H.C. Winsemius
Please Note
17 records found
1
Through a comprehensive literature review, CNNs, and UNet models are identified as promising tools for this task due to their ability to capture intricate patterns in datasets. The study compares the performance of the U-Net model against a statistics-based hydrological benchmark model, revealing the superior performance of the U-Net model.
Furthermore, the analysis explores how the performance of AI models varies with differing quantities of missing data, by masking available data and comparing reconstructed values against the ground truth, highlighting the importance of data availability.
Additionally, the study investigates the influence of spatial patterns in training data on model performance, including patchy versus random missing data in the field of view, simulating more datasets more likely available in reality. This clarifies the challenges encountered in predicting grid points under different training dataset conditions.
Finally, the study identifies areas within the dataset that are particularly challenging to predict, shedding light on factors contributing to prediction errors. These findings underscore the potential of AI models in hydrological applications and provide valuable insights for future research in the field.
Our findings show that U net is capable of reconstructing velocity fields from a river flow better than an average benchmark that uses the average values, with varying accuracy depending on input data.
The average benchmark model had a relative error close to 0.2 in every instance, whereas the U-Net model showed relative errors ranging from 0.085 to 0.006. Errors from a patchy mask are ranging from 0.09 8 to 0.031. ...
Through a comprehensive literature review, CNNs, and UNet models are identified as promising tools for this task due to their ability to capture intricate patterns in datasets. The study compares the performance of the U-Net model against a statistics-based hydrological benchmark model, revealing the superior performance of the U-Net model.
Furthermore, the analysis explores how the performance of AI models varies with differing quantities of missing data, by masking available data and comparing reconstructed values against the ground truth, highlighting the importance of data availability.
Additionally, the study investigates the influence of spatial patterns in training data on model performance, including patchy versus random missing data in the field of view, simulating more datasets more likely available in reality. This clarifies the challenges encountered in predicting grid points under different training dataset conditions.
Finally, the study identifies areas within the dataset that are particularly challenging to predict, shedding light on factors contributing to prediction errors. These findings underscore the potential of AI models in hydrological applications and provide valuable insights for future research in the field.
Our findings show that U net is capable of reconstructing velocity fields from a river flow better than an average benchmark that uses the average values, with varying accuracy depending on input data.
The average benchmark model had a relative error close to 0.2 in every instance, whereas the U-Net model showed relative errors ranging from 0.085 to 0.006. Errors from a patchy mask are ranging from 0.09 8 to 0.031.
This research aims to model a medium to large sized river with wide floodplains in three dimensions by integrating discharge data and a highly accurate bathymetry. The primary objective is to quantify the friction coefficient and establish a reliable rating-curve for the river system. By utilizing these key components, the study seeks to provide a comprehensive understanding of the hydraulic behavior of the river, contributing to improved water flow predictions and management strategies. The bathymetry data is acquired through two different methods. The dry bathymetry is obtained using an UAV (DJI Phantom 4) and photogrammetry (WebODM). The wet bathymetry data is collected using both, sonar with the Deeper Chirp+ and spatial referencing with the RTK-GNSS from ArduSimple. These methods are cost-effective and require minimal manpower, making them practical options for acquiring accurate bathymetric information. The discharge data is acquired using the open-source software, OpenRiverCam. OpenRiverCam uses Large Scale Particle Image Velocimetry (LSPIV) to determine the surface velocities and combines the results with the bathymetry data to calculate discharges, providing an efficient solution for assessing river flow characteristics. LSPIV has the advantage that it is a non-intrusive method of measuring the flow velocity and does not require physical probes or instruments in the water. The bathymetry data and discharge data are integrated into the Delft3D FM Suite to assess the accuracy of the measurements and estimate the friction coefficient in both the river and the floodplain. This modeling approach enables a comprehensive analysis of the hydraulic characteristics of a medium to large sized river and supports the evaluation of flow resistance in the study area.
The data acquisition took place at three study sites close to the Bui Dam, in the Black Volta Region, Ghana. The Bui Dam is the second largest hydro-power dam in Ghana managed by the Bui Power Authority (BPA). The Bui Bridge and Bamboi Bridge study sites are positioned downstream of the Bui Dam, allowing for accurate quantification of the discharge and the bathymetry measurements. The third study site, Chache, is positioned upstream of the dam, where daily water level measurements are taken. BPA has observed that the rating curve at this location is outdated. Therefore, efforts are made to update the rating curve and quantify the friction coefficient at this site in both the river and the floodplain.
