S.G. Pearson
Please Note
27 records found
1
The existing nearshore barriers often fail to intercept most of the sargassum due to poor coordination, unsuitable anchoring, poor design or excessive sargassum accumulation in “sacrificial zones.” If sargassum is allowed to stay still for more than 36 hours, it decomposes, releasing toxic gases, heavy metals and arsenic. The sacrificial zones are a problem area that all current onshore solutions share. To address this issue, this study features the design of a floating nearshore system that transforms these sacrificial zones into “opportunity zones”. It enables efficient interception and guidance, concentration, and extraction of sargassum before it reaches the shore. To attain the goal of the design, a multidisciplinary approach was applied; combining environmental and stakeholder analyses,the system design of a barrier with a collection point, and hydrodynamic simulations in Delft3D to optimize barrier orientation and performance. Different design concepts were developed and evaluated based on technical, operational, and environmental criteria. The resulting concept of the system features a modular floating barrier that guides sargassum towards a designated collection point, the opportunity zone, for extraction. This barrier is supported
by a buoyancy-stable floater, flexible mesh skirt, innovative connections and mooring system. The hydrodynamic analysis confirmed that the orientation of the barrier compared to the barrier significantly affects the flow efficiency of sargassum along the barrier. Through the hydrodynamic analysis, an optimal barrier angle was found to maximize redirection and minimize the length of the barrier. The collection point proposes a solution to collect clean sargassum, whilst minimizing the impact on the environment. This study shows that integrating civil engineering, design thinking, and local knowledge can yield a sustainable near-shore solution. It has to be noted that there are aspects of the design that need further consideration and detailing. This study forms a foundation for scalable sargassum
management. ...
The existing nearshore barriers often fail to intercept most of the sargassum due to poor coordination, unsuitable anchoring, poor design or excessive sargassum accumulation in “sacrificial zones.” If sargassum is allowed to stay still for more than 36 hours, it decomposes, releasing toxic gases, heavy metals and arsenic. The sacrificial zones are a problem area that all current onshore solutions share. To address this issue, this study features the design of a floating nearshore system that transforms these sacrificial zones into “opportunity zones”. It enables efficient interception and guidance, concentration, and extraction of sargassum before it reaches the shore. To attain the goal of the design, a multidisciplinary approach was applied; combining environmental and stakeholder analyses,the system design of a barrier with a collection point, and hydrodynamic simulations in Delft3D to optimize barrier orientation and performance. Different design concepts were developed and evaluated based on technical, operational, and environmental criteria. The resulting concept of the system features a modular floating barrier that guides sargassum towards a designated collection point, the opportunity zone, for extraction. This barrier is supported
by a buoyancy-stable floater, flexible mesh skirt, innovative connections and mooring system. The hydrodynamic analysis confirmed that the orientation of the barrier compared to the barrier significantly affects the flow efficiency of sargassum along the barrier. Through the hydrodynamic analysis, an optimal barrier angle was found to maximize redirection and minimize the length of the barrier. The collection point proposes a solution to collect clean sargassum, whilst minimizing the impact on the environment. This study shows that integrating civil engineering, design thinking, and local knowledge can yield a sustainable near-shore solution. It has to be noted that there are aspects of the design that need further consideration and detailing. This study forms a foundation for scalable sargassum
management.
Integrating Thermal and Coastal Dynamics in Modelling Permafrost Erosion
A Case Study at Barter Island
This study implements a novel method that integrates thermodynamics, hydrodynamics, and morphodynamics to predict the morphodynamic evolution of a permafrost-affected coastline. We developed and validated a process-based numerical model for Barter Island (North Slope, Alaska). This model showed skill in predicting the ground temperature distribution and the erosion of a permafrost bluff. Sensitivity analyses indicated that the environmental drivers affected by climate change (i.e., air and sea temperatures, water level) are expected to accelerate the erosion of permafrost-affected coastlines under the effects of climate change, confirming the findings of previous work. Rising temperatures will compound with diminishing sea ice to widen the annual window during which erosion can occur, which will increase the number of storm events that lead to erosion. Lower bluffs composed of finer sands are especially vulnerable.
The low computation costs mean that the model can be used to predict coastal erosion for larger regions, potentially benefiting strategic coastal management and policy-making.
Additionally, the developed model will improve global climate models. It can facilitate the mapping of permafrost degradation and organic carbon release, with the release of organic carbon through permafrost erosion being one of the greatest unknown drivers of global warming. Though further calibration is required, the developed model can be used as a tool to research the quantitative effects of climate change on the erosion of Arctic coastlines and gain a deeper understanding of how climate change affects the processes that ultimately lead to the erosion of permafrost bluffs. ...
This study implements a novel method that integrates thermodynamics, hydrodynamics, and morphodynamics to predict the morphodynamic evolution of a permafrost-affected coastline. We developed and validated a process-based numerical model for Barter Island (North Slope, Alaska). This model showed skill in predicting the ground temperature distribution and the erosion of a permafrost bluff. Sensitivity analyses indicated that the environmental drivers affected by climate change (i.e., air and sea temperatures, water level) are expected to accelerate the erosion of permafrost-affected coastlines under the effects of climate change, confirming the findings of previous work. Rising temperatures will compound with diminishing sea ice to widen the annual window during which erosion can occur, which will increase the number of storm events that lead to erosion. Lower bluffs composed of finer sands are especially vulnerable.
The low computation costs mean that the model can be used to predict coastal erosion for larger regions, potentially benefiting strategic coastal management and policy-making.
Additionally, the developed model will improve global climate models. It can facilitate the mapping of permafrost degradation and organic carbon release, with the release of organic carbon through permafrost erosion being one of the greatest unknown drivers of global warming. Though further calibration is required, the developed model can be used as a tool to research the quantitative effects of climate change on the erosion of Arctic coastlines and gain a deeper understanding of how climate change affects the processes that ultimately lead to the erosion of permafrost bluffs.
