Z.B. Wang
Please Note
31 records found
1
Two main methods are applied: a cross-shore elevation level analysis to assess spatial differences in subsidence and sediment supply, and a numerical model to assess the influence of each driver individually and combined. The elevation analysis revealed that subsidence varies spatially along the coast. Moreover, historic satellite images show that a site without subsidence has been accreting in the past, while a site experiencing subsidence remained stable during the same period. After 2004, they both began eroding. This suggests that differences in subsidence rates largely explain spatial variations in current coastline positions, while the erosion itself is likely driven by additional drivers. However, the limited spatial and temporal coverage of elevation transects highlights the need for more extensive data collection. Numerical modeling indicates that reduced wave heights and increased suspended sediment greatly reduce erosion rates, and can even overshadow the effect of subsidence when combined. This demonstrates that historic and ongoing fluvial deficit is likely the main driver of the current erosion. The role of intertidal structures remains inconclusive due to model limitations and differing theoretical interpretations. Refining the current model or developing more advanced alternatives will help improve understanding of these coastal erosion processes. This is needed to support the development of integrated solutions that protect both the communities and ecosystems of Bạc Liêu. ...
Two main methods are applied: a cross-shore elevation level analysis to assess spatial differences in subsidence and sediment supply, and a numerical model to assess the influence of each driver individually and combined. The elevation analysis revealed that subsidence varies spatially along the coast. Moreover, historic satellite images show that a site without subsidence has been accreting in the past, while a site experiencing subsidence remained stable during the same period. After 2004, they both began eroding. This suggests that differences in subsidence rates largely explain spatial variations in current coastline positions, while the erosion itself is likely driven by additional drivers. However, the limited spatial and temporal coverage of elevation transects highlights the need for more extensive data collection. Numerical modeling indicates that reduced wave heights and increased suspended sediment greatly reduce erosion rates, and can even overshadow the effect of subsidence when combined. This demonstrates that historic and ongoing fluvial deficit is likely the main driver of the current erosion. The role of intertidal structures remains inconclusive due to model limitations and differing theoretical interpretations. Refining the current model or developing more advanced alternatives will help improve understanding of these coastal erosion processes. This is needed to support the development of integrated solutions that protect both the communities and ecosystems of Bạc Liêu.
Sustainable management of muddy tidal flats
A case study of the Jiangsu coast, China
This research aims to deepen our understanding of unvegetated tidal flat morphodynamics by examining both natural processes and the impacts of human interventions. The insights gained will provide valuable theoretical guidance for the sustainable and effective management of tidal flat resources in the future. To achieve this, the study focuses on tidal flats along the Jiangsu Coast in China as a case study. Because it is a typical example famous for its extensive and diverse tidal flat systems. At the same time, it has a long history of coastal land reclamations. A multi-faceted approach is adopted, combining field dataset analysis, a process-based Delft3D model, and a hybrid DET-ESTMORF model, which together provide a robust foundation for theoretical insights in sustainable coastal management.
Based on a unique field measurement data along the Jiangsu Coast, the morphology and sediment characteristics of the unvegetated intertidal flats along this coast are analysed. Both cross-shore and alongshore variations are observed. In the cross-shore direction, sediments exhibit a pronounced coarsening from the landward to the seaward side, indicating tide-dominated forcing. In the alongshore direction, the coast is divided into two parts depending on its morphological state. The northern coast, which is predominantly eroding, exhibits steeper intertidal slopes and a complex mix of sediment types, ranging from extremely fine to coarse deposits. The variation in sediment composition is attributed to natural processes such as self-weight consolidation and surface armouring. In the accreting southern coast, while tidal flat slopes are generally becoming milder towards the south, the corresponding bed surface sediment grain size is becoming coarser southward. This relationship between slope and sediment grain size in the southern coast is opposite to the findings on other muddy tidal flats.
In order to investigate the mechanism behind the region-specific alongshore pattern of the southern Jiangsu Coast, we formulate a conceptual model with special focus on describing the alongshore variations in hydrodynamics and shoreline evolution. Subsequently, a highly schematized Delft3D numerical model is employed in diagnostic mode. By integrating these approaches, the sediment provenance is found to be the sole factor capable of explaining the observed pattern.
Apart from natural processes, anthropogenic activities can also induce significant changes in tidal flat morphology. Available information on the tidal flat morphological responses to human interventions is limited based on the single-time measurements data. We therefore evaluate the resilience of tidal flats to anthropogenic disturbances (specifically, upper flat enclosure reclamation) using an extended DET-ESTMORF model. A series of sensitivity tests under various environmental conditions is conducted with this model. Our findings indicate that the concave or convex shape of tidal flat profiles is primarily governed by dominant hydrodynamic forces (whether tidal or wave-driven), while other variables modulate the profile slope. For a tidal flat to revert to its pre-reclamation configuration, it must exhibit continuous seaward progradation under natural conditions. Such restoration typically occurs in environments with abundant sediment supply, subdued wave activity, and the absence of cross-shore constraints imposed by shore-parallel tidal channels.