This research has made significant progress in developing a three-dimensional discharge model and rating curve for medium to large rivers using advanced data collection methods and integration techniques. The study successfully combined photogrammetry and sonar measurements to effectively determine the bathymetry of the river, overcoming challenges related to high water velocities and dense vegetation. The LSPIV technique and OpenRiverCam were utilized to integrate surface velocities and discharge measurements, leading to a more comprehensive understanding of river dynamics. However, limitations were encountered in assessing the accuracy of the model at the Bamboi Bridge site due to the LSPIV results. This highlights the importance of obtaining more comprehensive data and observations to enhance the model’s accuracy. The comparison of rating curves at the Chache site resulted in positive results. Although, further verification during the wet period is required through velocity and discharge measurements to determine the accuracy. Overall, this research contributes to a better understanding of river behavior and provides valuable insights for water flow prediction in an efficient, cost-effective manner with minimal intensive manpower, ensuring a non-intrusive approach. ...
This research aims to model a medium to large sized river with wide floodplains in three dimensions by integrating discharge data and a highly accurate bathymetry. The primary objective is to quantify the friction coefficient and establish a reliable rating-curve for the river system. By utilizing these key components, the study seeks to provide a comprehensive understanding of the hydraulic behavior of the river, contributing to improved water flow predictions and management strategies. The bathymetry data is acquired through two different methods. The dry bathymetry is obtained using an UAV (DJI Phantom 4) and photogrammetry (WebODM). The wet bathymetry data is collected using both, sonar with the Deeper Chirp+ and spatial referencing with the RTK-GNSS from ArduSimple. These methods are cost-effective and require minimal manpower, making them practical options for acquiring accurate bathymetric information. The discharge data is acquired using the open-source software, OpenRiverCam. OpenRiverCam uses Large Scale Particle Image Velocimetry (LSPIV) to determine the surface velocities and combines the results with the bathymetry data to calculate discharges, providing an efficient solution for assessing river flow characteristics. LSPIV has the advantage that it is a non-intrusive method of measuring the flow velocity and does not require physical probes or instruments in the water. The bathymetry data and discharge data are integrated into the Delft3D FM Suite to assess the accuracy of the measurements and estimate the friction coefficient in both the river and the floodplain. This modeling approach enables a comprehensive analysis of the hydraulic characteristics of a medium to large sized river and supports the evaluation of flow resistance in the study area.
The data acquisition took place at three study sites close to the Bui Dam, in the Black Volta Region, Ghana. The Bui Dam is the second largest hydro-power dam in Ghana managed by the Bui Power Authority (BPA). The Bui Bridge and Bamboi Bridge study sites are positioned downstream of the Bui Dam, allowing for accurate quantification of the discharge and the bathymetry measurements. The third study site, Chache, is positioned upstream of the dam, where daily water level measurements are taken. BPA has observed that the rating curve at this location is outdated. Therefore, efforts are made to update the rating curve and quantify the friction coefficient at this site in both the river and the floodplain.
This research has made significant progress in developing a three-dimensional discharge model and rating curve for medium to large rivers using advanced data collection methods and integration techniques. The study successfully combined photogrammetry and sonar measurements to effectively determine the bathymetry of the river, overcoming challenges related to high water velocities and dense vegetation. The LSPIV technique and OpenRiverCam were utilized to integrate surface velocities and discharge measurements, leading to a more comprehensive understanding of river dynamics. However, limitations were encountered in assessing the accuracy of the model at the Bamboi Bridge site due to the LSPIV results. This highlights the importance of obtaining more comprehensive data and observations to enhance the model’s accuracy. The comparison of rating curves at the Chache site resulted in positive results. Although, further verification during the wet period is required through velocity and discharge measurements to determine the accuracy. Overall, this research contributes to a better understanding of river behavior and provides valuable insights for water flow prediction in an efficient, cost-effective manner with minimal intensive manpower, ensuring a non-intrusive approach.
Remote sensing has the potential to address this problem. The Global Water Watch is a platform that and provides earth-observed surface area dynamics that can be used to monitor small to medium-sized reservoirs worldwide and detect trends in water availability. While this method serves as a valuable indicator of water availability, it falls short in providing decision-makers with the necessary absolute volume time series and volume predictions. Currently, no platform exists beyond in-situ measurements to meet this essential need.
This thesis presents a novel method for retrieving near real-time volume time series in small to medium-sized man-made reservoirs worldwide using remotely sensed open data. The method utilises the MERIT-Hydro digital elevation model, HydroMT and stream flow methods by Eilander et al. (2023), and literature by Messager et al. (2016) to reconstruct reservoir bathymetry. This novel approach in reconstructing reservoir bathymetry enables the conversion of available reservoir area time series into volume time series. These were employed in autoregressive and multi-linear regression models to predict water availability up to six months in advance. The models incorporate ERA5 precipitation data by Hersbach's (2020) and the Standardised Precipitation and Evaporation Index (SPEI) by Beguería et al. (2021) to improve the accuracy of the volume predictions.
