S. Fazi
Please Note
28 records found
1
Dynamic Multi-Facility Coordination through Rolling Horizon Timeslot Optimisation
Modelling Real-Time Decision-Making for Port Logistics Planning
This study proposes an integrated and dynamic multi-facility coordination framework that applies real-time Estimated Time of Arrival (ETA) data into appointment rescheduling and reassignment decisions. Through a rolling horizon approach, schedules are continuously updated to reflect the most recent system state. The scenario analysis has demonstrated that the integration of real-time ETA data can reduce total waiting times by up to 96%, with the enablement of container reassignment resulting in the most efficient outcomes. Through multi-objective optimisation, the trade-off between minimising waiting times and limiting reschedules has been assessed. Sensitivity analyses further illustrated how congestion severity, timeslot duration, and fleet sizes influence overall system performance. The results indicate that collaborative, data-driven coordination mechanisms can significantly improve port logistics efficiency, reduce port congestion, and enhance service reliability. These findings provide a foundation for the development of dynamic decision-making models that balance operational stability for terminals with minimal delays for carriers. ...
This study proposes an integrated and dynamic multi-facility coordination framework that applies real-time Estimated Time of Arrival (ETA) data into appointment rescheduling and reassignment decisions. Through a rolling horizon approach, schedules are continuously updated to reflect the most recent system state. The scenario analysis has demonstrated that the integration of real-time ETA data can reduce total waiting times by up to 96%, with the enablement of container reassignment resulting in the most efficient outcomes. Through multi-objective optimisation, the trade-off between minimising waiting times and limiting reschedules has been assessed. Sensitivity analyses further illustrated how congestion severity, timeslot duration, and fleet sizes influence overall system performance. The results indicate that collaborative, data-driven coordination mechanisms can significantly improve port logistics efficiency, reduce port congestion, and enhance service reliability. These findings provide a foundation for the development of dynamic decision-making models that balance operational stability for terminals with minimal delays for carriers.
As a relatively new concept, synchromodality has mainly been studied at a theoretical level, focusing on its definition and potential. As the concept of synchromodality seems to gain attention from a broader public, more recent research has also focused on the more quantitative side. These quantitative studies primarily model the transport planning side of synchromodality. In these studies, some aspects in the supply chain have been overlooked so far, mainly the impact on critical infrastructure such as container terminals.
This research addresses this overlooked area in the existing academic landscape. Aspects such as the loading, unloading and stacking of containers are explicitly modelled in combination with synchromodal transport planning optimisation. This allows for an assessment of how synchromodality influences container terminal operations and how constraints and the dynamics at container terminals influence the transport planning. A multi-agent system approach is used as a framework for this model, as this presents a good option to model the different stakeholders involved in synchromodal transport.
The performance was analysed based on key performance metrics, including container relocation frequency, dwell times, and cost efficiency. The findings indicate that the integration of synchromodal transport planning with container terminal operations yields significant improvements. An iterative feedback loop between the transport planning agent and terminal agents facilitates more effective decision-making, leading to feasible transport planning, smoother operations, and improved resource utilisation.
Scenario analysis yielded further interesting results in terms of how a synchromodal planner would adapt to disruptions. The two most interesting findings are a decrease in the number of transshipments and a modal shift towards faster, more flexible, but also more expensive and more polluting transport modes.
In conclusion, this research demonstrates that the integration of synchromodal transport planning and container terminal operations improves the efficiency and adaptability of synchromodal logistics networks. Through these advances, this research contributes to ongoing efforts in the planning of synchromodal transport and the optimisation of container terminals, offering valuable information for both academia and industry.
...
As a relatively new concept, synchromodality has mainly been studied at a theoretical level, focusing on its definition and potential. As the concept of synchromodality seems to gain attention from a broader public, more recent research has also focused on the more quantitative side. These quantitative studies primarily model the transport planning side of synchromodality. In these studies, some aspects in the supply chain have been overlooked so far, mainly the impact on critical infrastructure such as container terminals.
This research addresses this overlooked area in the existing academic landscape. Aspects such as the loading, unloading and stacking of containers are explicitly modelled in combination with synchromodal transport planning optimisation. This allows for an assessment of how synchromodality influences container terminal operations and how constraints and the dynamics at container terminals influence the transport planning. A multi-agent system approach is used as a framework for this model, as this presents a good option to model the different stakeholders involved in synchromodal transport.
