C. Wehrmann
Please Note
33 records found
1
Steering the story
Assessing narrative-shift potential in mobility-focused urban living labs
This thesis investigates how the narrative-shift potential of mobility-focused urban living labs can be assessed and translates this into a practical design-support tool for organisers. Narrative-shift potential is defined as the extent to which a living lab contains theoretically grounded design conditions that may support participants or relevant actors in engaging with, reflecting on and possibly adopting or diffusing an alternative mobility narrative. The thesis does not measure actual participant-level narrative change.
The thesis consists of two main sections: a research and design section. The research section is aimed at answering the research question: “How can the narrative-shift potential of mobility-focused urban living labs be assessed?”. The design section is aimed at answering the design question: “How can the assessment of narrative-shift potential be translated into a practical design-support tool for organisers of mobility-focused urban living labs?”.
The research combines a targeted literature review, rubric development and qualitative multiple-case study analysis. Literature on mobility narratives, narrative persuasion and urban living labs is synthesised into six mechanisms associated with narrative-shift potential: deep immersion, reflexivity, participatory approach, socio-spatial relevance, network nurturing and social network inclusion. These mechanisms are operationalised into a ULL characterisation rubric and applied to three real-world cases: GEMINI, ALTHEA and sCOOL2walk.
The analysis shows that across cases, socio-spatial relevance, deep immersion and network nurturing are relatively strong, while reflexivity and social network inclusion are less deliberately developed. This suggests that mobility-focused urban living labs may already contain implicit narrative-shift potential, but that this potential is not always intentionally recognised or designed for.
The design phase translates these findings into the ULL Optimisation Tool, consisting of a ULL framing canvas, assessment rubric, mechanism prompt cards and optimisation canvas. A validation step led to the addition of a living lab fit check, a clearer distinction between target groups, users and enabling actors, and an explicit access check before participant-facing interventions are selected. The final output is a workshop-based tool that helps organisers define the intended narrative shift, assess mechanism expression, prioritise improvement opportunities and translate them into design interventions.
The tool helps organisers make narrative-shift potential explicit and identify context-specific opportunities for strengthening it. The thesis contributes a theoretically grounded and practically usable approach for assessing and designing conditions associated with narrative-shift potential in mobility-focused urban living labs. ...
This thesis investigates how the narrative-shift potential of mobility-focused urban living labs can be assessed and translates this into a practical design-support tool for organisers. Narrative-shift potential is defined as the extent to which a living lab contains theoretically grounded design conditions that may support participants or relevant actors in engaging with, reflecting on and possibly adopting or diffusing an alternative mobility narrative. The thesis does not measure actual participant-level narrative change.
The thesis consists of two main sections: a research and design section. The research section is aimed at answering the research question: “How can the narrative-shift potential of mobility-focused urban living labs be assessed?”. The design section is aimed at answering the design question: “How can the assessment of narrative-shift potential be translated into a practical design-support tool for organisers of mobility-focused urban living labs?”.
The research combines a targeted literature review, rubric development and qualitative multiple-case study analysis. Literature on mobility narratives, narrative persuasion and urban living labs is synthesised into six mechanisms associated with narrative-shift potential: deep immersion, reflexivity, participatory approach, socio-spatial relevance, network nurturing and social network inclusion. These mechanisms are operationalised into a ULL characterisation rubric and applied to three real-world cases: GEMINI, ALTHEA and sCOOL2walk.
The analysis shows that across cases, socio-spatial relevance, deep immersion and network nurturing are relatively strong, while reflexivity and social network inclusion are less deliberately developed. This suggests that mobility-focused urban living labs may already contain implicit narrative-shift potential, but that this potential is not always intentionally recognised or designed for.
The design phase translates these findings into the ULL Optimisation Tool, consisting of a ULL framing canvas, assessment rubric, mechanism prompt cards and optimisation canvas. A validation step led to the addition of a living lab fit check, a clearer distinction between target groups, users and enabling actors, and an explicit access check before participant-facing interventions are selected. The final output is a workshop-based tool that helps organisers define the intended narrative shift, assess mechanism expression, prioritise improvement opportunities and translate them into design interventions.
The tool helps organisers make narrative-shift potential explicit and identify context-specific opportunities for strengthening it. The thesis contributes a theoretically grounded and practically usable approach for assessing and designing conditions associated with narrative-shift potential in mobility-focused urban living labs.
Supporting the expert judgement process for quantifying uncertainties in policy research
A case study of the unique challenges with implementing structured expert elicitation for projecting policy effects
When research is performed to project policy effects, the context is so volatile that the accuracy of experts' judgements cannot be validated. Moreover, experts may focus on quantifying uncertainty while ignoring extreme uncertainties (war, future technological inventions), operating from a status quo point of view, in order to support the policy relevance of their research. This leads to a unique context of the expert judgement process. It is unclear how experts address expert judgement in this practice. Moreover, it is not yet known what problems may limit application of SEE protocols in this context.
I worked with the PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency to evaluate their expert judgement process for the KEV (The Climate and Energy Outlook). On a yearly basis their (sector) experts are required to judge dozens of uncertain variables for the projections of the progress on climate and energy goals. This includes policy effects, external factors like weather, and also scientific uncertainties like the inherent uncertainty of the models that are used for the projections.
How can practitioners in the policy research field be supported in implementing structured expert elicitation to improve their expert judgement?
To answer this research question and address it through communication design, I followed the Double Diamond method for design-based research (Discover-Define-Develop-Deliver). For the duration of a year, I was an intern at PBL, allowing me to observe and discuss their methodology, while inquiring after what problems they face. I helped organise a pilot for implementation of the IDEA protocol for structured expert elicitation. To evaluate this pilot I designed a focus group session with all different actors involved in the KEV project. Next, to discuss challenges and develop possible solutions I organised a co-design workshop with (sector) experts from different teams that work on the KEV.
