F. Lombardi
Please Note
14 records found
1
Powering the Dutch Greenhouse Energy Transition
Design of a Spectral-filtering agriphotovoltaic (APV) based sustainable multi-commodity energy hub and assessment of grid support, self-sufficiency and economic performance using Python for Power System Analysis (PyPSA)
A sustainable multi-commodity energy hub combining spectral-filtering APV, a battery, geothermal heat, thermal storage, a heat pump, and direct air capture was modelled in Python for Power System Analysis (PyPSA) for a 5.2 ha greenhouse at Koppert Cress in Monster, the Netherlands. The system was built up in three steps: an electrical system with APV and a battery energy storage system (BESS), a heating system adding geothermal heat, thermal storage, and a heat pump, and the full energy hub adding direct air capture with liquid CO\textsubscript{2} storage. Each configuration was evaluated on three key performance indicators mirroring the CHP's functions: Economic Performance, Self-Sufficiency, and Grid Support, the latter based on the imbalance settlement data of the Dutch grid operator. Evaluation was done using Modelling to Generate Alternatives with 5\% and 10\% cost slack, a rolling-horizon optimisation, and a sensitivity analysis on the geothermal capacity and the grid import limit.
The hub can supply the greenhouse's electricity, heat, and CO\textsubscript{2} demand without natural gas. The optimised battery raises the simple self-consumption of the APV electricity from 20.8\% to 90.2\%. Self-sufficiency reaches 16.4\% at the cost-optimal dispatch and 27.0\% within a 5\% cost increase, while the weighted grid alignment can be improved by 34.7\% within the same budget. Economic performance is the main barrier: the APV alone does not pay back within its lifetime, although the combination with the battery pays back in 19.2 years. The hub can therefore take over the CHP's core functions, but mainly when its grid support is actively valued. While these results reflect a single greenhouse, crop, and modelled year, they provide a quantified indication of how sustainable multi-commodity hubs can replace the CHP. ...
A sustainable multi-commodity energy hub combining spectral-filtering APV, a battery, geothermal heat, thermal storage, a heat pump, and direct air capture was modelled in Python for Power System Analysis (PyPSA) for a 5.2 ha greenhouse at Koppert Cress in Monster, the Netherlands. The system was built up in three steps: an electrical system with APV and a battery energy storage system (BESS), a heating system adding geothermal heat, thermal storage, and a heat pump, and the full energy hub adding direct air capture with liquid CO\textsubscript{2} storage. Each configuration was evaluated on three key performance indicators mirroring the CHP's functions: Economic Performance, Self-Sufficiency, and Grid Support, the latter based on the imbalance settlement data of the Dutch grid operator. Evaluation was done using Modelling to Generate Alternatives with 5\% and 10\% cost slack, a rolling-horizon optimisation, and a sensitivity analysis on the geothermal capacity and the grid import limit.
The hub can supply the greenhouse's electricity, heat, and CO\textsubscript{2} demand without natural gas. The optimised battery raises the simple self-consumption of the APV electricity from 20.8\% to 90.2\%. Self-sufficiency reaches 16.4\% at the cost-optimal dispatch and 27.0\% within a 5\% cost increase, while the weighted grid alignment can be improved by 34.7\% within the same budget. Economic performance is the main barrier: the APV alone does not pay back within its lifetime, although the combination with the battery pays back in 19.2 years. The hub can therefore take over the CHP's core functions, but mainly when its grid support is actively valued. While these results reflect a single greenhouse, crop, and modelled year, they provide a quantified indication of how sustainable multi-commodity hubs can replace the CHP.
System Conditions for Offshore Electricity Storage
A system-level assessment of cost-effectiveness and system impacts in a high offshore wind Dutch power system
The analysis uses a spatially resolved, cost-minimising optimisation model in Calliope, in which storage, generation, transmission, and selected offshore infrastructure compete endogenously. The offshore–onshore chain is represented explicitly, including offshore wind hubs, export cables, and landing points. Three conditions identified from the literature are varied in a structured scenario design: offshore wind capacity (30–45 GW), near-landing onshore storage availability, and the offshore storage cost premium (0–75%). Each of the 27 scenarios is run with offshore storage enabled and disabled, isolating its system-level contribution across 54 model runs.