Overall, the insights derived from this study enhance our understanding of the interactions between natural hydrodynamic processes, sediment dynamics, morphology change and human-induced alterations. The findings highlight the importance of continuous monitoring and the adoption of adaptive management strategies to ensure that coastal development preserves the ecological integrity and long-term stability of tidal flat systems.
...
This research aims to deepen our understanding of unvegetated tidal flat morphodynamics by examining both natural processes and the impacts of human interventions. The insights gained will provide valuable theoretical guidance for the sustainable and effective management of tidal flat resources in the future. To achieve this, the study focuses on tidal flats along the Jiangsu Coast in China as a case study. Because it is a typical example famous for its extensive and diverse tidal flat systems. At the same time, it has a long history of coastal land reclamations. A multi-faceted approach is adopted, combining field dataset analysis, a process-based Delft3D model, and a hybrid DET-ESTMORF model, which together provide a robust foundation for theoretical insights in sustainable coastal management.
Based on a unique field measurement data along the Jiangsu Coast, the morphology and sediment characteristics of the unvegetated intertidal flats along this coast are analysed. Both cross-shore and alongshore variations are observed. In the cross-shore direction, sediments exhibit a pronounced coarsening from the landward to the seaward side, indicating tide-dominated forcing. In the alongshore direction, the coast is divided into two parts depending on its morphological state. The northern coast, which is predominantly eroding, exhibits steeper intertidal slopes and a complex mix of sediment types, ranging from extremely fine to coarse deposits. The variation in sediment composition is attributed to natural processes such as self-weight consolidation and surface armouring. In the accreting southern coast, while tidal flat slopes are generally becoming milder towards the south, the corresponding bed surface sediment grain size is becoming coarser southward. This relationship between slope and sediment grain size in the southern coast is opposite to the findings on other muddy tidal flats.
In order to investigate the mechanism behind the region-specific alongshore pattern of the southern Jiangsu Coast, we formulate a conceptual model with special focus on describing the alongshore variations in hydrodynamics and shoreline evolution. Subsequently, a highly schematized Delft3D numerical model is employed in diagnostic mode. By integrating these approaches, the sediment provenance is found to be the sole factor capable of explaining the observed pattern.
Apart from natural processes, anthropogenic activities can also induce significant changes in tidal flat morphology. Available information on the tidal flat morphological responses to human interventions is limited based on the single-time measurements data. We therefore evaluate the resilience of tidal flats to anthropogenic disturbances (specifically, upper flat enclosure reclamation) using an extended DET-ESTMORF model. A series of sensitivity tests under various environmental conditions is conducted with this model. Our findings indicate that the concave or convex shape of tidal flat profiles is primarily governed by dominant hydrodynamic forces (whether tidal or wave-driven), while other variables modulate the profile slope. For a tidal flat to revert to its pre-reclamation configuration, it must exhibit continuous seaward progradation under natural conditions. Such restoration typically occurs in environments with abundant sediment supply, subdued wave activity, and the absence of cross-shore constraints imposed by shore-parallel tidal channels.
Overall, the insights derived from this study enhance our understanding of the interactions between natural hydrodynamic processes, sediment dynamics, morphology change and human-induced alterations. The findings highlight the importance of continuous monitoring and the adoption of adaptive management strategies to ensure that coastal development preserves the ecological integrity and long-term stability of tidal flat systems.
This research aims to unravel the varying sediment transport processes between mudflats and salt marshes under different hydrodynamic and sediment dynamic conditions. Chongming Saltmarsh from the Yangtze Estuary and Paulina Saltmarsh from the Western Scheldt Estuary have been selected as study cases. The distinct differences in hydrodynamic forcing and sediment availability between these two estuaries contribute to differing environments and states of their intertidal systems. These differences enable us to compare the sediment transport processes across divergent systems and explore the mechanisms governing the long-term evolution of salt marshes.