The performance was analysed based on key performance metrics, including container relocation frequency, dwell times, and cost efficiency. The findings indicate that the integration of synchromodal transport planning with container terminal operations yields significant improvements. An iterative feedback loop between the transport planning agent and terminal agents facilitates more effective decision-making, leading to feasible transport planning, smoother operations, and improved resource utilisation.
Scenario analysis yielded further interesting results in terms of how a synchromodal planner would adapt to disruptions. The two most interesting findings are a decrease in the number of transshipments and a modal shift towards faster, more flexible, but also more expensive and more polluting transport modes.
In conclusion, this research demonstrates that the integration of synchromodal transport planning and container terminal operations improves the efficiency and adaptability of synchromodal logistics networks. Through these advances, this research contributes to ongoing efforts in the planning of synchromodal transport and the optimisation of container terminals, offering valuable information for both academia and industry.
Truck Routing for Parcel Delivery
Solving a Multi-depot Pickup and Delivery Problem with Occasional Drivers using ALNS
Optimizing offshore wind farm transportation and installation strategies including manufacturing ports
Using a rolling horizon simulation model
Towards electric logistics by optimizing network design and operations
A case study for Heineken tank beer
The investigation employs a sequential exploratory strategy, beginning with qualitative analysis to identify core challenges and opportunities, followed by quantitative methods to refine network design and decision-making. Advanced clustering techniques such as the center of gravity, p-median, and k-means are utilized to determine optimal depot locations, essential for overcoming the operational range and charging limits of EVs. This approach aids in developing a logistics network that is both operationally efficient and environmentally sustainable.
A significant portion of the study focuses on vehicle routing within the two-echelon location-routing model. It considers critical factors like the limited range of EVs, multi-compartment transport requirements for bulk liquids, and specific customer delivery windows. The model integrates these elements to optimize vehicle routes for efficiency and regulatory compliance, illustrating its practical use through the two-echelon multi-compartment electric vehicle routing problem with time windows (2E-MCEVRPTW).
The practical application of this research is demonstrated in a case study of Heineken Netherlands, highlighting the logistical complexities of transitioning to an EV fleet for beer distribution. The study examines operational challenges such as vehicle range and product diversity management, proving the viability and effectiveness of the proposed models.
Results discussion reveals that strategic network design using the center of gravity method significantly enhances kilometer savings and operational efficiencies. However, the benefits diminish with additional hubs, indicating an optimal hub number exists. While transshipment costs pose a significant challenge, outweighing the kilometer savings, potential cost reductions through increased reefer capacity and reduced transshipment times are identified, pointing to possible areas for improvement.
The study concludes that the two-step optimization process, integrating network design and vehicle routing, effectively addresses the research question. It not only shows the potential of EVs in transforming logistics but also underscores the economic and operational challenges of adopting a two-echelon network. The findings lay a groundwork for future innovations in sustainable logistics, though they caution the need for tailored solutions across different operational contexts and suggest further research into computational strategies and customer clustering for enhanced route optimization. ...
The investigation employs a sequential exploratory strategy, beginning with qualitative analysis to identify core challenges and opportunities, followed by quantitative methods to refine network design and decision-making. Advanced clustering techniques such as the center of gravity, p-median, and k-means are utilized to determine optimal depot locations, essential for overcoming the operational range and charging limits of EVs. This approach aids in developing a logistics network that is both operationally efficient and environmentally sustainable.
A significant portion of the study focuses on vehicle routing within the two-echelon location-routing model. It considers critical factors like the limited range of EVs, multi-compartment transport requirements for bulk liquids, and specific customer delivery windows. The model integrates these elements to optimize vehicle routes for efficiency and regulatory compliance, illustrating its practical use through the two-echelon multi-compartment electric vehicle routing problem with time windows (2E-MCEVRPTW).
The practical application of this research is demonstrated in a case study of Heineken Netherlands, highlighting the logistical complexities of transitioning to an EV fleet for beer distribution. The study examines operational challenges such as vehicle range and product diversity management, proving the viability and effectiveness of the proposed models.
Results discussion reveals that strategic network design using the center of gravity method significantly enhances kilometer savings and operational efficiencies. However, the benefits diminish with additional hubs, indicating an optimal hub number exists. While transshipment costs pose a significant challenge, outweighing the kilometer savings, potential cost reductions through increased reefer capacity and reduced transshipment times are identified, pointing to possible areas for improvement.
