E. Lourens
Please Note
22 records found
1
Under stationary loading conditions, the mean damping estimates are accurate for both systems. However, the precision of damping estimates is significantly reduced at low and high relative amplitude ranges. At low amplitudes, the reduced precision in damping estimates arises because the Random Decrement Signatures (RDS) fail to accurately capture the system’s free decay, as segments are sampled at very low response levels. At high amplitudes, the lack of precision in damping estimates is primarily due to insufficient segment counts in the computation of the RDS, which prevents proper isolation of the system’s free vibration response.
Moreover, RDS corresponding to the system with amplitude-dependent damping exhibit a non-uniform decay, causing fitting errors when using non-linear Least Squares Minimization to estimate a constant damping value. These errors can be mitigated by reducing the length of the segments sampled by the Peak RDT algorithm.
Three types of non-stationarity are introduced in the excitation: time-varying mean, time-varying variance, and their combination. While the second case yields level-stationary response signals complying with the underlying assumptions of the Peak RDT, the other two introduce time-dependent non-zero means in the response data, leading to significant accuracy errors in mean damping estimates for both linear and non-linear systems.
In conclusion, the Peak RDT yields reliable damping estimates for systems with constant and amplitude-dependent damping only under stationary loading conditions. However, it must be acknowledged that the degrees of non-stationarity considered in this thesis is rather large. The Peak RDT might still produce reliable damping estimates for mildly non-stationary vibration responses.
...
Under stationary loading conditions, the mean damping estimates are accurate for both systems. However, the precision of damping estimates is significantly reduced at low and high relative amplitude ranges. At low amplitudes, the reduced precision in damping estimates arises because the Random Decrement Signatures (RDS) fail to accurately capture the system’s free decay, as segments are sampled at very low response levels. At high amplitudes, the lack of precision in damping estimates is primarily due to insufficient segment counts in the computation of the RDS, which prevents proper isolation of the system’s free vibration response.
Moreover, RDS corresponding to the system with amplitude-dependent damping exhibit a non-uniform decay, causing fitting errors when using non-linear Least Squares Minimization to estimate a constant damping value. These errors can be mitigated by reducing the length of the segments sampled by the Peak RDT algorithm.
Three types of non-stationarity are introduced in the excitation: time-varying mean, time-varying variance, and their combination. While the second case yields level-stationary response signals complying with the underlying assumptions of the Peak RDT, the other two introduce time-dependent non-zero means in the response data, leading to significant accuracy errors in mean damping estimates for both linear and non-linear systems.
In conclusion, the Peak RDT yields reliable damping estimates for systems with constant and amplitude-dependent damping only under stationary loading conditions. However, it must be acknowledged that the degrees of non-stationarity considered in this thesis is rather large. The Peak RDT might still produce reliable damping estimates for mildly non-stationary vibration responses.
Motions and Mechanical Loading on Monopile, Tension-Leg-Platform, and Semi-Submersible Offshore Wind Turbines
A Comparative Time Domain Analysis on Motion Responses and Mechanical Loadings on Offshore Wind Turbines Expressed in Bearing Lifetimes
The modeling program Orcaflex is used to describe the motions and loading of TLP and semi-submersible floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs). Bluewater Energy Services is currently designing a TLP platform for a wind turbine, and this design, along with a semi-submersible FOWT model, is compared with an IEA 15 MW bottom-fixed turbine. External loads such as waves and wind, generated from North Sea data, are considered. Additionally, the effects of design parameters like weight, waterline area, center of mass, and wind turbine generator (WTG) control settings are taken into account.
The study reveals that the semi-submersible platform is more susceptible to environmental loads, leading to some significant translational and rotational motions. Its stability relies on a large water surface area and a catenary mooring system, resulting in low system stiffness. In contrast, the bottom-fixed and TLP turbines exhibit lower motion fluctuations due to their higher system stiffness. The TLP experiences higher nacelle accelerations compared to the semi-submersible, except for heave acceleration, due to resonance with wave frequencies. Mechanical loadings are significantly influenced by wind speed and the turbine's controller. Before reaching the rated wind speed, mechanical loads increase with environmental loads, while post-rated wind speed, the loads stabilize or even decrease due to the controller's intervention.
Furthermore, the study identifies the driving factors for the lifetime of pitch, yaw, and main bearings. The pitch bearing's equivalent load is predominantly influenced by wind-induced moments, while the yaw bearing's load is largely governed by axial loads from the RNA's weight. The main upwind bearing's load is primarily affected by radial loads, with axial loads becoming more significant as wind loads increase.
The overall conclusion indicates that while platform motions influence system dynamics, their direct effect on mechanical loads is less significant compared to other factors such as wind loads and controller actions. The pitch controller plays a crucial role in managing mechanical loads, particularly for pitch bearings. Nevertheless, the relatively large mean angle of the semi-submersible platform impacts bearing lifetimes. The system's angle, combined with the weight of components, especially for the yaw bearing, is a critical factor in determining their lifetime. These findings are supported by existing literature, confirming the complex interplay between environmental conditions, system motions, and mechanical loadings in offshore wind turbines. ...
The modeling program Orcaflex is used to describe the motions and loading of TLP and semi-submersible floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs). Bluewater Energy Services is currently designing a TLP platform for a wind turbine, and this design, along with a semi-submersible FOWT model, is compared with an IEA 15 MW bottom-fixed turbine. External loads such as waves and wind, generated from North Sea data, are considered. Additionally, the effects of design parameters like weight, waterline area, center of mass, and wind turbine generator (WTG) control settings are taken into account.
The study reveals that the semi-submersible platform is more susceptible to environmental loads, leading to some significant translational and rotational motions. Its stability relies on a large water surface area and a catenary mooring system, resulting in low system stiffness. In contrast, the bottom-fixed and TLP turbines exhibit lower motion fluctuations due to their higher system stiffness. The TLP experiences higher nacelle accelerations compared to the semi-submersible, except for heave acceleration, due to resonance with wave frequencies. Mechanical loadings are significantly influenced by wind speed and the turbine's controller. Before reaching the rated wind speed, mechanical loads increase with environmental loads, while post-rated wind speed, the loads stabilize or even decrease due to the controller's intervention.
Furthermore, the study identifies the driving factors for the lifetime of pitch, yaw, and main bearings. The pitch bearing's equivalent load is predominantly influenced by wind-induced moments, while the yaw bearing's load is largely governed by axial loads from the RNA's weight. The main upwind bearing's load is primarily affected by radial loads, with axial loads becoming more significant as wind loads increase.