Saltmarsh creeks are recognized as efficient conduits that actively facilitate the exchange of water and sediment between mudflats and salt marshes. To identify the role of marsh creeks in sediment transport between two different intertidal systems, the sediment transport processes in a main creek and on the adjacent mudflat in Chongming Saltmarsh (China) and Paulina Saltmarsh (the Netherlands) have been investigated (Chapter 2). Our findings revealed notable differences and common patterns in sediment transport between the two systems. In Chongming, SSC exhibited significant asymmetry between flood and ebb tides, with large SSC peaks occurring during most flood periods. This asymmetry in SSC caused the marsh creek in Chongming to function as a conduit for sediment import. Furthermore, distinct overbank and underbank tides were observed in Chongming. During underbank tides, sediment was trapped and retained within the creeks, only to be eroded and transported to the marsh during subsequent overbank tides. Additionally, the mudflats in Chongming showed a relatively rapid recovery after erosion events. These mechanisms were not observed in Paulina Saltmarsh, where a net export of sediment through the marsh creek was recorded during calm weather. In both systems, the SSC in marsh creeks showed a slight increase due to local erosion of the creek bed but responded more significantly to the erosion of mudflats, indicating that the main sediment sources of the high SSC result from the sediment advection rather than local erosion. These comparative findings suggest that the role of marsh creeks in sediment import and export is closely linked to the availability of sediment from adjacent mudflats, highlighting the importance of mudflats for the growth of salt marshes.
After recognizing the role of main creeks in sediment transport within turbid systems, the role of creek tributaries in sediment delivery still remains poorly understood. Therefore, field measurements were conducted in a main creek and in a secondary creek within Chongming Saltmarsh. These measurements revealed the dual roles of saltmarsh creek systems in drainage and sediment transport, as well as the mechanisms driving residual sediment flux within saltmarsh creeks (Chapter 3). The results indicated that the main creek played a dominant role in sediment delivery, while the secondary creek, influenced by the presence of vegetation, was more effective as a drainage conduit and contributes less to sediment transport. Additionally, the direction and magnitude of residual sediment flux are influenced by the relative importance of asymmetries in net discharge and sediment concentration. Overbank tides primarily result in an ebb-dominant flow asymmetry, which tends to drive sediment export along with the net outflow. However, the abundance of sediment during flood tides can occasionally counteract this export tendency, mitigating the impact of flow asymmetry on sediment export.
Sediment can be imported from mudflats to salt marshes through marsh creeks and marsh edges. To address how varying tidal and wave conditions affect sediment transport within marsh creeks and over marsh edges (Chapter 4), a two-month field campaign was conducted in Paulina Saltmarsh. Field data revealed that tidal ranges determine the direction of residual sediment flux in the marsh creek, while wave intensity determines its magnitude. Conversely, wave intensity determines the direction of residual sediment flux over the marsh edge, whereas tidal ranges determine the magnitude. Specifically, sediment was imported through the marsh creek during tidal cycles with small tidal ranges and strong waves, whereas sediment was imported through the marsh edge during tidal cycles with large tidal ranges and weak waves. These findings offer deeper insights into sediment transport through marsh creeks and marsh edges under different tidal and wave conditions, which is crucial for effective salt marsh management.
This dissertation explores sediment transport between mudflats and salt marshes in two different systems, providing insights into the roles of marsh creeks and marsh edges in facilitating or impeding sediment import to salt marshes under varying conditions. The findings offer guidance for developing conservation and management strategies to support salt marsh growth in response to decreasing sediment supply and accelerating sea-level rise. ...
This research aims to unravel the varying sediment transport processes between mudflats and salt marshes under different hydrodynamic and sediment dynamic conditions. Chongming Saltmarsh from the Yangtze Estuary and Paulina Saltmarsh from the Western Scheldt Estuary have been selected as study cases. The distinct differences in hydrodynamic forcing and sediment availability between these two estuaries contribute to differing environments and states of their intertidal systems. These differences enable us to compare the sediment transport processes across divergent systems and explore the mechanisms governing the long-term evolution of salt marshes.
Saltmarsh creeks are recognized as efficient conduits that actively facilitate the exchange of water and sediment between mudflats and salt marshes. To identify the role of marsh creeks in sediment transport between two different intertidal systems, the sediment transport processes in a main creek and on the adjacent mudflat in Chongming Saltmarsh (China) and Paulina Saltmarsh (the Netherlands) have been investigated (Chapter 2). Our findings revealed notable differences and common patterns in sediment transport between the two systems. In Chongming, SSC exhibited significant asymmetry between flood and ebb tides, with large SSC peaks occurring during most flood periods. This asymmetry in SSC caused the marsh creek in Chongming to function as a conduit for sediment import. Furthermore, distinct overbank and underbank tides were observed in Chongming. During underbank tides, sediment was trapped and retained within the creeks, only to be eroded and transported to the marsh during subsequent overbank tides. Additionally, the mudflats in Chongming showed a relatively rapid recovery after erosion events. These mechanisms were not observed in Paulina Saltmarsh, where a net export of sediment through the marsh creek was recorded during calm weather. In both systems, the SSC in marsh creeks showed a slight increase due to local erosion of the creek bed but responded more significantly to the erosion of mudflats, indicating that the main sediment sources of the high SSC result from the sediment advection rather than local erosion. These comparative findings suggest that the role of marsh creeks in sediment import and export is closely linked to the availability of sediment from adjacent mudflats, highlighting the importance of mudflats for the growth of salt marshes.