The results show that experts face several unique challenges in their expert judgement process, which are not directly addressed by SEE protocols. The IDEA protocol shows promise to improve quality of judgements and transparency through increased documentation. However, the protocol lacks support experts say they require to select what uncertainties to address in their research, as well as adequate support to quantify their uncertainty interval.
Siloed teams lead to diverging methodology and definitions, as well as missing overall problem demarcation. Because there is limited opportunity for feedback on the accuracy of experts' judgements, there is no universal measure of what makes a judgement 'good'.
To address the problems faced by the practitioners at PBL, I designed an instructional video. It informs experts about SEE and provides tangible examples and actionable steps the practitioners can take on the short and long term, on the individual and organisational level. This provides the researchers with the knowledge and control to improve their own practice. At the same time, the video also acknowledges the unique challenges the experts face and reassures them of the confidence they can have in their practice to make decisions. By targeting both teamleaders and sector experts, the facilitating party and the practicing party are involved and given agency in this process.
Therefore, research requiring expert judgement on policy uncertainties presents some unique challenges in the expert judgement process. When accuracy cannot be used as a measure of quality, it is important that the researchers invest in the credibility of the methodology. SEE can provide structure and transparency, but additional instructions and methods are needed to support experts to confidently make judgements that balance accuracy and information.
Though this case study focuses on a specific organisation and group of experts, the lessons learned from this study indicate a variety of challenges when applying SEE in different research domains and contexts. This could possible indicate the stagnated implementation in practice. Additionally, this research and the development of structured expert elicitation for policy assessment support credibility of expert judgement in this political environment. ...
When research is performed to project policy effects, the context is so volatile that the accuracy of experts' judgements cannot be validated. Moreover, experts may focus on quantifying uncertainty while ignoring extreme uncertainties (war, future technological inventions), operating from a status quo point of view, in order to support the policy relevance of their research. This leads to a unique context of the expert judgement process. It is unclear how experts address expert judgement in this practice. Moreover, it is not yet known what problems may limit application of SEE protocols in this context.
I worked with the PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency to evaluate their expert judgement process for the KEV (The Climate and Energy Outlook). On a yearly basis their (sector) experts are required to judge dozens of uncertain variables for the projections of the progress on climate and energy goals. This includes policy effects, external factors like weather, and also scientific uncertainties like the inherent uncertainty of the models that are used for the projections.
How can practitioners in the policy research field be supported in implementing structured expert elicitation to improve their expert judgement?
To answer this research question and address it through communication design, I followed the Double Diamond method for design-based research (Discover-Define-Develop-Deliver). For the duration of a year, I was an intern at PBL, allowing me to observe and discuss their methodology, while inquiring after what problems they face. I helped organise a pilot for implementation of the IDEA protocol for structured expert elicitation. To evaluate this pilot I designed a focus group session with all different actors involved in the KEV project. Next, to discuss challenges and develop possible solutions I organised a co-design workshop with (sector) experts from different teams that work on the KEV.
The results show that experts face several unique challenges in their expert judgement process, which are not directly addressed by SEE protocols. The IDEA protocol shows promise to improve quality of judgements and transparency through increased documentation. However, the protocol lacks support experts say they require to select what uncertainties to address in their research, as well as adequate support to quantify their uncertainty interval.
Siloed teams lead to diverging methodology and definitions, as well as missing overall problem demarcation. Because there is limited opportunity for feedback on the accuracy of experts' judgements, there is no universal measure of what makes a judgement 'good'.
To address the problems faced by the practitioners at PBL, I designed an instructional video. It informs experts about SEE and provides tangible examples and actionable steps the practitioners can take on the short and long term, on the individual and organisational level. This provides the researchers with the knowledge and control to improve their own practice. At the same time, the video also acknowledges the unique challenges the experts face and reassures them of the confidence they can have in their practice to make decisions. By targeting both teamleaders and sector experts, the facilitating party and the practicing party are involved and given agency in this process.
Therefore, research requiring expert judgement on policy uncertainties presents some unique challenges in the expert judgement process. When accuracy cannot be used as a measure of quality, it is important that the researchers invest in the credibility of the methodology. SEE can provide structure and transparency, but additional instructions and methods are needed to support experts to confidently make judgements that balance accuracy and information.
Though this case study focuses on a specific organisation and group of experts, the lessons learned from this study indicate a variety of challenges when applying SEE in different research domains and contexts. This could possible indicate the stagnated implementation in practice. Additionally, this research and the development of structured expert elicitation for policy assessment support credibility of expert judgement in this political environment.
Lost in translation
Why fundamental findings are not translated to medical contexts, and how to optimize the translational activity in the neuroscience field
For this study, semi structured interviews were held with researchers from varying backgrounds in either fundamental, translational or clinical neuroscience. Transcripts were coded using iterative coding strategies and analysed for common themes. Based on this analysis, it seems expertise regarding effective translational research is not widely available, collaborators are difficult to find, and resources are sometimes only available for those with interdisciplinary collaborators. There seems to be an interest among researchers in a professional body focussing on translation embedded within the research institute. This body would have a role in helping find collaborators, increasing crosstalk and connections between clinical and fundamental researchers, as well as serving as a source of expertise regarding best translational practises.
These organisations, often called intermediaries, are characterised through three main roles: the knowledge broker, the network manager, and the system transitioner. Based on these three roles and available literature, different intermediary organisations are discussed through a novel framework that builds upon existing models from different fields. Two case studies are used to validate the framework and further explore trade offs and strategic choices made during the founding of the organisation or transitioning to a new strategy. Interviews with experts involved in these organisations were held and used to compare these two organisations based on the proposed framework. Based on their relationship to bridging and bonding social capital, autonomy, and knowledge aggregation, a first proposal is made regarding the best approach for this translational intermediary.