The overall conclusion indicates that while platform motions influence system dynamics, their direct effect on mechanical loads is less significant compared to other factors such as wind loads and controller actions. The pitch controller plays a crucial role in managing mechanical loads, particularly for pitch bearings. Nevertheless, the relatively large mean angle of the semi-submersible platform impacts bearing lifetimes. The system's angle, combined with the weight of components, especially for the yaw bearing, is a critical factor in determining their lifetime. These findings are supported by existing literature, confirming the complex interplay between environmental conditions, system motions, and mechanical loadings in offshore wind turbines.
Distributed Fibre Optic Sensing for Strain and Crack-Width Monitoring in Existing Concrete Structures
A laboratory study on surface-bonded DFOS for concrete
This thesis addresses these gaps through a combination of literature review and laboratory experiments on reinforced-concrete members with surface-bonded DFOS, complemented by a conceptual application to an existing prestressed concrete box-girder bridge. As a qualitative pilot, an inverted T-girder tested in three-point bending is instrumented with DFOS and digital image correlation (DIC). The distributed strain profiles clearly reveal the formation and growth of flexural and shear cracks, but they also expose weaknesses of generic installation guidelines, such as non-uniform adhesive layers, local debonding and data gaps near steep strain gradients. These observations are used to formulate a refined, evidence-based installation strategy for surface-bonded DFOS on concrete.
In a second phase, four reinforced-concrete beams are tested in four-point bending with DFOS, strain gauges and digital image correlation (DIC). Comparisons between DFOS and strain-gauge measurements in both tension and compression show that the fibre systematically underestimates the true concrete surface strain, but with an almost constant ratio for a given installation. This allows a strain-transfer efficiency factor to be identified so that DFOS strains can be converted into realistic concrete strains in the uncracked range. DFOS-based crack widths, obtained by integrating the corrected strain peaks around cracks, are then validated against DIC. For cracks above a practical resolution limit, good agreement is achieved as long as the DFOS signal around each crack is largely intact. When substantial parts of the peak are missing, the error in DFOS crack widths increases and the results become unreliable.
Overall, the thesis demonstrates that surface-bonded DFOS can be used quantitatively for strain and crack-width monitoring in existing concrete structures, provided that installation is treated as a carefully designed process, strain-transfer efficiency is calibrated, and simple data-quality checks are incorporated into the interpretation of crack measurements.
...
This thesis addresses these gaps through a combination of literature review and laboratory experiments on reinforced-concrete members with surface-bonded DFOS, complemented by a conceptual application to an existing prestressed concrete box-girder bridge. As a qualitative pilot, an inverted T-girder tested in three-point bending is instrumented with DFOS and digital image correlation (DIC). The distributed strain profiles clearly reveal the formation and growth of flexural and shear cracks, but they also expose weaknesses of generic installation guidelines, such as non-uniform adhesive layers, local debonding and data gaps near steep strain gradients. These observations are used to formulate a refined, evidence-based installation strategy for surface-bonded DFOS on concrete.
In a second phase, four reinforced-concrete beams are tested in four-point bending with DFOS, strain gauges and digital image correlation (DIC). Comparisons between DFOS and strain-gauge measurements in both tension and compression show that the fibre systematically underestimates the true concrete surface strain, but with an almost constant ratio for a given installation. This allows a strain-transfer efficiency factor to be identified so that DFOS strains can be converted into realistic concrete strains in the uncracked range. DFOS-based crack widths, obtained by integrating the corrected strain peaks around cracks, are then validated against DIC. For cracks above a practical resolution limit, good agreement is achieved as long as the DFOS signal around each crack is largely intact. When substantial parts of the peak are missing, the error in DFOS crack widths increases and the results become unreliable.
Overall, the thesis demonstrates that surface-bonded DFOS can be used quantitatively for strain and crack-width monitoring in existing concrete structures, provided that installation is treated as a carefully designed process, strain-transfer efficiency is calibrated, and simple data-quality checks are incorporated into the interpretation of crack measurements.
Vibration-based Bayesian FE-Model Updating for High-rise Buildings
Application of a Bayesian model updating technique for estimating the structural properties of high-rise buildings
The primary objective of this thesis was to overcome these limitations and enhance both the accuracy and reliability of structural parameter estimation. To this end, a vibration-based Bayesian finite element (FE) model updating approach was implemented. A simplified three-dimensional FE model, formulated as a lumped-mass stick model, was developed for the New Orleans Tower. The model was specifically designed to capture both torsional and shear deformations while maintaining the computational efficiency required for Bayesian inference.
Within this framework, the Bayesian methodology employs Bayes’ theorem together with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling to treat uncertain structural parameters, such as foundation stiffnesses and the concrete modulus of elasticity, as random variables. This produces a posterior probability distribution that formally quantifies the uncertainties associated with the updated parameters. The prior distributions were defined based on literature and engineering judgement, while the likelihood function was defined through a data-generating process. Furthermore, a novel mode-matching method based on the modal participation mass ratio was developed to robustly pair measured and modelled modes.
Model updating was performed for the New Orleans Tower through four different cases, each incorporating additional modal information. Overall, the Bayesian updating successfully produced models that closely matched the measured data. Across these cases, several advantages of the Bayesian approach were demonstrated, including the ability to detect parameter redundancy and overfitting, identify uninformative parameters, improve the solution through uncertainty reduction, and reveal the existence of multiple possible solutions.
The proposed modelling approach also exhibited improved performance compared to simplified analytical beam models. It successfully captured the third bending mode without compromising the accuracy of the lower modes. The first torsional mode was also well represented; however, the inclusion of the second torsional mode proved unsuccessful. This limitation is likely due to missing parameters or model features within the updating scheme rather than to deficiencies in the modelling approach itself.
The case study further revealed significant model inadequacies for higher modes. These inadequacies were primarily attributed to the exclusion of the effect of the adjoining low-rise structure and the assumption of rigid connections between structural elements. For studies where models with accurate higher modes are required, these effects may not be neglected. ...
The primary objective of this thesis was to overcome these limitations and enhance both the accuracy and reliability of structural parameter estimation. To this end, a vibration-based Bayesian finite element (FE) model updating approach was implemented. A simplified three-dimensional FE model, formulated as a lumped-mass stick model, was developed for the New Orleans Tower. The model was specifically designed to capture both torsional and shear deformations while maintaining the computational efficiency required for Bayesian inference.