Probabilistic modelling of tidal inlets
Sediment fate estimation in the coastal system using Markov chains
a novel approach in that it builds further on the connectivity approach of SedTRAILS, which is still quite a new development in the field of sediment transport at present. For different versions of the model, correspondence with physical properties of the system were found, that the development to estimate sediment pathways accurately look promising. The method of describing sediment transport pathways of a coastal system as an ARHMM is a form of probabilistic Machine Learning allowing for faster computation times by describing the patterns the system can make. This is in contrast to a process-based model that has to compute all of the underlying processes. The autoregressive component in this approach is expected to be essential in describing any type of dynamical system that consists of trackable pathways. Taking into account the position of a particle at the current time step highly limits the position a particle can have at the next time step in favor of accurately estimating sediment pathways. The modelling approach discussed can find uses in engineering applications where particle pathways are of importance like the dispersal of nourishments, but also other dispersion events like dispersed goods from when a vessel loses a container, as long as there is a process-based model available to create the necessary Lagrangian data. ...
a novel approach in that it builds further on the connectivity approach of SedTRAILS, which is still quite a new development in the field of sediment transport at present. For different versions of the model, correspondence with physical properties of the system were found, that the development to estimate sediment pathways accurately look promising. The method of describing sediment transport pathways of a coastal system as an ARHMM is a form of probabilistic Machine Learning allowing for faster computation times by describing the patterns the system can make. This is in contrast to a process-based model that has to compute all of the underlying processes. The autoregressive component in this approach is expected to be essential in describing any type of dynamical system that consists of trackable pathways. Taking into account the position of a particle at the current time step highly limits the position a particle can have at the next time step in favor of accurately estimating sediment pathways. The modelling approach discussed can find uses in engineering applications where particle pathways are of importance like the dispersal of nourishments, but also other dispersion events like dispersed goods from when a vessel loses a container, as long as there is a process-based model available to create the necessary Lagrangian data.
Uncertainty in nearshore trench siltation
Including nearshore processes in trench siltation predictions, while enabling probabilistic modelling
Inclusion of nearshore processes is missing in existing quick-assessment siltation tools. Complex process-based models, like Delft3D or XBeach, are capable of predicting siltation volumes in the nearshore environment accurately. However, these models demand large computation capacities. This makes them unsuitable for probabilistic modelling, requiring large numbers of calculations. Probabilistic modelling however is a crucial step in identifying and quantifying uncertainties and related risks in the execution. This research presents a quick-assessment tool that includes nearshore processes. Ensuring low complexity makes quick-assessment tools suitable for probabilistic modelling of siltation predictions, reducing and quantifying uncertainties within nearshore trench siltation.
This research presents an approach to include wave transformation and wave-driven currents into an existing siltation prediction tool (SedPit). The resulting SedPit Nearshore tool allows fast predictions of siltation volumes in the nearshore zone. The performance of the SedPit Nearshore tool is assessed by comparing it to data from a field case, and comparing the accuracy to the accuracy of the existing SedPit tool. The SedPit Nearshore tool gives accurate predictions on the total siltation volume, and gives good insights in the spatial distribution of siltation volumes. The potential of the SedPit Nearshore becomes most evident when comparing it to the existing SedPit tool. A great improvement compared to the existing SedPit tool is seen. For the test case, the SedPit Nearshore tool reduces the absolute error in redicting the total siltation volumes by 82% compared to the existing SedPit tool. The SedPit
Nearshore tool predicts the total siltation volume with an error margin of 7%, while the existing SedPit has an error margin of 41%. The largest improvements compared to the existing Sedpit are seen in the most onshore regions, as this is the zone where most wave-driven currents are generated. The computational speed of the tool has proven its applicability for analyses on model sensitivity and uncertainty quantification. Computation times are reduced by factor 9,000 when comparing it to XBeach, a complex process-based model. Bottom roughness ks and wave roller steepness β were identified as most influential free variables in driving nearshore siltation volumes. Calibrating the model to obtain likely values for a range of free variables has helped to reduce the 95% confidence interval of peak siltation rates by 36%.
The inclusion of wave-driven currents into existing siltation prediction tools has shown a great improvement in the accuracy of siltation predictions in the nearshore zone. Although the SedPit Nearshore tool is calibrated on one specific field case, the method and the workflow of the tool show potential to help as general prediction tool of nearshore trench siltation. The power of the SedPit Nearshore tool lays in its simplicity, making it a fast, efficient, and accurate tool, suited for probabilistic modelling. ...
Inclusion of nearshore processes is missing in existing quick-assessment siltation tools. Complex process-based models, like Delft3D or XBeach, are capable of predicting siltation volumes in the nearshore environment accurately. However, these models demand large computation capacities. This makes them unsuitable for probabilistic modelling, requiring large numbers of calculations. Probabilistic modelling however is a crucial step in identifying and quantifying uncertainties and related risks in the execution. This research presents a quick-assessment tool that includes nearshore processes. Ensuring low complexity makes quick-assessment tools suitable for probabilistic modelling of siltation predictions, reducing and quantifying uncertainties within nearshore trench siltation.
This research presents an approach to include wave transformation and wave-driven currents into an existing siltation prediction tool (SedPit). The resulting SedPit Nearshore tool allows fast predictions of siltation volumes in the nearshore zone. The performance of the SedPit Nearshore tool is assessed by comparing it to data from a field case, and comparing the accuracy to the accuracy of the existing SedPit tool. The SedPit Nearshore tool gives accurate predictions on the total siltation volume, and gives good insights in the spatial distribution of siltation volumes. The potential of the SedPit Nearshore becomes most evident when comparing it to the existing SedPit tool. A great improvement compared to the existing SedPit tool is seen. For the test case, the SedPit Nearshore tool reduces the absolute error in redicting the total siltation volumes by 82% compared to the existing SedPit tool. The SedPit
Nearshore tool predicts the total siltation volume with an error margin of 7%, while the existing SedPit has an error margin of 41%. The largest improvements compared to the existing Sedpit are seen in the most onshore regions, as this is the zone where most wave-driven currents are generated. The computational speed of the tool has proven its applicability for analyses on model sensitivity and uncertainty quantification. Computation times are reduced by factor 9,000 when comparing it to XBeach, a complex process-based model. Bottom roughness ks and wave roller steepness β were identified as most influential free variables in driving nearshore siltation volumes. Calibrating the model to obtain likely values for a range of free variables has helped to reduce the 95% confidence interval of peak siltation rates by 36%.
