J.J.A. Baselmans
Please Note
20 records found
1
Low-Tc Superconducting Detector for Future CMB Missions
Designing Lens-Antenna coupled Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors applicable to 50-90 GHz using β-Ta
Since Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) offer great multiplexing capabilities, high sensitivity, easy fabrication, and reduced cost, they would be ideal for CMB missions. MKIDs are superconducting pair-breaking detectors, which makes them capable of detecting photons with a minimum photon energy of twice the superconducting gap energy. The superconducting gap energy is intrinsic to the superconductor embedded in the detector's hybrid microwave resonator structure, and thus poses a direct limit on the frequencies the detector can measure. For example, the conventionally used Aluminum (Tc=1.2-1.4K) would only be able to detect photons with frequencies larger than 90GHz. β-phase Tantalum (β-Ta), a disordered superconductor with Tc=0.6-1.0K, would enable detection of frequencies as low as 45GHz.
In this thesis, we therefore investigate the viability of using β-Ta in designing hybrid MKIDs for frequencies in the 50-90GHz range.
The effect of quasiparticle trapping due to disorder in superconductors is known to reduce the sensitivity of MKIDs. Consequently, the volume of β-Ta within the microwave resonator must be minimized to mitigate this effect and achieve photon-noise-limited sensitivity. We opt for a lens-antenna coupled hybrid MKID design to decouple the frequency sensitive antenna and the active volume of the resonator, such that both can be optimized independently.
The detectors presented in this thesis have been designed for 70GHz radiation, at the center of the 50-90GHz range. The lens antenna features an extended hemispherical lens coupling radiation from a black body source to a twin-slot antenna. The twin-slot antenna couples this pair-breaking radiation to the volume of β-Ta. We consider β-Ta/NbTiN hybrid MKIDs for the quarter-wave resonators. To approximate the properties of the superconducting materials at both readout and pair-breaking frequencies, Mattis-Bardeen theory is used.
Given the large normal state resistivity of β-Ta, the narrow coplanar waveguide in the hybrid MKID has a large characteristic impedance. This makes it difficult for the twin-slot antenna to match in impedance. Therefore, the dimensions of the narrow coplanar waveguide have to be optimized to minimize both its active volume and characteristic impedance, simultaneously. We obtain a trade-off in its dimensions, which is also limited by UV lithography fabrication limitations. The twin-slot antenna design is subsequently optimized for a sufficient impedance match.
We identify radiation losses at readout frequencies due to the addition of the twin-slot antenna structure. These losses are found to exceed the dissipation within the quasiparticle system predicted by Mattis-Bardeen theory at low operating temperatures, and would therefore dominate the internal quality factor of the MKIDs.
Conclusively, this thesis presents a viable methodology to design MKIDs in the range of 50-90GHz using β-Ta. The dimension optimizations of the narrow coplanar waveguide and the twin-slot antenna are not fully decoupled, and their impedance matching poses challenges to the MKID design. For future research, it is important to find an approach that would give more engineering freedom in their separate designs.
...
Since Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors (MKIDs) offer great multiplexing capabilities, high sensitivity, easy fabrication, and reduced cost, they would be ideal for CMB missions. MKIDs are superconducting pair-breaking detectors, which makes them capable of detecting photons with a minimum photon energy of twice the superconducting gap energy. The superconducting gap energy is intrinsic to the superconductor embedded in the detector's hybrid microwave resonator structure, and thus poses a direct limit on the frequencies the detector can measure. For example, the conventionally used Aluminum (Tc=1.2-1.4K) would only be able to detect photons with frequencies larger than 90GHz. β-phase Tantalum (β-Ta), a disordered superconductor with Tc=0.6-1.0K, would enable detection of frequencies as low as 45GHz.
In this thesis, we therefore investigate the viability of using β-Ta in designing hybrid MKIDs for frequencies in the 50-90GHz range.
The effect of quasiparticle trapping due to disorder in superconductors is known to reduce the sensitivity of MKIDs. Consequently, the volume of β-Ta within the microwave resonator must be minimized to mitigate this effect and achieve photon-noise-limited sensitivity. We opt for a lens-antenna coupled hybrid MKID design to decouple the frequency sensitive antenna and the active volume of the resonator, such that both can be optimized independently.
The detectors presented in this thesis have been designed for 70GHz radiation, at the center of the 50-90GHz range. The lens antenna features an extended hemispherical lens coupling radiation from a black body source to a twin-slot antenna. The twin-slot antenna couples this pair-breaking radiation to the volume of β-Ta. We consider β-Ta/NbTiN hybrid MKIDs for the quarter-wave resonators. To approximate the properties of the superconducting materials at both readout and pair-breaking frequencies, Mattis-Bardeen theory is used.
Given the large normal state resistivity of β-Ta, the narrow coplanar waveguide in the hybrid MKID has a large characteristic impedance. This makes it difficult for the twin-slot antenna to match in impedance. Therefore, the dimensions of the narrow coplanar waveguide have to be optimized to minimize both its active volume and characteristic impedance, simultaneously. We obtain a trade-off in its dimensions, which is also limited by UV lithography fabrication limitations. The twin-slot antenna design is subsequently optimized for a sufficient impedance match.