Within this framework, the Bayesian methodology employs Bayes’ theorem together with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling to treat uncertain structural parameters, such as foundation stiffnesses and the concrete modulus of elasticity, as random variables. This produces a posterior probability distribution that formally quantifies the uncertainties associated with the updated parameters. The prior distributions were defined based on literature and engineering judgement, while the likelihood function was defined through a data-generating process. Furthermore, a novel mode-matching method based on the modal participation mass ratio was developed to robustly pair measured and modelled modes.
Model updating was performed for the New Orleans Tower through four different cases, each incorporating additional modal information. Overall, the Bayesian updating successfully produced models that closely matched the measured data. Across these cases, several advantages of the Bayesian approach were demonstrated, including the ability to detect parameter redundancy and overfitting, identify uninformative parameters, improve the solution through uncertainty reduction, and reveal the existence of multiple possible solutions.
The proposed modelling approach also exhibited improved performance compared to simplified analytical beam models. It successfully captured the third bending mode without compromising the accuracy of the lower modes. The first torsional mode was also well represented; however, the inclusion of the second torsional mode proved unsuccessful. This limitation is likely due to missing parameters or model features within the updating scheme rather than to deficiencies in the modelling approach itself.
The case study further revealed significant model inadequacies for higher modes. These inadequacies were primarily attributed to the exclusion of the effect of the adjoining low-rise structure and the assumption of rigid connections between structural elements. For studies where models with accurate higher modes are required, these effects may not be neglected.
A major challenge in monopile installation occurs when the tip of the pile contacts the seabed and establishes a connection with the lateral soil. This introduces an abrupt change in the overall system dynamics and increases the risk of DP instability problems of the vessel. These problems are not new to the offshore industry. However, with the introduction of the MCGF, the risk of DP instability increases, as there is now a much stronger dynamic coupling between the vessel, the monopile and the seabed. Therefore, it is important that the MCGF is properly controlled, as this directly influences the reaction forces applied to the vessel. However, properly tuning the MCGF controller is challenging, as it strongly depends on the lateral soil behavior. Currently, these controller gains are tuned using simulations in which the soil behavior is modeled using CPT data. Nevertheless, the estimated behavior based on this data contain large uncertainties and therefore the control settings might become suboptimal during the installation. Furthermore, since soil dynamics also changes during installation, it is beneficial to use a real-time estimation method that takes this into account. Therefore, this thesis investigates different identification methods to obtain real-time estimates of lateral soil behavior during the monopile installation process.
Two main approaches are explored; the augmented EKF approach and the GPLFM approach. The augmented EKF approach shows to be capable of estimating soil behavior by directly identifying the lateral and rotational soil stiffness values, given that the filter is carefully tuned. However, tuning the filter is computationally demanding due to the large number of tunable parameters, which makes this method impractical for site-specific tuning prior to installation using the first measurements obtained. This limitation is critical, as offshore installations face varying conditions at each site, and accurate estimation therefore requires site-specific tuning. To address this tuning challenge, an alternative method is introduced: the GPLFM approach. In this framework, the identification task is reformulated as a GP regression problem. An important advantage of this method is that the process covariance matrix is determined in a data-driven manner, providing a complete covariance structure governed by only a small number of tunable parameters. Consequently, the parameter space is greatly reduced, enabling efficient site-specific tuning. As a result, it is shown that it is possible to obtain accurate estimation results across varying conditions.
Therefore, it is found that the GPLFM method offers a promising solution for real-time estimation of lateral soil behavior during monopile installation. By providing real-time estimates, this study supports the development of more effective MCGF control strategie. This can in the future be used to improve the MCGF controller as it can now be adjusted automatically during the installation process rather than manually. Furthermore, it can help to prevent DP instability problems. ...
A major challenge in monopile installation occurs when the tip of the pile contacts the seabed and establishes a connection with the lateral soil. This introduces an abrupt change in the overall system dynamics and increases the risk of DP instability problems of the vessel. These problems are not new to the offshore industry. However, with the introduction of the MCGF, the risk of DP instability increases, as there is now a much stronger dynamic coupling between the vessel, the monopile and the seabed. Therefore, it is important that the MCGF is properly controlled, as this directly influences the reaction forces applied to the vessel. However, properly tuning the MCGF controller is challenging, as it strongly depends on the lateral soil behavior. Currently, these controller gains are tuned using simulations in which the soil behavior is modeled using CPT data. Nevertheless, the estimated behavior based on this data contain large uncertainties and therefore the control settings might become suboptimal during the installation. Furthermore, since soil dynamics also changes during installation, it is beneficial to use a real-time estimation method that takes this into account. Therefore, this thesis investigates different identification methods to obtain real-time estimates of lateral soil behavior during the monopile installation process.
Two main approaches are explored; the augmented EKF approach and the GPLFM approach. The augmented EKF approach shows to be capable of estimating soil behavior by directly identifying the lateral and rotational soil stiffness values, given that the filter is carefully tuned. However, tuning the filter is computationally demanding due to the large number of tunable parameters, which makes this method impractical for site-specific tuning prior to installation using the first measurements obtained. This limitation is critical, as offshore installations face varying conditions at each site, and accurate estimation therefore requires site-specific tuning. To address this tuning challenge, an alternative method is introduced: the GPLFM approach. In this framework, the identification task is reformulated as a GP regression problem. An important advantage of this method is that the process covariance matrix is determined in a data-driven manner, providing a complete covariance structure governed by only a small number of tunable parameters. Consequently, the parameter space is greatly reduced, enabling efficient site-specific tuning. As a result, it is shown that it is possible to obtain accurate estimation results across varying conditions.
Therefore, it is found that the GPLFM method offers a promising solution for real-time estimation of lateral soil behavior during monopile installation. By providing real-time estimates, this study supports the development of more effective MCGF control strategie. This can in the future be used to improve the MCGF controller as it can now be adjusted automatically during the installation process rather than manually. Furthermore, it can help to prevent DP instability problems.
The objective of this thesis is to perform a structural analysis of a geometrically non-linear Timoshenko beam using a physics informed neural network. The network is built using a variational principle (the principle of virtual work) and a force residual. Furthermore, two optimization algorithms, the adaptive weight loss algorithm and the adaptive activation function are separately used in conjunction with the model to examine the potential improvements on the convergence rate.