This intermediary tasked with optimizing the translational activity in the neuroscience field should be tasked with collecting and maintaining knowledge, be a centralised organisations with strong ties with different researchers in the network, and function autonomously from any existing institution. ...
For this study, semi structured interviews were held with researchers from varying backgrounds in either fundamental, translational or clinical neuroscience. Transcripts were coded using iterative coding strategies and analysed for common themes. Based on this analysis, it seems expertise regarding effective translational research is not widely available, collaborators are difficult to find, and resources are sometimes only available for those with interdisciplinary collaborators. There seems to be an interest among researchers in a professional body focussing on translation embedded within the research institute. This body would have a role in helping find collaborators, increasing crosstalk and connections between clinical and fundamental researchers, as well as serving as a source of expertise regarding best translational practises.
These organisations, often called intermediaries, are characterised through three main roles: the knowledge broker, the network manager, and the system transitioner. Based on these three roles and available literature, different intermediary organisations are discussed through a novel framework that builds upon existing models from different fields. Two case studies are used to validate the framework and further explore trade offs and strategic choices made during the founding of the organisation or transitioning to a new strategy. Interviews with experts involved in these organisations were held and used to compare these two organisations based on the proposed framework. Based on their relationship to bridging and bonding social capital, autonomy, and knowledge aggregation, a first proposal is made regarding the best approach for this translational intermediary.
This intermediary tasked with optimizing the translational activity in the neuroscience field should be tasked with collecting and maintaining knowledge, be a centralised organisations with strong ties with different researchers in the network, and function autonomously from any existing institution.
Overcoming challenges for the implementation of swale monitoring
An overview from the current practice to implementation
The research had two main objectives: (1) to explore current practice in research and in Dutch municipalities to identify performance criteria and monitoring techniques for swales to track the key functions of swales, and (2) to investigate motivators and challenges for municipal swale monitoring and develop a communication tool to address these.
A systematic literature review identified five key swale functions: water quantity, water quality, biodiversity, liveability and wellbeing. Water quantity and water quality functions are relatively well studied, with swales proven to reduce runoff and remove certain pollutants when properly designed and maintained. However, research is still lacking for the functions biodiversity, liveability, and wellbeing. The connections between the different functions were also explored, which showed the importance of recognising the connections and the influences of the different functions on each other. From this review, eight criteria were identified: infiltration rate, soil moisture, in- and outflow of pollutants, soil quality, vegetation development, temperature, resident experience and resident usage. For each criterion, quick-scan and in-depth monitoring techniques were proposed.
A survey among municipal workers who are involved with urban water management (mainly from South Holland) found that swales are seen as multifunctional objects, where water quantity and biodiversity are the most important functions. Monitoring is not part of the current practice, and swales are often only assessed on the functions during the design. However, there is interest in the implementation of monitoring, especially for water quantity and water quality. The main motivators for monitoring are to know the effect of swales on the long term and the ability to identify problems in time. The main challenges are keeping track of data and ensuring sufficient resources, like staff and budget.
To overcome these challenges, a workshop was designed to motivate practitioners to start monitoring the multiple swale functions. The workshop is aimed at municipal staff responsible for the organisation of maintenance for the different functions. By learning about the different functions and monitoring possibilities, the participants can create a monitoring plan that serves as a starting point for the actual implementation of monitoring. Evaluation by experts indicated that this workshop can motivate the target audience, because it increases the audience's awareness of swales, encourages them to consider the different functions and lets them practice with measuring, monitoring and retrieving data. It also provides them with a concrete and practical output that can be used in practice.
This study offers a framework to improve swale monitoring in the Netherlands. An overview of performance criteria with corresponding monitoring techniques is provided together with a communication tool that can bridge the gap between knowledge and practice.
...
The research had two main objectives: (1) to explore current practice in research and in Dutch municipalities to identify performance criteria and monitoring techniques for swales to track the key functions of swales, and (2) to investigate motivators and challenges for municipal swale monitoring and develop a communication tool to address these.
A systematic literature review identified five key swale functions: water quantity, water quality, biodiversity, liveability and wellbeing. Water quantity and water quality functions are relatively well studied, with swales proven to reduce runoff and remove certain pollutants when properly designed and maintained. However, research is still lacking for the functions biodiversity, liveability, and wellbeing. The connections between the different functions were also explored, which showed the importance of recognising the connections and the influences of the different functions on each other. From this review, eight criteria were identified: infiltration rate, soil moisture, in- and outflow of pollutants, soil quality, vegetation development, temperature, resident experience and resident usage. For each criterion, quick-scan and in-depth monitoring techniques were proposed.
A survey among municipal workers who are involved with urban water management (mainly from South Holland) found that swales are seen as multifunctional objects, where water quantity and biodiversity are the most important functions. Monitoring is not part of the current practice, and swales are often only assessed on the functions during the design. However, there is interest in the implementation of monitoring, especially for water quantity and water quality. The main motivators for monitoring are to know the effect of swales on the long term and the ability to identify problems in time. The main challenges are keeping track of data and ensuring sufficient resources, like staff and budget.
To overcome these challenges, a workshop was designed to motivate practitioners to start monitoring the multiple swale functions. The workshop is aimed at municipal staff responsible for the organisation of maintenance for the different functions. By learning about the different functions and monitoring possibilities, the participants can create a monitoring plan that serves as a starting point for the actual implementation of monitoring. Evaluation by experts indicated that this workshop can motivate the target audience, because it increases the audience's awareness of swales, encourages them to consider the different functions and lets them practice with measuring, monitoring and retrieving data. It also provides them with a concrete and practical output that can be used in practice.
This study offers a framework to improve swale monitoring in the Netherlands. An overview of performance criteria with corresponding monitoring techniques is provided together with a communication tool that can bridge the gap between knowledge and practice.