The study concludes that the two-step optimization process, integrating network design and vehicle routing, effectively addresses the research question. It not only shows the potential of EVs in transforming logistics but also underscores the economic and operational challenges of adopting a two-echelon network. The findings lay a groundwork for future innovations in sustainable logistics, though they caution the need for tailored solutions across different operational contexts and suggest further research into computational strategies and customer clustering for enhanced route optimization.
To tackle the 3D Bin Packing Problem (3DBPP), two approaches, Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) and Extreme Point Heuristic (EPH), are used in this paper. The MIP model maximizes space utilization through accurate optimization and is suitable for small-scale packing scenarios, while the EPH algorithm performs well in large-scale scenarios and generates high-quality approximate solutions in a short period. Although its space utilization is slightly lower than that of MIP, its solution efficiency is well suited to real logistics operations that require fast response time.
For the Build-up Scheduling Problem (BSP), a parallel machine scheduling model is used to optimize the assembly sequence and timing of ULDs to ensure that all ULDs can be loaded within a strict time window. Experimental results show that the model performs well in optimizing workstation load balancing and avoiding delays, which can significantly improve the scheduling efficiency of the whole system.
The research results in this paper are validated to show that the proposed two-stage framework has significant application value in improving space utilization, reducing cargo delays, and optimizing workstation scheduling in real logistics scenarios of Cainiao. Future research can introduce a feedback loop between the two phases, and combine real-time data with dynamic adjustment strategies, hybrid algorithms, and other methods to further improve the adaptability and efficiency of the model. ...
To tackle the 3D Bin Packing Problem (3DBPP), two approaches, Mixed Integer Programming (MIP) and Extreme Point Heuristic (EPH), are used in this paper. The MIP model maximizes space utilization through accurate optimization and is suitable for small-scale packing scenarios, while the EPH algorithm performs well in large-scale scenarios and generates high-quality approximate solutions in a short period. Although its space utilization is slightly lower than that of MIP, its solution efficiency is well suited to real logistics operations that require fast response time.
For the Build-up Scheduling Problem (BSP), a parallel machine scheduling model is used to optimize the assembly sequence and timing of ULDs to ensure that all ULDs can be loaded within a strict time window. Experimental results show that the model performs well in optimizing workstation load balancing and avoiding delays, which can significantly improve the scheduling efficiency of the whole system.
The research results in this paper are validated to show that the proposed two-stage framework has significant application value in improving space utilization, reducing cargo delays, and optimizing workstation scheduling in real logistics scenarios of Cainiao. Future research can introduce a feedback loop between the two phases, and combine real-time data with dynamic adjustment strategies, hybrid algorithms, and other methods to further improve the adaptability and efficiency of the model.
Expanding Puerto Rawson
Enhancing Fishery Capacity and Project Cargo Logistics
This report, titled Expanding Puerto Rawson: Enhancing Fishery Capacity and Project Cargo Logistics, presents a conceptual masterplan for the eco-friendly expansion of the Port of Rawson. The port’s proximity to a region abundant in marine resources makes it an attractive location for expansion. However, the port is facing strategic expansion problems and it could fail to accommodate the rise in demand from the fishery industry. This report carefully maps out the gap between the expected rise in demand and the currently existing infrastructure. After that, two models are created to transform the rise in demand that is expected by 2030 & 2040, to nautical demands for the port, like number of berths and required waterway width. The results from these model in combination with a strategic overview of the landscape, were used to come up with three conceptual designs that eventually converged into one final conceptual design by conducting an MCA. This conceptual design, together with the port waste management plan, could enable an eco-friendly and future-ready expansion of the Port of Rawson. ...
This report, titled Expanding Puerto Rawson: Enhancing Fishery Capacity and Project Cargo Logistics, presents a conceptual masterplan for the eco-friendly expansion of the Port of Rawson. The port’s proximity to a region abundant in marine resources makes it an attractive location for expansion. However, the port is facing strategic expansion problems and it could fail to accommodate the rise in demand from the fishery industry. This report carefully maps out the gap between the expected rise in demand and the currently existing infrastructure. After that, two models are created to transform the rise in demand that is expected by 2030 & 2040, to nautical demands for the port, like number of berths and required waterway width. The results from these model in combination with a strategic overview of the landscape, were used to come up with three conceptual designs that eventually converged into one final conceptual design by conducting an MCA. This conceptual design, together with the port waste management plan, could enable an eco-friendly and future-ready expansion of the Port of Rawson.