It is found that the geometrically non-linear Timoshenko beam can be accurately modeled (relative error of below 2% with respect to the finite element output) with a physics informed neural network. This accuracy can be achieved with a model possessing a relatively shallow size of four hidden layers containing eight neurons each. The adaptive weight loss algorithm and the adaptive activation algorithm both improve the convergence rate of the model, though they are not necessary to maintain the practicality of the model, as the convergence rate is adequate without these. It is recommended that the hyperbolic tangent function is utilized in conjunction with the Adam optimizer. The adaptive activation function can be incorporated into the model to improve the convergence rate significantly without substantially increasing the computational cost of the model. ...
The objective of this thesis is to perform a structural analysis of a geometrically non-linear Timoshenko beam using a physics informed neural network. The network is built using a variational principle (the principle of virtual work) and a force residual. Furthermore, two optimization algorithms, the adaptive weight loss algorithm and the adaptive activation function are separately used in conjunction with the model to examine the potential improvements on the convergence rate.
It is found that the geometrically non-linear Timoshenko beam can be accurately modeled (relative error of below 2% with respect to the finite element output) with a physics informed neural network. This accuracy can be achieved with a model possessing a relatively shallow size of four hidden layers containing eight neurons each. The adaptive weight loss algorithm and the adaptive activation algorithm both improve the convergence rate of the model, though they are not necessary to maintain the practicality of the model, as the convergence rate is adequate without these. It is recommended that the hyperbolic tangent function is utilized in conjunction with the Adam optimizer. The adaptive activation function can be incorporated into the model to improve the convergence rate significantly without substantially increasing the computational cost of the model.
Control of Flexible Floating Islands
Theoretical Framework for the Control of Flexible Floating Structures
From the insights gained during the literature review, we formulate a theoretical framework that serves as the basis for our methodology. We subsequently examine two distinct control scenarios—regular and irregular wave conditions—serving as a Proof of Concept, and we discuss the significant observations derived from these experiments. In conclusion, we summarize our findings and provide recommendations for future research directions.
We utilize a two-way monolithic Finite Element formulation of the flexible floating structure as a representation of the real-world system we aim to control. For our control strategy, we implement Model Predictive Control, which facilitates the incorporation of advanced functionalities, including the application of constraints. To enhance computational efficiency, we employ a Reduced Order Model (ROM) through Dynamic Mode Decomposition with Control (DMDc), trained using open-loop data derived from the Finite Element model. Additionally, we implement a Kalman filter to reconstruct the system's state from sparse and noisy measurements obtained from the floating structure.
We design two Reduced Order Models specifically for controlling the floating structure under the aforementioned conditions. Prior to executing the control strategies in these distinct scenarios, we conduct an in-depth investigation of DMDc, exploring its relationship with Koopman theory. We generate open-loop data free from pollution using the Finite Element model, which is subsequently utilized to derive the Reduced Order Model. A convergence study is performed by analyzing the eigenvalues and amplitudes of the DMDc, following methodologies established in prior research. We validate the DMDc models against validation datasets, allowing us to select the model exhibiting the smallest validation error. Furthermore, we ensure that the training datasets inherently encompass the wet modes by employing Proper Orthogonal Decomposition.
Our initial control scenario involves managing the floating structure under regular wave conditions. This case is pivotal for acquiring fundamental insights into the control mechanisms. We observe that the frequency of the control input aligns precisely with the excitation frequency. Subsequently, we extend our study to encompass the control of the floating structure in irregular wave conditions, characterized by a sea state defined by the JONSWAP spectrum. Consistent with our findings from the regular wave scenario, we discover that the control mechanism exploits the natural frequencies of the floating structure, which closely correspond to the energy-dense region of the sea state's spectrum. This is achieved by amplifying the reflected wave, thereby counteracting the incoming wave and reducing energy input into the system.
In conclusion, we advocate for further research to bolster the proposed method by examining various structural properties and wave environments, thereby providing robust evidence to validate the approach presented in this study. Our findings indicate that the integration of advanced control strategies, such as MPC and DMDc, holds significant promise for optimizing the performance and stability of flexible floating structures in dynamic offshore conditions. ...
From the insights gained during the literature review, we formulate a theoretical framework that serves as the basis for our methodology. We subsequently examine two distinct control scenarios—regular and irregular wave conditions—serving as a Proof of Concept, and we discuss the significant observations derived from these experiments. In conclusion, we summarize our findings and provide recommendations for future research directions.
We utilize a two-way monolithic Finite Element formulation of the flexible floating structure as a representation of the real-world system we aim to control. For our control strategy, we implement Model Predictive Control, which facilitates the incorporation of advanced functionalities, including the application of constraints. To enhance computational efficiency, we employ a Reduced Order Model (ROM) through Dynamic Mode Decomposition with Control (DMDc), trained using open-loop data derived from the Finite Element model. Additionally, we implement a Kalman filter to reconstruct the system's state from sparse and noisy measurements obtained from the floating structure.
We design two Reduced Order Models specifically for controlling the floating structure under the aforementioned conditions. Prior to executing the control strategies in these distinct scenarios, we conduct an in-depth investigation of DMDc, exploring its relationship with Koopman theory. We generate open-loop data free from pollution using the Finite Element model, which is subsequently utilized to derive the Reduced Order Model. A convergence study is performed by analyzing the eigenvalues and amplitudes of the DMDc, following methodologies established in prior research. We validate the DMDc models against validation datasets, allowing us to select the model exhibiting the smallest validation error. Furthermore, we ensure that the training datasets inherently encompass the wet modes by employing Proper Orthogonal Decomposition.
Our initial control scenario involves managing the floating structure under regular wave conditions. This case is pivotal for acquiring fundamental insights into the control mechanisms. We observe that the frequency of the control input aligns precisely with the excitation frequency. Subsequently, we extend our study to encompass the control of the floating structure in irregular wave conditions, characterized by a sea state defined by the JONSWAP spectrum. Consistent with our findings from the regular wave scenario, we discover that the control mechanism exploits the natural frequencies of the floating structure, which closely correspond to the energy-dense region of the sea state's spectrum. This is achieved by amplifying the reflected wave, thereby counteracting the incoming wave and reducing energy input into the system.
In conclusion, we advocate for further research to bolster the proposed method by examining various structural properties and wave environments, thereby providing robust evidence to validate the approach presented in this study. Our findings indicate that the integration of advanced control strategies, such as MPC and DMDc, holds significant promise for optimizing the performance and stability of flexible floating structures in dynamic offshore conditions.
