M.F.M. Hoogreef
Please Note
36 records found
1
Morphing Trailing Edge Wings for Transport Aircraft
A conceptual assessment
This thesis assesses the effect of implementing chordwise two-degree-of-freedom (2-DoF) compliant camber-twist morphing trailing-edge wings on the sizing, configuration, and performance of CS-25 transport aircraft. Block fuel consumption is used as the primary performance metric, as it captures the trade-off between improved aerodynamic efficiency and the sizing penalties introduced by morphing systems.
Three methodological contributions support this assessment. First, a parameterization method was developed to describe the morphed shape of an arbitrary base airfoil using the rear spar location and two pseudo-deflection angles. Control points on the camberline are rotated and fitted with a fourth-order polynomial, after which the airfoil surfaces are reconstructed while preserving suction-side arc length to reflect compliant structure constraints. Applied at multiple spanwise stations, this method represents camber-twist morphing at wing level.
Second, the Aircraft Trimmed Performance Analysis Tool (ATPAT) was developed to evaluate trimmed cruise aerodynamic efficiency of morphing-wing aircraft. ATPAT combines a vortex lattice method with strip theory and sweep theory to resolve induced, viscous, pressure, and wave drag with runtimes of seconds to one minute per evaluation. The tool was validated against experimental and computational data on the Fokker 100 and integrated into the Initiator aircraft design toolbox with Bayesian and gradient-based optimizers.
Third, two uncertain sizing inputs were explicitly addressed: morphing system mass and achievable high-lift increment. Morphing system mass was treated as a parameter bounded by the specific mass of Fowler flaps, while RANS CFD estimated a conservative sectional lift increase of 0.63 at full deflection.
The methodology was applied to the ATR 72-600 and Fokker 100. For both aircraft, morphing designs were heavier and required larger wing areas than conventional designs due to high-lift limitations, making field performance the main constraint. Relaxing landing field length by about 20% brought sizing outcomes closer to the reference aircraft.
For the ATR 72-600, aerodynamic gains did not offset the penalties. The morphing design matched conventional block fuel only on the harmonic mission and used 6% and 4% more fuel on shorter and maximum-fuel missions. For the Fokker 100, a block-fuel reduction of up to 3.6% was achieved on the harmonic mission after a 17.5% relaxation of landing field length, with sizing nearly identical to the reference aircraft. Its transonic cruise also offers additional drag reduction potential through wave drag reduction.
The results remain subject to uncertainty. The relative contributions of sizing effects and wave drag reduction were not isolated, morphing system mass remains uncertain, and high-lift performance estimates are based on limited airfoil data. More detailed experimental validation and segmented mission analysis are recommended to refine the estimated benefits of morphing wings.
...
This thesis assesses the effect of implementing chordwise two-degree-of-freedom (2-DoF) compliant camber-twist morphing trailing-edge wings on the sizing, configuration, and performance of CS-25 transport aircraft. Block fuel consumption is used as the primary performance metric, as it captures the trade-off between improved aerodynamic efficiency and the sizing penalties introduced by morphing systems.
Three methodological contributions support this assessment. First, a parameterization method was developed to describe the morphed shape of an arbitrary base airfoil using the rear spar location and two pseudo-deflection angles. Control points on the camberline are rotated and fitted with a fourth-order polynomial, after which the airfoil surfaces are reconstructed while preserving suction-side arc length to reflect compliant structure constraints. Applied at multiple spanwise stations, this method represents camber-twist morphing at wing level.
Second, the Aircraft Trimmed Performance Analysis Tool (ATPAT) was developed to evaluate trimmed cruise aerodynamic efficiency of morphing-wing aircraft. ATPAT combines a vortex lattice method with strip theory and sweep theory to resolve induced, viscous, pressure, and wave drag with runtimes of seconds to one minute per evaluation. The tool was validated against experimental and computational data on the Fokker 100 and integrated into the Initiator aircraft design toolbox with Bayesian and gradient-based optimizers.