After recognizing the role of main creeks in sediment transport within turbid systems, the role of creek tributaries in sediment delivery still remains poorly understood. Therefore, field measurements were conducted in a main creek and in a secondary creek within Chongming Saltmarsh. These measurements revealed the dual roles of saltmarsh creek systems in drainage and sediment transport, as well as the mechanisms driving residual sediment flux within saltmarsh creeks (Chapter 3). The results indicated that the main creek played a dominant role in sediment delivery, while the secondary creek, influenced by the presence of vegetation, was more effective as a drainage conduit and contributes less to sediment transport. Additionally, the direction and magnitude of residual sediment flux are influenced by the relative importance of asymmetries in net discharge and sediment concentration. Overbank tides primarily result in an ebb-dominant flow asymmetry, which tends to drive sediment export along with the net outflow. However, the abundance of sediment during flood tides can occasionally counteract this export tendency, mitigating the impact of flow asymmetry on sediment export.
Sediment can be imported from mudflats to salt marshes through marsh creeks and marsh edges. To address how varying tidal and wave conditions affect sediment transport within marsh creeks and over marsh edges (Chapter 4), a two-month field campaign was conducted in Paulina Saltmarsh. Field data revealed that tidal ranges determine the direction of residual sediment flux in the marsh creek, while wave intensity determines its magnitude. Conversely, wave intensity determines the direction of residual sediment flux over the marsh edge, whereas tidal ranges determine the magnitude. Specifically, sediment was imported through the marsh creek during tidal cycles with small tidal ranges and strong waves, whereas sediment was imported through the marsh edge during tidal cycles with large tidal ranges and weak waves. These findings offer deeper insights into sediment transport through marsh creeks and marsh edges under different tidal and wave conditions, which is crucial for effective salt marsh management.
This dissertation explores sediment transport between mudflats and salt marshes in two different systems, providing insights into the roles of marsh creeks and marsh edges in facilitating or impeding sediment import to salt marshes under varying conditions. The findings offer guidance for developing conservation and management strategies to support salt marsh growth in response to decreasing sediment supply and accelerating sea-level rise.
Predicting the short-term response to inlet interventions in Lake Bardawil
A study on the initial hydrodynamic and morphological response to inlet dredging interventions in Lake Bardawil, a shallow micro-tidal lagoon in northern Egypt
Long-term morphological modelling of tidal inlet systems
Implementing salt marshes in ASMITA
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
...
Currently, salt marshes are not implemented in ASMITA. However, salt marshes could be of importance to the morphological development in tidal inlet systems. Moreover, it is relevant to assess the resilience of the ecologically important salt marshes by themselves. The aim of this research is to implement salt marshes in ASMITA to assess their influence on the rest of the tidal inlet system and to gain insight into the long-term morphological response of salt marshes to accelerated SLR.
Salt marsh development is governed by horizontal and vertical processes. The marsh height increases by capturing mineral sediment and by the accumulation of plant biomass. Autocompaction and deep subsidence lead to a decrease in marsh height. The implementation of salt marshes in ASMITA relies solely on the input of mineral sediment. At the marsh edge, generally, a cyclic behaviour of sedimentation and cliff erosion occurs. Due to the high degree of spatial aggregation, cliff erosion is excluded from the model extension. The governing processes for salt marsh development in the ASMITA model extension are mineral sedimentation, sediment availability and relative SLR.
The spatial and temporal aggregation of governing processes for salt marsh development are included in the aggregated advection-diffusion equation and model parameters for the horizontal & vertical exchange of sediment, and sediment availability. Data analysis on hydrodynamic conditions and salt marsh development was conducted for the derivation and calibration of these model parameters. To verify the salt marsh implementation, three ASMITA models were created. A one-element salt marsh model consisting of only a salt marsh element, and two different multiple elements models, which contain the ebb-tidal delta, channels, tidal flats and salt marshes.
It can be concluded that ASMITA can model the mineral sedimentation on a salt marsh but depicts a large sensitivity to the parameter setting, particularly for the sediment concentration. Based on the chosen parameter configuration, the Oosterkwelder salt marsh is preserved when subjected to SLR rates below 16 mm/year.
The ASMITA salt marsh extension can be employed to obtain an expeditious first impression of long-term morphological salt marsh development. However, due to the lack of incorporation of detailed processes, the model should not be employed for in-depth analyses of salt marsh development. The interaction between the salt marsh element and the remaining tidal inlet system components requires further model improvements.