The Impact of Load Carrier Types and Staging-Level Designs on Cross-Docking Performance under Uncertainty
A Discrete Event Simulation Study
A Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model is developed to test the effects of staging-level design and load carrier types on the performance of the CDF. The simulation model captures input factors such as truck arrivals, freight levels, and the purity level of cross-docking. The simulation model’s performance is tested for different scenarios, and the effects of different design alternatives are analyzed.
The results demonstrate that two-stage cross-docking with pallets can significantly reduce the total makespan and improve operational efficiency compared to single-stage cross-docking with pallets. The results also show that using roll containers significantly decreases the chance of intra-terminal congestion but also results in longer unloading and reloading times. The research contributes to the understanding of cross-docking operations under uncertainty, stresses the importance of staginglevel
and load carrier type design on CDF performance, and provides insights for logistics companies seeking to optimize their e-commerce supply chains. ...
A Discrete Event Simulation (DES) model is developed to test the effects of staging-level design and load carrier types on the performance of the CDF. The simulation model captures input factors such as truck arrivals, freight levels, and the purity level of cross-docking. The simulation model’s performance is tested for different scenarios, and the effects of different design alternatives are analyzed.
The results demonstrate that two-stage cross-docking with pallets can significantly reduce the total makespan and improve operational efficiency compared to single-stage cross-docking with pallets. The results also show that using roll containers significantly decreases the chance of intra-terminal congestion but also results in longer unloading and reloading times. The research contributes to the understanding of cross-docking operations under uncertainty, stresses the importance of staginglevel
and load carrier type design on CDF performance, and provides insights for logistics companies seeking to optimize their e-commerce supply chains.
Understanding the Relationship between Lock Complex Effectiveness and System Performance
A Study of the Volkerak Complex
- With rising demand, the significance of lock condition in maintaining acceptable service levels and minimising CO2 emissions becomes more evident. The findings indicate a trade-off between preventive and corrective maintenance efforts. In challenging lock conditions, faster repairs and more frequent inspections are needed to prevent capacity problems, leading to longer waiting times. Notable differences in handling capacity are observed in the three lock conditions studied.
- The concept of baseline OEE proves to be valuable as a maintenance-oriented metric. It emphasises that proficient maintenance strategies can counteract deficiencies in the lock system, resulting in improved capacity, reduced transit times, and reduced CO2 emissions. A general rule of thumb suggests that improving baseline OEE by one point corresponds to about a 1.2%-1.5% improvement in waiting times and emissions.
- Changing MTTR and inspection policies influences baseline OEE scores, but these adjustments must be aligned with the lock condition. Frequent inspections might yield unnecessary availability losses when the lock is well maintained. Similarly, the extent of benefits of shorter MTTRs depends on the frequency of breakdowns.
- A prominent dilemma in lock systems involves balancing transit times and the number of levellings. Locking regimes capture this trade-off, where reducing waiting time thresholds increases levellings and operational costs. However, some strategies can achieve an improvement in both aspects. These include expanding traffic range and considering the current state of the system when assigning lock chambers to incoming vessels.
- Service-based OEE, integrating operational and maintenance policies, aligns better with waiting times and CO2 emissions compared to the service level alone. This composite index can serve the purpose of monitoring waterway network lock systems, helping to identify losses due to unavailability and reduced speed. ...
- With rising demand, the significance of lock condition in maintaining acceptable service levels and minimising CO2 emissions becomes more evident. The findings indicate a trade-off between preventive and corrective maintenance efforts. In challenging lock conditions, faster repairs and more frequent inspections are needed to prevent capacity problems, leading to longer waiting times. Notable differences in handling capacity are observed in the three lock conditions studied.
- The concept of baseline OEE proves to be valuable as a maintenance-oriented metric. It emphasises that proficient maintenance strategies can counteract deficiencies in the lock system, resulting in improved capacity, reduced transit times, and reduced CO2 emissions. A general rule of thumb suggests that improving baseline OEE by one point corresponds to about a 1.2%-1.5% improvement in waiting times and emissions.
- Changing MTTR and inspection policies influences baseline OEE scores, but these adjustments must be aligned with the lock condition. Frequent inspections might yield unnecessary availability losses when the lock is well maintained. Similarly, the extent of benefits of shorter MTTRs depends on the frequency of breakdowns.
