J.A. Pascoe
Please Note
27 records found
1
Evaluation of Wire-Derived Ultrasonically Atomized 316L Stainless Steel for Laser Powder Bed Fusion
A Comparative Study with Gas-Atomized Powder
This thesis characterizes wire-derived UA SS316L as a feedstock for laser powder bed fusion (LPBF), comparing directly with a commercial GA powder. A UA process window was first established through Archimedes density and image analysis of cubes. The densest UA parameter set was then applied to both feedstocks to fabricate cube, tensile, and hardness specimens under two scan strategies (67° and contour), and BCC lattices under 67°. Cubes were characterized for porosity, microstructure, crystallographic texture (EBSD), and phase composition (XRD). Mechanical performance was evaluated through tensile testing, Vickers hardness, and lattice compression. Powder reuse was assessed over five successive builds.
Both feedstocks achieved relative densities above 99%. Across both scan strategies, UA specimens showed slightly lower yield and ultimate tensile strengths than GA with slightly higher ductility, though the differences were modest. Feedstock type had limited influence on grain morphology, whereas scan strategy strongly affected crystallographic texture. Tensile and hardness values for all specimens fell within the range typically reported for LPBF SS316L. UA-derived BCC lattices exhibited compressive response comparable to GA counterparts. After five reuse cycles, UA powder exhibited only limited degradation in feedstock and part properties.
Overall, wire-derived UA SS316L is shown to be a viable LPBF feedstock for dense bulk components and BCC lattice structures. These findings provide a useful foundation for future work on ultrasonic atomization as a scrap-based route for metal AM feedstocks. ...
This thesis characterizes wire-derived UA SS316L as a feedstock for laser powder bed fusion (LPBF), comparing directly with a commercial GA powder. A UA process window was first established through Archimedes density and image analysis of cubes. The densest UA parameter set was then applied to both feedstocks to fabricate cube, tensile, and hardness specimens under two scan strategies (67° and contour), and BCC lattices under 67°. Cubes were characterized for porosity, microstructure, crystallographic texture (EBSD), and phase composition (XRD). Mechanical performance was evaluated through tensile testing, Vickers hardness, and lattice compression. Powder reuse was assessed over five successive builds.
Both feedstocks achieved relative densities above 99%. Across both scan strategies, UA specimens showed slightly lower yield and ultimate tensile strengths than GA with slightly higher ductility, though the differences were modest. Feedstock type had limited influence on grain morphology, whereas scan strategy strongly affected crystallographic texture. Tensile and hardness values for all specimens fell within the range typically reported for LPBF SS316L. UA-derived BCC lattices exhibited compressive response comparable to GA counterparts. After five reuse cycles, UA powder exhibited only limited degradation in feedstock and part properties.
Overall, wire-derived UA SS316L is shown to be a viable LPBF feedstock for dense bulk components and BCC lattice structures. These findings provide a useful foundation for future work on ultrasonic atomization as a scrap-based route for metal AM feedstocks.
...
Microstructural study of ZrB2 powder reinforced C/C-SiC composites
Investigating the influence of UHTC particle addition methods on the microstructure and oxidation resistance
The stiffener layout is optimized explicitly using the Moving Morphable Components method in a Python-OptiStruct loop, after which the skin is sized by free-size optimization based on the converged layout, which returns a homogenized skin definition, a continuous total thickness and fiber-angle percentages per element, but no lay-up. This thickness field is made manufacturable in three stages: clustering into discrete thickness zones, a stacking sequence table parametrization that builds a guide laminate from the free-size lamination parameters and drops plies in an importance-driven order subject to the standard laminate and ply-drop guidelines, and a morphological filter that regularizes each fiber angle along its own direction at the AFP minimum cut length. A secant-based compensation step then returns the filtered design to its target material budget.
The framework is applied to an aircraft flat pressure bulkhead under uniform out-of-plane pressure, in-plane compression and asymmetric pressure, with the stiffener layout optimizer first verified against a reference configuration from the literature. Compared at equal volume, the final manufacturable designs improve on a uniform panel baseline by 15%, 18% and 7%, corresponding to structural knockdowns of 22%, 8% and 18% against the free-size theoretical optimum. The delivered designs therefore recover between roughly a third and three quarters of the performance benefit available from the optimization. The cost of manufacturability is not a fixed penalty: relative to the total available performance gain from optimization, it is smallest for the membrane-dominated compression case, whose stiffness depends on how much material is present rather than exactly where, and largest where the optimum relies on a fragmented, bending-critical reinforcement network that the filter is forced to remove.
Sensitivity studies over requested volume fraction, minimum cut length and ply thickness confirm this trend, and a guideline relaxation study shows that removing laminate constraints does not reliably improve the delivered design. This traces to the structure of the framework itself: the guide laminate and ply-drop order are selected on structurally motivated but approximate criteria that are never re-evaluated against the compliance of the design they produce. Together with a compliance-based objective and a four-angle suite, this bounds how closely the manufacturable design can approach the theoretical optimum, and indicates where the framework can most readily be improved.