The inclusion of wave-driven currents into existing siltation prediction tools has shown a great improvement in the accuracy of siltation predictions in the nearshore zone. Although the SedPit Nearshore tool is calibrated on one specific field case, the method and the workflow of the tool show potential to help as general prediction tool of nearshore trench siltation. The power of the SedPit Nearshore tool lays in its simplicity, making it a fast, efficient, and accurate tool, suited for probabilistic modelling.
This thesis introduces a new methodology for assessing transient characteristics of resonant and energetic low-frequency oscillations using the Hilbert-Huang transform. The study is based on a 5-month dataset from a cross-shore transect of a reef at Roi-Namur in the Marshall Islands, where the reef geomorphology corresponds to a natural frequency in the very low-frequency range (VLF, 0.001-0.005 Hz).
The findings indicate that resonance in the dataset typically had a short persistence, with a median and 90th duration of approximately 5 and 10 minutes respectively. Normalised with the period of the oscillations, which have a typical frequency of 0.0035 Hz, these durations are equal to approximately 1 and 2 wave oscillations. While these results are consistent with previous notions about the potentially short durations of resonance for this particular reef and dataset, they contradict suggestions that resonance is associated with a build-up over several wave periods. Comparison of resonance durations with instances of coastal flooding at the site shows that resonance occurred for about 1 hour within a 24-hour recording period during overwash and large runup events, but also at other times. The duration of energetic VLF oscillations, in general, was more closely linked to the severity of coastal flooding events. While resonance did not directly correspond to coastal flooding, it was observed that energetic VLF oscillations persisted for longer durations under (close to) resonant conditions.
These results suggest the critical role of energetic VLF waves in coastal hazards, while resonance may be of secondary importance. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of this study, which focused on a single dataset from a specific reef geometry and included short-duration recordings (34 minutes). Moreover, this study demonstrates the application of the Hilbert-Huang transform for analysing sea surface elevation signals recorded at a coral reef.
The insights gained from this research underscore the importance of considering both energetic VLF oscillations and resonance in coastal hazard assessment. Future investigations should explore factors influencing the persistence of such oscillations, like the characteristics of incoming wave forcing, to enhance coastal hazard prediction. Furthermore, the Hilbert-Huang transform offers a versatile framework for exploring more aspects regarding the time-varying and non-linear behaviour of waves on coral reefs.
The methodology framework proposed in this study facilitates the bulk analysis of extensive field data and longer sea surface elevation recordings, enabling further exploration of reef morphology and hydrodynamic controls on the persistence of energetic and resonant VLF oscillations. ...
This thesis introduces a new methodology for assessing transient characteristics of resonant and energetic low-frequency oscillations using the Hilbert-Huang transform. The study is based on a 5-month dataset from a cross-shore transect of a reef at Roi-Namur in the Marshall Islands, where the reef geomorphology corresponds to a natural frequency in the very low-frequency range (VLF, 0.001-0.005 Hz).
The findings indicate that resonance in the dataset typically had a short persistence, with a median and 90th duration of approximately 5 and 10 minutes respectively. Normalised with the period of the oscillations, which have a typical frequency of 0.0035 Hz, these durations are equal to approximately 1 and 2 wave oscillations. While these results are consistent with previous notions about the potentially short durations of resonance for this particular reef and dataset, they contradict suggestions that resonance is associated with a build-up over several wave periods. Comparison of resonance durations with instances of coastal flooding at the site shows that resonance occurred for about 1 hour within a 24-hour recording period during overwash and large runup events, but also at other times. The duration of energetic VLF oscillations, in general, was more closely linked to the severity of coastal flooding events. While resonance did not directly correspond to coastal flooding, it was observed that energetic VLF oscillations persisted for longer durations under (close to) resonant conditions.
These results suggest the critical role of energetic VLF waves in coastal hazards, while resonance may be of secondary importance. However, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of this study, which focused on a single dataset from a specific reef geometry and included short-duration recordings (34 minutes). Moreover, this study demonstrates the application of the Hilbert-Huang transform for analysing sea surface elevation signals recorded at a coral reef.
The insights gained from this research underscore the importance of considering both energetic VLF oscillations and resonance in coastal hazard assessment. Future investigations should explore factors influencing the persistence of such oscillations, like the characteristics of incoming wave forcing, to enhance coastal hazard prediction. Furthermore, the Hilbert-Huang transform offers a versatile framework for exploring more aspects regarding the time-varying and non-linear behaviour of waves on coral reefs.
The methodology framework proposed in this study facilitates the bulk analysis of extensive field data and longer sea surface elevation recordings, enabling further exploration of reef morphology and hydrodynamic controls on the persistence of energetic and resonant VLF oscillations.
Analysing dispersal of sand nourishments using SedTRAILS
Evaluating the application of the SedTRAILS model on the Ameland ebb-tidal delta nourishment
Several schematisations of wave- and tidal forcing were tested. The wave forcing selection had little effect on the overall model results. Storm conditions included in the more detailed schematisation were underrepresented in the model results. The implementation of wave-driven bed velocity had little influence on result as well due to small magnitudes that were calculated for this. A significant difference was found between using a morphological tide and an artificial spring-neap tidal cycle however, requiring further investigation.
Investigation of the burial formulation gave insight into the response of the model to changes in the different parameters. Direct dependence of erosion probability on deposition probability presents a major limitation in the current implementation of burial. Additionally, deposition probability in its current form is positively dependent on the maximum bed shear stress. Inclusion of burial does provide significant room for calibration of results.