ASMITA modelling of the Wadden Sea with focus on the Groningerwad
Assessing how the Groningerwad will respond to accelerated sea level rise
Thesis small scale equilibria in tidal basins
A data-analysis and case study in the Ameland Inlet
In the first part of this thesis the morphological equilibrium for subbasins is examined. A numerical simulation using tracers is conducted in order to find the watersheds of the Ameland Inlet. The watersheds are used to divide the basin into subbasins of different scales. These subbasins are used to find a morphological equilibrium between the channel volume and tidal prism. The applicability limitations of the morphological equilibrium relation are also investigated in this part of the research.
In the second part of the research the newfound equilibrium is applied in an Asmita model. The modelling exercise is done in order to showcase a proof of concept of the multi element modelling approach. In this modelling approach both a 6 and 10-element model are used to look for the spatial differences in morphological behaviour within a basin.
In the first part of this thesis an equilibrium for the channel volume with respect to the tidal prism of subbasins in the Ameland inlet is found. This equation can be applied to basins (Channel and flat combined) with a minimum area of 40 km². This limitation is for both the equilibrium study as the Asmita modelling. The modelling exercise proofs that the multi element Asmita modelling is possible and gives a good insight into the spatial differences in morphological behaviour within the Ameland Inlet.
...
In the first part of this thesis the morphological equilibrium for subbasins is examined. A numerical simulation using tracers is conducted in order to find the watersheds of the Ameland Inlet. The watersheds are used to divide the basin into subbasins of different scales. These subbasins are used to find a morphological equilibrium between the channel volume and tidal prism. The applicability limitations of the morphological equilibrium relation are also investigated in this part of the research.
In the second part of the research the newfound equilibrium is applied in an Asmita model. The modelling exercise is done in order to showcase a proof of concept of the multi element modelling approach. In this modelling approach both a 6 and 10-element model are used to look for the spatial differences in morphological behaviour within a basin.
In the first part of this thesis an equilibrium for the channel volume with respect to the tidal prism of subbasins in the Ameland inlet is found. This equation can be applied to basins (Channel and flat combined) with a minimum area of 40 km². This limitation is for both the equilibrium study as the Asmita modelling. The modelling exercise proofs that the multi element Asmita modelling is possible and gives a good insight into the spatial differences in morphological behaviour within the Ameland Inlet.
Sediment Pathways on Ebb-Tidal Deltas
New Tools and Techniques for Analysis
The main goal of this project was to describe and quantify the pathways that sediment takes on an ebb-tidal delta. To reach this goal, we focused our analyses on Ameland ebb-tidal delta in the Netherlands. Before we could begin to tackle this challenge, we needed to develop new tools and techniques for analyzing a combination of field measurements and numerical models. These include a method for analyzing the stratigraphy and mapping the morphodynamic evolution of ebb-tidal deltas, a new metric for characterizing suspended sediment composition, and innovative use of sediment tracers. We also established a quantitative approach for looking at and thinking about sediment pathways via the sediment connectivity framework, and developed a Lagrangian model to visualize and predict these pathways efficiently.
The techniques developed here are useful in a wider range of coastal settings beyond Ameland, and are already being applied in practice. We foresee that the main impacts of this project will be to improve nourishment strategies, numerical modelling, and field data analysis. This dissertation also points forward to numerous opportunities for further investigation, including the continued development of the connectivity framework and SedTRAILS. By managing our coastal sediment more effectively, we will set the stage for a more sustainable future, in spite of the challenges that lie ahead. ...
The main goal of this project was to describe and quantify the pathways that sediment takes on an ebb-tidal delta. To reach this goal, we focused our analyses on Ameland ebb-tidal delta in the Netherlands. Before we could begin to tackle this challenge, we needed to develop new tools and techniques for analyzing a combination of field measurements and numerical models. These include a method for analyzing the stratigraphy and mapping the morphodynamic evolution of ebb-tidal deltas, a new metric for characterizing suspended sediment composition, and innovative use of sediment tracers. We also established a quantitative approach for looking at and thinking about sediment pathways via the sediment connectivity framework, and developed a Lagrangian model to visualize and predict these pathways efficiently.
The techniques developed here are useful in a wider range of coastal settings beyond Ameland, and are already being applied in practice. We foresee that the main impacts of this project will be to improve nourishment strategies, numerical modelling, and field data analysis. This dissertation also points forward to numerous opportunities for further investigation, including the continued development of the connectivity framework and SedTRAILS. By managing our coastal sediment more effectively, we will set the stage for a more sustainable future, in spite of the challenges that lie ahead.
Modeling Long-term Morphological Developments of Intertidal Flats
A Comparison Among Different Modeling Approaches
Different tools exist that can predict the long-term evolution of the mudflats, viz. Delft3D, ASMITA and the hybrid model (Delft3D-ASMITA). Since the hybrid model is newly developed, the comparison among the various approaches has not yet been available. However, it is significant to know if they can produce the same results.
