heritage risks, suggesting directions for future research and the potential for innovative applications in the field. ...
Conference paper (2025) - Y. Yu, E. Verbree, P.J.M. van Oosterom, U. Pottgiesser
3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) is an advanced 3D representation method that enhances point clouds by incorporating spectral image content, enabling high-fidelity heritage documentation. A 3DGS visualization presents these enriched Gaussians, ensuring high geometric accuracy, detailed texture representation, and efficient spatial reconstruction, thereby enhancing both precision and efficiency in digital heritage preservation. This paper applies 3DGS to modern architectural heritage, combining UAV-based data acquisition with advanced rendering techniques. Using the Delft University of Technology Aula and Library buildings as case study, the research establishes a workflow for efficient heritage documentation and visualization. ...

Unveiling insights for sustainable development through change detection in the built environment

Conference paper (2024) - V. Diaz Mercado, P.J.M. van Oosterom, B.M. Meijers, E. Verbree, Nauman Ahmed, Thijs van Lankveld
Change detection in the built environment is essential for sustainable development practices including Urban Planning and Development, Environmental Monitoring, and Conservation. Change detection provides valuable insights into dynamic processes, facilitates informed decision making, and supports sustainable development initiatives. Point clouds serve as foundational data sources for change detection in built environments, enabling analysts to detect, quantify, and interpret spatial changes with unparalleled accuracy and granularity. By leveraging the inherent characteristics of point clouds, researchers and practitioners can gain valuable insights into dynamic processes, inform decision making, and foster sustainable development in an ever-evolving built environment. We present the preliminary results of cloud-to-cloud (c2c) distance calculations for further change detection analysis of the entire Netherlands. This study utilises point cloud data from AHN2, 3, and 4 (Actueel Hoogtebestand Nederland1, The Netherlands). A method based on a 3D space-filling curve (SFC) was developed to calculate the c2c distances between AHN2, 3, and 4. This SFC method will allow change detection analysis to be carried out for the entire Netherlands. The change detection analysis outcomes can be accessed for future analysis in Potree2, a web-based point cloud rendered for large point clouds. The final implementation will allow the visualisation of AHN point clouds and their attributes, among which is the change in detection-related information. This research contributes to sustainable development practices by offering enhanced spatial insights and informed decision-making tools for further analysis and monitoring of the (built) environment in the Netherlands. [...] ...

Is the Most Complex Always the Most Suitable?

Conference paper (2024) - Vitali Diaz, Peter van Oosterom, B.M. Meijers, Edward Verbree, Nauman Ahmed, Thijs van Lankveld
Cloud-to-cloud (C2C) distance calculations are frequently performed as an initial stage in change detection and spatiotemporal analysis with point clouds. There are various methods for calculating C2C distance, also called inter-point distance, which refers to the distance between two corresponding point clouds captured at different epochs. These methods can be classified from simple to complex, with more steps and calculations required for the latter. Generally, it is assumed that a more complex method will result in a more precise calculation of inter-point distance, but this assumption is rarely evaluated. This paper compares eight commonly used methods for calculating the inter-point distance. The results indicate that the accuracy of distance calculations depends on the chosen method and a characteristic related to the point density, the intra-point distance, which refers to the distance between points within the same point cloud. The results are helpful for applications that analyze spatiotemporal point clouds for change detection. The findings will be helpful in future applications, including analyzing spatiotemporal point clouds for change detection. ...
Abstract (2024) - Vitali Diaz, Peter van Oosterom, Martijn Meijers, Edward Verbree, Nauman Ahmed, Thijs van Lankveld
The advantages of using point clouds for change detection analysis include comprehensive spatial and temporal representation, as well as high precision and accuracy in the calculations. These benefits make point clouds a powerful data type for spatio-temporal analysis. Nevertheless, most current change detection methods have been specifically designed and utilized for raster data. This research aims to identify the most suitable cloud-to-cloud (c2c) distance calculation algorithm for further implementation in change detection for spatio-temporal point clouds. Eight different methods, varying in complexity and execution time, are compared without converting the point cloud data into rasters. Hourly point cloud data from monitoring a beach-dune system's dynamics is used to carry out the comparison. The c2c distance methods are (1) the nearest neighbor, (2) least squares plane, (3) linear interpolation, (4) quadratic (height function), (5) 2.5D triangulation, (6) natural neighbor interpolation (NNI), (7) inverse distance weight (IDW) and (8) multiscale model to model cloud comparison (M3C2). We evaluate these algorithms, considering both the accuracy of the calculated distance and the execution time. The results can be valuable for analyzing and monitoring the (build) environment with spatio-temporal point cloud data. ...