Overall, this work shows that structural optimization and AFP manufacturing constraints can be combined in a single automated workflow, and quantifies the resulting structural cost for stiffened composite panels under a variety of load cases. This allows the cost of manufacturability to be predicted early in the design process and weighed when choosing parameters such as minimum cut length and ply thickness, rather than being discovered in later design stages
...
The stiffener layout is optimized explicitly using the Moving Morphable Components method in a Python-OptiStruct loop, after which the skin is sized by free-size optimization based on the converged layout, which returns a homogenized skin definition, a continuous total thickness and fiber-angle percentages per element, but no lay-up. This thickness field is made manufacturable in three stages: clustering into discrete thickness zones, a stacking sequence table parametrization that builds a guide laminate from the free-size lamination parameters and drops plies in an importance-driven order subject to the standard laminate and ply-drop guidelines, and a morphological filter that regularizes each fiber angle along its own direction at the AFP minimum cut length. A secant-based compensation step then returns the filtered design to its target material budget.
The framework is applied to an aircraft flat pressure bulkhead under uniform out-of-plane pressure, in-plane compression and asymmetric pressure, with the stiffener layout optimizer first verified against a reference configuration from the literature. Compared at equal volume, the final manufacturable designs improve on a uniform panel baseline by 15%, 18% and 7%, corresponding to structural knockdowns of 22%, 8% and 18% against the free-size theoretical optimum. The delivered designs therefore recover between roughly a third and three quarters of the performance benefit available from the optimization. The cost of manufacturability is not a fixed penalty: relative to the total available performance gain from optimization, it is smallest for the membrane-dominated compression case, whose stiffness depends on how much material is present rather than exactly where, and largest where the optimum relies on a fragmented, bending-critical reinforcement network that the filter is forced to remove.
Sensitivity studies over requested volume fraction, minimum cut length and ply thickness confirm this trend, and a guideline relaxation study shows that removing laminate constraints does not reliably improve the delivered design. This traces to the structure of the framework itself: the guide laminate and ply-drop order are selected on structurally motivated but approximate criteria that are never re-evaluated against the compliance of the design they produce. Together with a compliance-based objective and a four-angle suite, this bounds how closely the manufacturable design can approach the theoretical optimum, and indicates where the framework can most readily be improved.
Overall, this work shows that structural optimization and AFP manufacturing constraints can be combined in a single automated workflow, and quantifies the resulting structural cost for stiffened composite panels under a variety of load cases. This allows the cost of manufacturability to be predicted early in the design process and weighed when choosing parameters such as minimum cut length and ply thickness, rather than being discovered in later design stages
The research aims to expand and validate the Energy Balance with the Sliding Box analogy (EBSB) framework by comparing its predictions to a comprehensive experimental dataset covering both room-temperature and low-temperature conditions down to -30°C. The study considers a diversified selection of aluminum alloys with quasi-static property differences that emulate changes expected at low temperature. The investigated materials are 7075-T6, 2024-T3, 6061-T6, and an artificially over-aged 2024-A300. Additionally, thicknesses from 1 to 6.5 mm and two stress ratios, R=0.1 and R=0.5, are varied to evaluate their influence on the modeled fatigue crack-growth response. The methodology combines quasi-static tensile testing to determine case-specific elastic--plastic properties with constant-amplitude fatigue crack-growth experiments on standard geometry specimens. Crack growth is measured via periodic high-contrast image capture. Furthermore, Digital Image Correlation (DIC) is employed to evaluate plastic-zone development from periodic displacement-field measurements around the advancing crack tip.
The results demonstrate that the EBSB model—particularly in its direct sliding-box form—captures the general trends and order of magnitude of fatigue crack growth in aluminum alloys well. However, predictive accuracy is limited by the current formulation of the plastic energy dissipation term and by the treatment of stress-state transitions (plane stress/plane strain). The quantification of plastic-volume growth within the energy balance was varied in an attempt to capture increased energy absorption at low temperature. The model tends to overestimate crack-growth rates, especially for pronounced variations in yield strength and strain hardening relative to the 7075-T6 baseline. This effect is not mitigated by adopting larger plastic-zone approximations. For lower thicknesses of 7075-T6, however, using a larger plastic-zone estimate reduces model error, consistent with better agreement with the plane-stress assumption.
Overall, the EBSB model is sensitive to material-specific strain-energy absorption characteristics, particularly yield strength and the degree of strain hardening. Experimental observations confirm the expected increase in yield strength and work hardening at low temperature, but also reveal an unexpected decrease in ductility for the low-temperature 7075-T6 tests, highlighting the complex coupling between material behavior and environment. Improvements to the EBSB framework are proposed, including a parametrically defined plastic strain energy density derived from quasi-static stress--strain data and the introduction of a damping term to account for crack-shielding effects. Recommendations for future work include expanded cryogenic testing, improved DIC resolution, and the development of more robust analytical and numerical treatments to better capture strain hardening, stress-state transitions, and plastic-zone evolution. ...