Encouraging Maintenance
Development of an effective communication tool and strategy through qualitative research into triggers and barriers for electrical and electronic household appliance maintenance behaviors
Based on these insights, a set of magnetic reminder cards was developed and tested. Designed for washing machines and extendable to other EEAs, these cards combine simple instructions with visual and textual cues, including an option of planning the next maintenance activity, aimed at raising awareness and recurringly motivating the required maintenance activities. ...
Based on these insights, a set of magnetic reminder cards was developed and tested. Designed for washing machines and extendable to other EEAs, these cards combine simple instructions with visual and textual cues, including an option of planning the next maintenance activity, aimed at raising awareness and recurringly motivating the required maintenance activities.
A feeling of belonging
How a creative consultancy can add to the inclusion and feeling of belonging for people with invisible disabilities within their organisation
Research question: How can the organisation of Flatland add to the inclusion and feeling of belonging for people with invisible disabilities within their organisation?
Motivation
The research is also deeply personal, as I, the author, have an ‘invisible’ disability. Throughout the research, I have used insight stemming from both my own and others’ experiences. Prioritising qualitative data and lived experiences.
The recognition of the importance of D.E.I. efforts in companies and in society, in general, is growing. However, in many aspects the research and understanding are still severely lacking. Specifically, in the realms of disability and invisible disability inclusion, there are many knowledge gaps and misconceptions. Here I see the need for more lived experience data to close those gaps.
Approach
In chapter 3 a lens for understanding the invisibly disabled experience is created. This research uses the social perspective on disability:
“[Disability] results from the interaction between persons with impairments and attitudinal and environmental barriers that hinders their full and effective participation in society on an equal basis”
Having an invisible impairment produces extra workloads. An aspect of that is interpersonal, where advocating for oneself is both essential and challenging due to misconceptions and misunderstandings. The research further focuses on the intangible feeling of feelings like belonging. Here a belonging spectrum is introduced to further analyse findings.
The first step in collecting qualitative data is a creative session held with the employees of Flatland. Here the concepts of disability, invisible disability, and belonging are introduced and explored. Through the analysis of the drawings made in the session conclusions are drawn on their expressions of belonging and their understanding and view of disability. One finding was how the drawings on belonging favoured the more concrete right side of the belonging spectrum, often leaving out the left side that focuses more on the perspectives around thoughts and feelings. For the context of Flatland, the definition of belonging was defined as:
“ My place within this group is unquestioned. Within this space I can experiment, move, take up space, and express myself as I wish and am. “
After gathering the perspective from inside Flatland research is conducted on the experiences of the invisibly disabled. Several participants are asked to fill in an assignment booklet which then forms the basis of the interviews, a method called context mapping.
The booklet has assignments on the experience of disability: belonging and receiving help. The reporting of the results focuses on retaining the complexities of this lived experience, which display complicated relationships with receiving help.
Conclusion
The conversations that were held through the booklets brought up many topics that could be linked back to the belonging spectrum and more specifically those emotional, intangible aspects. The use of this research tool made space in conversation to discuss aspects of belonging. This finding brought us to the suggestion of implementing the research booklet as a tool within Flatland. As a first step to open up these conversations and make deliberate space for the emotional aspects of belonging. The added value being that this will be especially beneficial to the invisibly disabled, for whom the onus of advocating for themselves will slightly shift to the company. However, these conversations could have a curb-cut effect and benefit all employees.
The research ends on a discussion of what topics are not covered but deserve further attention and how the research is and isn’t representative. A vitally important part of any research so intertwined and critical of representation. ...
Research question: How can the organisation of Flatland add to the inclusion and feeling of belonging for people with invisible disabilities within their organisation?
Motivation
The research is also deeply personal, as I, the author, have an ‘invisible’ disability. Throughout the research, I have used insight stemming from both my own and others’ experiences. Prioritising qualitative data and lived experiences.
The recognition of the importance of D.E.I. efforts in companies and in society, in general, is growing. However, in many aspects the research and understanding are still severely lacking. Specifically, in the realms of disability and invisible disability inclusion, there are many knowledge gaps and misconceptions. Here I see the need for more lived experience data to close those gaps.
Approach
In chapter 3 a lens for understanding the invisibly disabled experience is created. This research uses the social perspective on disability:
“[Disability] results from the interaction between persons with impairments and attitudinal and environmental barriers that hinders their full and effective participation in society on an equal basis”
Having an invisible impairment produces extra workloads. An aspect of that is interpersonal, where advocating for oneself is both essential and challenging due to misconceptions and misunderstandings. The research further focuses on the intangible feeling of feelings like belonging. Here a belonging spectrum is introduced to further analyse findings.
The first step in collecting qualitative data is a creative session held with the employees of Flatland. Here the concepts of disability, invisible disability, and belonging are introduced and explored. Through the analysis of the drawings made in the session conclusions are drawn on their expressions of belonging and their understanding and view of disability. One finding was how the drawings on belonging favoured the more concrete right side of the belonging spectrum, often leaving out the left side that focuses more on the perspectives around thoughts and feelings. For the context of Flatland, the definition of belonging was defined as:
“ My place within this group is unquestioned. Within this space I can experiment, move, take up space, and express myself as I wish and am. “
After gathering the perspective from inside Flatland research is conducted on the experiences of the invisibly disabled. Several participants are asked to fill in an assignment booklet which then forms the basis of the interviews, a method called context mapping.
The booklet has assignments on the experience of disability: belonging and receiving help. The reporting of the results focuses on retaining the complexities of this lived experience, which display complicated relationships with receiving help.