- A prominent dilemma in lock systems involves balancing transit times and the number of levellings. Locking regimes capture this trade-off, where reducing waiting time thresholds increases levellings and operational costs. However, some strategies can achieve an improvement in both aspects. These include expanding traffic range and considering the current state of the system when assigning lock chambers to incoming vessels.
- Service-based OEE, integrating operational and maintenance policies, aligns better with waiting times and CO2 emissions compared to the service level alone. This composite index can serve the purpose of monitoring waterway network lock systems, helping to identify losses due to unavailability and reduced speed.
By applying a discrete event simulation (DES) to a case study regarding the construction of an offshore wind farm in the Baltic Sea, different scenarios have been evaluated and assessed in their resilience and performance in response to schedule changes. The findings highlight the importance of a compressed project schedule in achieving cost reductions. A strategy with approximately 75% overlap between load-in and load-out schedules was identified as the most cost-efficient approach. With this approach, cost savings are not only achieved by reducing operational expenses such as personnel and equipment rental, but most substantially by the decreased amount of demanded storage area spaces. With less storage spaces needed, both the construction costs for storage bunds and the area rental costs decrease. The analysis of the experiment on schedule overlap revealed that a scenario with only one support for load-out and zero supports for the load-in exhibited higher average waiting times and total maximum fines. However, this scenario still performed best in terms of total costs, as the waiting times for ships did not outweigh the expenses associated with additional supports. The study also examined the timing of arrivals and found that when a barge arrives the day after the installation vessel departs, the waiting time for unloading significantly decreases.
Collaboration among stakeholders is emphasized as a key recommendation stemming from the study. Involving all relevant actors in offshore wind projects from an early stage can yield extensive mutual benefits. By establishing an overarching supply chain management, coordinated by the project developer, overall construction costs can be reduced without harming any particular party.
The developed discrete event simulation might be applied to other projects to extend the research, under the requirement that the included assumptions are structurally evaluated. Investigating different project sizes, schedule variations and load-out methods could improve the overall understanding of the system dynamics and parameters. In combination with a discrete event simulation, a mathematical layout optimization might enable decision makers to make choices regarding the location and priority of placing wind turbine components in marshalling port, based on the installation variability. This could eventually lead to a decision-making tool suitable for cost-optimizing marshalling activities and installation strategies for wind farm constructions globally, contributing to the acceleration of the energy transition. ...
By applying a discrete event simulation (DES) to a case study regarding the construction of an offshore wind farm in the Baltic Sea, different scenarios have been evaluated and assessed in their resilience and performance in response to schedule changes. The findings highlight the importance of a compressed project schedule in achieving cost reductions. A strategy with approximately 75% overlap between load-in and load-out schedules was identified as the most cost-efficient approach. With this approach, cost savings are not only achieved by reducing operational expenses such as personnel and equipment rental, but most substantially by the decreased amount of demanded storage area spaces. With less storage spaces needed, both the construction costs for storage bunds and the area rental costs decrease. The analysis of the experiment on schedule overlap revealed that a scenario with only one support for load-out and zero supports for the load-in exhibited higher average waiting times and total maximum fines. However, this scenario still performed best in terms of total costs, as the waiting times for ships did not outweigh the expenses associated with additional supports. The study also examined the timing of arrivals and found that when a barge arrives the day after the installation vessel departs, the waiting time for unloading significantly decreases.
Collaboration among stakeholders is emphasized as a key recommendation stemming from the study. Involving all relevant actors in offshore wind projects from an early stage can yield extensive mutual benefits. By establishing an overarching supply chain management, coordinated by the project developer, overall construction costs can be reduced without harming any particular party.
The developed discrete event simulation might be applied to other projects to extend the research, under the requirement that the included assumptions are structurally evaluated. Investigating different project sizes, schedule variations and load-out methods could improve the overall understanding of the system dynamics and parameters. In combination with a discrete event simulation, a mathematical layout optimization might enable decision makers to make choices regarding the location and priority of placing wind turbine components in marshalling port, based on the installation variability. This could eventually lead to a decision-making tool suitable for cost-optimizing marshalling activities and installation strategies for wind farm constructions globally, contributing to the acceleration of the energy transition.