We identify radiation losses at readout frequencies due to the addition of the twin-slot antenna structure. These losses are found to exceed the dissipation within the quasiparticle system predicted by Mattis-Bardeen theory at low operating temperatures, and would therefore dominate the internal quality factor of the MKIDs.
Conclusively, this thesis presents a viable methodology to design MKIDs in the range of 50-90GHz using β-Ta. The dimension optimizations of the narrow coplanar waveguide and the twin-slot antenna are not fully decoupled, and their impedance matching poses challenges to the MKID design. For future research, it is important to find an approach that would give more engineering freedom in their separate designs.
These applications are, however, hindered by an unexplained microwave loss and, for MKID applications, an enhanced decay rate of the elementary excitations in the superconductor. Both these effects become stronger with increasing disorder. The elementary excitations are called quasiparticles and are essentially broken Cooper pairs. Their density decays as they recombine pair-wise into Cooper pairs. Since quasiparticles also induce microwave loss, these observations point towards an effect of disorder on the quasiparticle dynamics. It is however unclear how disorder affects the quasiparticle dynamics exactly..... ...
These applications are, however, hindered by an unexplained microwave loss and, for MKID applications, an enhanced decay rate of the elementary excitations in the superconductor. Both these effects become stronger with increasing disorder. The elementary excitations are called quasiparticles and are essentially broken Cooper pairs. Their density decays as they recombine pair-wise into Cooper pairs. Since quasiparticles also induce microwave loss, these observations point towards an effect of disorder on the quasiparticle dynamics. It is however unclear how disorder affects the quasiparticle dynamics exactly.....
Efficient Mid-Infrared Single-Photon Counting Kinetic Inductance Detectors
The Design and Experimental Evaluation of Lens-Absorber Coupled KIDs for 10 and 18.5 Microns
In this work, we present the design of lens-absorber coupled single-photon counting KIDs for two wavelengths within the band of LIFE: 10 µm and 18.5 µm. The absorber consists of two meandering 23 nm thick Al lines (ρ = 2.4 × 10−8 Ω m) with widths of 250 nm and 200 nm for 18.5 µm and 10 µm, respectively. The absorber is simulated using the Floquet theorem in CST. The absorber is divided into unit cells simulated with periodic boundary conditions. These unit cells must be smaller than 0.8λd to avoid crosstalk between absorbers. The simulation is performed for all angles from broadside incidence up to the subtended angle of the lens. These simulations show absorption efficiencies for the TE and TM fundamental Floquet modes of up to 81% and 65% for the 18.5 µm design and the 10 µm design, respectively. The absorber acts dominantly as an inductor and is coupled to a coplanar waveguide (CPW) to tune the resonance frequency of the KIDs.
We measured one of the designed chips: a chip with 18.5 µm lens-absorber coupled KIDs on a substrate. We performed power-integrating measurements to estimate the optical coupling of these devices. For these KIDs, we expect a total optical coupling of 1.77. This coupling is calculated with respect to a single mode and 1 polarization. Our absorber can couple to 2 polarizations and multiple modes, resulting in a coupling of larger than 1. The measurements show a reasonable match between the expected and measured optical coupling.
We also performed single-photon counting experiments. The KIDs showed a low resolving power, making distinguishing the source’s photons from noise and cosmic rays impossible. Phonon losses due to the substrate were assumed to cause this. Therefore, another chip was measured with 25 µm lens-absorber coupled KIDs on a membrane. The two chips share identical design and fabrication processes, differing only in foundation: one is built on a membrane, the other on a substrate. The KIDs on the membrane showed a relatively high resolving power of approximately 4. This confirmed the hypothesis that phonon losses were the cause of the low resolving power for the KIDs on a substrate.
Future work should focus on redesigning the absorbers and KIDs for use on a membrane and adding a quarter-wavelength backing reflector and matching layer to increase the optical efficiencies of the devices. ...
In this work, we present the design of lens-absorber coupled single-photon counting KIDs for two wavelengths within the band of LIFE: 10 µm and 18.5 µm. The absorber consists of two meandering 23 nm thick Al lines (ρ = 2.4 × 10−8 Ω m) with widths of 250 nm and 200 nm for 18.5 µm and 10 µm, respectively. The absorber is simulated using the Floquet theorem in CST. The absorber is divided into unit cells simulated with periodic boundary conditions. These unit cells must be smaller than 0.8λd to avoid crosstalk between absorbers. The simulation is performed for all angles from broadside incidence up to the subtended angle of the lens. These simulations show absorption efficiencies for the TE and TM fundamental Floquet modes of up to 81% and 65% for the 18.5 µm design and the 10 µm design, respectively. The absorber acts dominantly as an inductor and is coupled to a coplanar waveguide (CPW) to tune the resonance frequency of the KIDs.
We measured one of the designed chips: a chip with 18.5 µm lens-absorber coupled KIDs on a substrate. We performed power-integrating measurements to estimate the optical coupling of these devices. For these KIDs, we expect a total optical coupling of 1.77. This coupling is calculated with respect to a single mode and 1 polarization. Our absorber can couple to 2 polarizations and multiple modes, resulting in a coupling of larger than 1. The measurements show a reasonable match between the expected and measured optical coupling.