The results show that under baseline assumptions offshore storage is selected mainly when the cost premium is low (at or below roughly 25%) and offshore wind capacity is high (around 37.5 GW or more), concentrating at the hubs where wind can be overplanted relative to export cable capacity. The availability of landing point storage has little effect. Allocation ranges from negligible to about 112 GWh at the highest wind level and zero premium. Where allocation is largest, offshore storage produces a robust but modest system cost saving of up to about 78–79 M€/yr (0.3% of total system cost), substituting for onshore storage, reducing offshore wind curtailment, and, at the highest wind level, displacing export cable expansion and gas-fired dispatch and lowering CO2 emissions by around 2–2.5%. These patterns persist across a range of robustness checks. Offshore storage is therefore best understood as a conditional upstream response whose value arises from co-optimisation with offshore wind overplanting and export cable sizing. ...
The analysis uses a spatially resolved, cost-minimising optimisation model in Calliope, in which storage, generation, transmission, and selected offshore infrastructure compete endogenously. The offshore–onshore chain is represented explicitly, including offshore wind hubs, export cables, and landing points. Three conditions identified from the literature are varied in a structured scenario design: offshore wind capacity (30–45 GW), near-landing onshore storage availability, and the offshore storage cost premium (0–75%). Each of the 27 scenarios is run with offshore storage enabled and disabled, isolating its system-level contribution across 54 model runs.
The results show that under baseline assumptions offshore storage is selected mainly when the cost premium is low (at or below roughly 25%) and offshore wind capacity is high (around 37.5 GW or more), concentrating at the hubs where wind can be overplanted relative to export cable capacity. The availability of landing point storage has little effect. Allocation ranges from negligible to about 112 GWh at the highest wind level and zero premium. Where allocation is largest, offshore storage produces a robust but modest system cost saving of up to about 78–79 M€/yr (0.3% of total system cost), substituting for onshore storage, reducing offshore wind curtailment, and, at the highest wind level, displacing export cable expansion and gas-fired dispatch and lowering CO2 emissions by around 2–2.5%. These patterns persist across a range of robustness checks. Offshore storage is therefore best understood as a conditional upstream response whose value arises from co-optimisation with offshore wind overplanting and export cable sizing.
Congestion-Neutral Operation of Residential Battery Storage in the Dutch Electricity Grid
Modelling Grid Impact and Economic Feasibility for Aggregator-Controlled R-BESS
Practical recommendations include enabling congestion-neutral R-BESS through flexible constraints, distinguishing day-ahead and imbalance market, and clear coordination between DSOs and aggregators. Future research should extend to multinode grids, explore dynamic real-time signals, and further integrate market design for congestion-neutral flexibility services. All results of this thesis are open source. The complete model developed for this research is publicly available at: https://github.com/Tanneheemsbergen/pypsa-NL2025 ...
Practical recommendations include enabling congestion-neutral R-BESS through flexible constraints, distinguishing day-ahead and imbalance market, and clear coordination between DSOs and aggregators. Future research should extend to multinode grids, explore dynamic real-time signals, and further integrate market design for congestion-neutral flexibility services. All results of this thesis are open source. The complete model developed for this research is publicly available at: https://github.com/Tanneheemsbergen/pypsa-NL2025
Forecasting Costs Electrolysers
An Empirically Grounded Approach to Forecast the Cost of Electrolysers
To address these shortcomings, this thesis develops a probabilistic, empirically grounded framework to forecast both the deployment and capital expenditure (CAPEX) of alkaline electrolysis cells (AEC) and proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolysers. The framework integrates a logistic S-curve model to simulate technology deployment and a stochastic implementation of Wright’s Law to model cost reductions as a function of cumulative capacity, explicitly incorporating uncertainty through Monte Carlo simulations. Hindcasting validation is used to assess the robustness and predictive performance of the framework, ensuring alignment with historical trends.