Third, two uncertain sizing inputs were explicitly addressed: morphing system mass and achievable high-lift increment. Morphing system mass was treated as a parameter bounded by the specific mass of Fowler flaps, while RANS CFD estimated a conservative sectional lift increase of 0.63 at full deflection.
The methodology was applied to the ATR 72-600 and Fokker 100. For both aircraft, morphing designs were heavier and required larger wing areas than conventional designs due to high-lift limitations, making field performance the main constraint. Relaxing landing field length by about 20% brought sizing outcomes closer to the reference aircraft.
For the ATR 72-600, aerodynamic gains did not offset the penalties. The morphing design matched conventional block fuel only on the harmonic mission and used 6% and 4% more fuel on shorter and maximum-fuel missions. For the Fokker 100, a block-fuel reduction of up to 3.6% was achieved on the harmonic mission after a 17.5% relaxation of landing field length, with sizing nearly identical to the reference aircraft. Its transonic cruise also offers additional drag reduction potential through wave drag reduction.
The results remain subject to uncertainty. The relative contributions of sizing effects and wave drag reduction were not isolated, morphing system mass remains uncertain, and high-lift performance estimates are based on limited airfoil data. More detailed experimental validation and segmented mission analysis are recommended to refine the estimated benefits of morphing wings.
Combining an Asynchronous Multi-Point and a Multi-Fidelity Infill Strategy for Surrogate-Based Optimisation
An Empirical Evaluation on Unconstrained Problems
This thesis introduces and evaluates an asynchronous MP MF infill strategy, benchmarked against eleven unconstrained MF numerical problems, using expected runtime (ERT).
The asynchronous MP single-fidelity strategy (16 ranks) reduced the geometric mean ERT by 72.7% compared with the baseline Efficient Global Optimisation with Expected Improvement. The single-point MF strategy, on the other hand, increased the ERT by 21.2%, degrading performance. The combined asynchronous MP MF strategy achieved a 68.2% reduction relative to the baseline.
These results show that the asynchronous MP strategy substantially improves performance. In contrast, the selected MF strategy proves detrimental, indicating that a revised MF strategy is required to yield further gains. ...
This thesis introduces and evaluates an asynchronous MP MF infill strategy, benchmarked against eleven unconstrained MF numerical problems, using expected runtime (ERT).
The asynchronous MP single-fidelity strategy (16 ranks) reduced the geometric mean ERT by 72.7% compared with the baseline Efficient Global Optimisation with Expected Improvement. The single-point MF strategy, on the other hand, increased the ERT by 21.2%, degrading performance. The combined asynchronous MP MF strategy achieved a 68.2% reduction relative to the baseline.
These results show that the asynchronous MP strategy substantially improves performance. In contrast, the selected MF strategy proves detrimental, indicating that a revised MF strategy is required to yield further gains.
Liquid Hydrogen Tank Layouts in Blended Wing Body Aircraft
Conceptual Design and Comparative Evaluation
Prior research has investigated hydrogen-fueled BWB aircraft, highlighting different potential tank integration strategies. To the author's knowledge, no direct comparison of these hydrogen configurations highlights their relative performance impact compared to a consistent kerosene baseline aircraft. Therefore, this work compares different hydrogen tank configurations identified in prior research to a kerosene BWB baseline under consistent top-level aircraft requirements (TLARs), including a design range of 2500 nmi and 239 passengers. Technology assumptions for a 2050 entry into service (EIS) are applied. The analysis is complemented through the development of hydrogen and kerosene TAW configurations that fulfill the same TLARs.
The comparison is performed in three steps. First, a BWB is designed for each tank configuration using conceptual design methods. Second, the four tank layouts are compared and the layout is identified that imposes the lowest energy penalty on the BWB. Third, the integration penalty of the hydrogen BWB is compared to that of the hydrogen TAW.