When comparing the novel method to the method proposed by Messager et al. (2016), the novel method yielded more accurate reservoir volume estimations. The method successfully obtained bathymetries and accurate volume estimations when validating using 2 reservoirs in Zambia and 48 in India, demonstrating the potential of this novel approach. However, some reservoirs with complex shapes faced initial delineation challenges, resulting in inaccurate volume predictions. These issues could be resolved by manually delineating the area for bathymetry reconstruction. Moreover, regression models were applied to case study reservoirs in Eswatini and Lesotho, demonstrating reasonable predictive capabilities with the Heidke Skill Scores ranging from 0.77 to 1 for up to 2 months ahead. However, precise prediction of extreme decreases in reservoir levels requires a physically based approach that incorporates the volumetric time series provided by this novel method. The study emphasises the necessity of considering the volume time series’ memory to predict water availability and provides a valuable foundation for volume time series analysis using remotely sensed data. ...
Remote sensing has the potential to address this problem. The Global Water Watch is a platform that and provides earth-observed surface area dynamics that can be used to monitor small to medium-sized reservoirs worldwide and detect trends in water availability. While this method serves as a valuable indicator of water availability, it falls short in providing decision-makers with the necessary absolute volume time series and volume predictions. Currently, no platform exists beyond in-situ measurements to meet this essential need.
This thesis presents a novel method for retrieving near real-time volume time series in small to medium-sized man-made reservoirs worldwide using remotely sensed open data. The method utilises the MERIT-Hydro digital elevation model, HydroMT and stream flow methods by Eilander et al. (2023), and literature by Messager et al. (2016) to reconstruct reservoir bathymetry. This novel approach in reconstructing reservoir bathymetry enables the conversion of available reservoir area time series into volume time series. These were employed in autoregressive and multi-linear regression models to predict water availability up to six months in advance. The models incorporate ERA5 precipitation data by Hersbach's (2020) and the Standardised Precipitation and Evaporation Index (SPEI) by Beguería et al. (2021) to improve the accuracy of the volume predictions.
When comparing the novel method to the method proposed by Messager et al. (2016), the novel method yielded more accurate reservoir volume estimations. The method successfully obtained bathymetries and accurate volume estimations when validating using 2 reservoirs in Zambia and 48 in India, demonstrating the potential of this novel approach. However, some reservoirs with complex shapes faced initial delineation challenges, resulting in inaccurate volume predictions. These issues could be resolved by manually delineating the area for bathymetry reconstruction. Moreover, regression models were applied to case study reservoirs in Eswatini and Lesotho, demonstrating reasonable predictive capabilities with the Heidke Skill Scores ranging from 0.77 to 1 for up to 2 months ahead. However, precise prediction of extreme decreases in reservoir levels requires a physically based approach that incorporates the volumetric time series provided by this novel method. The study emphasises the necessity of considering the volume time series’ memory to predict water availability and provides a valuable foundation for volume time series analysis using remotely sensed data.
Remote river rating in resource constricted river basins
Exploring opportunities for ungauged basins through low-cost technological advancements
The first three chapters of this thesis provide an introduction in the form of a literature review, justification for the study and a description of the study area. In chapter 4, a framework is developed through an intensive review of traditional river monitoring processes. Uniquely effective and low-cost individual components are selected and placed within a framework. The ideal outcome is an interconnected framework which clearly presents the steps which are necessary for river monitoring in remote locations. The manner in which each critical step is related to the other is explained. Furthermore, the method by which modern technologies are assimilated into the method is described. Within the framework, critical thresholds are set up in order to signal the to the water manager whether the proposed model in its current state continues to perform as required.
Chapter 5 investigates how low-cost technologies such as UAVs in combination with low-cost GNSS devices can be used to generate river geometry for the purposes of application in a hydraulic model. Furthermore, performance of the open-source photogrammetry software substantiated the claim that, free and open-source available packages are capable of producing results which are as good as proprietary alternatives as shown by the RMSE analyses. A novel approach to generate a seamless bathymetry through merging and volumization was successfully tested. Results presented in this chapter encourage future studies to investigate the impact of variations in the number of Ground Control Points (GCPs) on discharge estimations in a hydraulic model with different hydrodynamic boundary conditions. This follow up was instituted in Chapter 6.
In this sixth chapter we accept that uncertainties in the data acquisition may propagate into uncertainties in the relationships found between discharge and state variables. This uncertainty prompts the need to understand the impact of varying geometries on hydraulic models. Specific attention is placed on variations caused by differing GCP numbers since the task of GCP placement is time consuming, potential dangerous and resource intensive in certain location and instances. We are successfully able to determine the minimum number of control points required to reproduce geometry. Overall, we successfully develop and test a workable method for water resources authorities to estimate river flows accurately through the application of advanced, low-cost technologies with minimal contact with measured variables.
