F. Messali
Please Note
92 records found
1
This paper presents a cyclic joint constitutive model within a Distinct Element Method framework to simulate the in-plane response of unreinforced masonry structures. The model combines multi-surface failure criteria, including tensile cut-off, Coulomb friction, and an elliptical compression cap. It incorporates exponential softening, a unified damage scalar for stiffness degradation, and a hardening–softening law for compression. Shear-induced dilatancy is captured via an uplift-correction mechanism with an exponential dilatancy-decay law, while stiffness degradation governs energy dissipation. The model is validated at both material and structural scales. Material-level simulations of cyclic compression and shear tests show close agreement with experimental data. Structural-scale validation on full-height calcium-silicate walls under combined compression and cyclic lateral loading demonstrates the ability to reproduce rocking-dominated, shear-dominated, and hybrid failure mechanisms. The model successfully replicated global hysteretic force–drift loops, capturing stiffness decay and energy dissipation, as well as local failures like cracking, sliding, and toe crushing. The model also reproduced the drift-dependent transition from rocking to friction-controlled sliding, a key mechanism for earthquake assessment. By integrating these features into a single, efficient framework, the proposed constitutive model provides a robust tool for evaluating seismic performance and conserving heritage.
This paper introduces a novel structural-based inverse approach that uniquely integrates MT-InSAR characteristics with structural response modelling to overcome these limitations. Unlike existing approaches, the method explicitly evaluates whether observed surface displacements adequately represent a target damage mechanism by comparing outputs from a pseudo sensor with those from a virtual MT-InSAR sensor. If this condition is satisfied, it then determines the minimum required number and optimal spatial arrangement of ideal PSs using modified pivoted QR factorisation, where satellite-induced positional uncertainties are rigorously modelled through Radial Basis Function kernels.
The proposed method was validated on a quay wall in Amsterdam using Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations of three distinct damage mechanisms. Results demonstrate its unique capability to quantitatively assess displacement representativeness and to pinpoint ideal PSs for robust monitoring. Leveraging these insights, the method was further applied to evaluate MT-InSAR monitoring feasibility across Amsterdam’s historic centre, successfully identifying quay wall segments amenable to reliable observation. This work represents a significant advancement in MT-InSAR-based SHM, providing a more targeted and structurally informed approach for real-world infrastructure monitoring. ...
This paper introduces a novel structural-based inverse approach that uniquely integrates MT-InSAR characteristics with structural response modelling to overcome these limitations. Unlike existing approaches, the method explicitly evaluates whether observed surface displacements adequately represent a target damage mechanism by comparing outputs from a pseudo sensor with those from a virtual MT-InSAR sensor. If this condition is satisfied, it then determines the minimum required number and optimal spatial arrangement of ideal PSs using modified pivoted QR factorisation, where satellite-induced positional uncertainties are rigorously modelled through Radial Basis Function kernels.
The proposed method was validated on a quay wall in Amsterdam using Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations of three distinct damage mechanisms. Results demonstrate its unique capability to quantitatively assess displacement representativeness and to pinpoint ideal PSs for robust monitoring. Leveraging these insights, the method was further applied to evaluate MT-InSAR monitoring feasibility across Amsterdam’s historic centre, successfully identifying quay wall segments amenable to reliable observation. This work represents a significant advancement in MT-InSAR-based SHM, providing a more targeted and structurally informed approach for real-world infrastructure monitoring.