The research aims to compare the three modeling approaches (Delft3D, ASMITA, and the hybrid model) based on a case study in South San Francisco Bay. This comparison will reveal the strengths and weaknesses of the three approaches as well as indications where the approaches may strengthen each other.
The research is conducted in three main phases. Phase 1 consists of the sensitivity analyses in Delft3D for the case of South San Francisco Bay; Phase 2 contains the calibration of one-element and multi-element ASMITA models to reproduce the Delft3D model; Phase 3 focuses on the potential to improve the simulation efficiency of Delft3D in the hybrid model.
Model result comparison shows that, after the calibration, the ASMITA and hybrid model can efficiently simulate the same cases as in Delft3D. However, the upper part (landwards end) of the mudflat is more sensitive to the water level changes in the hybrid model due to the different sediment transport computation modules. The power indicating the relation between the equilibrium and actual morphology as well as the reference level is the important calibration coefficient to adjust the steepness of a mudflat. It can be concluded that the Delft3D model is used as the foundation to calibrate ASMITA and the hybrid model, both of which can improve the simulation efficiency with simplifications, especially in the long-term morphological development.
The study provides clear insights into the comparisons among different modeling approaches in the case of the long-term morphological developments of mudflats by the impacts of sea-level rise. It is recommended to do further research on the configuration of a 2D model and the conduction of the combination of different modeling approaches in other similar cases to confirm the validation. ...
Different tools exist that can predict the long-term evolution of the mudflats, viz. Delft3D, ASMITA and the hybrid model (Delft3D-ASMITA). Since the hybrid model is newly developed, the comparison among the various approaches has not yet been available. However, it is significant to know if they can produce the same results.
The research aims to compare the three modeling approaches (Delft3D, ASMITA, and the hybrid model) based on a case study in South San Francisco Bay. This comparison will reveal the strengths and weaknesses of the three approaches as well as indications where the approaches may strengthen each other.
The research is conducted in three main phases. Phase 1 consists of the sensitivity analyses in Delft3D for the case of South San Francisco Bay; Phase 2 contains the calibration of one-element and multi-element ASMITA models to reproduce the Delft3D model; Phase 3 focuses on the potential to improve the simulation efficiency of Delft3D in the hybrid model.
Model result comparison shows that, after the calibration, the ASMITA and hybrid model can efficiently simulate the same cases as in Delft3D. However, the upper part (landwards end) of the mudflat is more sensitive to the water level changes in the hybrid model due to the different sediment transport computation modules. The power indicating the relation between the equilibrium and actual morphology as well as the reference level is the important calibration coefficient to adjust the steepness of a mudflat. It can be concluded that the Delft3D model is used as the foundation to calibrate ASMITA and the hybrid model, both of which can improve the simulation efficiency with simplifications, especially in the long-term morphological development.
The study provides clear insights into the comparisons among different modeling approaches in the case of the long-term morphological developments of mudflats by the impacts of sea-level rise. It is recommended to do further research on the configuration of a 2D model and the conduction of the combination of different modeling approaches in other similar cases to confirm the validation.
Morphodynamic Modelling of the Ameland Ebb-Tidal Delta
An Assessment of the 2018 - 2019 Pilot Nourishment
In the context of developing a future-proof coastal management and maintenance strategy, the efficiency of ebb-tidal delta nourishments has been further investigated in research programmes such as Coastal Genesis 2.0. For the Ameland inlet, this entailed the construction of a 5 million m3 pilot nourishment over the course of March 2018 to February 2019 and subsequent monitoring in the years following. This research investigates the impact of this pilot nourishment on the natural behaviour of the Ameland ebb-tidal delta. The second goal is to build further knowledge on the modelling capabilities of present state-of-the-art models for the Ameland ebb-tidal delta.
To this end, a process-based Delft3D model is applied to hindcast the morphological development of the ebb-tidal delta with a particular interest in the evolution of ebb-shields and -chutes over the course of 2005 to 2020. It is identified that the representation of the wave-induced processes is key for capturing the development of ebb-shields and -chutes in the model predictions. Therefore, we applied and experimented with an updated nonlinear wave orbital velocity parameterisation and assessed its contribution to the modelling performance.
This thesis demonstrates that the evolution of ebb-shields and chutes on the outer delta is contingent on its initial presence in the initial bathymetry. Hence, the initiation of ebb-shield development is not inherited in the model response. These insights have been integrated and synthesised to assess the application of the present state-of-the-art model as a forecasting tool for the morphological development of ebb-tidal delta nourishments.