Machine learning techniques for investigating the Coulomb friction and hysteresis in structural joints
A data driven approach for monitoring non-linearity in engineering systems
For identifying the uncertain system parameters like stiffness, viscous damping and magnitude of friction force, the SINDy algorithm is extended by using stick and slip temporal constraints. This is done by segregating the data of external forcing and response of SDoF system, applying the existing SINDy algorithm and applying the sticking and slipping conditions in the time domain. The proposed Extended SINDy approach estimates the system parameters more accurately compared to the existing SINDy algorithm.
For studying the hysteresis in the structural joints, a pinned column base-plate was considered in an elastic region. Further, the Dahl model with different slope parameter for each branch of moment-rotation hysteresis is employed. The correct values of parameters are estimated using the Bayesian Optimization technique. This procedure yields a functional form representing a resisting hysteretic moment-rotation behaviour in a structural joint with good accuracy.
...
For identifying the uncertain system parameters like stiffness, viscous damping and magnitude of friction force, the SINDy algorithm is extended by using stick and slip temporal constraints. This is done by segregating the data of external forcing and response of SDoF system, applying the existing SINDy algorithm and applying the sticking and slipping conditions in the time domain. The proposed Extended SINDy approach estimates the system parameters more accurately compared to the existing SINDy algorithm.
For studying the hysteresis in the structural joints, a pinned column base-plate was considered in an elastic region. Further, the Dahl model with different slope parameter for each branch of moment-rotation hysteresis is employed. The correct values of parameters are estimated using the Bayesian Optimization technique. This procedure yields a functional form representing a resisting hysteretic moment-rotation behaviour in a structural joint with good accuracy.
The focus of this work is on performing Bayesian system identification for real-world civil engineering structures within an acceptable running time, while using optic fibre measurements with a high spatial resolution. The proposed methodology employs a cheap-to-compute Gaussian process (GP) surrogate that replaces the main bottleneck of the Bayesian workflow for these type of problems: the evaluation of the log-likelihood. The GP surrogate is actively built by sequentially selecting new training points in areas that are expected to highly contribute to the accuracy of the posterior distribution. Once convergence is achieved, the surrogate is used to obtain the parameter estimates via Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling. Additionally, in order to accelerate the Bayesian workflow, cloud-based parallelization is used to perform multiple finite element analyses simultaneously.
A first synthetic case with an inexpensive frame model is used to test the methodology for problems with two and five probabilistic parameters. An encouraging outcome is obtained with the actively learned GP surrogate, with posterior distributions very close to the full MCMC procedure while requiring a number of physical model evaluations orders of magnitude lower.
After that, a second case study consisting of an existing reinforced concrete bridge with real measurements and a relatively expensive finite element model is investigated. A subset of discrete strain and translation sensors are used to perform an initial parameter estimation that almost exactly resembles the results from previous research on this bridge by Rózsás, et al. (2022), successfully validating the proposed procedure. Then, another parameter estimation is computed using available high resolution optic fibre measurements, after which is shown that the optic fibre provides the best improvements in model predictive capacity among all sensor groups, confirming its potential when combined with Bayesian system identification.
The results of the case studies indicate that the approach presented in this thesis has the capacity to greatly reduce the wall-clock time of Bayesian parameter estimation for real world civil engineering structures with optic fibre measurements, while maintaining a high degree of accuracy. Nevertheless, additional research is required for cases where the statistical parameters governing the measurement and model uncertainty are inferred along with the physical parameters. ...
The focus of this work is on performing Bayesian system identification for real-world civil engineering structures within an acceptable running time, while using optic fibre measurements with a high spatial resolution. The proposed methodology employs a cheap-to-compute Gaussian process (GP) surrogate that replaces the main bottleneck of the Bayesian workflow for these type of problems: the evaluation of the log-likelihood. The GP surrogate is actively built by sequentially selecting new training points in areas that are expected to highly contribute to the accuracy of the posterior distribution. Once convergence is achieved, the surrogate is used to obtain the parameter estimates via Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling. Additionally, in order to accelerate the Bayesian workflow, cloud-based parallelization is used to perform multiple finite element analyses simultaneously.
A first synthetic case with an inexpensive frame model is used to test the methodology for problems with two and five probabilistic parameters. An encouraging outcome is obtained with the actively learned GP surrogate, with posterior distributions very close to the full MCMC procedure while requiring a number of physical model evaluations orders of magnitude lower.
After that, a second case study consisting of an existing reinforced concrete bridge with real measurements and a relatively expensive finite element model is investigated. A subset of discrete strain and translation sensors are used to perform an initial parameter estimation that almost exactly resembles the results from previous research on this bridge by Rózsás, et al. (2022), successfully validating the proposed procedure. Then, another parameter estimation is computed using available high resolution optic fibre measurements, after which is shown that the optic fibre provides the best improvements in model predictive capacity among all sensor groups, confirming its potential when combined with Bayesian system identification.
The results of the case studies indicate that the approach presented in this thesis has the capacity to greatly reduce the wall-clock time of Bayesian parameter estimation for real world civil engineering structures with optic fibre measurements, while maintaining a high degree of accuracy. Nevertheless, additional research is required for cases where the statistical parameters governing the measurement and model uncertainty are inferred along with the physical parameters.
Striving to reduce the environmental impact of bridges, there lies a great potential in using materials with a low environmental impact, such as timber. This research combines the lack of knowledge about dynamic behaviour of footbridges with the need for using timber instead of other materials. It consists of two parts. The first part, the parameter study, investigates the influence of three preliminary design parameters on the dynamic behaviour of a long-span timber footbridge, namely the pylon height, the pylon shape and the amount of cables. The second part, the optimisation study, examines to what extent it is possible to design a long-span timber footbridge that does not need dampers to control excessive vibrations.
To this end, a parametric model of a bridge was made in which parameters can be varied and optimised to create realistic design variants. To be able to optimise taking into account dynamic behaviour, a python script was written to automatically determine the type of modes. The results of the parameter study show that the dynamic behaviour can be influenced by the parameters, although the results depend on the specific model, dimensions, parameter values and damping value. The results of the second part show that a with a 14% increase in mass a design variant that does not need dampers to control excessive vibrations can be obtained. ...