A BWB employing a combined tank configuration, with hydrogen tanks located beside and aft of the passenger cabin, is found to experience the lowest integration penalty. The BWB experiences a 12.5% penalty in block energy for the design mission, compared to a penalty of 10.5% experienced by the TAW. This indicates that the BWB is less well suited to hydrogen integration than the TAW under the specified TLARs. In addition, sensitivity studies are conducted to evaluate the impact of integration assumptions on the BWB. These show that reasonable variations in the assumptions do not change the conclusion of this study. The findings do not eliminate hydrogen-fueled BWB aircraft as a viable alternative to hydrogen-fueled TAW designs. In fact, literature shows that BWB configurations still offer an inherent efficiency advantage, although their higher integration penalty must be considered in the overall trade-off. ...
Prior research has investigated hydrogen-fueled BWB aircraft, highlighting different potential tank integration strategies. To the author's knowledge, no direct comparison of these hydrogen configurations highlights their relative performance impact compared to a consistent kerosene baseline aircraft. Therefore, this work compares different hydrogen tank configurations identified in prior research to a kerosene BWB baseline under consistent top-level aircraft requirements (TLARs), including a design range of 2500 nmi and 239 passengers. Technology assumptions for a 2050 entry into service (EIS) are applied. The analysis is complemented through the development of hydrogen and kerosene TAW configurations that fulfill the same TLARs.
The comparison is performed in three steps. First, a BWB is designed for each tank configuration using conceptual design methods. Second, the four tank layouts are compared and the layout is identified that imposes the lowest energy penalty on the BWB. Third, the integration penalty of the hydrogen BWB is compared to that of the hydrogen TAW.
A BWB employing a combined tank configuration, with hydrogen tanks located beside and aft of the passenger cabin, is found to experience the lowest integration penalty. The BWB experiences a 12.5% penalty in block energy for the design mission, compared to a penalty of 10.5% experienced by the TAW. This indicates that the BWB is less well suited to hydrogen integration than the TAW under the specified TLARs. In addition, sensitivity studies are conducted to evaluate the impact of integration assumptions on the BWB. These show that reasonable variations in the assumptions do not change the conclusion of this study. The findings do not eliminate hydrogen-fueled BWB aircraft as a viable alternative to hydrogen-fueled TAW designs. In fact, literature shows that BWB configurations still offer an inherent efficiency advantage, although their higher integration penalty must be considered in the overall trade-off.
A Family Design Framework for Hybrid-Electric Aircraft
Balancing Economic Viability and Climate Impact
This research implements the Delft Laminar Hump on the vertical stabilizer of subsonic transport aircraft by modeling the effect of the hump as a shift in transition location. By using a Quasi-3D aerodynamic analysis in combination with a transition location database, the effect of the hump on the lift and drag coefficient of the vertical stabilizer is analyzed. The transition location database is constructed by using the external velocity of airfoil sections of the vertical tailplane and the boundary layer solver and stability analysis developed by the Group of Flow Control and Stability within the Delft University of Technology. With this, the N-factor curves along the chord can be calculated. Knowing the respective N-factors of the clean and hump configuration, the associated transition locations can be determined, which are then used to calculate the lift and drag coefficients of the vertical tailplane. To evaluate the aerodynamic effect of the hump on the full aircraft directional and lateral stability a stability analysis based on a method by Fokker / Obert is performed and checked against the CS-25 for Large Aeroplanes regulations by European Aviation Safety Authority (EASA).
It was found that the Delft Laminar Hump (DeLaH) on the vertical stabilizer of a subsonic transport aircraft does not affect the vertical tailplane lift curve slope, thus not affecting the stability of the aircraft. In contrast, the vertical tailplane drag coefficient is reduced by the hump. Retrofitting the hump on Airbus A320 (conventional tail) and the Fokker F-28 Mk1000 (T-tail) results in a reduction of the vertical tailplane drag coefficient of 6.73% and 8.72%, respectively. Translating this vertical tail drag reduction to the full aircraft drag coefficient results in a reduction of 0.17% and 0.34%. To evaluate the effect of the hump on weight and fuel consumption, additional weight and mission analyses are performed. Evaluating the harmonic range, an fuel reduction due to the hump of 0.16% and 0.32% is established, for the Airbus A320 and Fokker F-28 Mk1000, respectively. The aircraft weight is reduced by the same percentage through the fuel reduction, as it is assumed that the added weight due to the hump itself is negligible.