Ultimately, it is shown that a model using schematised boundary conditions and an efficient morphological updating scheme is able the predict the yearly-averaged development of the pilot nourishment on the ebb-tidal delta. It is demonstrated that the 2019 pilot nourishment only locally influences the behaviour of the Ameland ebb-tidal delta. Nourished sediment is likely to be redistributed along the ebb-shields, contributing on the long-term to the sediment exchange process with the downdrift coast of Ameland. The location of the ebb-tidal delta nourishment is thereby important for the sediment exchange process and the development of local features. Placing ebb-tidal delta nourishments to the south of the Westgat invokes a primary sediment exchange between the coast of Terschelling and surrounding morphological features. A secondary readjustment of the Westgat thereby influences the development of the ebb-shields and -chutes. Constructing an ebb-tidal delta nourishment north of the Westgat results in a sediment exchange between the local ebb-shields and the downdrift coast of Ameland. Our results also demonstrate that an increase in the pilot nourishment construction height enhances the redistribution of sediment along the ebb-shields.
Lastly, this study identifies further opportunities for improving medium-term morphodynamic models for the Ameland inlet by incorporating time-dependent boundary conditions including new transport formulations such as SANTOSS. ...
In the context of developing a future-proof coastal management and maintenance strategy, the efficiency of ebb-tidal delta nourishments has been further investigated in research programmes such as Coastal Genesis 2.0. For the Ameland inlet, this entailed the construction of a 5 million m3 pilot nourishment over the course of March 2018 to February 2019 and subsequent monitoring in the years following. This research investigates the impact of this pilot nourishment on the natural behaviour of the Ameland ebb-tidal delta. The second goal is to build further knowledge on the modelling capabilities of present state-of-the-art models for the Ameland ebb-tidal delta.
To this end, a process-based Delft3D model is applied to hindcast the morphological development of the ebb-tidal delta with a particular interest in the evolution of ebb-shields and -chutes over the course of 2005 to 2020. It is identified that the representation of the wave-induced processes is key for capturing the development of ebb-shields and -chutes in the model predictions. Therefore, we applied and experimented with an updated nonlinear wave orbital velocity parameterisation and assessed its contribution to the modelling performance.
This thesis demonstrates that the evolution of ebb-shields and chutes on the outer delta is contingent on its initial presence in the initial bathymetry. Hence, the initiation of ebb-shield development is not inherited in the model response. These insights have been integrated and synthesised to assess the application of the present state-of-the-art model as a forecasting tool for the morphological development of ebb-tidal delta nourishments.
Ultimately, it is shown that a model using schematised boundary conditions and an efficient morphological updating scheme is able the predict the yearly-averaged development of the pilot nourishment on the ebb-tidal delta. It is demonstrated that the 2019 pilot nourishment only locally influences the behaviour of the Ameland ebb-tidal delta. Nourished sediment is likely to be redistributed along the ebb-shields, contributing on the long-term to the sediment exchange process with the downdrift coast of Ameland. The location of the ebb-tidal delta nourishment is thereby important for the sediment exchange process and the development of local features. Placing ebb-tidal delta nourishments to the south of the Westgat invokes a primary sediment exchange between the coast of Terschelling and surrounding morphological features. A secondary readjustment of the Westgat thereby influences the development of the ebb-shields and -chutes. Constructing an ebb-tidal delta nourishment north of the Westgat results in a sediment exchange between the local ebb-shields and the downdrift coast of Ameland. Our results also demonstrate that an increase in the pilot nourishment construction height enhances the redistribution of sediment along the ebb-shields.
Lastly, this study identifies further opportunities for improving medium-term morphodynamic models for the Ameland inlet by incorporating time-dependent boundary conditions including new transport formulations such as SANTOSS.
For this purpose, a Delft3D FM model of the area is set up and calibrated. This model is used to analyze sediment transport in the inlet under various forcing conditions. Transport pathways are visualized using SedTRAILS.
The model shows that flows and sediment transport in Burrard Inlet are tide-dominated and governed by the topography. Flows are strongly accelerated in constricted areas (First Narrows and Second Narrows), which leads to large velocity differences. Following the velocity field, sediment transport patterns are correspondingly dominated by these topographical restrictions. In the wider basins, flows slow down and form eddies. The model results suggest that these eddies act as sediment sinks. Additionally, sediment is lost into Indian Arm, a deep fjord with low flow velocities at the eastern end of Burrard Inlet. The possible pathways for sediment originating from the eroding shorelines at the TWN reserve are visualized. As soon as sediment from these banks is mobilized, it tends to move away from the shore with a final destination either in one of the eddies or in Indian Arm. The impact of wind and waves on the sediment transport patterns is limited.
Since first European contact in 1792, the shoreline of Burrard Inlet has changed significantly due to dredging activities, land developments, and industrial development as the city of Vancouver was built. Reconstructed historic shorelines are implemented in the model to assess the consequences of these shoreline changes on the sediment transport. Model results show that the tidal prism and the velocities in the Narrows have decreased since 1792, while the tidal range has increased. Moreover, sediment mobilized along the eroding shorelines showed greater potential for deposition along these same shores in 1792, compared to the present-day situation.