Conclusion
The conversations that were held through the booklets brought up many topics that could be linked back to the belonging spectrum and more specifically those emotional, intangible aspects. The use of this research tool made space in conversation to discuss aspects of belonging. This finding brought us to the suggestion of implementing the research booklet as a tool within Flatland. As a first step to open up these conversations and make deliberate space for the emotional aspects of belonging. The added value being that this will be especially beneficial to the invisibly disabled, for whom the onus of advocating for themselves will slightly shift to the company. However, these conversations could have a curb-cut effect and benefit all employees.
The research ends on a discussion of what topics are not covered but deserve further attention and how the research is and isn’t representative. A vitally important part of any research so intertwined and critical of representation.
Against this backdrop, it becomes essential to examine how experts in cybersecurity and quantum research perceive quantum cryptography, navigating between justified optimism and potentially misleading expectations.
Research aim and approach
This thesis explores the factors influencing the adoption of quantum cryptography in the Dutch cybersecurity industry and presents a communication tool for those who promote quantum cryptography, to help enhance future narratives surrounding adoption.
How can the opportunities and challenges of adopting quantum cryptography in the Dutch cybersecurity industry be understood through insights into stakeholder perceptions and adoption dynamics?
This is further broken down into four subquestions:
1. How is quantum cryptography perceived in the cybersecurity industry in the Netherlands?
2. Which theoretical perspectives can help explain the dynamics of innovation and technology adoptionrelevant to quantum cryptography?
3. What insights from adoption models of other security technologies can inform a tailored adoption model for quantum cryptography?
4. How do experts from cybersecurity and quantum cryptography assess the adoption of quantum cryptography in the cybersecurity industry, and which factors do they identify as most influential?
The findings to these research questions are applied in the design of a communication tool to conclude this research.
To answer these questions and apply them in a design, the research followed a triple diamond model (Discover–Define × 2 – Develop–Deliver). The first two diamonds focused on research and analysis, while the third translated findings into a communication design. The methodology combined:
1. A background study of perceptions of quantum cryptography in the cybersecurity industry;
2. The construction of a theoretical framework, drawing on adoption and innovation models;
3. A systematic literature review of adoption models for comparable disruptive security technologies (AI, blockchain, IoT);
4. Expert interviews with professionals in cybersecurity and quantum cryptography;
5. A design phase producing a communication tool to address narrative challenges.
Findings
Perceptions in the Dutch cybersecurity industry
The Dutch cybersecurity field is aware of the quantum threat but demonstrates little urgency or coordination in its response. Awareness is largely concentrated on QKD, with limited recognition of other quantum cryptographic protocols. Quantum cryptography is often viewed as a far future solution rather than an imminent opportunity.
Theoretical framework
Three dimensions help explain adoption dynamics:
• Why innovation is necessary: framed through the Red Queen hypothesis, cybersecurity is seen as a continuous race between attackers and defenders, with quantum computing as a disruptive shift.
• What drives or constrains adoption: Protection Motivation Theory highlights the role of perceived threats and coping abilities, while security economics reveals systemic disincentives for adoption.
• How adoption unfolds: models such as TAM, UTAUT, TOE, and DOI provide insights into processes of acceptance, diffusion, and integration. Together, these perspectives contextualise adoption of quantum cryptography as both a behavioural and systemic phenomenon.
Insights from adoption models of other technologies
Adoption studies of AI, blockchain, and IoT show that effective models are built by combining different theoretical frameworks and adding technology-specific factors. For quantum cryptography, a hypothetical adoption model is proposed that integrates TAM and TOE, supplemented by DOI innovation characteristics (e.g. relative advantage, complexity, compatibility). Additional factors such as perceived trust and perceived security are highlighted, given their critical importance in the context of data security
technologies.
Expert assessments and influential factors
Interviews revealed that adoption of quantum cryptography will depend most strongly on
• A convincing business case (marketing and relative advantage);
• Environmental drivers (standards, certifications, and government regulations);
• Social influence, including hype and lobbying.
Barriers are predominantly technological (complexity, immaturity, fragility of infrastructure, comparison with capabilities of classical cryptography) and organisational (knowledge gaps in both cybersecurity and quantum communities, cost considerations). Importantly, many factors interact: for example, complexity undermines perceived ease of use and trust, while immaturity diminishes relative advantage. To capture these interdependencies, an infographic synthesis was developed, mapping adoption factors, their relationships, and stakeholder perspectives. This visualisation serves both as an analytical synthesis and a decision-support tool, highlighting factors that have greater or more direct impacts on adoption intention and how their effects are viewed by stakeholders.
Design contribution
Building on the findings, a communication tool was designed to address the issue of fragmented narratives. Stakeholders often rely on a single narrative, such as the hype of absolute security. This oversimplifies the reality of quantum cryptography and risks undermining trust. The design introduces the ”Dice of Narratives of Quantum Cryptography”, a metaphorical cube with six narrative perspectives. Just as one cannot see all faces of a dice at once, stakeholders rarely perceive all narratives simultaneously. Rolling the dice becomes a way to encounter multiple perspectives, emphasising that only by combining narratives one can make a more balanced and trustworthy story. The tool is intended for use in policy workshops on conferences (e.g. Quantum Meets), engaging stakeholders such as policymakers, industry leaders, and advocates. By encouraging participants to combine and compare narratives, the tool promotes more nuanced discussions between stakeholder, so future users can make better informed decisions.
Future research directions
This exploratory study of quantum cryptography adoption in the Dutch cybersecurity industry suggests several avenues for further research. First, the proposed hypothetical adoption model could be validated through larger-scale surveys to assess the relative weight and interactions of factors across stakeholders. Longitudinal studies could track how perceptions evolve alongside technical developments and pilot projects. Comparative research across countries would reveal how adoption dynamics differ under varying levels of investment, regulation, and infrastructure readiness. The influence of hype, lobbying, and narratives needs deeper investigation, starting with systematic mapping of currently circulating narratives in industry, policy, and media. The role of standards and certifications on trust, investment decisions, and experimentation should also be explored. Finally, the adoption dynamics infographic that resulted from this research, provides additional paths for design-oriented studies, investigating how different lines of influence can be visualised, communicated, and tested in practice.