Additionally, two sensitivity analyses were performed, namely, sweep angle variation and surface area scaling to analyze the effectiveness of the hump for different vertical tailplane geometries. The effect of sweep angle on hump effectiveness does not affect the vertical tailplane lift curve slope and thus also not the stability coefficients. For the full aircraft drag coefficient, the hump effectiveness has an exponential relation with sweep angle and is most effective at lower sweep angles. A maximum full aircraft drag reduction was found of 0.41% at 30 deg sweep with an equivalent fuel reduction of 0.39%. Overall it is concluded that lower sweep angles are beneficial as the hump is most effective and results in reduced vertical tailplane weight, less fuel weight as well as an increased stability margin. Analyzing the effect of surface area scaling, the hump has no effect on the vertical tailplane lift curve slope regardless of surface area, again retaining the aircraft’s stability. For the full aircraft drag coefficient, the hump effectiveness increases linearly for increasing surface area up to 0.37% at a surface scaling factor of 1.2 times the original vertical tailplane surface area. In terms of fuel reduction, a maximum value of 0.35% was found. There will be an optimal vertical tailplane surface area, since the hump effectiveness increases for increasing surface area, whilst for the full aircraft drag, vertical tailplane weight, and fuel weight a smaller surface area is preferred. The stability margin becomes the limiting factor as a minimum surface area is required for sufficient stability. Comparing the baseline aircraft, the hump is more effective for the Fokker F-28 Mk1000 over the entire range of scaling factors and sweep angles. This leads to the suspicion that taper- and aspect ratio, and cruise speed play an important role in the effectiveness of the hump, but more research is required.
This research shows that the Delft Laminar Hump has a significant drag-reducing effect on the overall aircraft, whilst not affecting the aircraft’s stability. Even though the fuel savings for an individual aircraft are not very large, on a fleet level this would be significant. The hump can be retrofitted on existing aircraft by gluing it on the outer skin, making it a relatively simple and cheap way to improve efficiency for aircraft manufacturers. Nevertheless, more research is required before implementing the hump on commercial aircraft as it is still unknown whether the hump also works on the suction side of the wing as well as whether the hump causes a shock at cruise Mach. Also, interaction effects with the horizontal stabilizer and fuselage need to be taken into account, to fully quantify the effectiveness of the hump. Dedicated wind tunnel experiments, flight tests, and/or CFD simulations are necessary. ...
This research implements the Delft Laminar Hump on the vertical stabilizer of subsonic transport aircraft by modeling the effect of the hump as a shift in transition location. By using a Quasi-3D aerodynamic analysis in combination with a transition location database, the effect of the hump on the lift and drag coefficient of the vertical stabilizer is analyzed. The transition location database is constructed by using the external velocity of airfoil sections of the vertical tailplane and the boundary layer solver and stability analysis developed by the Group of Flow Control and Stability within the Delft University of Technology. With this, the N-factor curves along the chord can be calculated. Knowing the respective N-factors of the clean and hump configuration, the associated transition locations can be determined, which are then used to calculate the lift and drag coefficients of the vertical tailplane. To evaluate the aerodynamic effect of the hump on the full aircraft directional and lateral stability a stability analysis based on a method by Fokker / Obert is performed and checked against the CS-25 for Large Aeroplanes regulations by European Aviation Safety Authority (EASA).
It was found that the Delft Laminar Hump (DeLaH) on the vertical stabilizer of a subsonic transport aircraft does not affect the vertical tailplane lift curve slope, thus not affecting the stability of the aircraft. In contrast, the vertical tailplane drag coefficient is reduced by the hump. Retrofitting the hump on Airbus A320 (conventional tail) and the Fokker F-28 Mk1000 (T-tail) results in a reduction of the vertical tailplane drag coefficient of 6.73% and 8.72%, respectively. Translating this vertical tail drag reduction to the full aircraft drag coefficient results in a reduction of 0.17% and 0.34%. To evaluate the effect of the hump on weight and fuel consumption, additional weight and mission analyses are performed. Evaluating the harmonic range, an fuel reduction due to the hump of 0.16% and 0.32% is established, for the Airbus A320 and Fokker F-28 Mk1000, respectively. The aircraft weight is reduced by the same percentage through the fuel reduction, as it is assumed that the added weight due to the hump itself is negligible.