We also performed single-photon counting experiments. The KIDs showed a low resolving power, making distinguishing the source’s photons from noise and cosmic rays impossible. Phonon losses due to the substrate were assumed to cause this. Therefore, another chip was measured with 25 µm lens-absorber coupled KIDs on a membrane. The two chips share identical design and fabrication processes, differing only in foundation: one is built on a membrane, the other on a substrate. The KIDs on the membrane showed a relatively high resolving power of approximately 4. This confirmed the hypothesis that phonon losses were the cause of the low resolving power for the KIDs on a substrate.
Future work should focus on redesigning the absorbers and KIDs for use on a membrane and adding a quarter-wavelength backing reflector and matching layer to increase the optical efficiencies of the devices.
Photon Rate Estimation in MKIDs
Optimal Estimation of the Photon Rate in Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors via Statistical Digital Signal Processing Methods
Based on a literature study we identified a-SiC:H and hydrogenated amor- phous silicon (a-Si:H) as potentially promising low-loss dielectrics. In order to find the origin of the mm-submm loss, and to define which materials we investi- gated in this PhD project, we characterized the dielectrics’ material properties at room temperature prior to performing the cryogenic loss measurements. We deposited a-SiC:H at a substrate temperature Tsub of 400◦C using plasma- enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD), and we deposited the a-Si:H films at Tsub of 100◦C, 250◦C, and 350◦C. We characterized the films’ material properties using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Raman spec- troscopy and ellipsometry. For the a-Si:H we determined the hydrogen content and the microstructure parameter from the FTIR data, the bond-angle disorder from the Raman data, and the void volume fraction from the ellipsometry data. For both the a-Si:H and the a-SiC:H we determined the band gap and optical refractive index from the ellipsometry data, and the infrared refractive index from the FTIR data. From the Raman spectra we observed that the a-SiC:H and the a-Si:H films were amorphous. Furthermore, we performed electron diffraction spectroscopy to determine the Si to C ratio of the a-SiC:H. For the a-Si:H we found that the all the material properties depend monotonically on Tsub. Additionally, we measured the cryogenic microwave loss of the a-Si:H films, but we found no correlation between the microwave loss and Tsub.
No cryogenic mm-submm and microwave loss data was available for a- SiC:H. We measured the low-power and cryogenic microwave loss of the a- SiC:H and found that the microwave loss tangent (tanδ ∼ 10−5) is compa- rable to the loss of a-Si:H. Furthermore, we measured the mm-submm loss in the range of 270–385 GHz using an on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment. The observed mm-submm losss value of 1.2 × 10−4 at 350 GHz was significantly lower than what was reported for a-Si:H, which previously exhibited the low- est reported microwave and mm-subm wave loss values among the deposited dielectrics which are commonly used in superconducting ICs. Furthermore, we found that the mm-submm loss of the a-SiC:H increases monotonically with frequency. This was surprising in the framework of TLSs and led us to the hypothesis that another loss mechanism than TLSs might be dominant at mm- submm wavelengths. In addition to the low losses, the a-SiC:H was found to be beneficial thanks to its very low stress, lack of blisters, and the possibility to fabricate a membrane from the a-SiC:H on a c-Si wafer.
To study the origin of the frequency dependent mm-submm loss in the a- SiC:H, we extended the on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment to the 270–600 GHz range by making use of a wideband leaky antenna. Additionally, we measured the complex dielectric constant of the a-SiC:H in the 3–100 THz range using Fourier-transform spectroscopy (FTS). We modeled the FTS data using the Maxwell-Helmholtz-Drude (MHD) dispersion model and obtained the complex dielectric constant in the 3-100 THz range. Finally, we modeled the combined on-chip loss data from the Fabry-Pérot experiments and the FTS data by fitting the MHD dispersion model in the frequency range of 0.27–100 THz. Our model demonstrates that the mm-submm loss in the a-SiC:H above 200 GHz can be explained by the absorption tail of vibrational modes which are located above 10 THz. These results pave the way for a thorough understanding of the mm-submm loss in deposited dielectrics.
The low losses of the a-SiC:H allow for integrated superconducting spec- trometers with a large frequency bandwidth and relatively high resolving pow- ers without sacrificing too much optical efficiency. This has led to the application of the a-SiC:H in the DESHIMA 2.0 filter bank, which has seen first light in 2023 at the ASTE telescope in the Atacama Desert. ...
Based on a literature study we identified a-SiC:H and hydrogenated amor- phous silicon (a-Si:H) as potentially promising low-loss dielectrics. In order to find the origin of the mm-submm loss, and to define which materials we investi- gated in this PhD project, we characterized the dielectrics’ material properties at room temperature prior to performing the cryogenic loss measurements. We deposited a-SiC:H at a substrate temperature Tsub of 400◦C using plasma- enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD), and we deposited the a-Si:H films at Tsub of 100◦C, 250◦C, and 350◦C. We characterized the films’ material properties using Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), Raman spec- troscopy and ellipsometry. For the a-Si:H we determined the hydrogen content and the microstructure parameter from the FTIR data, the bond-angle disorder from the Raman data, and the void volume fraction from the ellipsometry data. For both the a-Si:H and the a-SiC:H we determined the band gap and optical refractive index from the ellipsometry data, and the infrared refractive index from the FTIR data. From the Raman spectra we observed that the a-SiC:H and the a-Si:H films were amorphous. Furthermore, we performed electron diffraction spectroscopy to determine the Si to C ratio of the a-SiC:H. For the a-Si:H we found that the all the material properties depend monotonically on Tsub. Additionally, we measured the cryogenic microwave loss of the a-Si:H films, but we found no correlation between the microwave loss and Tsub.