The development and application of low-cost technologies for river flow monitoring has led to the following important conclusions:
• For the purpose of flow estimation, there is no need to use more than seven GCPs to establish accurate UAV-based geometry. Rather, it is more crucial to distribute the available markers to be maximally representative of the terrain elevations. Furthermore, it may be necessary to place more markers in close proximity to locations where one may expect the largest challenge for photogrammetry software (e.g.: water, thick forest/vegetation)
• In order to limit the impact of the “doming” effect on terrain geometry measurements, one of the most effective, yet easily implementable mechanisms is to measure a river line using Real Time Kinematic (RTK) Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) equipment. This data can then be used to correct the terrain post photogrammetry processing.
...
The first three chapters of this thesis provide an introduction in the form of a literature review, justification for the study and a description of the study area. In chapter 4, a framework is developed through an intensive review of traditional river monitoring processes. Uniquely effective and low-cost individual components are selected and placed within a framework. The ideal outcome is an interconnected framework which clearly presents the steps which are necessary for river monitoring in remote locations. The manner in which each critical step is related to the other is explained. Furthermore, the method by which modern technologies are assimilated into the method is described. Within the framework, critical thresholds are set up in order to signal the to the water manager whether the proposed model in its current state continues to perform as required.
Chapter 5 investigates how low-cost technologies such as UAVs in combination with low-cost GNSS devices can be used to generate river geometry for the purposes of application in a hydraulic model. Furthermore, performance of the open-source photogrammetry software substantiated the claim that, free and open-source available packages are capable of producing results which are as good as proprietary alternatives as shown by the RMSE analyses. A novel approach to generate a seamless bathymetry through merging and volumization was successfully tested. Results presented in this chapter encourage future studies to investigate the impact of variations in the number of Ground Control Points (GCPs) on discharge estimations in a hydraulic model with different hydrodynamic boundary conditions. This follow up was instituted in Chapter 6.
In this sixth chapter we accept that uncertainties in the data acquisition may propagate into uncertainties in the relationships found between discharge and state variables. This uncertainty prompts the need to understand the impact of varying geometries on hydraulic models. Specific attention is placed on variations caused by differing GCP numbers since the task of GCP placement is time consuming, potential dangerous and resource intensive in certain location and instances. We are successfully able to determine the minimum number of control points required to reproduce geometry. Overall, we successfully develop and test a workable method for water resources authorities to estimate river flows accurately through the application of advanced, low-cost technologies with minimal contact with measured variables.
The development and application of low-cost technologies for river flow monitoring has led to the following important conclusions:
• For the purpose of flow estimation, there is no need to use more than seven GCPs to establish accurate UAV-based geometry. Rather, it is more crucial to distribute the available markers to be maximally representative of the terrain elevations. Furthermore, it may be necessary to place more markers in close proximity to locations where one may expect the largest challenge for photogrammetry software (e.g.: water, thick forest/vegetation)
• In order to limit the impact of the “doming” effect on terrain geometry measurements, one of the most effective, yet easily implementable mechanisms is to measure a river line using Real Time Kinematic (RTK) Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) equipment. This data can then be used to correct the terrain post photogrammetry processing.
A new spatial resampling method for synthetic precipitation generation in the Rhine basin
MSc thesis graduation report
observed precipitation. This is problematic for catchments with a time of concentration shorter than the resolution of the used data and conflicts with the increasing occurrence of more local, short duration extremes not yet observed.
In this thesis, it was researched if spatial permutation of precipitation could provide a solution to these problems by introducing historical events from related locations into the area of interest. The generated precipitation series were expected to have a larger variety of precipitation events compared to the historical data, thereby representing the current changing weather patterns better and being more suitable for small basins. This is beneficial for insurance companies, governments and aid organizations which rely on long term precipitation series to generate event catalogues and risk predictions.
To develop, improve and widen the knowledge about the effects of spatial permutation, four different questions were formulated for a case study on spatial permutation in the Rhine basin. A literature study showed that precipitation regimes in Europe can be defined based on spatial and temporal variability, precipitation amounts and the influence of controlling factors like atmospheric circulations, topography and climate change. This information was used to built three permutation models. The first model shifted historical precipitation fields over fixed distances and directions. In the second model this fixed approach was replaced by semi-random vectors including spatial and temporal correlation. The last
model used a vector approach with vectors conditioned with historical wind data. The effect of each model on the Generalized Extreme Value (GEV) distributions, the cumulative distribution functions (cdfs) and the main characteristics of precipitation for different basins and aggregation times was determined. The July 2021 Meuse flood was used as example to show the working method of each model visually and to better understand the effect of each permutation model on individual extreme events.
The results showed that spatial permutation did influence precipitation patterns, characteristics and statistics. Strongest changes in extreme precipitation events were seen for small basins and short aggregation times. The permutation direction and distance were important determinants for the outcome of each model. Precipitation permutation with semi-random vector fields was shown to be a promising method which allowed for the inclusion of both spatial and temporal correlation. However, the model had a high sensitivity to the initial and boundary conditions. Wind based vector fields were able to replicate the most important historical precipitation characteristics while at the same time generating new extremes. Yet, a clear trade off was visible between similarity of the historically observed and modelled precipitation characteristics and the number of new extremes introduced.