Additionally, two sensitivity analyses were performed, namely, sweep angle variation and surface area scaling to analyze the effectiveness of the hump for different vertical tailplane geometries. The effect of sweep angle on hump effectiveness does not affect the vertical tailplane lift curve slope and thus also not the stability coefficients. For the full aircraft drag coefficient, the hump effectiveness has an exponential relation with sweep angle and is most effective at lower sweep angles. A maximum full aircraft drag reduction was found of 0.41% at 30 deg sweep with an equivalent fuel reduction of 0.39%. Overall it is concluded that lower sweep angles are beneficial as the hump is most effective and results in reduced vertical tailplane weight, less fuel weight as well as an increased stability margin. Analyzing the effect of surface area scaling, the hump has no effect on the vertical tailplane lift curve slope regardless of surface area, again retaining the aircraft’s stability. For the full aircraft drag coefficient, the hump effectiveness increases linearly for increasing surface area up to 0.37% at a surface scaling factor of 1.2 times the original vertical tailplane surface area. In terms of fuel reduction, a maximum value of 0.35% was found. There will be an optimal vertical tailplane surface area, since the hump effectiveness increases for increasing surface area, whilst for the full aircraft drag, vertical tailplane weight, and fuel weight a smaller surface area is preferred. The stability margin becomes the limiting factor as a minimum surface area is required for sufficient stability. Comparing the baseline aircraft, the hump is more effective for the Fokker F-28 Mk1000 over the entire range of scaling factors and sweep angles. This leads to the suspicion that taper- and aspect ratio, and cruise speed play an important role in the effectiveness of the hump, but more research is required.
This research shows that the Delft Laminar Hump has a significant drag-reducing effect on the overall aircraft, whilst not affecting the aircraft’s stability. Even though the fuel savings for an individual aircraft are not very large, on a fleet level this would be significant. The hump can be retrofitted on existing aircraft by gluing it on the outer skin, making it a relatively simple and cheap way to improve efficiency for aircraft manufacturers. Nevertheless, more research is required before implementing the hump on commercial aircraft as it is still unknown whether the hump also works on the suction side of the wing as well as whether the hump causes a shock at cruise Mach. Also, interaction effects with the horizontal stabilizer and fuselage need to be taken into account, to fully quantify the effectiveness of the hump. Dedicated wind tunnel experiments, flight tests, and/or CFD simulations are necessary.
Development of Short-Range Laminar Aircraft
Conceptual Design with Integrated System Sizing
Prior works assessing laminar flow technologies have mostly focused on evaluating their aerodynamic performance and, in the case of the HLFC, on the influence of system design. The impact of these technologies on the overall aircraft performance has received only limited consideration, with the majority of studies focusing on long-range aircraft, utilizing simplified models for HLFC systems, and considering only one laminar flow technology at a time.
This study adopts a holistic approach to assess the potential fuel savings that could be achieved by combined application of NLF and HLFC technologies on the various components of a short-to-medium range aircraft concept, with an intended entry into service in 2035. To achieve this objective, a conceptual aircraft design process is employed. This process captures the aerodynamic effects of laminar flow technologies and fully integrates the HLFC system design to provide an accurate estimate of aircraft performance.
The findings of this study reveal a potential for fuel savings of 5.9\% on the design mission through the combined application of NLF and HLFC, compared to a turbulent aircraft with an equivalent technology level. Additionally, the results indicate that strategic combination of the two technologies on a single component can significantly reduce complexity while further enhancing fuel savings. A failure analysis also provides an initial estimate of the impact of various failure scenarios on the aircraft's performance.
These findings demonstrate that, despite the aircraft's short range, the combined implementation of the two laminar flow technologies offers a potential for fuel savings with reduced complexity, motivating further research in their application to this aircraft category. ...