The research aims to expand and validate the Energy Balance with the Sliding Box analogy (EBSB) framework by comparing its predictions to a comprehensive experimental dataset covering both room-temperature and low-temperature conditions down to -30°C. The study considers a diversified selection of aluminum alloys with quasi-static property differences that emulate changes expected at low temperature. The investigated materials are 7075-T6, 2024-T3, 6061-T6, and an artificially over-aged 2024-A300. Additionally, thicknesses from 1 to 6.5 mm and two stress ratios, R=0.1 and R=0.5, are varied to evaluate their influence on the modeled fatigue crack-growth response. The methodology combines quasi-static tensile testing to determine case-specific elastic--plastic properties with constant-amplitude fatigue crack-growth experiments on standard geometry specimens. Crack growth is measured via periodic high-contrast image capture. Furthermore, Digital Image Correlation (DIC) is employed to evaluate plastic-zone development from periodic displacement-field measurements around the advancing crack tip.
The results demonstrate that the EBSB model—particularly in its direct sliding-box form—captures the general trends and order of magnitude of fatigue crack growth in aluminum alloys well. However, predictive accuracy is limited by the current formulation of the plastic energy dissipation term and by the treatment of stress-state transitions (plane stress/plane strain). The quantification of plastic-volume growth within the energy balance was varied in an attempt to capture increased energy absorption at low temperature. The model tends to overestimate crack-growth rates, especially for pronounced variations in yield strength and strain hardening relative to the 7075-T6 baseline. This effect is not mitigated by adopting larger plastic-zone approximations. For lower thicknesses of 7075-T6, however, using a larger plastic-zone estimate reduces model error, consistent with better agreement with the plane-stress assumption.
Overall, the EBSB model is sensitive to material-specific strain-energy absorption characteristics, particularly yield strength and the degree of strain hardening. Experimental observations confirm the expected increase in yield strength and work hardening at low temperature, but also reveal an unexpected decrease in ductility for the low-temperature 7075-T6 tests, highlighting the complex coupling between material behavior and environment. Improvements to the EBSB framework are proposed, including a parametrically defined plastic strain energy density derived from quasi-static stress--strain data and the introduction of a damping term to account for crack-shielding effects. Recommendations for future work include expanded cryogenic testing, improved DIC resolution, and the development of more robust analytical and numerical treatments to better capture strain hardening, stress-state transitions, and plastic-zone evolution.
This work focuses on adapting the z-pinning concept, previously applied in PLA systems, to the challenges of anisotropic, shear-aligning LCPs. A z-pinning methodology is developed around the commercial filament Vectra® A950, utilizing a bottom-up insertion process enabled by custom G-code routines. Vertical pins are extruded into pre-formed voids during the print, allowing control over pin shape, height, and placement. The approach leverages standard FFF hardware, requiring only a narrow-tip nozzle and careful synchronization of extrusion timing to ensure consistent pin deposition.
Mechanical testing was conducted on both pinned and unpinned tensile specimens printed in the Z-direction. The results demonstrate that z-pinning significantly enhances performance when properly implemented. The best configuration, tall pins arranged in an ABA staggering pattern, achieved a 40% increase in peak load and a tenfold increase in energy absorption before reaching peak load. Fracture analysis revealed more distributed fracture patterns, with signs of crack deflection and arrest, indicating a transition from brittle delamination to
more progressive failure modes.
These findings validate the feasibility of z-pinning for improving the mechanical properties of 3D-printed LCP components. However, the benefits are highly sensitive to process execution, as poor pin deposition may negate reinforcement or introduce stress concentrators. The study underscores the importance of concurrent design and manufacturing development, showing that even in single-material systems, structural performance can be engineered through localized deposition strategies. This opens a path toward more robust, anisotropy-mitigated 3D-printed parts using high-performance polymers. ...
This work focuses on adapting the z-pinning concept, previously applied in PLA systems, to the challenges of anisotropic, shear-aligning LCPs. A z-pinning methodology is developed around the commercial filament Vectra® A950, utilizing a bottom-up insertion process enabled by custom G-code routines. Vertical pins are extruded into pre-formed voids during the print, allowing control over pin shape, height, and placement. The approach leverages standard FFF hardware, requiring only a narrow-tip nozzle and careful synchronization of extrusion timing to ensure consistent pin deposition.
Mechanical testing was conducted on both pinned and unpinned tensile specimens printed in the Z-direction. The results demonstrate that z-pinning significantly enhances performance when properly implemented. The best configuration, tall pins arranged in an ABA staggering pattern, achieved a 40% increase in peak load and a tenfold increase in energy absorption before reaching peak load. Fracture analysis revealed more distributed fracture patterns, with signs of crack deflection and arrest, indicating a transition from brittle delamination to
more progressive failure modes.
These findings validate the feasibility of z-pinning for improving the mechanical properties of 3D-printed LCP components. However, the benefits are highly sensitive to process execution, as poor pin deposition may negate reinforcement or introduce stress concentrators. The study underscores the importance of concurrent design and manufacturing development, showing that even in single-material systems, structural performance can be engineered through localized deposition strategies. This opens a path toward more robust, anisotropy-mitigated 3D-printed parts using high-performance polymers.