The results reveal that achieving the IEA Net Zero Emissions (NZE) 2050 targets would require average annual growth rates of 46% for AEC and 49% for PEM technologies, significantly higher than historical growth trends of around 39%. Even under a more conservative industrial-use scenario, focusing only on sectors such as refining, ammonia, and methanol production, substantial acceleration remains necessary, with required growth rates of 41% for AEC and 45% for PEM. These findings highlight the immense scale of the deployment challenge and the value of explicitly addressing uncertainty when evaluating policy pathways.
Cost forecasts demonstrate a clear divergence between the two technologies. AEC shows a positive experience exponent, suggesting a negative learning rate, implying potential cost increases with expanded deployment. This trend is not statistically significant (p = 0.41), and the model exhibits low explanatory power (R2 = 0.04), indicating that historical data do not support a strong cost-deployment relationship for AEC. In contrast, PEM electrolysers display a statistically significant learning rate of 3.3% (p < 0.01), with an experience exponent of –0.0480 and a higher model fit (R2 = 0.62). Under the reference scenario, AEC median CAPEX is projected to rise to 1,921 EUR/kW by 2030 and 2,076 EUR/kW by 2050, with a wide interquartile range reflecting large uncertainties. For PEM, median CAPEX declines to 1,800 EUR/kW by 2030 and further to 1,533 EUR/kW by 2050, with more pronounced cost reductions under high deployment scenarios.
This transparent and modular framework not only improves cost forecasting for electrolysers but is also adaptable to other emerging energy technologies facing similar learning and deployment uncertainties. By relying on openly available data and explicitly quantifying uncertainty, it provides a robust foundation for analysts, policymakers, and scenario developers. Moreover, its structure makes it suitable for integration into Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs), supporting more realistic and adaptive long-term energy transition planning. Future research should focus on expanding its application across technologies, refining empirical learning rates, and assessing policy impacts within comprehensive system-level analyses, ultimately enabling more confident and informed decisions towards a net-zero future.
The data and the code are available at: https://doi.org/10.4121/82988dc7-099b-45e2-81e2-3850cee1b940 ...
To address these shortcomings, this thesis develops a probabilistic, empirically grounded framework to forecast both the deployment and capital expenditure (CAPEX) of alkaline electrolysis cells (AEC) and proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolysers. The framework integrates a logistic S-curve model to simulate technology deployment and a stochastic implementation of Wright’s Law to model cost reductions as a function of cumulative capacity, explicitly incorporating uncertainty through Monte Carlo simulations. Hindcasting validation is used to assess the robustness and predictive performance of the framework, ensuring alignment with historical trends.
The results reveal that achieving the IEA Net Zero Emissions (NZE) 2050 targets would require average annual growth rates of 46% for AEC and 49% for PEM technologies, significantly higher than historical growth trends of around 39%. Even under a more conservative industrial-use scenario, focusing only on sectors such as refining, ammonia, and methanol production, substantial acceleration remains necessary, with required growth rates of 41% for AEC and 45% for PEM. These findings highlight the immense scale of the deployment challenge and the value of explicitly addressing uncertainty when evaluating policy pathways.
Cost forecasts demonstrate a clear divergence between the two technologies. AEC shows a positive experience exponent, suggesting a negative learning rate, implying potential cost increases with expanded deployment. This trend is not statistically significant (p = 0.41), and the model exhibits low explanatory power (R2 = 0.04), indicating that historical data do not support a strong cost-deployment relationship for AEC. In contrast, PEM electrolysers display a statistically significant learning rate of 3.3% (p < 0.01), with an experience exponent of –0.0480 and a higher model fit (R2 = 0.62). Under the reference scenario, AEC median CAPEX is projected to rise to 1,921 EUR/kW by 2030 and 2,076 EUR/kW by 2050, with a wide interquartile range reflecting large uncertainties. For PEM, median CAPEX declines to 1,800 EUR/kW by 2030 and further to 1,533 EUR/kW by 2050, with more pronounced cost reductions under high deployment scenarios.