No cryogenic mm-submm and microwave loss data was available for a- SiC:H. We measured the low-power and cryogenic microwave loss of the a- SiC:H and found that the microwave loss tangent (tanδ ∼ 10−5) is compa- rable to the loss of a-Si:H. Furthermore, we measured the mm-submm loss in the range of 270–385 GHz using an on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment. The observed mm-submm losss value of 1.2 × 10−4 at 350 GHz was significantly lower than what was reported for a-Si:H, which previously exhibited the low- est reported microwave and mm-subm wave loss values among the deposited dielectrics which are commonly used in superconducting ICs. Furthermore, we found that the mm-submm loss of the a-SiC:H increases monotonically with frequency. This was surprising in the framework of TLSs and led us to the hypothesis that another loss mechanism than TLSs might be dominant at mm- submm wavelengths. In addition to the low losses, the a-SiC:H was found to be beneficial thanks to its very low stress, lack of blisters, and the possibility to fabricate a membrane from the a-SiC:H on a c-Si wafer.
To study the origin of the frequency dependent mm-submm loss in the a- SiC:H, we extended the on-chip Fabry-Pérot experiment to the 270–600 GHz range by making use of a wideband leaky antenna. Additionally, we measured the complex dielectric constant of the a-SiC:H in the 3–100 THz range using Fourier-transform spectroscopy (FTS). We modeled the FTS data using the Maxwell-Helmholtz-Drude (MHD) dispersion model and obtained the complex dielectric constant in the 3-100 THz range. Finally, we modeled the combined on-chip loss data from the Fabry-Pérot experiments and the FTS data by fitting the MHD dispersion model in the frequency range of 0.27–100 THz. Our model demonstrates that the mm-submm loss in the a-SiC:H above 200 GHz can be explained by the absorption tail of vibrational modes which are located above 10 THz. These results pave the way for a thorough understanding of the mm-submm loss in deposited dielectrics.
The low losses of the a-SiC:H allow for integrated superconducting spec- trometers with a large frequency bandwidth and relatively high resolving pow- ers without sacrificing too much optical efficiency. This has led to the application of the a-SiC:H in the DESHIMA 2.0 filter bank, which has seen first light in 2023 at the ASTE telescope in the Atacama Desert.
While detectors have been developed previously covering the upper band of this frequency range at 6.98 THz and 12 THz, the lower band remains uncovered. Therefore, lens-absorber coupled MKIDs designed to operate at 1.5 THz are presented, with their performance analysed using models based on the Geometrical Optics-Fourier Optics (GOFO) technique in combination with a Floquet wave approach for periodic absorbers. Additionally, the design methodology of MKIDs to operate at specific readout frequencies is discussed. Absorber coupled MKIDs are limited to lower resonance frequencies with respect to comparable antenna based MKIDs, which offer advantages for space-based missions due to reduced power consumption, but do present challenges for readout systems operating at higher frequencies. In this thesis, two lens-absorber coupled MKID designs were developed and are currently being fabricated as candidates to experimentally demonstrate highly sensitive detector arrays operating at 1.5 THz.
The imaging spectrometers in the POEMM and PRIMA missions require a dispersive element to separate different wavelengths of the incoming radiation. The dispersive element envisioned for these missions, the Virtually Imaged Phased Array (VIPA), suffers from non-idealities, causing phase aberrations in the transmitted field, and part of the power transmitting towards unwanted propagation directions, which can degrade instrument performance. This thesis presents and analyses optimisation techniques to mitigate these effects, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and degrees of freedom for designing the full instrument.
Furthermore, absorbers, unlike antenna-based devices, are multi-mode detectors. Understanding how absorbers couple to higher-order modes is crucial for optimising their performance. This thesis introduces and validates a model based on a novel experimental technique, Energy Absorption Interferometry (EAI), to extract a modal description of detectors. In the future steps related to the POEMM mission, the findings from this initial investigation into multi-mode absorbers will be used to gain insight and explore possible improvement routes in the coupling of these detectors to complex optical systems. ...
While detectors have been developed previously covering the upper band of this frequency range at 6.98 THz and 12 THz, the lower band remains uncovered. Therefore, lens-absorber coupled MKIDs designed to operate at 1.5 THz are presented, with their performance analysed using models based on the Geometrical Optics-Fourier Optics (GOFO) technique in combination with a Floquet wave approach for periodic absorbers. Additionally, the design methodology of MKIDs to operate at specific readout frequencies is discussed. Absorber coupled MKIDs are limited to lower resonance frequencies with respect to comparable antenna based MKIDs, which offer advantages for space-based missions due to reduced power consumption, but do present challenges for readout systems operating at higher frequencies. In this thesis, two lens-absorber coupled MKID designs were developed and are currently being fabricated as candidates to experimentally demonstrate highly sensitive detector arrays operating at 1.5 THz.
The imaging spectrometers in the POEMM and PRIMA missions require a dispersive element to separate different wavelengths of the incoming radiation. The dispersive element envisioned for these missions, the Virtually Imaged Phased Array (VIPA), suffers from non-idealities, causing phase aberrations in the transmitted field, and part of the power transmitting towards unwanted propagation directions, which can degrade instrument performance. This thesis presents and analyses optimisation techniques to mitigate these effects, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency and degrees of freedom for designing the full instrument.