Striving to reduce the environmental impact of bridges, there lies a great potential in using materials with a low environmental impact, such as timber. This research combines the lack of knowledge about dynamic behaviour of footbridges with the need for using timber instead of other materials. It consists of two parts. The first part, the parameter study, investigates the influence of three preliminary design parameters on the dynamic behaviour of a long-span timber footbridge, namely the pylon height, the pylon shape and the amount of cables. The second part, the optimisation study, examines to what extent it is possible to design a long-span timber footbridge that does not need dampers to control excessive vibrations.
To this end, a parametric model of a bridge was made in which parameters can be varied and optimised to create realistic design variants. To be able to optimise taking into account dynamic behaviour, a python script was written to automatically determine the type of modes. The results of the parameter study show that the dynamic behaviour can be influenced by the parameters, although the results depend on the specific model, dimensions, parameter values and damping value. The results of the second part show that a with a 14% increase in mass a design variant that does not need dampers to control excessive vibrations can be obtained.
The first objective of this thesis is to derive the analytical expressions needed to be able to predict the dynamic response of many different cases of bridges so that as many real scenarios as possible can be treated. This means that these expressions would be used to investigate damaged beam bridges that can be modelled as an assembly of beams with any number of different material properties, any type of interface or boundary conditions and any number of cracks. For this reason an approach to analyze the bridge as an assembly of n piecewise homogeneous damaged Euler-Bernoulli beams jointed at their edges, will be presented, using the generalized functions to obtain a single expression of the solution which depends on the 4 integration constants associated with the boundary conditions. The closed-form expressions of these 4 constants will be provided. Furthermore, in the presence of internal or externals springs, translational or rotational, additional constants representing the discontinuities have to be taken into account and are computed by considering one additional condition for each discontinuity. The feasibility of this approach and the corresponding analytical formulations is shown with two numerical applications that include all the different capabilities mentioned. Moreover, the implementation of these expressions in a deterministic approach for damage localization is presented, mainly as another example of the many possibilities of the use of analytical formulations instead of other approaches and as an introduction of the so called Inverse Problem with deterministic and probabilistic methods.
The second objective concerns the optimization of damage identification on bridges by comparing different quantities that are evaluated while measuring the response of the bridge (direct monitoring) and the response of the moving vehicle when it passes along the bridge (indirect monitoring). First, the governing equations for the dynamic response of these models are derived, considering the crack(s) as a rotational spring, the bridge as an Euler-Bernoulli beam (or multiple with different properties) and the moving vehicle as a spring-mass system. In this manner, the dynamic response of the bridge is calculated (modal characteristics and displacement) as well as the one of the moving oscillator (displacement and acceleration) and the reaction force acting on the surface of the beam from the moving vehicles. Numerical applications with different beam properties and different number of cracks are performed, using MATLAB for the analytical expressions and SAP2000 for the finite element model, to derive the optimal quantity to be used for damage identification. Lastly, the results are validated by considering and comparing an alternative way of modelling crack, namely as a zone with reduced rigidity, for the same numerical examples, leading to the same conclusions about the crack(s) identification.
Last but not least, the third objective of this thesis is to be able deal not only with the widely used time-invariant damages, namely the always-open crack model, but also with time-variant damages and in this case with the switching crack model. To achieve this, the analytical expressions for the closed-form solutions of the mode shapes derived for the always-open crack are modified to be able to tackle the switching crack model by introducing a Boolean switching crack array which identifies open cracks, modelled as rotational springs. These new expressions would still be able to be used for any number of Euler-Bernoulli beams, any type of interface or boundary conditions and any number of switching cracks. Then, the governing equations for the dynamic response of this model are derived, considering the moving vehicles as moving masses in order to validate the approach with numerical examples existing in the literature and then by introducing its new capabilities. Further, as the computational strategy has been validated, a comparison between time-variant and time-invariant damages is performed concerning crack identification, so that the reader would recognize the importance of understanding the dynamic behavior of different ways of modelling damage in complicate engineering systems like bridges.
...
The first objective of this thesis is to derive the analytical expressions needed to be able to predict the dynamic response of many different cases of bridges so that as many real scenarios as possible can be treated. This means that these expressions would be used to investigate damaged beam bridges that can be modelled as an assembly of beams with any number of different material properties, any type of interface or boundary conditions and any number of cracks. For this reason an approach to analyze the bridge as an assembly of n piecewise homogeneous damaged Euler-Bernoulli beams jointed at their edges, will be presented, using the generalized functions to obtain a single expression of the solution which depends on the 4 integration constants associated with the boundary conditions. The closed-form expressions of these 4 constants will be provided. Furthermore, in the presence of internal or externals springs, translational or rotational, additional constants representing the discontinuities have to be taken into account and are computed by considering one additional condition for each discontinuity. The feasibility of this approach and the corresponding analytical formulations is shown with two numerical applications that include all the different capabilities mentioned. Moreover, the implementation of these expressions in a deterministic approach for damage localization is presented, mainly as another example of the many possibilities of the use of analytical formulations instead of other approaches and as an introduction of the so called Inverse Problem with deterministic and probabilistic methods.
The second objective concerns the optimization of damage identification on bridges by comparing different quantities that are evaluated while measuring the response of the bridge (direct monitoring) and the response of the moving vehicle when it passes along the bridge (indirect monitoring). First, the governing equations for the dynamic response of these models are derived, considering the crack(s) as a rotational spring, the bridge as an Euler-Bernoulli beam (or multiple with different properties) and the moving vehicle as a spring-mass system. In this manner, the dynamic response of the bridge is calculated (modal characteristics and displacement) as well as the one of the moving oscillator (displacement and acceleration) and the reaction force acting on the surface of the beam from the moving vehicles. Numerical applications with different beam properties and different number of cracks are performed, using MATLAB for the analytical expressions and SAP2000 for the finite element model, to derive the optimal quantity to be used for damage identification. Lastly, the results are validated by considering and comparing an alternative way of modelling crack, namely as a zone with reduced rigidity, for the same numerical examples, leading to the same conclusions about the crack(s) identification.
Last but not least, the third objective of this thesis is to be able deal not only with the widely used time-invariant damages, namely the always-open crack model, but also with time-variant damages and in this case with the switching crack model. To achieve this, the analytical expressions for the closed-form solutions of the mode shapes derived for the always-open crack are modified to be able to tackle the switching crack model by introducing a Boolean switching crack array which identifies open cracks, modelled as rotational springs. These new expressions would still be able to be used for any number of Euler-Bernoulli beams, any type of interface or boundary conditions and any number of switching cracks. Then, the governing equations for the dynamic response of this model are derived, considering the moving vehicles as moving masses in order to validate the approach with numerical examples existing in the literature and then by introducing its new capabilities. Further, as the computational strategy has been validated, a comparison between time-variant and time-invariant damages is performed concerning crack identification, so that the reader would recognize the importance of understanding the dynamic behavior of different ways of modelling damage in complicate engineering systems like bridges.