A New Method of Measuring Overall Warehouse Performance
An Automated E-Commerce Retail Warehouse
A Data-Driven Approach for Generation of Tactical Planning Rules Regarding Buffer Time in Initial Railway Timetables
A Case Study on the Differentiation of Buffer Times in the Railway Timetable of Nederlandse Spoorwegen
Night-time container transport between port and hinterland using a hub with extended opening hours
A case study for the port of Rotterdam
How coordination of production and warehouse decisions affects the product flow between factories and warehouses for manufacturing firms
Mathematical models and a case study at Kraft Heinz
The installation of monopiles using the MUST comprises three phases: the barge mooring / lift-off, upending / slewing and lowering / driving phase. Based on the results from a qualitative critical event analysis, the lift-off phase is expected to be limiting. Hence, a hydrodynamic model is developed to quantitatively analyse this phase. Experimental simulations, which are performed in parallel with the model development, result in the preliminary conclusions that multiple pendulum effects influence the results to a limited extent, while viscous roll damping and hydrodynamic interaction effects can be strong determinants of the resulting responses.
The relative z-motion between the lifted monopile and the barge and the barge roll response are identified as governing parameters. To reduce the first limiting factor, a system that allows for instantaneously increasing the vertical clearance between the monopile and the barge is proposed. The effectiveness of this system is tested for two barge loadcases. For the first case, the average workability increase for the optimal heading at a typical location is calculated as 8.3%. For the second, the increase is marginal, as the barge responses are more limiting. Furthermore, is it found that a Passive Motion Compensator (PMC) can reduce the probability of the introduction of snap loads in the winch cable, and therefore allows for system optimisations. A PMC with 10% of critical damping can reduce the required winch capacity with a factor of 2.3 w.r.t. the uncompensated case.
It is recommended to perform follow-up studies into the system performance during upending / slewing and lowering / driving. Also, it is advised to evaluate the effect of a larger barge and a PMC on the workability. To balance the associated investments and workability increases, the logistical models developed in a parallel study can be used. Finally, for iterative calculations, it was found to be beneficial to make an estimate based on a fast simplified model and to subsequently feed the results back into a more detailed, but slower model.
...
The installation of monopiles using the MUST comprises three phases: the barge mooring / lift-off, upending / slewing and lowering / driving phase. Based on the results from a qualitative critical event analysis, the lift-off phase is expected to be limiting. Hence, a hydrodynamic model is developed to quantitatively analyse this phase. Experimental simulations, which are performed in parallel with the model development, result in the preliminary conclusions that multiple pendulum effects influence the results to a limited extent, while viscous roll damping and hydrodynamic interaction effects can be strong determinants of the resulting responses.
The relative z-motion between the lifted monopile and the barge and the barge roll response are identified as governing parameters. To reduce the first limiting factor, a system that allows for instantaneously increasing the vertical clearance between the monopile and the barge is proposed. The effectiveness of this system is tested for two barge loadcases. For the first case, the average workability increase for the optimal heading at a typical location is calculated as 8.3%. For the second, the increase is marginal, as the barge responses are more limiting. Furthermore, is it found that a Passive Motion Compensator (PMC) can reduce the probability of the introduction of snap loads in the winch cable, and therefore allows for system optimisations. A PMC with 10% of critical damping can reduce the required winch capacity with a factor of 2.3 w.r.t. the uncompensated case.
It is recommended to perform follow-up studies into the system performance during upending / slewing and lowering / driving. Also, it is advised to evaluate the effect of a larger barge and a PMC on the workability. To balance the associated investments and workability increases, the logistical models developed in a parallel study can be used. Finally, for iterative calculations, it was found to be beneficial to make an estimate based on a fast simplified model and to subsequently feed the results back into a more detailed, but slower model.
To quantitatively compare the strategies, and to consider stochastic processes (e.g., weather conditions), a discrete-event simulation modelling approach is adopted. To arrive at substantiated conclusions, a framework is followed, which provides a roadmap and rigour criteria for the design, implementation and evaluation phases. First, a conceptual model is developed and face validated. Next, a numerical “base model” is constructed, which describes the most basic strategy. This model is face validated by industry experts and evaluated by parameter variability, convergence and historical data validation tests. It is concluded that the base model is structured according to shared practical experiences, responds satisfactory to parameter changes, requires 35 simulation runs to converge, and has good predictive capabilities. Hence, it is deemed suitable to function as a “template” for the modelling of the other strategies.