With the knowledge obtained, it can be concluded that spatial permutation is a promising method to generate more divers precipitation time series for the Rhine basin. Both semi-random and wind-based vector permutations can already be used to generate new precipitation series as long as the initial and boundary conditions are chosen carefully. To improve the results, a fusion of spatial and temporal relations and a physically wind-based vector generation method is advised. In addition, possibilities are seen in a combination of the currently used temporal resampling algorithms and a spatial permutation approach. The outcomes of these suggestions are not known yet. Nevertheless, it is expected that a better understanding of spatial permutation, on top of the results presented in this thesis, can advance the current methodologies used to generate long term precipitation series. Therefore, it is hoped that this research provides the incentives to explore spatial permutation of precipitation patterns in more detail and in such, contributes to a more accurate risk profile for the livelihoods of people worldwide. ...
observed precipitation. This is problematic for catchments with a time of concentration shorter than the resolution of the used data and conflicts with the increasing occurrence of more local, short duration extremes not yet observed.
In this thesis, it was researched if spatial permutation of precipitation could provide a solution to these problems by introducing historical events from related locations into the area of interest. The generated precipitation series were expected to have a larger variety of precipitation events compared to the historical data, thereby representing the current changing weather patterns better and being more suitable for small basins. This is beneficial for insurance companies, governments and aid organizations which rely on long term precipitation series to generate event catalogues and risk predictions.
To develop, improve and widen the knowledge about the effects of spatial permutation, four different questions were formulated for a case study on spatial permutation in the Rhine basin. A literature study showed that precipitation regimes in Europe can be defined based on spatial and temporal variability, precipitation amounts and the influence of controlling factors like atmospheric circulations, topography and climate change. This information was used to built three permutation models. The first model shifted historical precipitation fields over fixed distances and directions. In the second model this fixed approach was replaced by semi-random vectors including spatial and temporal correlation. The last
model used a vector approach with vectors conditioned with historical wind data. The effect of each model on the Generalized Extreme Value (GEV) distributions, the cumulative distribution functions (cdfs) and the main characteristics of precipitation for different basins and aggregation times was determined. The July 2021 Meuse flood was used as example to show the working method of each model visually and to better understand the effect of each permutation model on individual extreme events.
The results showed that spatial permutation did influence precipitation patterns, characteristics and statistics. Strongest changes in extreme precipitation events were seen for small basins and short aggregation times. The permutation direction and distance were important determinants for the outcome of each model. Precipitation permutation with semi-random vector fields was shown to be a promising method which allowed for the inclusion of both spatial and temporal correlation. However, the model had a high sensitivity to the initial and boundary conditions. Wind based vector fields were able to replicate the most important historical precipitation characteristics while at the same time generating new extremes. Yet, a clear trade off was visible between similarity of the historically observed and modelled precipitation characteristics and the number of new extremes introduced.
With the knowledge obtained, it can be concluded that spatial permutation is a promising method to generate more divers precipitation time series for the Rhine basin. Both semi-random and wind-based vector permutations can already be used to generate new precipitation series as long as the initial and boundary conditions are chosen carefully. To improve the results, a fusion of spatial and temporal relations and a physically wind-based vector generation method is advised. In addition, possibilities are seen in a combination of the currently used temporal resampling algorithms and a spatial permutation approach. The outcomes of these suggestions are not known yet. Nevertheless, it is expected that a better understanding of spatial permutation, on top of the results presented in this thesis, can advance the current methodologies used to generate long term precipitation series. Therefore, it is hoped that this research provides the incentives to explore spatial permutation of precipitation patterns in more detail and in such, contributes to a more accurate risk profile for the livelihoods of people worldwide.
River discharge modelling based on surface flow velocity estimations
A combination of Large-Scale Particle Image Velocimetry and three dimensional discharge modelling
Flood Wave Monitoring using LSPIV
A methodology for monitoring flood waves in an equatorial urban stream with fast response time
LSPIV uses videos to extract surface flow velocities by tracing movements of seeds on the water's surface. Combined with the local bathymetry and water level, an estimation of the river's discharge can be made. This study consists of two sets of experiments. The first set of experiments were performed at the Dommel regarding processing software, image preparation, seeding densities, and point of views and discussed by assessing their accuracy relative to benchmark measurements -- using the mean error and root mean squared error -- and the method's precision – using the relative standard deviation.