Through modelling these various configurations of SedTRAILS, results consistently showed a recirculation of sediment from the nourishment on the ebb-tidal delta together with bypassing around the edge of the ebb-tidal delta, as seen in Figure 1. However, the degree to which bypassing occurs depends heavily on the chosen burial configuration. The bypassing is largely a result of flow around the periphery of the ebb-tidal delta and differs from known bar migration and shoal attachment pathways. Transport into the Wadden Sea basin was not found, likely due to the underestimation of influence of storm conditions.
To improve dispersal modelling with SedTRAILS, the impact of storm conditions needs to be more accurately included in the model. An under-representation of energetic wave conditions leads to a consistent underestimation of wave-related transport. Additionally, more investigation into the effects of the spring-neap tidal cycle is required. The significant difference presented here is an early indication that this is an important factor for SedTRAILS. Validation of dispersal modelled with SedTRAILS can be achieved through quantification of transport, assigning a volume of sediment per particle. ...
Several schematisations of wave- and tidal forcing were tested. The wave forcing selection had little effect on the overall model results. Storm conditions included in the more detailed schematisation were underrepresented in the model results. The implementation of wave-driven bed velocity had little influence on result as well due to small magnitudes that were calculated for this. A significant difference was found between using a morphological tide and an artificial spring-neap tidal cycle however, requiring further investigation.
Investigation of the burial formulation gave insight into the response of the model to changes in the different parameters. Direct dependence of erosion probability on deposition probability presents a major limitation in the current implementation of burial. Additionally, deposition probability in its current form is positively dependent on the maximum bed shear stress. Inclusion of burial does provide significant room for calibration of results.
Through modelling these various configurations of SedTRAILS, results consistently showed a recirculation of sediment from the nourishment on the ebb-tidal delta together with bypassing around the edge of the ebb-tidal delta, as seen in Figure 1. However, the degree to which bypassing occurs depends heavily on the chosen burial configuration. The bypassing is largely a result of flow around the periphery of the ebb-tidal delta and differs from known bar migration and shoal attachment pathways. Transport into the Wadden Sea basin was not found, likely due to the underestimation of influence of storm conditions.
To improve dispersal modelling with SedTRAILS, the impact of storm conditions needs to be more accurately included in the model. An under-representation of energetic wave conditions leads to a consistent underestimation of wave-related transport. Additionally, more investigation into the effects of the spring-neap tidal cycle is required. The significant difference presented here is an early indication that this is an important factor for SedTRAILS. Validation of dispersal modelled with SedTRAILS can be achieved through quantification of transport, assigning a volume of sediment per particle.
Assessment of flood risk mitigation and water quality improvement measures in coastal lagoon systems
Modelling of the hydraulic behaviour of the Ciénaga de la Virgen in Cartagena de Indias, Colombia
The Ciénaga de la Virgen in Cartagena, Colombia, is a prime example of a coastal lagoon that faces problems such as pollution, contamination, floods, and droughts, which are common in the area. The consortium ConAgua had proposed multiple measures to enhance the natural dynamics of the Ciénaga, commissioned by the Dutch governmental organisation Rijksdienst voor Ondernemend Nederland.
This report analysed the influence of those measures on the water safety and quality of the Ciénaga.
As part of this, the lagoon and its behaviour were simulated using the numerical hydrodynamic model Delft3D. The measures were implemented in this program, and by altering the boundary conditions, the effects of each measure under different circumstances were evaluated.
The implemented baseline model represents a dry month, normal tides and current bathymetry. Modifications were adapted to evaluate the effect of the limited data and observe the impact of extreme rainfall, sea level rise and wind forcing. Combinations of measures and their behaviour were also simulated.
For the water quality, the flushing time was considered by means of a tracer. Inserting a passive tracer, which either indicated polluted water (1) or clean water (0) into the model, made it possible to analyse the reduction and/or mixing of the pollution. For water safety, the rise in water level at any observation point within the Ciénaga was compared to the baseline model without measures, and the maximum water levels within the month were considered.
The simulations showed a significant impact of tides, wind, and sea level rise on the behaviour of the lagoon. Incorporating wind showed an improved refreshment rate due to the enhanced mixing and altered the plume formation into the Caribbean Sea. However, there are windless days on which the advantage of wind may not be taken into account.
Other simulations, such as the simulation of the combined measures, showed that combinations are not merely the sum of the individual measures and their effect, but the total hydraulic behaviour is altered.
Furthermore, the importance of a clean discharge from the urban and rural side into the Ciénaga was demonstrated. Due to the low refreshment rate, polluted water lingers inside the Ciénaga for a long time, affecting the ecology and the health of the surrounding residents.
In short, the rate of improvement of the water quality by the measures is limited, because the effects remain local. Therefore, achieving water of proper quality is a challenge. The measures did not negatively influence the water levels inside the Ciénaga. For flood risk, it is important to prioritise other effects since it remains a problem in the area.
The report shows that preserving healthy lagoons worldwide is important. To maintain proper water quality, the input of clean freshwater and sufficient mixing due to tidal (ensured by inlets) and/or wind forcing is important. Likewise, the effect of floods and droughts should be limited since many people live near the lagoon. However, water safety cannot be assessed solely by the water levels inside the lagoon. Models can help to assess challenging problems regarding water quality and safety in complex lagoon systems. In future steps, it is recommended that more data be gathered through measurements and observations to assess the quality of the lagoon with more certainty.
...
The Ciénaga de la Virgen in Cartagena, Colombia, is a prime example of a coastal lagoon that faces problems such as pollution, contamination, floods, and droughts, which are common in the area. The consortium ConAgua had proposed multiple measures to enhance the natural dynamics of the Ciénaga, commissioned by the Dutch governmental organisation Rijksdienst voor Ondernemend Nederland.
This report analysed the influence of those measures on the water safety and quality of the Ciénaga.
As part of this, the lagoon and its behaviour were simulated using the numerical hydrodynamic model Delft3D. The measures were implemented in this program, and by altering the boundary conditions, the effects of each measure under different circumstances were evaluated.