Bayesian system identification, including parameter estimation and model selection, is widely used to infer partially known, unobservable parameters of the models of physical systems when measurement data is available. A common assumption in the Bayesian system identification literature is that the discrepancy between model predictions and measurements can be described as independent, identically distributed realizations from a univariate Gaussian distribution. However, the decreasing cost of sensors and monitoring systems leads to more frequent structural measurements in close proximity to each other (e.g. fiber optics and strain gauges). In such cases, dependency in modeling uncertainty could be significant, both in space and time, and the assumption of uncorrelated Gaussian error may lead to inaccurate parameter estimation.
The aim of this thesis is to explore how Bayesian system identification can be feasibly performed using large datasets when spatial and/or temporal dependence might be present and to assess the impact of considering this dependence. A pool of models, each assuming a different correlation structure, is defined and Bayesian inference is performed. In particular, stress measurements obtained on a steel road bridge are used to update the parameters of the corresponding FE model and the parameters of the correlation structure. The results are compared to a reference model where only measurements of the response peaks are used under the assumption of independence. Nested sampling is utilized to compute the evidence under each model and Bayesian model selection is applied. The question of efficiently performing system identification for large datasets (N > 102 for temporal dependencies and N > 103 for combined spatial and temporal dependencies) is investigated, and a novel approach for efficiently calculating the exact log-likelihood is derived. An approximation based on the Fisher information matrix is used to efficiently calculate the information content of measurements.
It is found that the choice of correlation function can significantly affect the posterior distribution of the model prediction uncertainty. Additionally, it is shown that using large datasets and considering dependence makes it possible to perform system identification for a larger number of parameters compared to the reference model. The results of the case study indicate that using measurements from multiple sensors under combined spatial and temporal dependence and additive model prediction error yields reduced uncertainty in the posterior and up to 29% reduction of the posterior predictive credible interval range compared to the reference case. Furthermore, the efficiency of the proposed likelihood evaluation method is assessed. Using this method, exact calculation of the log-likelihood can be performed for >106 points in under a second in the case of correlation in one dimension. For combined spatial and temporal correlation it is shown to be approximately 900 times faster than naive evaluation for a 64 by 64 grid of observations. The results of the case study indicate that the described approach can be feasibly applied to real-world structures and can potentially improve parameter estimation and reduce prediction uncertainty. These findings suggest that further research into the approach could yield improvements over current methods.
...
Bayesian system identification, including parameter estimation and model selection, is widely used to infer partially known, unobservable parameters of the models of physical systems when measurement data is available. A common assumption in the Bayesian system identification literature is that the discrepancy between model predictions and measurements can be described as independent, identically distributed realizations from a univariate Gaussian distribution. However, the decreasing cost of sensors and monitoring systems leads to more frequent structural measurements in close proximity to each other (e.g. fiber optics and strain gauges). In such cases, dependency in modeling uncertainty could be significant, both in space and time, and the assumption of uncorrelated Gaussian error may lead to inaccurate parameter estimation.
The aim of this thesis is to explore how Bayesian system identification can be feasibly performed using large datasets when spatial and/or temporal dependence might be present and to assess the impact of considering this dependence. A pool of models, each assuming a different correlation structure, is defined and Bayesian inference is performed. In particular, stress measurements obtained on a steel road bridge are used to update the parameters of the corresponding FE model and the parameters of the correlation structure. The results are compared to a reference model where only measurements of the response peaks are used under the assumption of independence. Nested sampling is utilized to compute the evidence under each model and Bayesian model selection is applied. The question of efficiently performing system identification for large datasets (N > 102 for temporal dependencies and N > 103 for combined spatial and temporal dependencies) is investigated, and a novel approach for efficiently calculating the exact log-likelihood is derived. An approximation based on the Fisher information matrix is used to efficiently calculate the information content of measurements.
It is found that the choice of correlation function can significantly affect the posterior distribution of the model prediction uncertainty. Additionally, it is shown that using large datasets and considering dependence makes it possible to perform system identification for a larger number of parameters compared to the reference model. The results of the case study indicate that using measurements from multiple sensors under combined spatial and temporal dependence and additive model prediction error yields reduced uncertainty in the posterior and up to 29% reduction of the posterior predictive credible interval range compared to the reference case. Furthermore, the efficiency of the proposed likelihood evaluation method is assessed. Using this method, exact calculation of the log-likelihood can be performed for >106 points in under a second in the case of correlation in one dimension. For combined spatial and temporal correlation it is shown to be approximately 900 times faster than naive evaluation for a 64 by 64 grid of observations. The results of the case study indicate that the described approach can be feasibly applied to real-world structures and can potentially improve parameter estimation and reduce prediction uncertainty. These findings suggest that further research into the approach could yield improvements over current methods.
Damping identification techniques, such as the Half-power Bandwidth method and the Random Decrement technique are commonly used. However, these are not applicable to buildings with closely spaced modes, and require extensive measurements. Besides, they only provide a damping value, and cannot find damping of separate components of a system. A novel technique, the Energy Flux Analysis, approaches damping from an energy point of view, making it more widely applicable, and allowing for damping identification in components of a structure. The Energy Flux Analysis has been verified to lab structures, but its performance when applied to a high-rise structures using in situ measurements is still unknown.
The aim of this research is to investigate the sensitivities of and prerequisites for the application of the Energy Flux Analysis to high-rise buildings excited by wind using spatially limited measurements. The sensitivities were sought for in the uncertainty of required input for the Energy Flux Analysis: structure motion, which includes internal forces, wind load, data acquisition, and structural properties. The research was performed through application of the Energy Flux Analysis to the New Orleans tower in Rotterdam.
While the sensitivity to structural properties and the magnitude of measurements is limited, the Energy Flux Analysis demonstrated to be highly sensitive to the phase of structural motion, internal forces, and wind load. The first two points are relevant for computing the energy flux at the boundary of a system, when one is interested in damping in the superstructure and due to soil-structure interaction separately. The last point is relevant when one is interested in the total or superstructure damping.