Prior works assessing laminar flow technologies have mostly focused on evaluating their aerodynamic performance and, in the case of the HLFC, on the influence of system design. The impact of these technologies on the overall aircraft performance has received only limited consideration, with the majority of studies focusing on long-range aircraft, utilizing simplified models for HLFC systems, and considering only one laminar flow technology at a time.
This study adopts a holistic approach to assess the potential fuel savings that could be achieved by combined application of NLF and HLFC technologies on the various components of a short-to-medium range aircraft concept, with an intended entry into service in 2035. To achieve this objective, a conceptual aircraft design process is employed. This process captures the aerodynamic effects of laminar flow technologies and fully integrates the HLFC system design to provide an accurate estimate of aircraft performance.
The findings of this study reveal a potential for fuel savings of 5.9\% on the design mission through the combined application of NLF and HLFC, compared to a turbulent aircraft with an equivalent technology level. Additionally, the results indicate that strategic combination of the two technologies on a single component can significantly reduce complexity while further enhancing fuel savings. A failure analysis also provides an initial estimate of the impact of various failure scenarios on the aircraft's performance.
These findings demonstrate that, despite the aircraft's short range, the combined implementation of the two laminar flow technologies offers a potential for fuel savings with reduced complexity, motivating further research in their application to this aircraft category.
To address these issues, this study proposes an integral tank concept featuring a double wall architecture with vacuum insulation. The main advantage of this design is the use of an external stiffened wall that can be directly connected to the remaining airframe. In addition, having stiffeners on the outside ensures the required space for systems routing and addresses concerns with the crash worthiness of the structure. A parametric method, coupled with finite element analysis is developed to size the external load bearing wall, enabling quick analysis and mass estimations of different tank configurations. The method consists of a sizing optimization with the objective of minimizing the structural mass under constraints on the strength, buckling stability and fatigue behaviour.
The feasibility of the concept is then evaluated on an aft tank for a short/medium range aircraft in configurations with and without a forward tank. Preliminary results under this realistic scenario point to fuel containment efficiencies of up to 0.71, which are consistent with existing designs. Moreover, buckling stability is identified as the critical design criterion, highlighting the importance of using a stiffened shell design. These findings show the viability of the proposed concept from a structural standpoint and provide the basis for further research. The optimum solution at an aircraft level can be obtained by integrating the developed framework into a multidisciplinary aircraft design tool. ...
To address these issues, this study proposes an integral tank concept featuring a double wall architecture with vacuum insulation. The main advantage of this design is the use of an external stiffened wall that can be directly connected to the remaining airframe. In addition, having stiffeners on the outside ensures the required space for systems routing and addresses concerns with the crash worthiness of the structure. A parametric method, coupled with finite element analysis is developed to size the external load bearing wall, enabling quick analysis and mass estimations of different tank configurations. The method consists of a sizing optimization with the objective of minimizing the structural mass under constraints on the strength, buckling stability and fatigue behaviour.
The feasibility of the concept is then evaluated on an aft tank for a short/medium range aircraft in configurations with and without a forward tank. Preliminary results under this realistic scenario point to fuel containment efficiencies of up to 0.71, which are consistent with existing designs. Moreover, buckling stability is identified as the critical design criterion, highlighting the importance of using a stiffened shell design. These findings show the viability of the proposed concept from a structural standpoint and provide the basis for further research. The optimum solution at an aircraft level can be obtained by integrating the developed framework into a multidisciplinary aircraft design tool.
Hydrogen on Pole Position
The development of a fuel cell electric vehicle model and a comparative lap time optimisation study between different powertrain technologies
The objectives of this thesis are twofold, with their primary focus on evaluating the effect of changing the typical design variables for an SBW, such as the wing span, root chord, spanwise strut attachment location, wing taper ratio, wing sweep and engine location on the aerodynamics, weights and performance of an SBW. The first objective was to evaluate the significance of including the propeller slipstream effects in the preliminary stage design optimisation of a low-speed, short-range SBW. This aligned with the hypothesis that the performance of an SBW could be enhanced by using swirl recovery. The second objective of this thesis was to investigate the sensitivity of various design variables to the aircraft’s fuel burn and other performance metrics at the optimum SBW design.