Out-of-plane seismic behavior of non-framed unreinforced masonry walls with pre-existing seismic damage
Numerical study via a block-based modeling approach
This study examines the influence of in-plane (IP) pre-deformations and -damages on the two-way bending out-of-plane (OOP) seismic response of non-framed unreinforced masonry (URM) walls. IP and OOP behaviors of non-framed URM walls are often studied individually and their interaction, such as the effects studied here, remains insufficiently explored. Hence, current design and assessment techniques of non-framed URM walls do not consider the effects of pre-damage and pre-deformation, overestimating safety. This paper addresses this gap. First, a simplified micro-scale numerical modeling approach is developed within Finite Element framework using expanded blocks and zero-thickness interface elements. Shell elements are adopted instead of solid blocks, which are traditionally more common in such studies, to enhance computational efficiency for extensive explorations. Second, the approach is validated against wall IP and OOP experiments, showing good accuracy and reliability. Third, the effects of IP pre-damage and pre-deformation on two-way OOP bending strength and stiffness, called IP/OOP interaction effects, are investigated in a parametric study. The effects of wall openings, IP boundary conditions, vertical pre-compression, and horizontal confinement on interaction effects are investigated. OOP loading is performed at different IP performance states identified via a crack-based approach. According to the results, IP pre-damage or pre-deformation reduced OOP strength between 0% and 30% and OOP stiffness between 30% and 50% for the walls studied in this research and representative of Dutch calcium silicate masonry, emphasizing the importance of accounting for IP/OOP interactions in seismic design and assessment of URM walls. Vertical pre-compression and horizontal confinement are identified as most influential parameters due to their effect on arching mechanisms. Existing analytical models, typically developed for one-way spanning walls, significantly overestimate the loss of OOP performance due to pre-deformation or pre-damage in two-way spanning walls. The study establishes a foundation for structured future research into IP/OOP interaction.
Experimental out-of-plane seismic response of URM gables
Role of roof flexibility and differential input
Simulating the seismic behaviour of unreinforced masonry (URM) is challenging due to large deformations and severe damage. Capturing this highly nonlinear response requires advanced numerical modelling strategies that represent block separation, debonding, friction, and impact. Discontinuum-based modelling strategies, such as the Distinct Element Method (DEM), are well suited, as they explicitly represent bond failure and damage progression from cracking to collapse. DEM relies on the explicit time integration scheme of motion equations; hence, the choice of the damping scheme becomes critical. Typically, mass-proportional damping is used in dynamic analysis, often without complementing it with stiffness-proportional damping which requires unpractical reduction of the time steps to ensure numerical stability. Yet relying solely on mass-proportional damping can overdamp low frequencies and underdamp high frequencies. This study implements and validates an alternative damping approach, Maxwell damping, where multiple spring-dashpot elements are introduced at unit-mortar interfaces within a simplified micro-model. This work introduces an optimization algorithm to tune the Maxwell elements without heuristics, targeting near-uniform damping over a broad frequency range. Effectiveness is assessed against shake-table tests on a full-scale cross-vault URM specimen. Predicted displacements, accelerations, damage evolution, and computational efficiency is compared with mass-proportional and zero-viscous damping models. This study investigates Maxwell damping as a practical relaxation scheme for the seismic analysis of complex masonry systems using DEM, building on prior formulations in the literature and extending them to the present modelling and validation context.
Out-of-plane response of URM gable walls
From experimental testing to modeling and assessment tools
A fast, NLTHA-based assessment method for out-of-plane capacity of URM walls
The Wandenaanpak framework for the Groningen building stock
To address this challenge, a two-tier sub-structured finite element modelling approach has been previously developed by the authors to reduce computational effort without introducing undue conservatism. Tier 1 models the soil as linear elastic to simulate how traffic load is transferred to the quay structure, while Tier 2 employs a non-linear model for the masonry wall and timber foundation, incorporating normal stresses from Tier 1 and soil effects via boundary elements. Compared to previous works, the approach in this work introduces key refinements: phase analysis now simulates all construction stages to capture deformation evolution, soil-structure interaction is improved with more representative stiffness formulations, shear stresses from Tier 1 are transferred to Tier 2, and nonlinear timber behaviour is modelled to explicitly simulate pile failure. The need for this approach arises from field inspections conducted by divers, which revealed diffuse degradation of timber foundation piles. Traditional assessment methods based on 2D sectional analysis would overestimate the probability of collapse because they cannot capture the spatial variability of damage along the quay. To overcome this limitation, the study introduces probabilistic foundation damage scenarios that reflect realistic variability in pile properties. ...
To address this challenge, a two-tier sub-structured finite element modelling approach has been previously developed by the authors to reduce computational effort without introducing undue conservatism. Tier 1 models the soil as linear elastic to simulate how traffic load is transferred to the quay structure, while Tier 2 employs a non-linear model for the masonry wall and timber foundation, incorporating normal stresses from Tier 1 and soil effects via boundary elements. Compared to previous works, the approach in this work introduces key refinements: phase analysis now simulates all construction stages to capture deformation evolution, soil-structure interaction is improved with more representative stiffness formulations, shear stresses from Tier 1 are transferred to Tier 2, and nonlinear timber behaviour is modelled to explicitly simulate pile failure. The need for this approach arises from field inspections conducted by divers, which revealed diffuse degradation of timber foundation piles. Traditional assessment methods based on 2D sectional analysis would overestimate the probability of collapse because they cannot capture the spatial variability of damage along the quay. To overcome this limitation, the study introduces probabilistic foundation damage scenarios that reflect realistic variability in pile properties.