This transparent and modular framework not only improves cost forecasting for electrolysers but is also adaptable to other emerging energy technologies facing similar learning and deployment uncertainties. By relying on openly available data and explicitly quantifying uncertainty, it provides a robust foundation for analysts, policymakers, and scenario developers. Moreover, its structure makes it suitable for integration into Integrated Assessment Models (IAMs), supporting more realistic and adaptive long-term energy transition planning. Future research should focus on expanding its application across technologies, refining empirical learning rates, and assessing policy impacts within comprehensive system-level analyses, ultimately enabling more confident and informed decisions towards a net-zero future.
The data and the code are available at: https://doi.org/10.4121/82988dc7-099b-45e2-81e2-3850cee1b940
Results showthat reliable delivery under contract based capacity limitation is possible with out changing core processes, by coordinating on site energy assets and, where appropriate, adding a modest battery sized to the typical call profile. Under imperfect information, fea sibility depends mainly on the asset state at the start of a call and on forecast quality. We see that simple operating rules help manage this risk. The economic analysis indicates that asset based flexibility can be delivered at activation prices lower than those linked to production shifting or shedding, as long as compensation covers the extra costs of delivery and account for the bill savings the site might get.
The contributions are a transparent framework that follows Dutch market practices, facil ity scale evidence on feasibility and economics for a medium voltage wastewater treatment plant, and practical guidance for programme design and site operations. The reasoning ex tends to other process driven utilities and it points to a scalable path for distribution system operators to procure dependable congestion relief at a competitive cost. ...
Results showthat reliable delivery under contract based capacity limitation is possible with out changing core processes, by coordinating on site energy assets and, where appropriate, adding a modest battery sized to the typical call profile. Under imperfect information, fea sibility depends mainly on the asset state at the start of a call and on forecast quality. We see that simple operating rules help manage this risk. The economic analysis indicates that asset based flexibility can be delivered at activation prices lower than those linked to production shifting or shedding, as long as compensation covers the extra costs of delivery and account for the bill savings the site might get.
The contributions are a transparent framework that follows Dutch market practices, facil ity scale evidence on feasibility and economics for a medium voltage wastewater treatment plant, and practical guidance for programme design and site operations. The reasoning ex tends to other process driven utilities and it points to a scalable path for distribution system operators to procure dependable congestion relief at a competitive cost.
Current TSA methods mainly rely on passive clustering, focusing on the statistical proximity between the representative periods and the full-space time-series. However, this approach does not guarantee a satisfactory solution for the final expansion planning problem in general cases, even with predefined extreme periods implemented such as days with maximum load and minimum available RES. The operation of the power system and extreme conditions are highly sensitive to the specific power system configurations, making the standalone TSA method unreliable in practical applications.
To improve the time-series aggregation in terms of the power system operation, firstly, the methods of assessing the performance of the estimated investment decision are explored directly in terms of the objective function. By introducing the full-space operational cost model for the power system with the estimated investment decision, the operational cost error made by representative periods can be obtained, referred to as the operational estimation error. The actual objective difference between the estimated investment decision and the optimal investment decision found by the full-space expansion planning model can also be evaluated, denoted as the optimality gap. It is found that the optimality gap is bounded by the difference in the operational estimation error of representative periods for the power system with the two investment decisions. As the operations of the power system with the estimated and optimal investment decisions are better estimated, the simplified model can provide a closer investment decision.