Impact on Cold spray Repairs
Damage mechanisms of cold spray repairs subjected to low velocity impact
The primary objective of this research was to identify and characterize the dominant damage mecha- nisms that occur in cold spray coatings and repairs under LVI conditions. Six types of cold sprayed aluminum alloy coupons were evaluated, including both flat coatings and double curved blend-out re- pairs and cold spray depositions of AA1XXX and AA2024. The depositions were applied using either a robotic system or a manual gun. All specimens were subjected to controlled impact loading via drop weight and/or quasi static indentation tests. The results were analyzed using high-speed camera imaging, optical microscopy, and scanning electron microscopy of both surface and cross-sectional features.
Key output parameters such as dent depth, dent width, absorbed energy, and crack formation were analyzed and compared across different coupon types and impact energies. Results show that:
• Deposition geometry plays a critical role in how the material deforms under impact.
• The ductility of the deposition and substrate materials (e.g., AA1XXX vs. AA2024) influences both energy absorption and crack resistance for varying impact location.
• Coarse-gritsurfacepreparationenhancesbondingandincreasesresistancetodelaminationcom- pared to finer surface treatments.
• Barely visible impact damage does not apply to cold spray depositions as a dent is always visible. However, the substrate (non-impact side) showed different crack thresholds and damage mech- anisms compared to the cold spray deposition. The substrate cracked more severely compared to the cold spray deposition.
• Manual gun-sprayed depositions exhibit non-uniform properties, leading to variable crack thresh- olds across the repair area.
To compare performance independently of thickness, the impact data was normalized by the deposi- tion thickness. This revealed that thin coatings (like AA1XXX on top of AA2024) show lower energy absorption per millimeter compared to blend-out repairs.
In conclusion, the study highlights the critical influence of deposition material, geometry, thickness, and surface treatment on the performance of cold spray repairs under impact. It demonstrates key differences between robotic and manual spray systems, particularly in terms of uniformity and damage treshodls. The results show that cold spray depositions are able to withstand low velocity impact and can thus be used to repair dents in cowling inlet lips. The insights contribute to the ongoing research to integrate manual cold spray gun systems into aerospace repairs. ...
The primary objective of this research was to identify and characterize the dominant damage mecha- nisms that occur in cold spray coatings and repairs under LVI conditions. Six types of cold sprayed aluminum alloy coupons were evaluated, including both flat coatings and double curved blend-out re- pairs and cold spray depositions of AA1XXX and AA2024. The depositions were applied using either a robotic system or a manual gun. All specimens were subjected to controlled impact loading via drop weight and/or quasi static indentation tests. The results were analyzed using high-speed camera imaging, optical microscopy, and scanning electron microscopy of both surface and cross-sectional features.
Key output parameters such as dent depth, dent width, absorbed energy, and crack formation were analyzed and compared across different coupon types and impact energies. Results show that:
• Deposition geometry plays a critical role in how the material deforms under impact.
• The ductility of the deposition and substrate materials (e.g., AA1XXX vs. AA2024) influences both energy absorption and crack resistance for varying impact location.
• Coarse-gritsurfacepreparationenhancesbondingandincreasesresistancetodelaminationcom- pared to finer surface treatments.
• Barely visible impact damage does not apply to cold spray depositions as a dent is always visible. However, the substrate (non-impact side) showed different crack thresholds and damage mech- anisms compared to the cold spray deposition. The substrate cracked more severely compared to the cold spray deposition.
• Manual gun-sprayed depositions exhibit non-uniform properties, leading to variable crack thresh- olds across the repair area.
To compare performance independently of thickness, the impact data was normalized by the deposi- tion thickness. This revealed that thin coatings (like AA1XXX on top of AA2024) show lower energy absorption per millimeter compared to blend-out repairs.
In conclusion, the study highlights the critical influence of deposition material, geometry, thickness, and surface treatment on the performance of cold spray repairs under impact. It demonstrates key differences between robotic and manual spray systems, particularly in terms of uniformity and damage treshodls. The results show that cold spray depositions are able to withstand low velocity impact and can thus be used to repair dents in cowling inlet lips. The insights contribute to the ongoing research to integrate manual cold spray gun systems into aerospace repairs.
However, a challenge with the CZM in modeling damage in composites lies in determining which damage mechanism occurs at a given numerical interface. To date, fracture simulation in composite laminates has mainly relied on methods designed for isotropic materials, which come with notable modeling constraints such as limiting the arbitrariness of damage evolution and requiring experimental data on fracture propagation.
In this thesis, a novel approach is proposed to ensure arbitrary damage development solely based on the structural stress state using the DG/CZM approach. ...
However, a challenge with the CZM in modeling damage in composites lies in determining which damage mechanism occurs at a given numerical interface. To date, fracture simulation in composite laminates has mainly relied on methods designed for isotropic materials, which come with notable modeling constraints such as limiting the arbitrariness of damage evolution and requiring experimental data on fracture propagation.
In this thesis, a novel approach is proposed to ensure arbitrary damage development solely based on the structural stress state using the DG/CZM approach.