The second set of experiments were performed along the Chuo Kikuu, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. A flood wave was monitored through the capture of 73 5 second videos. These videos were turned into separate frames and corrected for lens distortion and perspective distortion. Thereafter the frames were gray scaled and gamma correction was applied. After the LSPIV process additional filtering removed unrealistic low flow velocities, and through substitution missing velocities were replaced with flow velocities based on the vertical logarithmic progression relationship between the surface flow velocities and water depth. The surface flow velocities found using this method match optical observations. Discharges were estimated using the empirical depth-average coefficient and local bathymetry. Results showed that the post-processing reduces the uncertainty bandwidth with 37% and increases the mean flow velocities with 96%.
The found discharges were compared with precipitation measurements observed at a nearby TAHMO meteorological station. The total volumetric precipitation was determined by estimating the contributing catchment using a digital elevation map and the locations of man-made drainage systems. When comparing the volumetric precipitation with the flood wave, a runoff coefficient of 53% [35-68] is found. This coefficient falls within the ranges found in literature, but is probably an underestimation of the true runoff due to an overestimation of the catchment area and underestimation of the discharges.
This study shows that the LSPIV method is feasible for continuously monitoring flood waves in an urban environment. Especially during peak flows LSPIV proves to be valuable, as observations using conventional gauging methods are labour intensive, unsafe, or not executable. Because of the possibility to monitor streams from a distance -- which ensures access to power and safety against vandalism -- there is a possibility to observe complete flood waves at regular intervals without the need for direct contact with the water. For Dar es Salaam, this method opens doors for continuous and secure stream monitoring, at low costs and with local devices. ...
LSPIV uses videos to extract surface flow velocities by tracing movements of seeds on the water's surface. Combined with the local bathymetry and water level, an estimation of the river's discharge can be made. This study consists of two sets of experiments. The first set of experiments were performed at the Dommel regarding processing software, image preparation, seeding densities, and point of views and discussed by assessing their accuracy relative to benchmark measurements -- using the mean error and root mean squared error -- and the method's precision – using the relative standard deviation.
The second set of experiments were performed along the Chuo Kikuu, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. A flood wave was monitored through the capture of 73 5 second videos. These videos were turned into separate frames and corrected for lens distortion and perspective distortion. Thereafter the frames were gray scaled and gamma correction was applied. After the LSPIV process additional filtering removed unrealistic low flow velocities, and through substitution missing velocities were replaced with flow velocities based on the vertical logarithmic progression relationship between the surface flow velocities and water depth. The surface flow velocities found using this method match optical observations. Discharges were estimated using the empirical depth-average coefficient and local bathymetry. Results showed that the post-processing reduces the uncertainty bandwidth with 37% and increases the mean flow velocities with 96%.
The found discharges were compared with precipitation measurements observed at a nearby TAHMO meteorological station. The total volumetric precipitation was determined by estimating the contributing catchment using a digital elevation map and the locations of man-made drainage systems. When comparing the volumetric precipitation with the flood wave, a runoff coefficient of 53% [35-68] is found. This coefficient falls within the ranges found in literature, but is probably an underestimation of the true runoff due to an overestimation of the catchment area and underestimation of the discharges.
This study shows that the LSPIV method is feasible for continuously monitoring flood waves in an urban environment. Especially during peak flows LSPIV proves to be valuable, as observations using conventional gauging methods are labour intensive, unsafe, or not executable. Because of the possibility to monitor streams from a distance -- which ensures access to power and safety against vandalism -- there is a possibility to observe complete flood waves at regular intervals without the need for direct contact with the water. For Dar es Salaam, this method opens doors for continuous and secure stream monitoring, at low costs and with local devices.
The remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir area was used to come up with Level-Area-Storage(LAS) relationships for the five main reservoirs in the Oum Er Rbia basin. These curves were able to approximate the present set of LAS curves well. Hence, were used in place of the local LAS curves in a water allocation decision model called RIBASIM. Thus, we had two scenarios one where the local LAS curves were used to optimize reservoir operations and the other where remotely sensed LAS curves were used instead of the local LAS curves.
The operating rule curves in the water allocation decision model were then optimized for the two scenarios. The optimization was done to maximize the performance of the system across three objectives: a)public water supply, b)irrigation and c)hydroelectricity generation. A trade-off between the three objective functions was then shown using parallel and scatter plots. It was observed that for the same set of LAS curves the performance across all three objectives improved post-optimization of the operating rule curves. This showed that there were rooms for improvement in the existing reservoir operating rule curves. The operating rule curves for the water allocation decision model with remotely sensed LAS curves were then optimized. The best set of operating rule curves that we got from the second optimization were then used with the local LAS curves to see how the system would perform with these operating rule curves. This gave us an idea of the feasibility of using remotely sensed data to come up with water management decisions and also to assess the benefits of using remotely sensed time-series data. Though the performance over the three objectives was not as good as the results we got by optimizing the system with local LAS curves, it was better than the system performance across the three objectives with the existing set of operating rules and local LAS curves. Thus, it can be used when there is a dearth of proper LAS curves.