...
Against this backdrop, it becomes essential to examine how experts in cybersecurity and quantum research perceive quantum cryptography, navigating between justified optimism and potentially misleading expectations.
Research aim and approach
This thesis explores the factors influencing the adoption of quantum cryptography in the Dutch cybersecurity industry and presents a communication tool for those who promote quantum cryptography, to help enhance future narratives surrounding adoption.
How can the opportunities and challenges of adopting quantum cryptography in the Dutch cybersecurity industry be understood through insights into stakeholder perceptions and adoption dynamics?
This is further broken down into four subquestions:
1. How is quantum cryptography perceived in the cybersecurity industry in the Netherlands?
2. Which theoretical perspectives can help explain the dynamics of innovation and technology adoptionrelevant to quantum cryptography?
3. What insights from adoption models of other security technologies can inform a tailored adoption model for quantum cryptography?
4. How do experts from cybersecurity and quantum cryptography assess the adoption of quantum cryptography in the cybersecurity industry, and which factors do they identify as most influential?
The findings to these research questions are applied in the design of a communication tool to conclude this research.
To answer these questions and apply them in a design, the research followed a triple diamond model (Discover–Define × 2 – Develop–Deliver). The first two diamonds focused on research and analysis, while the third translated findings into a communication design. The methodology combined:
1. A background study of perceptions of quantum cryptography in the cybersecurity industry;
2. The construction of a theoretical framework, drawing on adoption and innovation models;
3. A systematic literature review of adoption models for comparable disruptive security technologies (AI, blockchain, IoT);
4. Expert interviews with professionals in cybersecurity and quantum cryptography;
5. A design phase producing a communication tool to address narrative challenges.
Findings
Perceptions in the Dutch cybersecurity industry
The Dutch cybersecurity field is aware of the quantum threat but demonstrates little urgency or coordination in its response. Awareness is largely concentrated on QKD, with limited recognition of other quantum cryptographic protocols. Quantum cryptography is often viewed as a far future solution rather than an imminent opportunity.
Theoretical framework
Three dimensions help explain adoption dynamics:
• Why innovation is necessary: framed through the Red Queen hypothesis, cybersecurity is seen as a continuous race between attackers and defenders, with quantum computing as a disruptive shift.
• What drives or constrains adoption: Protection Motivation Theory highlights the role of perceived threats and coping abilities, while security economics reveals systemic disincentives for adoption.
• How adoption unfolds: models such as TAM, UTAUT, TOE, and DOI provide insights into processes of acceptance, diffusion, and integration. Together, these perspectives contextualise adoption of quantum cryptography as both a behavioural and systemic phenomenon.
Insights from adoption models of other technologies
Adoption studies of AI, blockchain, and IoT show that effective models are built by combining different theoretical frameworks and adding technology-specific factors. For quantum cryptography, a hypothetical adoption model is proposed that integrates TAM and TOE, supplemented by DOI innovation characteristics (e.g. relative advantage, complexity, compatibility). Additional factors such as perceived trust and perceived security are highlighted, given their critical importance in the context of data security
technologies.
Expert assessments and influential factors
Interviews revealed that adoption of quantum cryptography will depend most strongly on
• A convincing business case (marketing and relative advantage);
• Environmental drivers (standards, certifications, and government regulations);
• Social influence, including hype and lobbying.
Barriers are predominantly technological (complexity, immaturity, fragility of infrastructure, comparison with capabilities of classical cryptography) and organisational (knowledge gaps in both cybersecurity and quantum communities, cost considerations). Importantly, many factors interact: for example, complexity undermines perceived ease of use and trust, while immaturity diminishes relative advantage. To capture these interdependencies, an infographic synthesis was developed, mapping adoption factors, their relationships, and stakeholder perspectives. This visualisation serves both as an analytical synthesis and a decision-support tool, highlighting factors that have greater or more direct impacts on adoption intention and how their effects are viewed by stakeholders.
Design contribution
Building on the findings, a communication tool was designed to address the issue of fragmented narratives. Stakeholders often rely on a single narrative, such as the hype of absolute security. This oversimplifies the reality of quantum cryptography and risks undermining trust. The design introduces the ”Dice of Narratives of Quantum Cryptography”, a metaphorical cube with six narrative perspectives. Just as one cannot see all faces of a dice at once, stakeholders rarely perceive all narratives simultaneously. Rolling the dice becomes a way to encounter multiple perspectives, emphasising that only by combining narratives one can make a more balanced and trustworthy story. The tool is intended for use in policy workshops on conferences (e.g. Quantum Meets), engaging stakeholders such as policymakers, industry leaders, and advocates. By encouraging participants to combine and compare narratives, the tool promotes more nuanced discussions between stakeholder, so future users can make better informed decisions.
Future research directions
This exploratory study of quantum cryptography adoption in the Dutch cybersecurity industry suggests several avenues for further research. First, the proposed hypothetical adoption model could be validated through larger-scale surveys to assess the relative weight and interactions of factors across stakeholders. Longitudinal studies could track how perceptions evolve alongside technical developments and pilot projects. Comparative research across countries would reveal how adoption dynamics differ under varying levels of investment, regulation, and infrastructure readiness. The influence of hype, lobbying, and narratives needs deeper investigation, starting with systematic mapping of currently circulating narratives in industry, policy, and media. The role of standards and certifications on trust, investment decisions, and experimentation should also be explored. Finally, the adoption dynamics infographic that resulted from this research, provides additional paths for design-oriented studies, investigating how different lines of influence can be visualised, communicated, and tested in practice.