Tow-Based Discontinuous Composites for Toughening Adhesively Bonded Composite Joints
Experimental investigation on the influence of UD/TBDC ply hybrid CFRP substrates on the mode I fracture toughness
For CFRP laminates, Double-Cantilever Beam (DCB) samples were tested across three configurations: a non-toughened baseline and two TBDC-toughened variants. Based on previous research, three DCB configurations identified as the most promising for leveraging TBDC toughening in adhesive joints were tested. The [90/45/-45/TBDC/0]s and [90/60/90/-60/TBDC/0]s laminate substrates were bonded with the low-toughness adhesive Araldite 2015-1, while the [0/TBDC/90_2/0]s substrate was bonded with AF 163-2U, a high-toughness adhesive.
TBDC-toughened CFRP laminates demonstrated up to 130% higher fracture toughness compared to non-toughened counterparts. This was due to TBDC material crack propagation mechanisms such as crack branching, deflection, and fiber bridging.
In adhesively bonded joints, TBDC interleaves in CFRP substrates enhanced the decay of fracture toughness in specimens where cracks deflected from the bond line into the substrate, leading to a less abrupt reduction after reaching peak values. Joints with low-toughness adhesive exhibited more than a 100% increase in crack length from peak fracture toughness to the final value compared to non-TBDC-toughened substrate joints. Meanwhile, joints with high-toughness adhesive demonstrated toughness values 150% to 750% greater than those observed in non-toughened configurations at comparable crack lengths.
These findings highlight the potential of TBDC interleaves to enhance joint toughness, presenting new pathways to improve the safety of composite bonded structures.
...
For CFRP laminates, Double-Cantilever Beam (DCB) samples were tested across three configurations: a non-toughened baseline and two TBDC-toughened variants. Based on previous research, three DCB configurations identified as the most promising for leveraging TBDC toughening in adhesive joints were tested. The [90/45/-45/TBDC/0]s and [90/60/90/-60/TBDC/0]s laminate substrates were bonded with the low-toughness adhesive Araldite 2015-1, while the [0/TBDC/90_2/0]s substrate was bonded with AF 163-2U, a high-toughness adhesive.
TBDC-toughened CFRP laminates demonstrated up to 130% higher fracture toughness compared to non-toughened counterparts. This was due to TBDC material crack propagation mechanisms such as crack branching, deflection, and fiber bridging.
In adhesively bonded joints, TBDC interleaves in CFRP substrates enhanced the decay of fracture toughness in specimens where cracks deflected from the bond line into the substrate, leading to a less abrupt reduction after reaching peak values. Joints with low-toughness adhesive exhibited more than a 100% increase in crack length from peak fracture toughness to the final value compared to non-TBDC-toughened substrate joints. Meanwhile, joints with high-toughness adhesive demonstrated toughness values 150% to 750% greater than those observed in non-toughened configurations at comparable crack lengths.
These findings highlight the potential of TBDC interleaves to enhance joint toughness, presenting new pathways to improve the safety of composite bonded structures.
Listening to liquid hydrogen tanks
A feasibility study into localising damage in double-walled tanks using acoustic emssion
To be able to perform experiments, a metal double-walled vacuum insulated tank with a fixed and flexible support was cut in half to make the inner tank accessible. Pencil lead break tests were performed on the inner and outer tank and recorded by lead zirconate titanate (PZT) sensors to assess localisation accuracy. It was found that a pencil lead break (PLB) performed on the inner tank could be detected by a sensor placed on the outer tank. Subsequently, an accuracy of 80% was achieved in making the distinction whether the PLB was located on the inner or outer tank. For the PLBs placed on the inner tank a 1D localisation accuracy of 17 [mm] and 21 [mm] was achievable for the flexible and fixed support respectively. For the outer tank a 1D localisation accuracy of 46 [mm] was achievable, while for 2D localisation this was 41 [mm].
It is concluded that with sensors placed solely on the outer tank, both the inner and outer tank can be monitored. Additionally, simulated damage on the inner and outer tank could be localised with an accuracy below 10% of the tank’s dimension. Therefore, based on the feasibility study performed, acoustic emission-based structural health monitoring is deemed a viable method to enhance the reliability and safety of metal double-walled vacuum insulated LH2 tanks. ...
To be able to perform experiments, a metal double-walled vacuum insulated tank with a fixed and flexible support was cut in half to make the inner tank accessible. Pencil lead break tests were performed on the inner and outer tank and recorded by lead zirconate titanate (PZT) sensors to assess localisation accuracy. It was found that a pencil lead break (PLB) performed on the inner tank could be detected by a sensor placed on the outer tank. Subsequently, an accuracy of 80% was achieved in making the distinction whether the PLB was located on the inner or outer tank. For the PLBs placed on the inner tank a 1D localisation accuracy of 17 [mm] and 21 [mm] was achievable for the flexible and fixed support respectively. For the outer tank a 1D localisation accuracy of 46 [mm] was achievable, while for 2D localisation this was 41 [mm].
It is concluded that with sensors placed solely on the outer tank, both the inner and outer tank can be monitored. Additionally, simulated damage on the inner and outer tank could be localised with an accuracy below 10% of the tank’s dimension. Therefore, based on the feasibility study performed, acoustic emission-based structural health monitoring is deemed a viable method to enhance the reliability and safety of metal double-walled vacuum insulated LH2 tanks.