Furthermore, absorbers, unlike antenna-based devices, are multi-mode detectors. Understanding how absorbers couple to higher-order modes is crucial for optimising their performance. This thesis introduces and validates a model based on a novel experimental technique, Energy Absorption Interferometry (EAI), to extract a modal description of detectors. In the future steps related to the POEMM mission, the findings from this initial investigation into multi-mode absorbers will be used to gain insight and explore possible improvement routes in the coupling of these detectors to complex optical systems.
Kinetic inductance detectors (KIDs) are promising superconducting, energy resolving devices capable of single photon detection in the near-infrared and visible regimes. Another often cited advantage of KIDs is that, in theory, many detectors can easily be coupled to a single set of readout electronics. To make devices capable of producing images comparable to those achieved with CCDs we need a similar amount of pixels. The largest KID arrays to date are in the order of a thousand pixels on one readout line, whereas CCDs have in the order of millions of pixels. In this thesis some theoretical and practical limits on KID multiplexability while retaining high pixel yield are explored. ...
Kinetic inductance detectors (KIDs) are promising superconducting, energy resolving devices capable of single photon detection in the near-infrared and visible regimes. Another often cited advantage of KIDs is that, in theory, many detectors can easily be coupled to a single set of readout electronics. To make devices capable of producing images comparable to those achieved with CCDs we need a similar amount of pixels. The largest KID arrays to date are in the order of a thousand pixels on one readout line, whereas CCDs have in the order of millions of pixels. In this thesis some theoretical and practical limits on KID multiplexability while retaining high pixel yield are explored.
In this thesis, we model the OKID’s single photon pulse with a local model of the recombination process, that does include this diffusion. To this end, we analyze the downconversion process, which describes the generation of particles due to a photon absorption. This analysis therefore gives information on the initial conditions of the recombination process. Next, we study and solve this diffusion and recombination model.
Next, we test the response pulse predicted by this model against measurement data of the single photon pulses of a β-Ta OKID, for different photon energies. We show that the model must assume that an unfeasibly high number of quasiparticles is excited in order to reproduce the data. Furthermore, the pulses generated by the model exhibit a dependence on the absorbed photon energy, which is not observed in the data. Therefore we reason that the model must be missing some photon energy dependent effect. We reason that this energy dependence could lie in the downconversion process, or that it could lie in the responsivity of the OKID.
We also investigate the pulses of OKIDs that are designed with an absorber composed of multiple small elements of β-Ta, which constrain the quasiparticles in space. We measure the correspondence of the size of the β-Ta elements and the decay time of the response pulse. We show that the decay time increases for larger elements, until it saturates. This behavior is also predicted by our model. We therefore conclude that the diffusion indeed plays a significant role in the cause of supra-exponential decay. ...
In this thesis, we model the OKID’s single photon pulse with a local model of the recombination process, that does include this diffusion. To this end, we analyze the downconversion process, which describes the generation of particles due to a photon absorption. This analysis therefore gives information on the initial conditions of the recombination process. Next, we study and solve this diffusion and recombination model.
Next, we test the response pulse predicted by this model against measurement data of the single photon pulses of a β-Ta OKID, for different photon energies. We show that the model must assume that an unfeasibly high number of quasiparticles is excited in order to reproduce the data. Furthermore, the pulses generated by the model exhibit a dependence on the absorbed photon energy, which is not observed in the data. Therefore we reason that the model must be missing some photon energy dependent effect. We reason that this energy dependence could lie in the downconversion process, or that it could lie in the responsivity of the OKID.
We also investigate the pulses of OKIDs that are designed with an absorber composed of multiple small elements of β-Ta, which constrain the quasiparticles in space. We measure the correspondence of the size of the β-Ta elements and the decay time of the response pulse. We show that the decay time increases for larger elements, until it saturates. This behavior is also predicted by our model. We therefore conclude that the diffusion indeed plays a significant role in the cause of supra-exponential decay.
Pushing the Fano limit
Improvement of Fano-limited single-photon counting MKID detectors
Visible to Near-Infrared Kinetic Inductance Detectors
Energy-Resolving Single Photon Detectors
Quasiparticle Dynamics in Disordered Superconductors
Modeling the Single Photon Response
However, MKIDs don’t have the photon absorption efficiency and resolving power to do this yet.
In this thesis we look at the single photon pulses of a new superconducting material, beta phased tantalum (β-Ta), since this material shows promising properties for MKIDs. The single photon pulse shapes of this material are not yet fully understood. Therefore we will create models for the quasiparticle dynamics in β-ta to try and further our understanding of the single photon pulses in this material.
From the Rothwarf-Taylor equations we derive multiple models. These are then tested on the data. We first try the double exponential model which does not work. Then we look at the 1/t model and this model does seem to work better. We propose a different response time of the system. Fitting a new response time we get a very good fit to the single photon pulses. The main hypothesis is that there is an extra relaxation time for the quasiparticles as they need to distribute themselves throughout the superconductor. We see that the fitted response time is wavelength dependent which would support the hypothesis.
We conclude that the 1/t model with an adjusted response time explains the single photon pule shapes the best. ...
However, MKIDs don’t have the photon absorption efficiency and resolving power to do this yet.