The objective of this paper is to investigate and propose a method for Indoor Localisation based on Isovists, with the aim of extending the fields of Location-based Services and Geomatics. Various methods and combinations incorporating Isovist concepts, Space Syntax, and visibility graphs are examined and assessed. By investigating these approaches, this study aims to create a comprehensive methodology to achieve localisation using Isovists. The main conclusion drawn from this research is that an Indoor Localisation method based on Isovists is not only feasible but can also effectively support Location-based Services. The analysis and evaluation of all the components have been thoroughly conducted, indicating that when properly integrated, they can provide substantial value for LBS applications. As this is a new method for Indoor Localisation, there is significant scope for future work, particularly in terms of connecting it with existing techniques and integrating them into user applications. ...
Journal article (2024) - Algan Mert Yasar, Robert Voûte, Edward Verbree
This study investigates the feasibility of directly utilizing 3D indoor point clouds for real-time indoor navigation, particularly to enhance emergency response processes. Traditional indoor navigation research primarily focuses on creating navigation systems from pre-existing indoor models, resulting in a graph representation that simplifies spatial relationships, requires post-processing, and delivers results only afterwards, often overlooking real-time obstacles and complex layouts such as those in modern office floors. This research proposes an original approach by leveraging real-time generated 3D models using HoloLens 2 sensors, which combine RGB images and depth sensor output to create a comprehensive point cloud. The study explores path planning directly within these point clouds without the need for extensive preprocessing or segmentation, aiming to provide immediate navigation support with minimal delay. Utilizing the Rapidly Exploring Random Trees (RRT) algorithm, the research seeks to minimize preprocessing and swiftly visualize navigable paths, evaluating the system's performance in terms of processing time and path viability. This approach addresses the limitations of traditional graph-based methods and the challenges posed by outdated or unavailable indoor models, offering a promising solution for real-time emergency navigation assistance. ...
Localisation and navigation technologies have vastly evolved during the last years, facilitating users’ guidance in various environments. Unlike outdoor environments where GNSS comprises a universal solution, in indoor environments various localisation techniques have been used, each one with its drawbacks. Thus, this research investigates the reliability of the ceilings towards indoor localisation, by using components that are included in a simple mobile device. The choice of ceilings lies in their advantages, which include the incorporation of various characteristic components, as well as the absence of obstacles between them and the sensor. Indoor localisation is achieved based on LiDAR point clouds and images from RGB sensors of mobile devices. Additionally, this research involves location tracking of different users, to discover different movement patterns in an indoor facility. The proposed methodology revealed the robustness of the Coloured ICP algorithm for in-door localisation based on point clouds, both in terms of time efficiency and quality, while the combination of the SURF feature detector and SIFT descriptor provides the optimal indoor localisation results with image data. The proposed pipeline revealed encouraging results for use in emergencies, based on static data acquisition of a user, while it is also suitable for dynamic applications, in case a sensor is mounted on an automated device for indoor mapping operations. The captured point clouds of the ceilings can also be used as a reference to CAD and BIM models, to help the modelling of the existing utilities and their components in an indoor facility. ...
Conference paper (2022) - Vitali Diaz, Haicheng Liu, Peter van Oosterom, Martijn Meijers, Edward Verbree, Fedor Baart, Maarten Pronk, Thijs van Lankveld
Point cloud is made up of a multitude of three-dimensional (3D) points with one or more attributes attached. Point cloud is the third data paradigm in addition to the well-established object (vector) and gridded (raster) representations, since point cloud data can be directly collected, computed, stored, and analyzed without converting to other types. Modern ways of data acquisition, including laser scanning from airborne, mobile, or static platforms, multi-beam echo-sounding, and dense image matching from photos, generate millions to trillions of 3D points with attached attributes. If the collection is carried out in different periods, one of the essential attributes is precisely time, allowing spatiotemporal analysis to be performed. Its use is widespread in some fields such as metrology and quality inspection, virtual reality, indoor/outdoor navigation, object detection, vegetation monitoring, building modeling, cultural heritage, and diverse visualization applications. There are some examples in fields related to hydroinformatics, mainly related to terrain modeling. Due to its nature of big data, over the past decades, a series of developments have been carried out in the different processing chains for the optimal use of point cloud. This research seeks to introduce the various point cloud developments from which the hydroinformatics community and research could benefit. A review of recent advances is made, mainly including the analysis and visualization of point cloud for dealing with water-related problems. Potential areas of application and development in hydroinformatics are identified. These include, for example, the topics of coastal monitoring, coastal erosion, shallow water assessment, ice sheet change analysis, sea-level rise assessment, monitoring of levels in water bodies, crop and vegetation monitoring, analysis of the effects of groundwater depletion, detail tracing of basins and channels, analysis of floods with detailed terrain models, and drought monitoring in crops and forests. The challenges to overcome and ongoing developments regarding point cloud application in hydroinformatics are also discussed. ...