The implemented baseline model represents a dry month, normal tides and current bathymetry. Modifications were adapted to evaluate the effect of the limited data and observe the impact of extreme rainfall, sea level rise and wind forcing. Combinations of measures and their behaviour were also simulated.
For the water quality, the flushing time was considered by means of a tracer. Inserting a passive tracer, which either indicated polluted water (1) or clean water (0) into the model, made it possible to analyse the reduction and/or mixing of the pollution. For water safety, the rise in water level at any observation point within the Ciénaga was compared to the baseline model without measures, and the maximum water levels within the month were considered.
The simulations showed a significant impact of tides, wind, and sea level rise on the behaviour of the lagoon. Incorporating wind showed an improved refreshment rate due to the enhanced mixing and altered the plume formation into the Caribbean Sea. However, there are windless days on which the advantage of wind may not be taken into account.
Other simulations, such as the simulation of the combined measures, showed that combinations are not merely the sum of the individual measures and their effect, but the total hydraulic behaviour is altered.
Furthermore, the importance of a clean discharge from the urban and rural side into the Ciénaga was demonstrated. Due to the low refreshment rate, polluted water lingers inside the Ciénaga for a long time, affecting the ecology and the health of the surrounding residents.
In short, the rate of improvement of the water quality by the measures is limited, because the effects remain local. Therefore, achieving water of proper quality is a challenge. The measures did not negatively influence the water levels inside the Ciénaga. For flood risk, it is important to prioritise other effects since it remains a problem in the area.
The report shows that preserving healthy lagoons worldwide is important. To maintain proper water quality, the input of clean freshwater and sufficient mixing due to tidal (ensured by inlets) and/or wind forcing is important. Likewise, the effect of floods and droughts should be limited since many people live near the lagoon. However, water safety cannot be assessed solely by the water levels inside the lagoon. Models can help to assess challenging problems regarding water quality and safety in complex lagoon systems. In future steps, it is recommended that more data be gathered through measurements and observations to assess the quality of the lagoon with more certainty.
This research aims to develop mitigation measures to this estuarine salt intrusion following the Building with Nature-philosophy. Thus, the goal of this research is to develop nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion. This is achieved by (1) exploring the potential of estuary-scale interventions to affect salt intrusion; (2) conceptualising various nature-based solutions that mitigate salt intrusion; (3) evaluating nature-based solutions in a multidisciplinary context; and, to conclude, (4) reflecting on the role of nature-based solutions.
The exploration of potential estuary-scale modifications is a computationally expensive endeavour for which a novel simulation strategy is developed. This strategy is presented in Chapter 2 and proposes the use of machine learning techniques to determine the input space - i.e., which model simulations to execute, and which to exclude. The aim of the strategy is to put more focus on exploring the output space instead of exploring the input space.
Subsequently, the model simulations are analysed in Chapter 3. Thus, Chapters 2 and 3 present respectively the method and the results of an extensive sensitivity analysis of estuarine salt intrusion to estuary-scale modifications. The end-result of Chapter 3 includes a shortlist of potential nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion, including a ranking based on the sensitivity analysis.
The conceptualisation of nature-based solutions focuses mainly on two potential options: (1) a (temporary) sill, or submerged dam (Ch. 4); and (2) enhancement of intertidal area (Ch. 5). In addition to these novel nature-based solutions, Chapter 6 evaluates a third nature-based solution: shallowing of an estuary. From a physical perspective, this mitigation measure is well-known but mainly poses challenges in the socio-economic domain, which is why it is not extensively covered in the conceptualisation-phase of this dissertation but the evaluation-phase instead.
Both the sill and the intertidal area show a dependency on estuary class in how effectively the mitigation measures are. For the sill it holds that the weaker the tide, the more effective the sill mitigates landward salt transport - i.e., salt intrusion. When the tide is limited, salt intrusion is largely (if not fully) driven by gravitational circulation, for which the sill functions as a wall beyond which the formed salt wedge can hardly penetrate. However, with tidal energy increasing, the tidal momentum to push the saline water over the sill also increases resulting in more salt intrusion - the sill functions more like a speed-bump than a wall. All in all, a sill is most effective for estuaries with little tidal influence.
Enhancement of intertidal area increases the mixing in the estuary. When the dominant salt transport mechanism is related to the estuarine circulation, this enhanced mixing by increasing the intertidal area reduces the salt intrusion. However, the opposite holds for estuaries in which the salt transport is dominated by the tidal oscillation. This means that in case of salt wedge and partially mixed estuaries, enhancement of the intertidal area reduces salt intrusion; and in case of well-mixed estuaries, the intertidal area increase promotes salt intrusion. Thus, the additional (vertical) mixing caused by the intertidal areas reduces salt intrusion as long as there is something to mix - i.e., as long as there is a (sufficient) vertical salinity gradient.
The evaluation of nature-based solutions is inherently multidisciplinary. In this dissertation,
two different perspectives are considered: (1) socio-economy (Ch. 6), and (2) socio-ecology (Ch. 7). In both cases, the Rhine-Meuse Delta is considered as case study.
The socio-economic evaluation addresses the effect of water depth on two major stakeholders in an estuary: a port, and water boards. These stakeholders have opposing interests regarding the water depth: a port benefits from enhanced water depth to facilitate larger vessels, but the resulting contamination of freshwater reserves via salt intrusion is negatively affecting water intakes, and everyone that depends on them. Chapter 6 presents a multidisciplinary evaluation method based on Pareto-fronts, which are to inform decision- and policy-makers. The Pareto-front in Chapter 6 shows that the port performance remains relatively unaffected for shallowing until two metres with the current bed levels, while the freshwater availability improves. However, beyond this level of shallowing, port performance drops substantially against limited gains in freshwater availability.