Stimulating Publishing Open Educational Resources within the Industrial Design Engineering Faculty
Researching the motivational factors that influence teachers from the Industrial Design Engineering bachelor to publish and/or create open educational resources
This thesis starts by using literature to create a combined framework which combined the reasoned action approach with the OER adoption pyramid. This combined framework showed multiple factors that are relevant in influencing the motivation of teachers to create or publish OER. These motivational factors were incorporated into the questions and topics that were discussed in the semi structured interviews. The outcome of the interviews was compiled into a causal loop diagram that showed how different factors influence the willingness of teachers to create or publish OER. The causal loop diagram also showed how some factors could be both a driver and barrier depending on the situation. Based on the interview results the critical nodes were identified in the causal loop diagram. The critical nodes being: available time, perceived institutional support, perceive time and effort it cost to publish OER, clarity in expectations of OER, social responsibility to create/publish OER, Sharing ER with colleagues.
Using the critical nodes, a design goal was formulated. This design goal resulted in the design of a roadmap that laid out the phases in which the TU Delft can support IDE teachers in publishing their educational resources as open educational resources. The first phase addresses the creation of a designated support team and spreading awareness about OER. The second phase outlines that teachers first publish in a closed system, since sharing their material with colleagues is something teachers already do. During the second phase the educational material will also be improved via peer-to-peer feedback and the support team will ensure the quality. In the final phase the material will be published as open educational resource.
In conclusion, using this roadmap should make it easier to increase the creation and publication of OER at the IDE faculty by lowering barriers for teachers and playing into teachers’ drivers. For further research, it is recommended to validate the design and look into possible differences between teachers for master and bachelor courses. ...
This thesis starts by using literature to create a combined framework which combined the reasoned action approach with the OER adoption pyramid. This combined framework showed multiple factors that are relevant in influencing the motivation of teachers to create or publish OER. These motivational factors were incorporated into the questions and topics that were discussed in the semi structured interviews. The outcome of the interviews was compiled into a causal loop diagram that showed how different factors influence the willingness of teachers to create or publish OER. The causal loop diagram also showed how some factors could be both a driver and barrier depending on the situation. Based on the interview results the critical nodes were identified in the causal loop diagram. The critical nodes being: available time, perceived institutional support, perceive time and effort it cost to publish OER, clarity in expectations of OER, social responsibility to create/publish OER, Sharing ER with colleagues.
Using the critical nodes, a design goal was formulated. This design goal resulted in the design of a roadmap that laid out the phases in which the TU Delft can support IDE teachers in publishing their educational resources as open educational resources. The first phase addresses the creation of a designated support team and spreading awareness about OER. The second phase outlines that teachers first publish in a closed system, since sharing their material with colleagues is something teachers already do. During the second phase the educational material will also be improved via peer-to-peer feedback and the support team will ensure the quality. In the final phase the material will be published as open educational resource.
In conclusion, using this roadmap should make it easier to increase the creation and publication of OER at the IDE faculty by lowering barriers for teachers and playing into teachers’ drivers. For further research, it is recommended to validate the design and look into possible differences between teachers for master and bachelor courses.
Eyes on the Tracks: Train Driver Acceptance of Driver Condition Monitoring Systems
Exploring how to Promote Acceptance in the Design of an Alertness Feedback System based on Eye Measurements
An explorative, qualitative approach led to conducting focus groups with train drivers and office employees to investigate the sensitive topic of alertness. In total, four train drivers and four office employees participated. To analyze the results qualitatively, thematic analysis was performed by coding iteratively. For current alertness strategies, the results showed that drivers recognize sleepiness the most, while fatigue and mind-wandering (task-related tiredness) are perceived as similar to sleepiness. Distraction was not recognized, as they are occupied more with a ’distributing’ and ’prioritizing’ their attention. Designing DCM feedback in a way that promotes acceptance is proposed to consider how drivers find a device useful, how their perceptions of autonomy and competence are influenced, and how to foster the trust towards the organization with respect to data use. The conclusions call for considering both rational factors (perceived usefulness) and affective factors (as a feeling of competence and autonomy might be related to intrinsic motivation) in the design of alertness feedback systems for train drivers. ...
An explorative, qualitative approach led to conducting focus groups with train drivers and office employees to investigate the sensitive topic of alertness. In total, four train drivers and four office employees participated. To analyze the results qualitatively, thematic analysis was performed by coding iteratively. For current alertness strategies, the results showed that drivers recognize sleepiness the most, while fatigue and mind-wandering (task-related tiredness) are perceived as similar to sleepiness. Distraction was not recognized, as they are occupied more with a ’distributing’ and ’prioritizing’ their attention. Designing DCM feedback in a way that promotes acceptance is proposed to consider how drivers find a device useful, how their perceptions of autonomy and competence are influenced, and how to foster the trust towards the organization with respect to data use. The conclusions call for considering both rational factors (perceived usefulness) and affective factors (as a feeling of competence and autonomy might be related to intrinsic motivation) in the design of alertness feedback systems for train drivers.
The academic changemaker
Helping climate and energy researchers reflect on their role in action-oriented transdisciplinary collaborations
The attitude of anesthesia assistants towards Artificial Intelligence-assisted patient monitoring in the Operating Room
Using the knowledge on their attitude and motivation to create an educational module that supports anesthesia assistants in their awareness and understanding of the impact of AI-assisted monitoring
Through literature research and semi-structured interviews, it was found that among anesthesia assistants there is little knowledge on the possibilities of AI at the OR, but that their attitude towards AI-assisted monitoring is positive as long as only suggestions are given. Only two out of eight anesthesia assistants are cautiously positive towards the possibility of AI to automate the monitoring process. Furthermore, it was found that the motivational factors of autonomy, relatedness, competence, self-efficacy, and self-actualisation are all important to very important in the motivation of anesthesia assistants. Overall, none of these factors stands out in being most or least important. The expected impact of AI on these motivational factors among anesthesia assistants varies from negative to positive and is highly dependent on the form of AI-assisted monitoring. As various forms of interrelatedness between all these motivational factors are identified by the anesthesia assistants, specific to their working practice and environment, the impact on one motivational factor might indirectly also impact others.