...
For this purpose, a Delft3D FM model of the area is set up and calibrated. This model is used to analyze sediment transport in the inlet under various forcing conditions. Transport pathways are visualized using SedTRAILS.
The model shows that flows and sediment transport in Burrard Inlet are tide-dominated and governed by the topography. Flows are strongly accelerated in constricted areas (First Narrows and Second Narrows), which leads to large velocity differences. Following the velocity field, sediment transport patterns are correspondingly dominated by these topographical restrictions. In the wider basins, flows slow down and form eddies. The model results suggest that these eddies act as sediment sinks. Additionally, sediment is lost into Indian Arm, a deep fjord with low flow velocities at the eastern end of Burrard Inlet. The possible pathways for sediment originating from the eroding shorelines at the TWN reserve are visualized. As soon as sediment from these banks is mobilized, it tends to move away from the shore with a final destination either in one of the eddies or in Indian Arm. The impact of wind and waves on the sediment transport patterns is limited.
Since first European contact in 1792, the shoreline of Burrard Inlet has changed significantly due to dredging activities, land developments, and industrial development as the city of Vancouver was built. Reconstructed historic shorelines are implemented in the model to assess the consequences of these shoreline changes on the sediment transport. Model results show that the tidal prism and the velocities in the Narrows have decreased since 1792, while the tidal range has increased. Moreover, sediment mobilized along the eroding shorelines showed greater potential for deposition along these same shores in 1792, compared to the present-day situation.
Dynamic Morphology of the Sittaung Estuary, Myanmar
A detailed investigation and modelling of rapid bank erosion
Regardless of this uncertainty, great confidence is put in the performance of the numerical model, as in accordance with existing literature of the study area and theory on well-mixed estuary, important mechanisms in the supply of sediment to the trench were found to be: salinity-induced circulation, tidal rectification, Stokes’ drift and river discharge. Additionally, the governing sediment trapping mechanisms of the trench, found by the model, are in line with state-of-the-art literature. In contrast, yet unidentified by literature, the longitudinal salinity gradient over the estuary also seem to dominantly influence the trapping efficiency of the trench, in particular during flood in which it induces a strong decrease in sediment trapping. In comparison, it is believed that engineering tools, applied for trenches in estuaries, are prone to very high epistemic uncertainty caused by model inadequacy. This is because stand-alone application of the engineering tool on the problem gave a significant over-estimation of the siltation volumes, as predicted by the numerical model. Furthermore, the engineering tool was found to behave differently within a tidal cycle, and on changing environmental conditions. Above epistemic uncertainties due to model inadequacy could, however, not be quantifiably supported, as the total quantifiable uncertainty was in the same order of the numerical model. In conclusion, the degree of certainty of the trench siltation rates is believed to be improved significantly using a detailed numerical model instead of engineering tools. However, a huge drawback of the application of detailed numerical models, is the complexity and the impracticality of the numerical model. Therefore, this thesis opts for the development/use of a more sophisticated semi-empirical tool for engineering measures in estuaries. Though, more research is recommended on trenches in both similar and different type of estuaries in order to generalize and confirm the findings of this thesis. ...
Regardless of this uncertainty, great confidence is put in the performance of the numerical model, as in accordance with existing literature of the study area and theory on well-mixed estuary, important mechanisms in the supply of sediment to the trench were found to be: salinity-induced circulation, tidal rectification, Stokes’ drift and river discharge. Additionally, the governing sediment trapping mechanisms of the trench, found by the model, are in line with state-of-the-art literature. In contrast, yet unidentified by literature, the longitudinal salinity gradient over the estuary also seem to dominantly influence the trapping efficiency of the trench, in particular during flood in which it induces a strong decrease in sediment trapping. In comparison, it is believed that engineering tools, applied for trenches in estuaries, are prone to very high epistemic uncertainty caused by model inadequacy. This is because stand-alone application of the engineering tool on the problem gave a significant over-estimation of the siltation volumes, as predicted by the numerical model. Furthermore, the engineering tool was found to behave differently within a tidal cycle, and on changing environmental conditions. Above epistemic uncertainties due to model inadequacy could, however, not be quantifiably supported, as the total quantifiable uncertainty was in the same order of the numerical model. In conclusion, the degree of certainty of the trench siltation rates is believed to be improved significantly using a detailed numerical model instead of engineering tools. However, a huge drawback of the application of detailed numerical models, is the complexity and the impracticality of the numerical model. Therefore, this thesis opts for the development/use of a more sophisticated semi-empirical tool for engineering measures in estuaries. Though, more research is recommended on trenches in both similar and different type of estuaries in order to generalize and confirm the findings of this thesis.