The simulation results are evaluated for each of the considered substructures separately. (i) MP – TP installation. In general, assembly-line installation strategies, in which two Heavy Lift Vessels (HLVs) are deployed, are associated with the shortest installation time. The shuttling – assembly-line and the shuttling–alternating (in which MPs and TPs are installed alternatingly) strategies are associated with the lowest costs. Both involve a shuttling transportation strategy, in which the HLV(s) ensure(s) both the transportation and installation of the components. The mooring of barges alongside an HLV in feeder strategies (feeder vessels supply components to an HLV, which stays at the wind farm under development) and the installation of TPs by a relatively small HLV in assembly-line strategies are identified as the main bottlenecks. Reducing these by relatively simple solutions can result in significant performance increases. Lastly, the project start date is found to be a strong determinant of strategy performance. (ii) Jacket – foundation pile installation. The assembly-line strategies are found to result in the shortest jacket installation times as well. However, only the shuttling – assembly-line strategy is additionally associated with the lowest costs. Furthermore, it is found that a separate pile-dredging vessel can help to reduce the time and costs associated with separate phases installation strategies, in which jackets and their foundation piles are installed in different phases. Also for jackets, the barge mooring alongside the HLV is identified to be the largest bottleneck. Reducing this bottleneck can result in significant performance benefits. Lastly, a relationship is found between the performance of jacket installation strategies and the project start date, although weaker than for MP installation.
The developed decision support tool can provide a platform for further research into the logistics of offshore wind and other industries, whereas the obtained results are only valid within the set boundaries. To widen the applicability, it is recommended to perform follow-up studies in which a stochastic mechanical failure component is included, and the sensitivity to the wind farm size and port-to-farm distance is tested. Furthermore, it is advised to extend this study to investigate the potential of the industry adopting a more holistic process or market point of view. ...
To quantitatively compare the strategies, and to consider stochastic processes (e.g., weather conditions), a discrete-event simulation modelling approach is adopted. To arrive at substantiated conclusions, a framework is followed, which provides a roadmap and rigour criteria for the design, implementation and evaluation phases. First, a conceptual model is developed and face validated. Next, a numerical “base model” is constructed, which describes the most basic strategy. This model is face validated by industry experts and evaluated by parameter variability, convergence and historical data validation tests. It is concluded that the base model is structured according to shared practical experiences, responds satisfactory to parameter changes, requires 35 simulation runs to converge, and has good predictive capabilities. Hence, it is deemed suitable to function as a “template” for the modelling of the other strategies.
The simulation results are evaluated for each of the considered substructures separately. (i) MP – TP installation. In general, assembly-line installation strategies, in which two Heavy Lift Vessels (HLVs) are deployed, are associated with the shortest installation time. The shuttling – assembly-line and the shuttling–alternating (in which MPs and TPs are installed alternatingly) strategies are associated with the lowest costs. Both involve a shuttling transportation strategy, in which the HLV(s) ensure(s) both the transportation and installation of the components. The mooring of barges alongside an HLV in feeder strategies (feeder vessels supply components to an HLV, which stays at the wind farm under development) and the installation of TPs by a relatively small HLV in assembly-line strategies are identified as the main bottlenecks. Reducing these by relatively simple solutions can result in significant performance increases. Lastly, the project start date is found to be a strong determinant of strategy performance. (ii) Jacket – foundation pile installation. The assembly-line strategies are found to result in the shortest jacket installation times as well. However, only the shuttling – assembly-line strategy is additionally associated with the lowest costs. Furthermore, it is found that a separate pile-dredging vessel can help to reduce the time and costs associated with separate phases installation strategies, in which jackets and their foundation piles are installed in different phases. Also for jackets, the barge mooring alongside the HLV is identified to be the largest bottleneck. Reducing this bottleneck can result in significant performance benefits. Lastly, a relationship is found between the performance of jacket installation strategies and the project start date, although weaker than for MP installation.
The developed decision support tool can provide a platform for further research into the logistics of offshore wind and other industries, whereas the obtained results are only valid within the set boundaries. To widen the applicability, it is recommended to perform follow-up studies in which a stochastic mechanical failure component is included, and the sensitivity to the wind farm size and port-to-farm distance is tested. Furthermore, it is advised to extend this study to investigate the potential of the industry adopting a more holistic process or market point of view.