Besides, optimizing operating rule curves, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area was used to assess the effects of sedimentation in the reservoir storage. It was observed that for larger reservoirs the percentage change is not much as compared to the smaller reservoirs. Apart from the size of the reservoir, more study is required to make a detailed analysis of how factors like topography and soil texture influence the rate of sedimentation. Despite its limitations, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area can be used to perform a qualitative analysis of the rate of sedimentation and can give reservoir authorities an idea of the need for bathymetry. This can help in avoiding unnecessary bathymetries which are infeasible both economically and physically. ...
The remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir area was used to come up with Level-Area-Storage(LAS) relationships for the five main reservoirs in the Oum Er Rbia basin. These curves were able to approximate the present set of LAS curves well. Hence, were used in place of the local LAS curves in a water allocation decision model called RIBASIM. Thus, we had two scenarios one where the local LAS curves were used to optimize reservoir operations and the other where remotely sensed LAS curves were used instead of the local LAS curves.
The operating rule curves in the water allocation decision model were then optimized for the two scenarios. The optimization was done to maximize the performance of the system across three objectives: a)public water supply, b)irrigation and c)hydroelectricity generation. A trade-off between the three objective functions was then shown using parallel and scatter plots. It was observed that for the same set of LAS curves the performance across all three objectives improved post-optimization of the operating rule curves. This showed that there were rooms for improvement in the existing reservoir operating rule curves. The operating rule curves for the water allocation decision model with remotely sensed LAS curves were then optimized. The best set of operating rule curves that we got from the second optimization were then used with the local LAS curves to see how the system would perform with these operating rule curves. This gave us an idea of the feasibility of using remotely sensed data to come up with water management decisions and also to assess the benefits of using remotely sensed time-series data. Though the performance over the three objectives was not as good as the results we got by optimizing the system with local LAS curves, it was better than the system performance across the three objectives with the existing set of operating rules and local LAS curves. Thus, it can be used when there is a dearth of proper LAS curves.
Besides, optimizing operating rule curves, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area was used to assess the effects of sedimentation in the reservoir storage. It was observed that for larger reservoirs the percentage change is not much as compared to the smaller reservoirs. Apart from the size of the reservoir, more study is required to make a detailed analysis of how factors like topography and soil texture influence the rate of sedimentation. Despite its limitations, the remotely sensed time-series data of reservoir surface area can be used to perform a qualitative analysis of the rate of sedimentation and can give reservoir authorities an idea of the need for bathymetry. This can help in avoiding unnecessary bathymetries which are infeasible both economically and physically.
The design of an early warning system for floods in Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania
A case study for the local bus company
The probability level of a flood event is determined by training the EWS with historic flood and rainfall data. In addition, the implementation of both a hydrological and relational model in the EWS was tested. The results show that the hydrological model is the better option. The results also show that the implementation of an EWS ensures a decrease in financial damage endured by the BRT-system. The produced outcome of the EWS was validated by a 'leave one out' method. This validation was done by consecutively leaving one flood event out of the historical data frame and analyzing the variability of the resulting outcome. Finally, the designed EWS is best implemented in the BRT-system alongside the EWS-systems currently in place.
...
The probability level of a flood event is determined by training the EWS with historic flood and rainfall data. In addition, the implementation of both a hydrological and relational model in the EWS was tested. The results show that the hydrological model is the better option. The results also show that the implementation of an EWS ensures a decrease in financial damage endured by the BRT-system. The produced outcome of the EWS was validated by a 'leave one out' method. This validation was done by consecutively leaving one flood event out of the historical data frame and analyzing the variability of the resulting outcome. Finally, the designed EWS is best implemented in the BRT-system alongside the EWS-systems currently in place.
Community mapping for flood modelling
A case study of the Ramani Huria community mapping project in Dar es Salaam
River-width determination by the use of optical remote sensing missions
A research based on the determination of sub-pixel accurate river-widths using optical remote sensing
Discharge is one of the conditions in a river, which is relevant to have data on during regular periods but in particular during or after extreme events. This thesis focussed on an approach, by using remote sensing, to obtain data that can be used for further research to determine discharge. River-width is one of the current variables researched to be used as a substitute for river stage data. River stage is currently used to obtain estimations for river discharge via earlier obtained river stage-discharge relations, which can be transformed into river width-discharge relations.
The objective of this thesis was to develop a method to obtain sub-pixel accurate river-width estimations by remote sensing. The objective to estimate river-widths on sub-pixel base originates from the need of river-width estimations with higher accuracy than the freely available optical satellite resolutions of 10 to 20 metres. The study contains the improvement of the current water classification methods by including analyses for discriminating band combinations, to construct site-specific indices. This was noticed to be needed, due to the conventional indices, like the NDWI, performing differently with the presence of certain land types.
By having multiple indices based on uncorrelated satellite bands transformed into probability bands, it is possible to combine indices, via Bayes theorem. Based on the site-specific indices and index combinations, the aim is to develop relations between spectral information and water fractions of pixels that could lead to a more detailed river-width estimation by including sub-pixel information.