These results on attitude and motivation are incorporated in the design of an educational module for anesthesia assistants. The module consists of two parts. One part regarding AI-assisted monitoring and one part regarding the motivational factors that are important for their motivation and the impact of AI on motivation. Design requirements by the anesthesia assistants, as well as an expert validation by an anesthesia educator, are used to finalise the design of the module. This module can help anesthesia assistants to develop awareness and understanding of how AI-assisted monitoring, in the form of giving suggestions, can support them in their patient monitoring task. Furthermore, it helps them to develop awareness and understanding on their own motivation and the impact that the use of AI-assisted monitoring may have on their motivation, guiding them towards becoming deliberate professionals. ...
Through literature research and semi-structured interviews, it was found that among anesthesia assistants there is little knowledge on the possibilities of AI at the OR, but that their attitude towards AI-assisted monitoring is positive as long as only suggestions are given. Only two out of eight anesthesia assistants are cautiously positive towards the possibility of AI to automate the monitoring process. Furthermore, it was found that the motivational factors of autonomy, relatedness, competence, self-efficacy, and self-actualisation are all important to very important in the motivation of anesthesia assistants. Overall, none of these factors stands out in being most or least important. The expected impact of AI on these motivational factors among anesthesia assistants varies from negative to positive and is highly dependent on the form of AI-assisted monitoring. As various forms of interrelatedness between all these motivational factors are identified by the anesthesia assistants, specific to their working practice and environment, the impact on one motivational factor might indirectly also impact others.
These results on attitude and motivation are incorporated in the design of an educational module for anesthesia assistants. The module consists of two parts. One part regarding AI-assisted monitoring and one part regarding the motivational factors that are important for their motivation and the impact of AI on motivation. Design requirements by the anesthesia assistants, as well as an expert validation by an anesthesia educator, are used to finalise the design of the module. This module can help anesthesia assistants to develop awareness and understanding of how AI-assisted monitoring, in the form of giving suggestions, can support them in their patient monitoring task. Furthermore, it helps them to develop awareness and understanding on their own motivation and the impact that the use of AI-assisted monitoring may have on their motivation, guiding them towards becoming deliberate professionals.
Expanding Through Collisions
A Dual Perspective on the Future of a Synthetic Cell
Collaboration through a game
A design-based research on the controversy in the case of peat meadow areas in the Netherlands
To create a situation in which stakeholders can work together towards a solution instead of just focusing on their own priorities, the stakeholders should take a step back and build trust on other levels with the different stakeholder groups. This should help them to open up to insights that other stakeholders may have, which could lead to a situation in which they could work together. With this as a foundation, a participatory tool was chosen that could help to build a situation for a more effective collaboration: a serious game. The digital board game ‘Samen door het veen' (translation: Together through the peat) was designed, played with representative players, and analysed with the concepts of collaboration and double loop learning. The results showed that the players built more trust during the game and gained more insight into the perspective of other players, so the game seems to achieve its goals quite well. It can be concluded that the game is fun to play and that it has quite some potential for stimulating double loop learning and creating a situation in which more effective collaboration could take place. ...
To create a situation in which stakeholders can work together towards a solution instead of just focusing on their own priorities, the stakeholders should take a step back and build trust on other levels with the different stakeholder groups. This should help them to open up to insights that other stakeholders may have, which could lead to a situation in which they could work together. With this as a foundation, a participatory tool was chosen that could help to build a situation for a more effective collaboration: a serious game. The digital board game ‘Samen door het veen' (translation: Together through the peat) was designed, played with representative players, and analysed with the concepts of collaboration and double loop learning. The results showed that the players built more trust during the game and gained more insight into the perspective of other players, so the game seems to achieve its goals quite well. It can be concluded that the game is fun to play and that it has quite some potential for stimulating double loop learning and creating a situation in which more effective collaboration could take place.
Creating adaptive master Applied Mathematics graduates
Closing the gap between programme and professional career
Development of a communication strategy for thorium molten salt reactor research
Negotiating nuclear energy in the Dutch energy transition
Energy from the surface
Structural geology and fracture network characterisation of the Daly Waters Arch, Northern Territory (Australia) & communication approach for technical uncertainties in geothermal energy implementation in the Dutch energy transition
The second part of the report focuses on the Netherlands, where ambitious goals have been set for the implementation of geothermal energy in the energy transition. During the gas production in Groningen, a negative social perspective towards mining operations, in general, was developed. For the implementation of geothermal energy, an approach for the communication of technical uncertainties between the initiators and the local public of a geothermal project is designed in this study. Technical uncertainties that are present in geothermal energy implementation in the Netherlands have been identified during semi-structured expert-interviews with different stakeholders in the spectrum of geothermal energy. The approach addresses guidelines for the communication of the context, the goal, the technical uncertainties present in the geothermal project, the main communicating actors, their reference frames, and the situation in which the communication process takes place. ...
The second part of the report focuses on the Netherlands, where ambitious goals have been set for the implementation of geothermal energy in the energy transition. During the gas production in Groningen, a negative social perspective towards mining operations, in general, was developed. For the implementation of geothermal energy, an approach for the communication of technical uncertainties between the initiators and the local public of a geothermal project is designed in this study. Technical uncertainties that are present in geothermal energy implementation in the Netherlands have been identified during semi-structured expert-interviews with different stakeholders in the spectrum of geothermal energy. The approach addresses guidelines for the communication of the context, the goal, the technical uncertainties present in the geothermal project, the main communicating actors, their reference frames, and the situation in which the communication process takes place.