This paper investigates settlement-induced damages in unreinforced masonry (URM) walls using a high-fidelity block-based numerical modeling approach. The research aims to address gaps in the understanding of settlement effects on URM walls with flanges, particularly with respect to their seismic out-of-plane (OOP) behavior. A parametric study is conducted on four wall specimens with varying geometries, boundary conditions, and settlement scenarios, including symmetric and asymmetric patterns. The numerical models are developed via a high-fidelity block-based finite element method that simulates masonry using expanded blocks connected by zero-thickness joints, allowing for detailed analysis of cracking patterns and damage mechanisms. Different damage states, from no visible cracks to near-collapse conditions, are identified in the response of the walls and are used as initial conditions for subsequent monotonic static pushover OOP loading. The results highlight the significant influence of settlement-induced pre-damages on the OOP response of URM walls, with varying degrees of impact observed across different specimen configurations. The findings underscore the importance of considering even “light” settlement-induced pre-damages when assessing the seismic performance of URM structures, particularly in subsidence-prone regions. Under symmetric hogging, such pre-damage level can reduce OOP stiffness and peak strength by up to 41% and 20%, respectively. This study lays the groundwork for future investigations into the seismic behavior of pre-damaged masonry structures under dynamic loading and offers valuable insights for the development of more accurate assessment and mitigation strategies for buildings subjected to settlement deformations.
Numerical modeling of the out-of-plane dynamic response of masonry gable walls via a high-fidelity block-based finite element modeling approach – part II
Post-diction and application to other structural configurations
The out-of-plane (OOP) dynamic behavior of unreinforced masonry (URM) gable walls was investigated in this paper using a high-fidelity block-based numerical modeling approach, building on the participation of the authors in the ERIES SUPREME blind prediction competition. In this paper, the numerical models developed for the competition were updated based on the experimental data published after the competition to further improve accuracy. The improvement was obtained by slight recalibration of mortar joint tensile strength and friction between the walls and the loading set-up. The updated models were also adopted to simulate a third wall originally excluded from the competition. The models were then used to complement the experimental campaign with additional configurations in a parametric study. Specifically, the influence of roof-wall connections and pre-existing damage on the performance of the gable walls were examined to address gaps identified in both experimental and numerical studies of the past. Stronger roof-wall connections, while improving global stability and increasing wall OOP strength in the static regime by up to 140%, led to collapse at dynamic loading intensities reduced by an average of 28% and up to a maximum of 57%. This early collapse resulted from the transfer of larger dynamic demands to the gable walls. This higher demand transfer also caused earlier damage initiation and considerable changes in collapse mechanisms, effects not captured by static analysis, highlighting the uncertainties governing dynamic behavior and the need for robust methodologies to address them. Finally, light pre-damage, modelled in this study as a crack at the base of the walls, had only a minor influence on failure mechanisms and OOP resistance.
An existing interface material model for quasi-brittle fracture, originally developed within the Discrete Element Method framework, is implemented and enhanced for use in implicit Finite Element analyses of unreinforced masonry structures. The model captures mixed-mode fracture in tension-shear and combines cohesion with Coulomb friction in compression-shear. To address convergence issues arising when loading–unloading takes place, due to a discontinuity in the traction–separation relation, a regularization of the frictional contribution is proposed. A new model parameter is introduced and a calibration procedure to ensure numerical robustness and objectivity is presented. Furthermore, the consistent tangent stiffness matrix is derived to improve convergence in full-scale simulations. The improved model is applied within a simplified micromodelling approach to simulate the in-plane cyclic response of 2D masonry structures, including a shear wall and a spandrel subjected to a combination of horizontal and vertical actions. The results demonstrate that the model accurately reproduces key aspects of masonry behaviour, including stiffness degradation, energy dissipation, and crack patterns, while maintaining robustness and efficiency in complex cyclic loading scenarios.