In this thesis we look at the single photon pulses of a new superconducting material, beta phased tantalum (β-Ta), since this material shows promising properties for MKIDs. The single photon pulse shapes of this material are not yet fully understood. Therefore we will create models for the quasiparticle dynamics in β-ta to try and further our understanding of the single photon pulses in this material.
From the Rothwarf-Taylor equations we derive multiple models. These are then tested on the data. We first try the double exponential model which does not work. Then we look at the 1/t model and this model does seem to work better. We propose a different response time of the system. Fitting a new response time we get a very good fit to the single photon pulses. The main hypothesis is that there is an extra relaxation time for the quasiparticles as they need to distribute themselves throughout the superconductor. We see that the fitted response time is wavelength dependent which would support the hypothesis.
We conclude that the 1/t model with an adjusted response time explains the single photon pule shapes the best.
dark current. This makes MKIDs a promising candidate for mid-IR detectors for the LIFE initiative. In this thesis we investigate what development is necessary to meet the detector requirements set by the LIFE initiative. We also investigate how the performance of MKIDs can be reliably measured in the mid-IR.
Currently, there are no single-photon counting MKIDs designed for the mid-IR. Measurements are done with two MKID devices that originally have been designed for the near- and far-IR bandwidths. Prior to this work the near-IR detector has shown single-photon counting 1545 nm and the far-IR detector at 38 𝜇m. In this work we show the single-photon counting ability of MKIDs 3.8 and 8.5 𝜇m. This is the first time that single-photon counting has been shown at 8.5 𝜇m. The resolving power (𝐸/𝛿𝐸) at 8.5 𝜇m is found to be about 4. Experiments are planned at 18.5 𝜇m for which a setup has been designed with a cryogenic black-body radiator as the source. This is the longest wavelength required for the LIFE spectrometer. We also perform an optimisation of the near-IR detector geometry to see if a realistic device can be made that is sufficiently sensitive to 18.5 𝜇m radiation. The results show that a realistic design could in theory be made but this strongly depends on how the detector is limited by the noise.
Next steps are to design a dedicated MKID for the mid-IR to determine its efficiency and dark current. This will also require us to improve the current measurement setup as measurements show that we suffer from thermal background radiation which limits the detector performance. ...
dark current. This makes MKIDs a promising candidate for mid-IR detectors for the LIFE initiative. In this thesis we investigate what development is necessary to meet the detector requirements set by the LIFE initiative. We also investigate how the performance of MKIDs can be reliably measured in the mid-IR.
Currently, there are no single-photon counting MKIDs designed for the mid-IR. Measurements are done with two MKID devices that originally have been designed for the near- and far-IR bandwidths. Prior to this work the near-IR detector has shown single-photon counting 1545 nm and the far-IR detector at 38 𝜇m. In this work we show the single-photon counting ability of MKIDs 3.8 and 8.5 𝜇m. This is the first time that single-photon counting has been shown at 8.5 𝜇m. The resolving power (𝐸/𝛿𝐸) at 8.5 𝜇m is found to be about 4. Experiments are planned at 18.5 𝜇m for which a setup has been designed with a cryogenic black-body radiator as the source. This is the longest wavelength required for the LIFE spectrometer. We also perform an optimisation of the near-IR detector geometry to see if a realistic device can be made that is sufficiently sensitive to 18.5 𝜇m radiation. The results show that a realistic design could in theory be made but this strongly depends on how the detector is limited by the noise.
Next steps are to design a dedicated MKID for the mid-IR to determine its efficiency and dark current. This will also require us to improve the current measurement setup as measurements show that we suffer from thermal background radiation which limits the detector performance.
Octave-band THz channelizing filter-banks with moderate spectral resolution of the order R=500 are investigated in this work. These systems allow for a size reduction of several orders of magnitude compared to conventional spectrometers with similar spectral resolution. The proposed filters are half-wavelength resonators, which naturally provide a free-spectral range of an octave. The performance of those filters, both when in isolation and when embedded in a filter-bank, is analyzed using a newly-developed circuit model. This tool also provides design insights such as the required filter ordering and separation within the filter-bank to enable an efficient circuit. The actual implementation of the superconducting filter-bank on a chip is investigated for two of the main on-chip technologies: co-planar waveguide (CPW) and microstrip. Despite the easier manufacturing of co-planar circuitry, that technology is not suited for channelizing THz filter-banks as it suffers from radiation issues. Instead microstrip technology is non-radiative and, although it suffers from the moderate dissipation in deposited dielectrics such as a-Si, it provides a very reliable platform to build THz filter-banks. Half-wavelength I-shaped resonators are proposed as suitable filtering structures with which frequency-sparse filter-banks have been built to test their performance in semi-isolation. The measurements were based on both a frequency response characterization of the filters as well as their optical efficiency, showing good agreement between the two. The measured performance of these filters showed pass-bands with an average peak coupling efficiency of 27% and a spectral resolution R≈940. The coupling is significantly better than earlier results based upon planar technology.