Subsequently, looking into the operational estimation error, the performance of representative periods in estimating the full-space operational cost is highly unevenly distributed among the full-space time-series. Representative periods fail to accurately estimate a minor portion of the full-space time-series, causing extremely high operational estimation errors that contribute to the majority of the total operational estimation error. This uneven distribution remains as the number of representative periods increases, indicating that standalone TSA methods are not capable of capturing the extreme conditions of the specific power system operation.
Therefore, to improve the time-series aggregation in terms of its ability to better estimate the operation of the power system, bad-performing representative periods and original periods with high operational estimation error can be identified and prioritized, forming a feedback enhancement loop. Case studies show that the feedback enhancement with re-clustering on the bad-performing representative periods improves the optimality gap by more than 50% compared with the standard mean-based clustering method. ...
Current TSA methods mainly rely on passive clustering, focusing on the statistical proximity between the representative periods and the full-space time-series. However, this approach does not guarantee a satisfactory solution for the final expansion planning problem in general cases, even with predefined extreme periods implemented such as days with maximum load and minimum available RES. The operation of the power system and extreme conditions are highly sensitive to the specific power system configurations, making the standalone TSA method unreliable in practical applications.
To improve the time-series aggregation in terms of the power system operation, firstly, the methods of assessing the performance of the estimated investment decision are explored directly in terms of the objective function. By introducing the full-space operational cost model for the power system with the estimated investment decision, the operational cost error made by representative periods can be obtained, referred to as the operational estimation error. The actual objective difference between the estimated investment decision and the optimal investment decision found by the full-space expansion planning model can also be evaluated, denoted as the optimality gap. It is found that the optimality gap is bounded by the difference in the operational estimation error of representative periods for the power system with the two investment decisions. As the operations of the power system with the estimated and optimal investment decisions are better estimated, the simplified model can provide a closer investment decision.
Subsequently, looking into the operational estimation error, the performance of representative periods in estimating the full-space operational cost is highly unevenly distributed among the full-space time-series. Representative periods fail to accurately estimate a minor portion of the full-space time-series, causing extremely high operational estimation errors that contribute to the majority of the total operational estimation error. This uneven distribution remains as the number of representative periods increases, indicating that standalone TSA methods are not capable of capturing the extreme conditions of the specific power system operation.
Therefore, to improve the time-series aggregation in terms of its ability to better estimate the operation of the power system, bad-performing representative periods and original periods with high operational estimation error can be identified and prioritized, forming a feedback enhancement loop. Case studies show that the feedback enhancement with re-clustering on the bad-performing representative periods improves the optimality gap by more than 50% compared with the standard mean-based clustering method.
To overcome these limitations, this report evaluates the material requirements of hundreds of radically different energy configurations that would allow Europe to become energy self-sufficient and carbon- neutral by 2050. The solutions were generated with the Euro-Calliope framework using an extension of the modeling-to-generate-alternatives approach, creating spatially explicit practically optimal results (SPORES). This approach broadens the solution space and explores energy configurations that are within 10% of the cost-optimal solution.
The results reveal that future energy configurations will be inherently material-intensive, primarily due to the large-scale deployment of power technologies and electric vehicles. In contrast, technologies such as infrastructure expansion and heating systems pose minimal challenges regarding resource consumption. The findings confirm that equally feasible energy system designs can have significantly different CRM demands, with some configurations more likely to face supply-chain bottlenecks for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Trade-offs emerge between specific CRMs and energy system options. For example, high electrification of the transport sector requires nearly double the amount of CRMs compared to configurations with greater biofuel utilization. However, reducing the number of EVs significantly limits flexibility in energy configurations, pushing Europe toward an energy system design that maximizes biofuel.
Nevertheless, this research identifies key strategies that may help mitigate CRM demand in electric vehicles. In the next 15 to 20 years, recycling could become a significant alternative to mining for meeting a substantial share of raw material needs. This report estimates that end-of-life battery recycling rates could decrease the need for newly mined materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel by more than half. However, in the short-term, the availability of these minerals will be insufficient for recycling to become a practical solution. Furthermore, technical and economic barriers currently limit the potential of recycling and the complete shift to battery technologies that do not rely on critical raw materials. This provides actionable guidance for integrating circular economy efforts into energy policy.