The phase differences occurring between structure motion and internal forces are a direct result of damping. Material damping resulted in a phase difference between stress and strain in the numerical model, while a local damper resulted in a phase difference between structure motion at different locations. The many damping mechanisms occurring in a high-rise structure may each affect the phase of structure motion and internal forces differently. When these phase differences are not taken into account in the Energy Flux Analysis, for instance due to extrapolation of measurements, an erroneous result will be obtained. A brief investigation was performed as to whether these effects can be expected in true structures, but additional research is required.
The fluctuating wind load at the natural frequency of the structure is dominant for the flux of energy from wind to the structure, which is obtained by multiplication of the wind load with the structure velocity. Again, the phase of this wind load is highly important. When measured at one location, little is known about the phase of the wind load at other heights. Different approaches of extrapolating the measured wind load demonstrated a large scatter in the Energy Flux Analysis results. In this research, the Energy Flux Analysis found not to be repeatable, which was proven to be a direct result of the phase difference between the measured wind load and structure velocity. Possible causes for this varying phase difference were formulated.
It is essential, but due to the major advantages of the Energy Flux Analysis also profitable, to perform further research into its application to high-rise structures. Therefore, this study provides extensive recommendations mostly focused on simple numerical and lab experiments. ...
Damping identification techniques, such as the Half-power Bandwidth method and the Random Decrement technique are commonly used. However, these are not applicable to buildings with closely spaced modes, and require extensive measurements. Besides, they only provide a damping value, and cannot find damping of separate components of a system. A novel technique, the Energy Flux Analysis, approaches damping from an energy point of view, making it more widely applicable, and allowing for damping identification in components of a structure. The Energy Flux Analysis has been verified to lab structures, but its performance when applied to a high-rise structures using in situ measurements is still unknown.
The aim of this research is to investigate the sensitivities of and prerequisites for the application of the Energy Flux Analysis to high-rise buildings excited by wind using spatially limited measurements. The sensitivities were sought for in the uncertainty of required input for the Energy Flux Analysis: structure motion, which includes internal forces, wind load, data acquisition, and structural properties. The research was performed through application of the Energy Flux Analysis to the New Orleans tower in Rotterdam.
While the sensitivity to structural properties and the magnitude of measurements is limited, the Energy Flux Analysis demonstrated to be highly sensitive to the phase of structural motion, internal forces, and wind load. The first two points are relevant for computing the energy flux at the boundary of a system, when one is interested in damping in the superstructure and due to soil-structure interaction separately. The last point is relevant when one is interested in the total or superstructure damping.
The phase differences occurring between structure motion and internal forces are a direct result of damping. Material damping resulted in a phase difference between stress and strain in the numerical model, while a local damper resulted in a phase difference between structure motion at different locations. The many damping mechanisms occurring in a high-rise structure may each affect the phase of structure motion and internal forces differently. When these phase differences are not taken into account in the Energy Flux Analysis, for instance due to extrapolation of measurements, an erroneous result will be obtained. A brief investigation was performed as to whether these effects can be expected in true structures, but additional research is required.
The fluctuating wind load at the natural frequency of the structure is dominant for the flux of energy from wind to the structure, which is obtained by multiplication of the wind load with the structure velocity. Again, the phase of this wind load is highly important. When measured at one location, little is known about the phase of the wind load at other heights. Different approaches of extrapolating the measured wind load demonstrated a large scatter in the Energy Flux Analysis results. In this research, the Energy Flux Analysis found not to be repeatable, which was proven to be a direct result of the phase difference between the measured wind load and structure velocity. Possible causes for this varying phase difference were formulated.
It is essential, but due to the major advantages of the Energy Flux Analysis also profitable, to perform further research into its application to high-rise structures. Therefore, this study provides extensive recommendations mostly focused on simple numerical and lab experiments.
Towards Real-Time Structural Health Monitoring using Low-Cost Dual Frequency GNSS Receivers
From a Geodetic Perspective
Offshore Wind Farm Installation Planning
Decision-support tool for the analysis of new installation concepts
The goal of this study is to determine the potential of a neural network based model in predicting hydrodynamic behavior of semi-submersible crane vessels. Hindcast weather data, vessel motion measurements and model test data are used to train several different neural network architectures. The research into the potential of neural networks in predicting hydrodynamic behavior is split into two main categories: the frequency domain and the time domain.
Within the frequency domain, wave forecasts can be used to predict a response spectrum. The neural network in this case acts as a conventional RAO. In an artificial environment, four architectures are tested and the results show that neural networks are able to make accurate predictions in a fully linear environment. When tested on project data, where the vessel sails at operational draft, the neural network predictions shows a slightly higher accuracy than the diffraction based predictions for the specific test case. Another network is tested on transit data, where the vessel sails at an inconvenient draft. The results from these tests show that there is potential for a neural network to be used as a substitute for Response Amplitude Operators.
The time domain models focus on predicting ship response based on surface height signals and/or hindcast vessel motion measurements. The first model is trained and tested on model test data from an SSCV. The input of the neural network is surface height measurements and the output is pitch motion prediction. The model shows that it is capable of predicting both first and second order pitch motions. Another time domain model has MRU roll measurements as input and it tries to predict the future 60 seconds of roll motion. Many network topologies and optimizer settings are tested but none are capable of predicting future motions.
...
The goal of this study is to determine the potential of a neural network based model in predicting hydrodynamic behavior of semi-submersible crane vessels. Hindcast weather data, vessel motion measurements and model test data are used to train several different neural network architectures. The research into the potential of neural networks in predicting hydrodynamic behavior is split into two main categories: the frequency domain and the time domain.
Within the frequency domain, wave forecasts can be used to predict a response spectrum. The neural network in this case acts as a conventional RAO. In an artificial environment, four architectures are tested and the results show that neural networks are able to make accurate predictions in a fully linear environment. When tested on project data, where the vessel sails at operational draft, the neural network predictions shows a slightly higher accuracy than the diffraction based predictions for the specific test case. Another network is tested on transit data, where the vessel sails at an inconvenient draft. The results from these tests show that there is potential for a neural network to be used as a substitute for Response Amplitude Operators.
The time domain models focus on predicting ship response based on surface height signals and/or hindcast vessel motion measurements. The first model is trained and tested on model test data from an SSCV. The input of the neural network is surface height measurements and the output is pitch motion prediction. The model shows that it is capable of predicting both first and second order pitch motions. Another time domain model has MRU roll measurements as input and it tries to predict the future 60 seconds of roll motion. Many network topologies and optimizer settings are tested but none are capable of predicting future motions.