The coupling between the quasi-optical reflector system of a telescope and the on-chip filter-bank requires of a broadband antenna. Currently, broadband integrated anti-reflection-coated lenses are being developed for this purpose, but their manufacturing is specially complicated for cryogenics and require mechanical actuators to perform beam scanning in the case of a multi-object spectrometer. In this dissertation, we propose a broadband phased-array antenna concept with electronic beam-steering that exploits two key properties of superconductors in its feeding network: the negligible conductor loss and the tunable kinetic inductance with a bias current. The focused connected array antenna concept proposed is based on the broadband impedance matching enabled by the connected arrays and the largely frequency-independent far fields of near-field focused apertures. To demonstrate this concept we designed, fabricated and tested two low frequency (3-6 GHz) prototypes in PCB technology: one pointing broadside and another one scanning. The measured fields met the predictions to a large degree and provided with a reflector aperture efficiency in excess of 60% over an octave of bandwidth and allowing to scan one half-power beamwidth at the lowest frequency with a frequency-averaged scan loss of 0.2 dB. Both the directivity and the gain were measured, allowing to report the losses, which chiefly originated from the tin-finished copper lines in the PCB. As a result, we can expect a highly-efficient reflector feed at THz frequencies with beam-steering capabilities in the near future.
The beam-steering concept proposed for the phased-array antenna relies on the current-dependent kinetic inductance of superconducting lines. With this effect, the phase velocity of biased superconducting lines may be modified, allowing thereby an electronic tuning of the phase-shift introduced. Prior to the integration of such phase-shifters with the phased-array antenna, we devised an on-chip platform based a tunable Fabry-Pérot resonator to quantify the phase-shifting capabilities at THz frequencies. In this concept, the dc bias currents are injected in the proximity of the edges of the resonator through 9th order Chebyshev stepped-impedance low-pass filters, whose high rejection mitigates any possible disturbance to the THz resonances. Using a circuit model including the resonator and the low-pass filters, as well as the simulated properties of the superconducting buried microstrip lines used in the designs, we anticipate an expected maximum tuning of dφ/φ=-df/f≈2%. With such tuning range millimeter-long tunable delay lines will be required for THz superconducting phased-array. ...
Octave-band THz channelizing filter-banks with moderate spectral resolution of the order R=500 are investigated in this work. These systems allow for a size reduction of several orders of magnitude compared to conventional spectrometers with similar spectral resolution. The proposed filters are half-wavelength resonators, which naturally provide a free-spectral range of an octave. The performance of those filters, both when in isolation and when embedded in a filter-bank, is analyzed using a newly-developed circuit model. This tool also provides design insights such as the required filter ordering and separation within the filter-bank to enable an efficient circuit. The actual implementation of the superconducting filter-bank on a chip is investigated for two of the main on-chip technologies: co-planar waveguide (CPW) and microstrip. Despite the easier manufacturing of co-planar circuitry, that technology is not suited for channelizing THz filter-banks as it suffers from radiation issues. Instead microstrip technology is non-radiative and, although it suffers from the moderate dissipation in deposited dielectrics such as a-Si, it provides a very reliable platform to build THz filter-banks. Half-wavelength I-shaped resonators are proposed as suitable filtering structures with which frequency-sparse filter-banks have been built to test their performance in semi-isolation. The measurements were based on both a frequency response characterization of the filters as well as their optical efficiency, showing good agreement between the two. The measured performance of these filters showed pass-bands with an average peak coupling efficiency of 27% and a spectral resolution R≈940. The coupling is significantly better than earlier results based upon planar technology.
The coupling between the quasi-optical reflector system of a telescope and the on-chip filter-bank requires of a broadband antenna. Currently, broadband integrated anti-reflection-coated lenses are being developed for this purpose, but their manufacturing is specially complicated for cryogenics and require mechanical actuators to perform beam scanning in the case of a multi-object spectrometer. In this dissertation, we propose a broadband phased-array antenna concept with electronic beam-steering that exploits two key properties of superconductors in its feeding network: the negligible conductor loss and the tunable kinetic inductance with a bias current. The focused connected array antenna concept proposed is based on the broadband impedance matching enabled by the connected arrays and the largely frequency-independent far fields of near-field focused apertures. To demonstrate this concept we designed, fabricated and tested two low frequency (3-6 GHz) prototypes in PCB technology: one pointing broadside and another one scanning. The measured fields met the predictions to a large degree and provided with a reflector aperture efficiency in excess of 60% over an octave of bandwidth and allowing to scan one half-power beamwidth at the lowest frequency with a frequency-averaged scan loss of 0.2 dB. Both the directivity and the gain were measured, allowing to report the losses, which chiefly originated from the tin-finished copper lines in the PCB. As a result, we can expect a highly-efficient reflector feed at THz frequencies with beam-steering capabilities in the near future.
The beam-steering concept proposed for the phased-array antenna relies on the current-dependent kinetic inductance of superconducting lines. With this effect, the phase velocity of biased superconducting lines may be modified, allowing thereby an electronic tuning of the phase-shift introduced. Prior to the integration of such phase-shifters with the phased-array antenna, we devised an on-chip platform based a tunable Fabry-Pérot resonator to quantify the phase-shifting capabilities at THz frequencies. In this concept, the dc bias currents are injected in the proximity of the edges of the resonator through 9th order Chebyshev stepped-impedance low-pass filters, whose high rejection mitigates any possible disturbance to the THz resonances. Using a circuit model including the resonator and the low-pass filters, as well as the simulated properties of the superconducting buried microstrip lines used in the designs, we anticipate an expected maximum tuning of dφ/φ=-df/f≈2%. With such tuning range millimeter-long tunable delay lines will be required for THz superconducting phased-array.