Optimisation of Fibre Metal Laminate Splice Designs with Focus on Fatigue Performance
A Multi-Disciplinary Approach
The bulk of research into the splice joint has been conducted in the early 2000s for the A380 program, where a specific type of splice has been implemented, the overlap splice. While it is a proven design, it was expected that other splice designs could be as good if not better than the overlap splice. Further, the pre-existing design guidelines on the splices were not suited for detailed design that would target specific mechanical strengths of the joint, like durability and
damage tolerance. Therefore, this research focused on design iterations of the two splice types, the butt splice and the overlap splice, that would provide insights into splice design guidelines against fatigue and demonstrate which splice configuration is a superior joint. An extension
of this research focuses on identification of location and lifetime to damage initiation within the splice using analytical numerical methods, which was previously done on uninterrupted FMLs, but not on spliced FMLs.
Research comprises of a multi-disciplinary approach, combining Finite Element Method (FEM), numerical predictive modelling and experimental investigations that then also doubled as means of validation of the models built. Design iterations were based on the influence that the parameters, labeled a through e, within the splice joint have on the overall stress field within the joint and how that affects the joint’s fatigue life to damage initiation, Ni, a fatigue
performance indicator of the study. It has been discovered that changing the tolerances within the splices provides little influence on the stress field within the splice, which resulted in several iterations of the splice design approaching smaller and more lightweight joint alterations. The designs showed excellent durability characteristics when compared to the Limit of Validity (LOV) cycles set by the aviation authorities, such as EASA and FAA. The Finite Element (FE) model was able to accurately depict the stress field within the splice, validated by the experimental data through strain fields captured using Digital Image Correlation (DIC) technique, and consequently accurately pointed to the location of damage initiation, which in all cases was the outer-most overlap on the flush side of the joint. Along with the adapted predictive numerical model it was possible to predict the damage initiation lives in the spliced specimens with a blunt notch. The predictions in the samples without the notch resulted in far lesser agreement with experiments. This was likely caused by to the limitations of the model, which only took into account quasi-static loading without damage and is highly dependent on the reference data used.
It was concluded that splices can be designed smaller and lighter than previously done due to the tighter tolerances allowed within the splice. Overlaps of 5 mm in both the unnotched butt splice and the unnotched overlap splice, however, resulted in an alternative damage progression mode, specifically a complete delamination of the external overlap rather than metal fatigue cracking. This is attributed to the rising average shear stress in the adhesive. Regardless, the smallest and lightest iterations of the butt splice and the overlap splice with
5 mm overlaps and gaps between aluminium interruptions showed excellent durability and the design iterations were found to affect the damage initiation life very little, considering that fatigue damage initiation is a subject to scatter. It is hard to draw a concrete conclusion on the damage tolerance of the updated designs due to alternative damage modes and lack of research thereof. While both splice types were deemed to be successful in their role of a joining structure, the butt splice was concluded to be superior to the overlap splice when it came to fatigue performance, consistently developing visible damage later than the overlap splice. This gap in fatigue performance is expected to expand if thicker layers or larger number of layers are to be considered. This is because of the secondary bending which occurred in the joint, more so for the overlap splice than the butt splice judging from FEA results and experiments.
It is recommended that a more extensive FE model is developed using the model built in this research as a foundation. The current model could be expanded in several ways, such as simulations of damage progression, individual modelling of the fibre layers, fibre failure models, and a curing simulation. This will improve the validity of the methodology, specifically concerning the unnotched splice specimens, and improve the predictions of not only initiation lives, but also failure lives.
...
The bulk of research into the splice joint has been conducted in the early 2000s for the A380 program, where a specific type of splice has been implemented, the overlap splice. While it is a proven design, it was expected that other splice designs could be as good if not better than the overlap splice. Further, the pre-existing design guidelines on the splices were not suited for detailed design that would target specific mechanical strengths of the joint, like durability and
damage tolerance. Therefore, this research focused on design iterations of the two splice types, the butt splice and the overlap splice, that would provide insights into splice design guidelines against fatigue and demonstrate which splice configuration is a superior joint. An extension
of this research focuses on identification of location and lifetime to damage initiation within the splice using analytical numerical methods, which was previously done on uninterrupted FMLs, but not on spliced FMLs.
Research comprises of a multi-disciplinary approach, combining Finite Element Method (FEM), numerical predictive modelling and experimental investigations that then also doubled as means of validation of the models built. Design iterations were based on the influence that the parameters, labeled a through e, within the splice joint have on the overall stress field within the joint and how that affects the joint’s fatigue life to damage initiation, Ni, a fatigue
performance indicator of the study. It has been discovered that changing the tolerances within the splices provides little influence on the stress field within the splice, which resulted in several iterations of the splice design approaching smaller and more lightweight joint alterations. The designs showed excellent durability characteristics when compared to the Limit of Validity (LOV) cycles set by the aviation authorities, such as EASA and FAA. The Finite Element (FE) model was able to accurately depict the stress field within the splice, validated by the experimental data through strain fields captured using Digital Image Correlation (DIC) technique, and consequently accurately pointed to the location of damage initiation, which in all cases was the outer-most overlap on the flush side of the joint. Along with the adapted predictive numerical model it was possible to predict the damage initiation lives in the spliced specimens with a blunt notch. The predictions in the samples without the notch resulted in far lesser agreement with experiments. This was likely caused by to the limitations of the model, which only took into account quasi-static loading without damage and is highly dependent on the reference data used.