Future research would benefit from adopting a more dynamic approach to better capture future material requirements. This can be done by incorporating potential improvements in material intensities, a wider range of sub-technologies, and their evolving market shares. Furthermore, exploring alternative energy configurations and examining how changes in constraints, such as self-sufficiency or moving further away from the cost-optimal solution, affect system design and material demand would be beneficial. Finally, material constraints could be included directly in energy models by limiting CRM demand, which would allow the assessment of feasible energy configurations. ...
To overcome these limitations, this report evaluates the material requirements of hundreds of radically different energy configurations that would allow Europe to become energy self-sufficient and carbon- neutral by 2050. The solutions were generated with the Euro-Calliope framework using an extension of the modeling-to-generate-alternatives approach, creating spatially explicit practically optimal results (SPORES). This approach broadens the solution space and explores energy configurations that are within 10% of the cost-optimal solution.
The results reveal that future energy configurations will be inherently material-intensive, primarily due to the large-scale deployment of power technologies and electric vehicles. In contrast, technologies such as infrastructure expansion and heating systems pose minimal challenges regarding resource consumption. The findings confirm that equally feasible energy system designs can have significantly different CRM demands, with some configurations more likely to face supply-chain bottlenecks for materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel. Trade-offs emerge between specific CRMs and energy system options. For example, high electrification of the transport sector requires nearly double the amount of CRMs compared to configurations with greater biofuel utilization. However, reducing the number of EVs significantly limits flexibility in energy configurations, pushing Europe toward an energy system design that maximizes biofuel.
Nevertheless, this research identifies key strategies that may help mitigate CRM demand in electric vehicles. In the next 15 to 20 years, recycling could become a significant alternative to mining for meeting a substantial share of raw material needs. This report estimates that end-of-life battery recycling rates could decrease the need for newly mined materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel by more than half. However, in the short-term, the availability of these minerals will be insufficient for recycling to become a practical solution. Furthermore, technical and economic barriers currently limit the potential of recycling and the complete shift to battery technologies that do not rely on critical raw materials. This provides actionable guidance for integrating circular economy efforts into energy policy.
Future research would benefit from adopting a more dynamic approach to better capture future material requirements. This can be done by incorporating potential improvements in material intensities, a wider range of sub-technologies, and their evolving market shares. Furthermore, exploring alternative energy configurations and examining how changes in constraints, such as self-sufficiency or moving further away from the cost-optimal solution, affect system design and material demand would be beneficial. Finally, material constraints could be included directly in energy models by limiting CRM demand, which would allow the assessment of feasible energy configurations.
Exploring the value of load-shifting for cost-optimal power grids
A research case for the Dutch power grid in 2035 through analysis of possible scenarios
While Energy System Optimisation Models (ESOMs) enable robust system planning, they often oversimplify or neglect Demand Response, particularly load-shifting capabilities. This thesis validates modeling frameworks for load-shifting and proposes a novel framework for modeling aggregated load-shifting in large-scale ESOMs. This approach accurately accounts for load-shifting characteristics without requiring extensive process-specific constraints.
Case study results for the Netherlands demonstrate that load-shifting provides significant value in a fossil-free power grid by adding flexibility and reducing overall system costs, particularly in battery energy storage investments. However, controllable flexibility assets remain crucial for peak demand management and facilitating renewable energy integration. Furthermore, power grid configurations incorporating Demand Response showed greater robustness against weather and demand variations, suggesting that networks utilizing implicit flexibility are more economical and risk-averse than those relying solely on explicit flexibility solutions. ...