A Design of Experiments (DOE) approach was used to explore the design space involving the typical influential SBW design parameters. The geometry and mesh files were created using OpenVSP for every DOE point. This was followed by the aerodynamic analysis in a panel method-based software called Flightstream, which could capture the relevant aerodynamic flow phenomena with reasonable accuracy. The aerodynamic analysis was performed twice- first without considering slipstream effects and second by simulating them. Regression-based analytical equations, particularly designed for the weight estimation of the wing and strut, were used from the literature. Empirical equations from FLOPS were used for the rest of the aircraft components. The performance of the SBW was calculated iteratively using the Breguet range equation along with a few modifications. All the SBW designs were constrained by a maximum wing loading criterion.
From two sets of the DOE results (with and without propeller effects), it was observed that the two optimum SBW designs were identical in terms of external geometry and performance. A deeper investigation revealed that the variation in the spanwise engine positioning (to maximise the swirl recovery) resulted in a marginal change of the induced drag (less than two drag counts). It was concluded that the propeller slipstream effects could be excluded from the preliminary stage, design optimisation of a propeller-powered, short-range SBW to reduce computational expense. However, the results should be treated with a pinch of salt due to the limitations of panel methods. Moreover, the SBW was optimised only for cruise, not for other flight phases such as take-off and climb, which may benefit from swirl recovery.
Finally, a sensitivity analysis was performed to evaluate the trends in the performance metrics, such as fuel burn, lift-to-drag ratio, wing loading and maximum take-off weight when subjected to variations in the design variables at the optimum. The impact of the fuel burn was quantified, while the other performance metrics were qualitatively answered. The research findings revealed that certain design variables had a greater influence on fuel burn than others when varied by ±10% w.r.t their optimum value... ...
The objectives of this thesis are twofold, with their primary focus on evaluating the effect of changing the typical design variables for an SBW, such as the wing span, root chord, spanwise strut attachment location, wing taper ratio, wing sweep and engine location on the aerodynamics, weights and performance of an SBW. The first objective was to evaluate the significance of including the propeller slipstream effects in the preliminary stage design optimisation of a low-speed, short-range SBW. This aligned with the hypothesis that the performance of an SBW could be enhanced by using swirl recovery. The second objective of this thesis was to investigate the sensitivity of various design variables to the aircraft’s fuel burn and other performance metrics at the optimum SBW design.
A Design of Experiments (DOE) approach was used to explore the design space involving the typical influential SBW design parameters. The geometry and mesh files were created using OpenVSP for every DOE point. This was followed by the aerodynamic analysis in a panel method-based software called Flightstream, which could capture the relevant aerodynamic flow phenomena with reasonable accuracy. The aerodynamic analysis was performed twice- first without considering slipstream effects and second by simulating them. Regression-based analytical equations, particularly designed for the weight estimation of the wing and strut, were used from the literature. Empirical equations from FLOPS were used for the rest of the aircraft components. The performance of the SBW was calculated iteratively using the Breguet range equation along with a few modifications. All the SBW designs were constrained by a maximum wing loading criterion.
From two sets of the DOE results (with and without propeller effects), it was observed that the two optimum SBW designs were identical in terms of external geometry and performance. A deeper investigation revealed that the variation in the spanwise engine positioning (to maximise the swirl recovery) resulted in a marginal change of the induced drag (less than two drag counts). It was concluded that the propeller slipstream effects could be excluded from the preliminary stage, design optimisation of a propeller-powered, short-range SBW to reduce computational expense. However, the results should be treated with a pinch of salt due to the limitations of panel methods. Moreover, the SBW was optimised only for cruise, not for other flight phases such as take-off and climb, which may benefit from swirl recovery.
Finally, a sensitivity analysis was performed to evaluate the trends in the performance metrics, such as fuel burn, lift-to-drag ratio, wing loading and maximum take-off weight when subjected to variations in the design variables at the optimum. The impact of the fuel burn was quantified, while the other performance metrics were qualitatively answered. The research findings revealed that certain design variables had a greater influence on fuel burn than others when varied by ±10% w.r.t their optimum value...