It was concluded that splices can be designed smaller and lighter than previously done due to the tighter tolerances allowed within the splice. Overlaps of 5 mm in both the unnotched butt splice and the unnotched overlap splice, however, resulted in an alternative damage progression mode, specifically a complete delamination of the external overlap rather than metal fatigue cracking. This is attributed to the rising average shear stress in the adhesive. Regardless, the smallest and lightest iterations of the butt splice and the overlap splice with
5 mm overlaps and gaps between aluminium interruptions showed excellent durability and the design iterations were found to affect the damage initiation life very little, considering that fatigue damage initiation is a subject to scatter. It is hard to draw a concrete conclusion on the damage tolerance of the updated designs due to alternative damage modes and lack of research thereof. While both splice types were deemed to be successful in their role of a joining structure, the butt splice was concluded to be superior to the overlap splice when it came to fatigue performance, consistently developing visible damage later than the overlap splice. This gap in fatigue performance is expected to expand if thicker layers or larger number of layers are to be considered. This is because of the secondary bending which occurred in the joint, more so for the overlap splice than the butt splice judging from FEA results and experiments.
It is recommended that a more extensive FE model is developed using the model built in this research as a foundation. The current model could be expanded in several ways, such as simulations of damage progression, individual modelling of the fibre layers, fibre failure models, and a curing simulation. This will improve the validity of the methodology, specifically concerning the unnotched splice specimens, and improve the predictions of not only initiation lives, but also failure lives.
The first aim of this thesis is to propose a novel analysis method to address the issue of volume interdependence in the PJET. To achieve this, a concept called "equivalent velocity" is introduced. The equivalent velocity represents the velocity at which a spherical droplet should impact a surface to exert the same kinetic energy per impingement as the actual water slug moving at the impact velocity. By utilizing this concept, the velocity-number of impacts plot takes into account the volume interdependence in erosion experiments.
The second aim is to utilize the PJET to analyze the erosion behavior of PA and PD coatings. The investigation focuses on understanding the relationship between impact velocity and the number of impacts until the incubation period and the breakthrough. The incubation period refers to the interval until the damage is visible and the breakthrough is the moment until the filler underneath the coating is exposed. Additionally, the erosion damage progression of the coatings was analyzed, and the lifetime prediction was evaluated using an existing long-term leading-edge rain erosion model.
The experimental results revealed that the ductile material (PD) exhibits a longer resistance to erosion compared to the stiff material (PA), with the mean number of impacts until breakthrough being 2 to 3 times higher for PD. Moreover, the long-term leading-edge rain erosion model highlights the importance of the accurate measurement of material properties, as lifetime prediction is very sensitive to ultimate tensile strength and Poisson’s ratio.
However, it is crucial to validate the equivalent velocity method through experiments and numerical modeling, while also improving the experimental method to allow for continuous observation of the erosion process in a controlled environment with temperature and humidity regulation. Conducting tests in a wider range of velocities is also recommended. Additionally, improvements for the rain erosion model are necessary to accommodate the utilization of the equivalent velocity. ...
The first aim of this thesis is to propose a novel analysis method to address the issue of volume interdependence in the PJET. To achieve this, a concept called "equivalent velocity" is introduced. The equivalent velocity represents the velocity at which a spherical droplet should impact a surface to exert the same kinetic energy per impingement as the actual water slug moving at the impact velocity. By utilizing this concept, the velocity-number of impacts plot takes into account the volume interdependence in erosion experiments.
The second aim is to utilize the PJET to analyze the erosion behavior of PA and PD coatings. The investigation focuses on understanding the relationship between impact velocity and the number of impacts until the incubation period and the breakthrough. The incubation period refers to the interval until the damage is visible and the breakthrough is the moment until the filler underneath the coating is exposed. Additionally, the erosion damage progression of the coatings was analyzed, and the lifetime prediction was evaluated using an existing long-term leading-edge rain erosion model.
The experimental results revealed that the ductile material (PD) exhibits a longer resistance to erosion compared to the stiff material (PA), with the mean number of impacts until breakthrough being 2 to 3 times higher for PD. Moreover, the long-term leading-edge rain erosion model highlights the importance of the accurate measurement of material properties, as lifetime prediction is very sensitive to ultimate tensile strength and Poisson’s ratio.
However, it is crucial to validate the equivalent velocity method through experiments and numerical modeling, while also improving the experimental method to allow for continuous observation of the erosion process in a controlled environment with temperature and humidity regulation. Conducting tests in a wider range of velocities is also recommended. Additionally, improvements for the rain erosion model are necessary to accommodate the utilization of the equivalent velocity.