While Energy System Optimisation Models (ESOMs) enable robust system planning, they often oversimplify or neglect Demand Response, particularly load-shifting capabilities. This thesis validates modeling frameworks for load-shifting and proposes a novel framework for modeling aggregated load-shifting in large-scale ESOMs. This approach accurately accounts for load-shifting characteristics without requiring extensive process-specific constraints.
Case study results for the Netherlands demonstrate that load-shifting provides significant value in a fossil-free power grid by adding flexibility and reducing overall system costs, particularly in battery energy storage investments. However, controllable flexibility assets remain crucial for peak demand management and facilitating renewable energy integration. Furthermore, power grid configurations incorporating Demand Response showed greater robustness against weather and demand variations, suggesting that networks utilizing implicit flexibility are more economical and risk-averse than those relying solely on explicit flexibility solutions.
Grid reinforcement can not happen instantly and requires a considerable investment while currently not enough skilled labourers are available. Together with this labour shortage and time delay, a large cost is associated with this action. Another factor is the eventual over generation from distributed energy resources (DER’s) reducing power grid stability. All these considerations provide the basis for research into the possibilities of LV PV curtailment. There is a significant amount of research on the effects of curtailment, however this research mainly focuses on the LV effects or looks at not technically feasible curtailment options.
The current overloaded grid can be solved by different ways of curtailing LV PV alongside medium voltage (MV) and high voltage (HV) curtailment. Different options result in more curtailed energy correlated with lower grid loading or less curtailed energy but more residual network loading. The current German-implemented method sets a power limit of 70% of the installed power for small PV systems and requires a gradual curtailment possibility for larger systems. This approach has proven to provide a good trade-off between loading reduction and generation losses for now. Other curtailment may be more effective in the future. Therefore the research question of this thesis is How will LV connected PV curtailment affect the loading of the MV and HV network?.
In order to determine the impact of different curtailment methods a simulation based approach was chosen. Further on in this thesis the generation of power consumption and generation data will be discussed, as well as the implemented and explored curtailment methods. The selected networks are based on the amount of LV PV present together with the network capacity relative to the total amount of installed PV generation.
At the moment MV to LV transformers are the main bottleneck, which can only be solved by installing larger transformers or curtailing LV connections. When analysing all other assets an optimisation approach reduces grid loading the most, however this is far from necessary. In order to keep MV cable loading and HV to MV transformer loading within limits any form of curtailment is functional, even curtailment methods which do not impact LV connections.
The main takeaways from this thesis are that curtailment will become necessary in the coming years. Combined with the fact that LV curtailment has to be implemented within 10 years in order to avoid overloading the MV to LV transformers.
All in all a system wide approach is preferred, as this reduces loading with minimal energy curtailment. This can be achieved with an optimisation approach or propagating rules associated to the maximally loaded asset. Considerations, which should be explored further, are the financial impact, social impact of curtailment and complexity of the system. As these impact customers both directly and indirectly. ...
Grid reinforcement can not happen instantly and requires a considerable investment while currently not enough skilled labourers are available. Together with this labour shortage and time delay, a large cost is associated with this action. Another factor is the eventual over generation from distributed energy resources (DER’s) reducing power grid stability. All these considerations provide the basis for research into the possibilities of LV PV curtailment. There is a significant amount of research on the effects of curtailment, however this research mainly focuses on the LV effects or looks at not technically feasible curtailment options.
The current overloaded grid can be solved by different ways of curtailing LV PV alongside medium voltage (MV) and high voltage (HV) curtailment. Different options result in more curtailed energy correlated with lower grid loading or less curtailed energy but more residual network loading. The current German-implemented method sets a power limit of 70% of the installed power for small PV systems and requires a gradual curtailment possibility for larger systems. This approach has proven to provide a good trade-off between loading reduction and generation losses for now. Other curtailment may be more effective in the future. Therefore the research question of this thesis is How will LV connected PV curtailment affect the loading of the MV and HV network?.