Multiwavelength observations of active galactic nuclei
Using current facilities and development of enabling technologies
AGN and can only be identified by means of their radio jet – a stream of relativistic particles that can reach far outside the AGN’s host galaxy. This absence of electromagnetic radiation and prominence of the radio jet is thought to be the result of the low accretion rate of the super-massive black hole driving this AGN type. I show that ‘jet-mode’ AGN have a strong preference for the most massive galaxies, which typically have little star formation. The presence or absence of a dusty torus and the resulting difference in broadband mid-infrared emission could be a powerful tool to separate ‘radiative-mode’ and ‘jet-mode’ AGN without using spectroscopy. Unfortunately, the inherent scatter in the mid-infrared emission of galaxies due to dust heated by stars is too large to separate the two populations reliably.
Far-infrared observations could help resolve this, by constraining the mid-infrared contribution of dust heated by stars. However, current far-infrared surveys do not have the depth or the area to give the number statistics required to calibrate this procedure. In this thesis I have investigated the properties of microwave kinetic inductance detectors. These detectors will enable the far-infrared instruments with 10.000 pixels as a result of their inherent potential for frequency domain multiplexing. This is a huge leap from the 100 pixel far-infrared instruments currently on telescopes. I have shown that microwave kinetic inductance detectors made from NbTiN and Al can satisfy all the requirements to enable a new generation of large format far-infrared cameras, which are required to constrain the far-infrared emission of many galaxies. ...
AGN and can only be identified by means of their radio jet – a stream of relativistic particles that can reach far outside the AGN’s host galaxy. This absence of electromagnetic radiation and prominence of the radio jet is thought to be the result of the low accretion rate of the super-massive black hole driving this AGN type. I show that ‘jet-mode’ AGN have a strong preference for the most massive galaxies, which typically have little star formation. The presence or absence of a dusty torus and the resulting difference in broadband mid-infrared emission could be a powerful tool to separate ‘radiative-mode’ and ‘jet-mode’ AGN without using spectroscopy. Unfortunately, the inherent scatter in the mid-infrared emission of galaxies due to dust heated by stars is too large to separate the two populations reliably.
Far-infrared observations could help resolve this, by constraining the mid-infrared contribution of dust heated by stars. However, current far-infrared surveys do not have the depth or the area to give the number statistics required to calibrate this procedure. In this thesis I have investigated the properties of microwave kinetic inductance detectors. These detectors will enable the far-infrared instruments with 10.000 pixels as a result of their inherent potential for frequency domain multiplexing. This is a huge leap from the 100 pixel far-infrared instruments currently on telescopes. I have shown that microwave kinetic inductance detectors made from NbTiN and Al can satisfy all the requirements to enable a new generation of large format far-infrared cameras, which are required to constrain the far-infrared emission of many galaxies.
In this thesis, TLSs from surface and bulk sources are modelled, so that their behaviour can be predicted through numerical computations of the field distributions inside the resonators. These calculations not only provide a guide for sensible chip designs, but allow for interpretation of experimental data and determination of dominant TLS sources.
It is found that for Al CPW resonators on Si or SiN, the noise is surface dominated but with a non-negligible bulk contribution, while for microstrips on a SiN membrane, the noise is bulk dominated. As the loss in microstrips for narrow microstrips is dominated by the substrate-air interface, the dominant TLS loss and noise sources do not necessarily coincide and should be treated independently. This makes it impossible to determine the dominant CPW surface noise contribution. Additionally, microstrips and CPWs on the same dielectric perform similarly, while Si is better than SiN, both in terms of loss and noise, due to a combination of SiN interface and bulk effects. Finally, material dependent loss and noise parameters have been determined and the importance of thorough Si surface cleaning has been established, yielding the best Al CPW noise ever encountered.
For sub-mm astronomy in space, the logical path to improvement would be the use of thorough cleaned Si as a dielectric, overetching and the use of LEKIDS and hybrid resonators, where microstrips are still viable for use. Importantly, having located the important TLS locations for various cases, tackling these problems areas further could provide the step towards background limited performance in space. ...
In this thesis, TLSs from surface and bulk sources are modelled, so that their behaviour can be predicted through numerical computations of the field distributions inside the resonators. These calculations not only provide a guide for sensible chip designs, but allow for interpretation of experimental data and determination of dominant TLS sources.
It is found that for Al CPW resonators on Si or SiN, the noise is surface dominated but with a non-negligible bulk contribution, while for microstrips on a SiN membrane, the noise is bulk dominated. As the loss in microstrips for narrow microstrips is dominated by the substrate-air interface, the dominant TLS loss and noise sources do not necessarily coincide and should be treated independently. This makes it impossible to determine the dominant CPW surface noise contribution. Additionally, microstrips and CPWs on the same dielectric perform similarly, while Si is better than SiN, both in terms of loss and noise, due to a combination of SiN interface and bulk effects. Finally, material dependent loss and noise parameters have been determined and the importance of thorough Si surface cleaning has been established, yielding the best Al CPW noise ever encountered.
For sub-mm astronomy in space, the logical path to improvement would be the use of thorough cleaned Si as a dielectric, overetching and the use of LEKIDS and hybrid resonators, where microstrips are still viable for use. Importantly, having located the important TLS locations for various cases, tackling these problems areas further could provide the step towards background limited performance in space.