The socio-ecological evaluation focuses on the effects of reopening a closed-off estuary on two opposing interests as well: freshwater availability, and estuarine ecosystem functioning. Reopening is beneficial for the ecological diversity in the former estuary, but comes at the costs of returning saline influences into a freshwater lake - i.e., freshwater availability is hampered. The ecological implications are mapped by translating hydrodynamic (model) data to an ecotopes-potential map due to which the ecological impact of interventions can be quantified. As in Chapter 6, Pareto-fronts are used as method to inform decision- and policy-makers. The Pareto-front in Chapter 7 shows an increased ecological diversity in the former-estuary without impeding the freshwater availability when partially opening the gates. However, once the salt intrusion reaches the most western water intakes, the freshwater availability drops without major gains in diversity.
This dissertation has shown the complexity of developing future-proof nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion. Building on the lessons learned, the reflection of this dissertation proposes a next step for nature-based solutions: DARE (diverse, adaptive, and robust engineering; Ch. 8). DARE is based on nature's own approach to dealing with uncertainties. The three axes of DARE show how to deal with uncertainties in the three dimensions of engineering: (1) a diverse set of solutions to deal with uncertainty in forcing conditions; (2) an adaptive approach with room to change course in response to the uncertainty that comes with time; and (3) robust - or even antifragile - solutions regarding the uncertainty in performance. With DARE, the focus shifts from the input to the output: Which part of the output is desirable, and what are the options to get there?
The nature-based solutions presented in this dissertation form a starting point for further explorations, with work in this dissertation already being used as a stepping stone for other studies. Besides further exploring the opportunities of nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion, next steps also include bringing these findings into practice. This includes reassessing past estuarine modifications from a new perspective, one that is less susceptible to the challenges that the future may have in store.
...
This research aims to develop mitigation measures to this estuarine salt intrusion following the Building with Nature-philosophy. Thus, the goal of this research is to develop nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion. This is achieved by (1) exploring the potential of estuary-scale interventions to affect salt intrusion; (2) conceptualising various nature-based solutions that mitigate salt intrusion; (3) evaluating nature-based solutions in a multidisciplinary context; and, to conclude, (4) reflecting on the role of nature-based solutions.
The exploration of potential estuary-scale modifications is a computationally expensive endeavour for which a novel simulation strategy is developed. This strategy is presented in Chapter 2 and proposes the use of machine learning techniques to determine the input space - i.e., which model simulations to execute, and which to exclude. The aim of the strategy is to put more focus on exploring the output space instead of exploring the input space.
Subsequently, the model simulations are analysed in Chapter 3. Thus, Chapters 2 and 3 present respectively the method and the results of an extensive sensitivity analysis of estuarine salt intrusion to estuary-scale modifications. The end-result of Chapter 3 includes a shortlist of potential nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion, including a ranking based on the sensitivity analysis.
The conceptualisation of nature-based solutions focuses mainly on two potential options: (1) a (temporary) sill, or submerged dam (Ch. 4); and (2) enhancement of intertidal area (Ch. 5). In addition to these novel nature-based solutions, Chapter 6 evaluates a third nature-based solution: shallowing of an estuary. From a physical perspective, this mitigation measure is well-known but mainly poses challenges in the socio-economic domain, which is why it is not extensively covered in the conceptualisation-phase of this dissertation but the evaluation-phase instead.
Both the sill and the intertidal area show a dependency on estuary class in how effectively the mitigation measures are. For the sill it holds that the weaker the tide, the more effective the sill mitigates landward salt transport - i.e., salt intrusion. When the tide is limited, salt intrusion is largely (if not fully) driven by gravitational circulation, for which the sill functions as a wall beyond which the formed salt wedge can hardly penetrate. However, with tidal energy increasing, the tidal momentum to push the saline water over the sill also increases resulting in more salt intrusion - the sill functions more like a speed-bump than a wall. All in all, a sill is most effective for estuaries with little tidal influence.
Enhancement of intertidal area increases the mixing in the estuary. When the dominant salt transport mechanism is related to the estuarine circulation, this enhanced mixing by increasing the intertidal area reduces the salt intrusion. However, the opposite holds for estuaries in which the salt transport is dominated by the tidal oscillation. This means that in case of salt wedge and partially mixed estuaries, enhancement of the intertidal area reduces salt intrusion; and in case of well-mixed estuaries, the intertidal area increase promotes salt intrusion. Thus, the additional (vertical) mixing caused by the intertidal areas reduces salt intrusion as long as there is something to mix - i.e., as long as there is a (sufficient) vertical salinity gradient.
The evaluation of nature-based solutions is inherently multidisciplinary. In this dissertation,
two different perspectives are considered: (1) socio-economy (Ch. 6), and (2) socio-ecology (Ch. 7). In both cases, the Rhine-Meuse Delta is considered as case study.
The socio-economic evaluation addresses the effect of water depth on two major stakeholders in an estuary: a port, and water boards. These stakeholders have opposing interests regarding the water depth: a port benefits from enhanced water depth to facilitate larger vessels, but the resulting contamination of freshwater reserves via salt intrusion is negatively affecting water intakes, and everyone that depends on them. Chapter 6 presents a multidisciplinary evaluation method based on Pareto-fronts, which are to inform decision- and policy-makers. The Pareto-front in Chapter 6 shows that the port performance remains relatively unaffected for shallowing until two metres with the current bed levels, while the freshwater availability improves. However, beyond this level of shallowing, port performance drops substantially against limited gains in freshwater availability.
The socio-ecological evaluation focuses on the effects of reopening a closed-off estuary on two opposing interests as well: freshwater availability, and estuarine ecosystem functioning. Reopening is beneficial for the ecological diversity in the former estuary, but comes at the costs of returning saline influences into a freshwater lake - i.e., freshwater availability is hampered. The ecological implications are mapped by translating hydrodynamic (model) data to an ecotopes-potential map due to which the ecological impact of interventions can be quantified. As in Chapter 6, Pareto-fronts are used as method to inform decision- and policy-makers. The Pareto-front in Chapter 7 shows an increased ecological diversity in the former-estuary without impeding the freshwater availability when partially opening the gates. However, once the salt intrusion reaches the most western water intakes, the freshwater availability drops without major gains in diversity.