Propeller Slipstream Effects on Longitudinal Static Stability
Effect of the Rethorst Correction at the Horizontal Stabilizer
The thesis has three primary objectives. First, it seeks to enhance the fidelity of the existing BLI model within a conceptual aircraft design tool. The improvement involves transitioning from the actuator disk theory to the blade element theory (BET) with gradient-based optimization. Additionally, a surrogate model is established with this improvement through multidisciplinary design optimization (MDO), design of experiment (DoE), and response surface methodology (RSM) to predict power-saving benefits based on fuselage geometric and operational parameters. Comparison reveals discrepancies between the existing BLI model and the surrogate model, emphasizing the influence of blade aerodynamics.
The second and third objectives delve into the sensitivity of aircraft-level performance and powertrain settings. The conceptual aircraft design tool, Aircraft Design Initiator (Initiator), is used for sizing, with the surrogate model integrated. The study uses a regional turboprop ATR-72 as a reference conventional aircraft design and employs a partial-turboelectric (PTE) architecture for the hybrid-electric powertrain in the radical aircraft design. A sensitivity analysis varying design parameters by 20%, including fuselage slenderness ratio, propeller size ratio, and shaft-power ratio, reveals their impact on BLI effects and aircraft-level performance.
The study reveals that fuselage length significantly impacts fuel weight and, consequently, aircraft performance. Surprisingly, aero-propulsive benefits from BLI do not directly enhance overall aircraft performance, attributed to an associated weight penalty. Instead, the shaft-power ratio and propeller size ratio prove significant at the system level. Further investigation into powertrain settings suggests that radical BLI-equipped aircraft designs are not able to surpass the energy efficiency of conventional counterparts. Additionally, the proposed surrogate model exhibits a limited applicable range, especially under high BLI propeller disk loading, rooted in underlying physical constraints in propeller design. These findings prompt a critical examination of the feasibility of hybrid-electric powertrains with BLI for regional turboprop aircraft, with a note of caution regarding potential variations in modeling methods and assumptions. ...
The thesis has three primary objectives. First, it seeks to enhance the fidelity of the existing BLI model within a conceptual aircraft design tool. The improvement involves transitioning from the actuator disk theory to the blade element theory (BET) with gradient-based optimization. Additionally, a surrogate model is established with this improvement through multidisciplinary design optimization (MDO), design of experiment (DoE), and response surface methodology (RSM) to predict power-saving benefits based on fuselage geometric and operational parameters. Comparison reveals discrepancies between the existing BLI model and the surrogate model, emphasizing the influence of blade aerodynamics.
The second and third objectives delve into the sensitivity of aircraft-level performance and powertrain settings. The conceptual aircraft design tool, Aircraft Design Initiator (Initiator), is used for sizing, with the surrogate model integrated. The study uses a regional turboprop ATR-72 as a reference conventional aircraft design and employs a partial-turboelectric (PTE) architecture for the hybrid-electric powertrain in the radical aircraft design. A sensitivity analysis varying design parameters by 20%, including fuselage slenderness ratio, propeller size ratio, and shaft-power ratio, reveals their impact on BLI effects and aircraft-level performance.
The study reveals that fuselage length significantly impacts fuel weight and, consequently, aircraft performance. Surprisingly, aero-propulsive benefits from BLI do not directly enhance overall aircraft performance, attributed to an associated weight penalty. Instead, the shaft-power ratio and propeller size ratio prove significant at the system level. Further investigation into powertrain settings suggests that radical BLI-equipped aircraft designs are not able to surpass the energy efficiency of conventional counterparts. Additionally, the proposed surrogate model exhibits a limited applicable range, especially under high BLI propeller disk loading, rooted in underlying physical constraints in propeller design. These findings prompt a critical examination of the feasibility of hybrid-electric powertrains with BLI for regional turboprop aircraft, with a note of caution regarding potential variations in modeling methods and assumptions.