The resulting method was able to show discriminating abilities in satellite bands and band combinations, specifically for an area of interest, other than the conventional NDWI and MNDWI. With the use of river edge information, the spectral bands could be transformed into spatial water probability bands, indicating a probability for the present pixels to be water. The probability indices and index combinations showed to reduce a large part of the occurring misclassifications. With the use of ROC curves, to assess the classification performance of the indices and combination of indices, variation in misclassification of certain land types between days were observed for certain indices.
The probability bands, which are based on the river’s edge value distribution, also seemed to be useful, especially for the pan-sharpened MNDWI and the Bayes 0-3 indices, to obtain the needed water fraction relations for sub-pixel base estimations. A comparison in river-width estimation of a conventional automated water classification method; Otsu’s thresholding method and a Supervised training map classification method were made against the use of probability indices with sub-pixel water fraction relationships. It was found that the use of sub-pixel information resulted in a significant improvement of the accuracy for river-width estimations. For the first and second fieldwork day, the average river-width deviations of the pan-sharpened MNDWI and Bayes0-3 decreased, respectively, from 16 and 9 metres, to under 5 and 7 metre deviation by including the found water fraction relationships. ...
Discharge is one of the conditions in a river, which is relevant to have data on during regular periods but in particular during or after extreme events. This thesis focussed on an approach, by using remote sensing, to obtain data that can be used for further research to determine discharge. River-width is one of the current variables researched to be used as a substitute for river stage data. River stage is currently used to obtain estimations for river discharge via earlier obtained river stage-discharge relations, which can be transformed into river width-discharge relations.
The objective of this thesis was to develop a method to obtain sub-pixel accurate river-width estimations by remote sensing. The objective to estimate river-widths on sub-pixel base originates from the need of river-width estimations with higher accuracy than the freely available optical satellite resolutions of 10 to 20 metres. The study contains the improvement of the current water classification methods by including analyses for discriminating band combinations, to construct site-specific indices. This was noticed to be needed, due to the conventional indices, like the NDWI, performing differently with the presence of certain land types.
By having multiple indices based on uncorrelated satellite bands transformed into probability bands, it is possible to combine indices, via Bayes theorem. Based on the site-specific indices and index combinations, the aim is to develop relations between spectral information and water fractions of pixels that could lead to a more detailed river-width estimation by including sub-pixel information.
The resulting method was able to show discriminating abilities in satellite bands and band combinations, specifically for an area of interest, other than the conventional NDWI and MNDWI. With the use of river edge information, the spectral bands could be transformed into spatial water probability bands, indicating a probability for the present pixels to be water. The probability indices and index combinations showed to reduce a large part of the occurring misclassifications. With the use of ROC curves, to assess the classification performance of the indices and combination of indices, variation in misclassification of certain land types between days were observed for certain indices.
The probability bands, which are based on the river’s edge value distribution, also seemed to be useful, especially for the pan-sharpened MNDWI and the Bayes 0-3 indices, to obtain the needed water fraction relations for sub-pixel base estimations. A comparison in river-width estimation of a conventional automated water classification method; Otsu’s thresholding method and a Supervised training map classification method were made against the use of probability indices with sub-pixel water fraction relationships. It was found that the use of sub-pixel information resulted in a significant improvement of the accuracy for river-width estimations. For the first and second fieldwork day, the average river-width deviations of the pan-sharpened MNDWI and Bayes0-3 decreased, respectively, from 16 and 9 metres, to under 5 and 7 metre deviation by including the found water fraction relationships.
(VOD) in March are used, the latter obtained from satellite data company VanderSat. The final set of predictors and predictands is narrowed down based on which data is available and with which quality (timeliness, reliability, accuracy). Initial results, show higher accuracy and weighted accuracy values for the models including soil moisture data compared to the ones without soil moisture, expect for the last month in the growing season, where it give opposite results. The outcome of the model can support humanitarian organisations to increase the lead time necessary to act upon a drought trigger and reduce the impact of such event. ...
(VOD) in March are used, the latter obtained from satellite data company VanderSat. The final set of predictors and predictands is narrowed down based on which data is available and with which quality (timeliness, reliability, accuracy). Initial results, show higher accuracy and weighted accuracy values for the models including soil moisture data compared to the ones without soil moisture, expect for the last month in the growing season, where it give opposite results. The outcome of the model can support humanitarian organisations to increase the lead time necessary to act upon a drought trigger and reduce the impact of such event.
Droughts and Decisions
Pastoralism, Decision Junctures and Rain Forecasting
Community mapped elevation through a low-cost, dual-frequency GNSS receiver
A performance study in Delft (the Netherlands) and Dar es Salaam (Tanzania)
Remote river rating in Zambia
A case study in the Luangwa river basin