The occurrence of barely visible impact damage (BVID) in aircraft composite structures, especially in adhesive joints, is a serious issue that can jeopardise an aircraft's structural safety during operation. However, virtual testing and numerous numerical approaches allow high-fidelity simulation of damage initiation and propagation in adhesives and composite adherends to predict the residual strength of the bonding accurately. Although the development is fast, accurate impact simulation is still computationally very expensive and thus not applicable in industrial cases where behaviour needs to be analysed to assess the structures' design, maintenance and repair.
This thesis investigated two topics that allow robust and accurate simulation methods to assess the effect of manufacturing and impact damage on the residual strength of bonded joints. The first topic is related to the development of the composite material damage model, where the multiscale material model is created by the use of a representative volume element (RVE). The second topic of simulation methodology is the development of the quasi-static simulation approach for the damage tolerance assessment of bonded joints. Modelling approaches to simulate residual strength are investigated through the finite element modelling of three groups (i) pristine, (ii) artificially damaged during manufacturing, and (iii) impacted bonded joints. In the numerical models, an approach based on the observation of the fracture surface of single-lap joints in different geometry and layup configuration is proposed in which the damage assessment focuses on the bondline area up to the first 0° ply. For the modelling of the damage in joints, two modelling techniques were studied, first removing elements in the damaged area and second detachment of the elements. Utilising those techniques, simplified approaches to model damage resulting from the impact were studied, with the modelling of impact damage as a hole, where all through-thickness elements are deleted and as delamination, where interlaminar cohesive zone elements are deleted.
The developed multiscale material model allowed for an accurate representation of failure modes occurring in the composite material by the characterisation of elastic, damage and plasticity parameters of the fibre and matrix constituents in the homogenisation and inverse characterisation process. The results showed that the deletion of the elements can be used to represent defects and damage of different kinds in the composite bonded joints, both in the adhesive and adherend. The comparison of different representations of the impact damage in the single lap joint configuration revealed that the best prediction in terms of the ultimate load, failure mode and size of the model is obtained with the simplified representation as a single delamination positioned before the first 0° ply in the layup and in the studied adherend configuration that was between the first (45°) and second (0°) ply in the layup. The study ends with the conclusion that in different geometries of single lap joints and different damage types studied, a numerical analysis should focus on the region of the overlap edge and in the thickness direction from the bondline up to the first 0° ply in the lay-up. The results and numerical method developed during this thesis create a base for the further investigation of a variety of impact cases on bonded joints. ...
The occurrence of barely visible impact damage (BVID) in aircraft composite structures, especially in adhesive joints, is a serious issue that can jeopardise an aircraft's structural safety during operation. However, virtual testing and numerous numerical approaches allow high-fidelity simulation of damage initiation and propagation in adhesives and composite adherends to predict the residual strength of the bonding accurately. Although the development is fast, accurate impact simulation is still computationally very expensive and thus not applicable in industrial cases where behaviour needs to be analysed to assess the structures' design, maintenance and repair.
This thesis investigated two topics that allow robust and accurate simulation methods to assess the effect of manufacturing and impact damage on the residual strength of bonded joints. The first topic is related to the development of the composite material damage model, where the multiscale material model is created by the use of a representative volume element (RVE). The second topic of simulation methodology is the development of the quasi-static simulation approach for the damage tolerance assessment of bonded joints. Modelling approaches to simulate residual strength are investigated through the finite element modelling of three groups (i) pristine, (ii) artificially damaged during manufacturing, and (iii) impacted bonded joints. In the numerical models, an approach based on the observation of the fracture surface of single-lap joints in different geometry and layup configuration is proposed in which the damage assessment focuses on the bondline area up to the first 0° ply. For the modelling of the damage in joints, two modelling techniques were studied, first removing elements in the damaged area and second detachment of the elements. Utilising those techniques, simplified approaches to model damage resulting from the impact were studied, with the modelling of impact damage as a hole, where all through-thickness elements are deleted and as delamination, where interlaminar cohesive zone elements are deleted.
The developed multiscale material model allowed for an accurate representation of failure modes occurring in the composite material by the characterisation of elastic, damage and plasticity parameters of the fibre and matrix constituents in the homogenisation and inverse characterisation process. The results showed that the deletion of the elements can be used to represent defects and damage of different kinds in the composite bonded joints, both in the adhesive and adherend. The comparison of different representations of the impact damage in the single lap joint configuration revealed that the best prediction in terms of the ultimate load, failure mode and size of the model is obtained with the simplified representation as a single delamination positioned before the first 0° ply in the layup and in the studied adherend configuration that was between the first (45°) and second (0°) ply in the layup. The study ends with the conclusion that in different geometries of single lap joints and different damage types studied, a numerical analysis should focus on the region of the overlap edge and in the thickness direction from the bondline up to the first 0° ply in the lay-up. The results and numerical method developed during this thesis create a base for the further investigation of a variety of impact cases on bonded joints.
Predicting Future Aircraft Spare Part Purchases by Using Previous Sales Records and Technical Maintenance Documentation
Master Thesis Aerospace Engineering