This dissertation has shown the complexity of developing future-proof nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion. Building on the lessons learned, the reflection of this dissertation proposes a next step for nature-based solutions: DARE (diverse, adaptive, and robust engineering; Ch. 8). DARE is based on nature's own approach to dealing with uncertainties. The three axes of DARE show how to deal with uncertainties in the three dimensions of engineering: (1) a diverse set of solutions to deal with uncertainty in forcing conditions; (2) an adaptive approach with room to change course in response to the uncertainty that comes with time; and (3) robust - or even antifragile - solutions regarding the uncertainty in performance. With DARE, the focus shifts from the input to the output: Which part of the output is desirable, and what are the options to get there?
The nature-based solutions presented in this dissertation form a starting point for further explorations, with work in this dissertation already being used as a stepping stone for other studies. Besides further exploring the opportunities of nature-based solutions to mitigate salt intrusion, next steps also include bringing these findings into practice. This includes reassessing past estuarine modifications from a new perspective, one that is less susceptible to the challenges that the future may have in store.
Impact of the Eastern Scheldt Storm Surge Barrier on the Morphodynamics of the Ebb-Tidal Delta
In relation to coastal management
The study is focused on examining the response of a coastal system to structural presence, based on currents, waves and sediment and propagule pathways, to optimise restoration strategies. The coastline of Demak in Indonesia is chosen as the system to be modelled due to the persistent erosion problem in the region and the ongoing use of permeable and impermeable structures to mitigate the problem. A nested model was set-up in Delft3D-4 to estimate the flow hydrodynamics resulting from river discharge, tide and wind forcing in the area. Wave propagation in the region was also modelled using Delft3D-4 with a standalone nested wave model. Output from the hydrodynamic models served as input for the Lagrangian particle tracking model, SedTRAILS, to compute the sediment and propagule pathways.
The hydrodynamic models demonstrate a decrease in both current magnitude and wave activity behind the structures, with a greater reduction observed in the case of impermeable structures. However, the radius of influence is constrained to less than a kilometre from the structures. The sediment pathways reveal reduced sediment movement behind the structures. However, the sediment imported due to the structures are sourced from within the intertidal basin which could trigger coastline retreat in the region. Additional tests uncover impermeable structures with larger length to opening size ratio, placed closer to the mangrove fringe to be able to retain sediment with comparatively higher efficiency. In case of propagules, the trapping behaviour of the structures is less apparent, with dependencies on the relative location of the structure to the sources and the direction of wind. In Demak, when structures are located relatively offshore to the propagule sources, they are able to trap the propagules, thereby creating a possibility for mangrove restoration. The study concludes that coastal structures enhance sediment and propagule retention, with varying efficacy depending on the type, location and length of the structure, suggesting their potential utility as a valuable tool for mangrove restoration. ...
The study is focused on examining the response of a coastal system to structural presence, based on currents, waves and sediment and propagule pathways, to optimise restoration strategies. The coastline of Demak in Indonesia is chosen as the system to be modelled due to the persistent erosion problem in the region and the ongoing use of permeable and impermeable structures to mitigate the problem. A nested model was set-up in Delft3D-4 to estimate the flow hydrodynamics resulting from river discharge, tide and wind forcing in the area. Wave propagation in the region was also modelled using Delft3D-4 with a standalone nested wave model. Output from the hydrodynamic models served as input for the Lagrangian particle tracking model, SedTRAILS, to compute the sediment and propagule pathways.
The hydrodynamic models demonstrate a decrease in both current magnitude and wave activity behind the structures, with a greater reduction observed in the case of impermeable structures. However, the radius of influence is constrained to less than a kilometre from the structures. The sediment pathways reveal reduced sediment movement behind the structures. However, the sediment imported due to the structures are sourced from within the intertidal basin which could trigger coastline retreat in the region. Additional tests uncover impermeable structures with larger length to opening size ratio, placed closer to the mangrove fringe to be able to retain sediment with comparatively higher efficiency. In case of propagules, the trapping behaviour of the structures is less apparent, with dependencies on the relative location of the structure to the sources and the direction of wind. In Demak, when structures are located relatively offshore to the propagule sources, they are able to trap the propagules, thereby creating a possibility for mangrove restoration. The study concludes that coastal structures enhance sediment and propagule retention, with varying efficacy depending on the type, location and length of the structure, suggesting their potential utility as a valuable tool for mangrove restoration.
Sediment bypassing at Ameland inlet
And the role of an ebb-tidal delta nourishment
For this purpose, a Delft3D FM model of the area is set up and calibrated. This model is used to analyze sediment transport in the inlet under various forcing conditions. Transport pathways are visualized using SedTRAILS.
The model shows that flows and sediment transport in Burrard Inlet are tide-dominated and governed by the topography. Flows are strongly accelerated in constricted areas (First Narrows and Second Narrows), which leads to large velocity differences. Following the velocity field, sediment transport patterns are correspondingly dominated by these topographical restrictions. In the wider basins, flows slow down and form eddies. The model results suggest that these eddies act as sediment sinks. Additionally, sediment is lost into Indian Arm, a deep fjord with low flow velocities at the eastern end of Burrard Inlet. The possible pathways for sediment originating from the eroding shorelines at the TWN reserve are visualized. As soon as sediment from these banks is mobilized, it tends to move away from the shore with a final destination either in one of the eddies or in Indian Arm. The impact of wind and waves on the sediment transport patterns is limited.
Since first European contact in 1792, the shoreline of Burrard Inlet has changed significantly due to dredging activities, land developments, and industrial development as the city of Vancouver was built. Reconstructed historic shorelines are implemented in the model to assess the consequences of these shoreline changes on the sediment transport. Model results show that the tidal prism and the velocities in the Narrows have decreased since 1792, while the tidal range has increased. Moreover, sediment mobilized along the eroding shorelines showed greater potential for deposition along these same shores in 1792, compared to the present-day situation.
...
For this purpose, a Delft3D FM model of the area is set up and calibrated. This model is used to analyze sediment transport in the inlet under various forcing conditions. Transport pathways are visualized using SedTRAILS.