Point clouds contain high detail and high accuracy geometry representation of the scanned Earth surface parts. To manage the huge amount of data, the point clouds are traditionally organized on location and map-scale; e.g. in an octree structure, where top-levels of the tree contain few points suitable for small scale overviews and lower levels of the tree contain more points suitable for large scale detailed views. The drawback of this solution is that it is based on discrete levels, causing visual artifacts in the form of data density shocks when creating the commonly used perspective views. This paper presents a method based on an optimized distribution of points over continuous levels, avoiding the visualization shocks. The traditional distribution ratio's of data amounts over discrete levels of raster or vector data is considered the reference. How to convert this to point clouds with continuous levels (still benefiting from the proven advantages of the data distribution in discrete levels for efficient access at a wide range of scales)? In our solution, for each point a cLoD (continuous Level of Detail) value is computed and added as dimension to the point. A SFC (Space Filling Curve)-based nD data clustering technique can be used to organize the points, so that they can be efficiently queried. It should be noted that also other multi-dimensional indexing and clustering techniques could be applied to realize continuous levels based on the cLoD value. Besides the mathematical foundation of the approach also several implementations are described, varying from a 3D web-browser based solution to an augmented reality point cloud app in a mobile phone. The cLoD enables interactive real-time visualization using perspective views without data density shocks, while supporting continuous zoom-in/out and progressive data streaming between server and client. The described cLoD based approach is generic and supports different types of point clouds: from airborne, terrestrial, mobile and indoor laser scanning, but also from dense matching optical imagery or multi-beam echo soundings. ...
Journal article (2021) - Y. A. Lumban-Gaol, Z. Chen, M. Smit, X. Li, M. A. Erbaşu, E. Verbree, J. Balado, M. Meijers, N. Van Der Vaart
Point cloud data have rich semantic representations and can benefit various applications towards a digital twin. However, they are unordered and anisotropically distributed, thus being unsuitable for a typical Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) to handle. With the advance of deep learning, several neural networks claim to have solved the point cloud semantic segmentation problem. This paper evaluates three different neural networks for semantic segmentation of point clouds, namely PointNet++, PointCNN and DGCNN. A public indoor scene of the Amersfoort railway station is used as the study area. Unlike the typical indoor scenes and even more from the ubiquitous outdoor ones in currently available datasets, the station consists of objects such as the entrance gates, ticket machines, couches, and garbage cans. For the experiment, we use subsets from the data, remove the noise, evaluate the performance of the selected neural networks. The results indicate an overall accuracy of more than 90% for all the networks but vary in terms of mean class accuracy and mean Intersection over Union (IoU). The misclassification mainly occurs in the classes of couch and garbage can. Several factors that may contribute to the errors are analyzed, such as the quality of the data and the proportion of the number of points per class. The adaptability of the networks is also heavily dependent on the training location: the overall characteristics of the train station make a trained network for one location less suitable for another. ...
Journal article (2021) - Guan ting Zhang, Edward Verbree, Xiao jun Wang
Sustainable development can only be achieved with an innovative improvement from the way we currently analyze, design, build and manage our urban spaces. Current digital analysis and design methods for cities, such as visibility analysis, deeply rely on mapping and modeling techniques. However, most methods fall short of depicting the real visual landscape in the urban realm and this could bring a significant error in visibility calculations which may lead to an improper decision for urban spaces. The technical development of light detection and ranging(LiDAR) technology introduces new approaches for urban study. LiDAR utilizes point clouds including thousands or even millions of georeferenced points, and thus can support 3-D digital representation of urban landscape with detailed information and high resolution. Besides the superiority in representing urban landscape, LiDAR point clouds also has a clear advantage in quantitative analysis and provides better visibility than traditional models. In this paper, we first introduced a novel approach to map visibility in the urban built environment involving vegetation data directly using airborne LiDAR point clouds. This approach calculates neighborhood statistics for occlusion detection. Then we presented 2 case with different scenarios showing how our approach can be used to obtain a precise visibility in an urban area in the Netherlands. At last, we discussed how point clouds based visibility models can be further explored and can better assist urban design. ...
In guiding the energy transition efforts towards renewable energy sources, 3D city models were shown to be useful tools when assessing the annual solar energy generation potential of urban landscapes. However, the simplified roof geometry included in these 3D city models and the lack of additional semantic information about the buildings' roof often yield less accurate solar potential evaluations than desirable. In this paper we propose three different methods to infer and store additional information into 3D city models, namely on physical obstacles present on the roof and existing solar panels. Both can be used to increase the accuracy of roof solar panel retrofit potential. These methods are developed and tested on the open datasets available in the Netherlands, specifically AHN3 lidar point-cloud and PDOK aerial photography. However, we believe they can be adapted to different environments as well, based on the available datasets and their precision locally available. ...
Journal article (2021) - Bart Peter Smit, Robert Voûte, Edward Verbree
Emergency operations are a key example for the need of digital twins in the way it is complex, urgent and uncertain. First, the process is complex, as many organizations are involved. Second, it is urgent, as most damage is done in the first moments of an emergency. Third, it is uncertain, as situational conditions tend to change quickly. For outdoor operations, spatial information systems help in creating an overview of the situation, for example by displaying positions of first responder units involved with the incident. However, spatial data of indoor environments is scarce. Static information of the building, such as floor plans, are often outdated or non-existent. Dynamic operational data such as positions of first responders within the building are only available in a very limited way as well, and often without visual representation. To create situation awareness of indoor first responder operation environments, this paper successfully proposes a proof of concept with two objectives. First, the proof of concept will collect spatial environment data in the form of mapping and tracking data by using a Microsoft HoloLens. This means the geometry of the building will be collected, together with traversed routes within the building. Second, the data will be streamed and displayed to a remote first responder coordinator in real-time to create a common operational picture. This enables the coordinator to quickly build situation awareness of the operation environment, enabling the coordinator to improve the quality of decisions, thereby improving first responder performance. The proof of concept showed that situation awareness on all three levels increases with the real-time (live) availability (visualisations) of 3D indoor environments. This concept needs to be tested further on usability and performance. ...

Reopening the Workspace with Indoor Localisation

Indoor localisation methods are an essential part for the management of COVID-19 restrictions, social distancing, and the flow of people in the indoor environment. Moving towards an open work space in this scenario requires effective real-time localisation services and tools, along with a comprehensive understanding of the 3D indoor space. This project’s main objective is to analyse how ArcGIS Indoors can be used with location awareness methods to elaborate and develop space management tools for COVID-19 restrictions in order to reopen the workspace for TU Delft Campus. This was accomplished by using six Arduino micro controllers, which were programmed in C++ to scan all available Wi-Fi fingerprints in the east wing of the Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment of TU Delft and send over the data to an ArcGIS Indoor Information Model (AIIM). The data stored on the AIIM is then accessed using the app on the user’s Android device using REST Application Programming Interface (API) where a kNN based matching algorithm then identifies the location of the user. The results show that the localisation is not consistent for rooms that are directly above each other or share common access points. However, when functioning to locate different tables inside a room, the system proved to uniquely distinguish between the specific tables. As a result, we can conclude that based on the size of the rooms, more Arduino devices should be installed to achieve an ideal accuracy. Finally, recommendations are made for the continuation of this research. ...
Because unknown interior layouts can have serious consequences in time-sensitive situations, crisis response teams request many potential solutions for visualizing indoor environments in crisis scenarios. This research uses a game engine to directly visualize point cloud data input of indoor environments for generating clear interaction between the environment and viewers, to aid decision-making in high-stress moments. The prospective final product is an integration of game-oriented visualization and cartography, hosted within Unreal Engine 4 (UE4), allowing users to navigate throughout an indoor environment, and customizing certain interaction features. The UE4 project consists of 4 modules: data preprocessing, render style, functional module, and user interface. Finally, this research uses a single-floor indoor point cloud dataset collected from a building in Rotterdam, the Netherlands for the implementation. ...
Journal article (2020) - J. Balado, E. González, E. Verbree, L. Díaz-Vilariño, H. Lorenzo
Occlusions accompany serious problems that reduce the applicability of numerous algorithms. The aim of this work is to detect and characterize urban ground gaps based on occluding object. The point clouds for input have been acquired with Mobile Laser Scanning and have been previously segmented into ground, buildings and objects, which have been classified. The method generates various raster images according to segmented point cloud elements, and detects gaps within the ground based on their connectivity and the application of the hit-or-miss transform. The method has been tested in four real case studies in the cities of Vigo and Paris, and an accuracy of 99.6% has been obtained in occlusion detection and labelling. Cars caused 80.6% of the occlusions. Each car occluded an average ground area of 11.9 m2. The proposed method facilitates knowing the percentage of occluded ground, and if this would be reduced in successive multi-temporal acquisitions based on mobility characteristics of each object class. ...