The model shows that flows and sediment transport in Burrard Inlet are tide-dominated and governed by the topography. Flows are strongly accelerated in constricted areas (First Narrows and Second Narrows), which leads to large velocity differences. Following the velocity field, sediment transport patterns are correspondingly dominated by these topographical restrictions. In the wider basins, flows slow down and form eddies. The model results suggest that these eddies act as sediment sinks. Additionally, sediment is lost into Indian Arm, a deep fjord with low flow velocities at the eastern end of Burrard Inlet. The possible pathways for sediment originating from the eroding shorelines at the TWN reserve are visualized. As soon as sediment from these banks is mobilized, it tends to move away from the shore with a final destination either in one of the eddies or in Indian Arm. The impact of wind and waves on the sediment transport patterns is limited.
Since first European contact in 1792, the shoreline of Burrard Inlet has changed significantly due to dredging activities, land developments, and industrial development as the city of Vancouver was built. Reconstructed historic shorelines are implemented in the model to assess the consequences of these shoreline changes on the sediment transport. Model results show that the tidal prism and the velocities in the Narrows have decreased since 1792, while the tidal range has increased. Moreover, sediment mobilized along the eroding shorelines showed greater potential for deposition along these same shores in 1792, compared to the present-day situation.
Coastal Aeolian Sediment Transport in an Active Bed Surface Layer
Tracer Study and Conceptual Model
Nature based alternatives regarding coastal and environmental climate change hazards
A case study of the Tsleil-Waututh Nation foreshore
San Francisco Bay is one of the largest estuaries of the US Pacific Coast with an area of 4000 km2. It consists of two hydrologically distinctive sub-embayments North Bay and South Bay. South Bay is unique as it does not experience the freshwater flushing typical for estuaries. It experiences the largest freshwater input during a regime of reverse estuarine circulation during Winter, when the entire Bay becomes fresher following peak discharges from the northern rivers. Hence both saline and freshwater enter from Central Bay through the same entrance. South Bay is dealing with increased risk of inundation due to the combination of sea level rise and land subsidence and a deteriorating water quality. Understanding sediment pathways within South Bay and sediment exchange at its entrance can support the development of management strategies dealing with turbidity depended algae blooms and the development of salt marshes as a measure against sea level rise. Additionally, by understanding the current factors controlling fine sediment dynamics, future implications of climate change can be better predicted. Though San Francisco Bay is the topic of much research, a process-based model with a model domain covering the entire Bay is a novel approach to analyse fine sediment dynamics in South Bay. Methods
A Delft3D-DELWAQ buffer layer model was calibrated against a newly available combination of local high-frequency suspended sediment concentration (SSC) measurements and two-monthly, depth varying SSC measurements across the entire 145 km length of the Bay. Subsequently the method of Sediment Connectivity was applied to analyse sediment pathways and net sediment fluxes in South Bay. Sediment Connectivity is an approach that uses network analysis to quantify sediment fluxes based on a schematization of San Francisco Bay into 17 segments. Large data sets of spatial and temporal output were reduced to a 17x17 adjacency matrix permitting a more straightforward analysis and the application of different statistical metrics unavailable in more traditional approaches. Results and implications Calibration enabled the model to better capture seasonal and episodic variations in SSCs across the Bay. Connectivity analysis uniquely revealed key dominant pathways, which agree well with literature. Additionally, it unveiled intra-basin transport pathways, regions of erosion and sedimentation and an indication of the varying controlling forcings during the year. Finally, this study acts as a proof of concept for the Sediment Connectivity method that could be applied in other estuaries. ...
San Francisco Bay is one of the largest estuaries of the US Pacific Coast with an area of 4000 km2. It consists of two hydrologically distinctive sub-embayments North Bay and South Bay. South Bay is unique as it does not experience the freshwater flushing typical for estuaries. It experiences the largest freshwater input during a regime of reverse estuarine circulation during Winter, when the entire Bay becomes fresher following peak discharges from the northern rivers. Hence both saline and freshwater enter from Central Bay through the same entrance. South Bay is dealing with increased risk of inundation due to the combination of sea level rise and land subsidence and a deteriorating water quality. Understanding sediment pathways within South Bay and sediment exchange at its entrance can support the development of management strategies dealing with turbidity depended algae blooms and the development of salt marshes as a measure against sea level rise. Additionally, by understanding the current factors controlling fine sediment dynamics, future implications of climate change can be better predicted. Though San Francisco Bay is the topic of much research, a process-based model with a model domain covering the entire Bay is a novel approach to analyse fine sediment dynamics in South Bay. Methods
A Delft3D-DELWAQ buffer layer model was calibrated against a newly available combination of local high-frequency suspended sediment concentration (SSC) measurements and two-monthly, depth varying SSC measurements across the entire 145 km length of the Bay. Subsequently the method of Sediment Connectivity was applied to analyse sediment pathways and net sediment fluxes in South Bay. Sediment Connectivity is an approach that uses network analysis to quantify sediment fluxes based on a schematization of San Francisco Bay into 17 segments. Large data sets of spatial and temporal output were reduced to a 17x17 adjacency matrix permitting a more straightforward analysis and the application of different statistical metrics unavailable in more traditional approaches. Results and implications Calibration enabled the model to better capture seasonal and episodic variations in SSCs across the Bay. Connectivity analysis uniquely revealed key dominant pathways, which agree well with literature. Additionally, it unveiled intra-basin transport pathways, regions of erosion and sedimentation and an indication of the varying controlling forcings during the year. Finally, this study acts as a proof of concept for the Sediment Connectivity method that could be applied in other estuaries.
Stability of intertidal and subtidal areas after Delta21 plan
Evaluating the consequences for the morphological development produced by the interventaion
Coral Restoration for Coastal Hazard Risk Reduction
The effect of coral restoration on wave transformation over various reef morphologies and the resulting runup
Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment due to Hurricane Activity
Case Study of St. Martin, the Caribbean