In order to determine the impact of different curtailment methods a simulation based approach was chosen. Further on in this thesis the generation of power consumption and generation data will be discussed, as well as the implemented and explored curtailment methods. The selected networks are based on the amount of LV PV present together with the network capacity relative to the total amount of installed PV generation.
At the moment MV to LV transformers are the main bottleneck, which can only be solved by installing larger transformers or curtailing LV connections. When analysing all other assets an optimisation approach reduces grid loading the most, however this is far from necessary. In order to keep MV cable loading and HV to MV transformer loading within limits any form of curtailment is functional, even curtailment methods which do not impact LV connections.
The main takeaways from this thesis are that curtailment will become necessary in the coming years. Combined with the fact that LV curtailment has to be implemented within 10 years in order to avoid overloading the MV to LV transformers.
All in all a system wide approach is preferred, as this reduces loading with minimal energy curtailment. This can be achieved with an optimisation approach or propagating rules associated to the maximally loaded asset. Considerations, which should be explored further, are the financial impact, social impact of curtailment and complexity of the system. As these impact customers both directly and indirectly.
This research aimed to find the main system-level trade-offs involved with integrating AWE and floating wind turbines in a highly-renewable future energy system. To do so, a modelling workflow was developed that consists of future costs and performance estimation, wind resource assessment and integration into a high-resolution large-scale energy system cost-optimization model, based on the Calliope modelling framework. The investigated region contains 10 countries in the North Sea region. The wind resource and system balancing are hourly-resolved. Key findings include:
Onshore AWE significantly outperforms onshore wind turbines due to higher wind resource availability.
The main limiting factor in large-scale onshore AWE deployment is the spatial energy density.
Offshore AWE shows highly identical performance compared to offshore wind alternatives.
Deployment of offshore AWE is mainly cost driven.
Floating wind turbines demonstrate great potential because of the high capacity factors that can be achieved in high wind resource areas where conventional offshore wind is not technically feasible.
Offshore wind potential in general strongly depends on available onshore technical potential.
The outcomes show significant potential for both emerging technologies that could be realized in the near future. This study provides first exploratory findings that lay the foundation for future studies in the context of this research topic. Multiple directions for follow-up research have been identified to quantify this potential in more detail. ...
This research aimed to find the main system-level trade-offs involved with integrating AWE and floating wind turbines in a highly-renewable future energy system. To do so, a modelling workflow was developed that consists of future costs and performance estimation, wind resource assessment and integration into a high-resolution large-scale energy system cost-optimization model, based on the Calliope modelling framework. The investigated region contains 10 countries in the North Sea region. The wind resource and system balancing are hourly-resolved. Key findings include:
Onshore AWE significantly outperforms onshore wind turbines due to higher wind resource availability.
The main limiting factor in large-scale onshore AWE deployment is the spatial energy density.
Offshore AWE shows highly identical performance compared to offshore wind alternatives.
Deployment of offshore AWE is mainly cost driven.
Floating wind turbines demonstrate great potential because of the high capacity factors that can be achieved in high wind resource areas where conventional offshore wind is not technically feasible.
Offshore wind potential in general strongly depends on available onshore technical potential.
The outcomes show significant potential for both emerging technologies that could be realized in the near future. This study provides first exploratory findings that lay the foundation for future studies in the context of this research topic. Multiple directions for follow-up research have been identified to quantify this potential in more detail.
Design and Application of MGA Analysis Package
A Python-based clustering package using machine learning algorithms to analyze near optimal energy systems
This thesis aims to design a clustering-based analysis method and Python package (MGA analysis package) based on the designed method to analyze the results of the MGA based optimization model using machine learning algorithms. The package is developed for energy analysts and users of the MGA optimization method to simplify the analysis of results. MGA analysis package clusters the solution space and identifies representative solutions for each cluster. Along with that, it provides a regional equality index to assess the distribution of energy infrastructure. An interactive dashboard is designed to use the MGA analysis package with three to four user inputs and provides information graphically and in text format. The MGA analysis package is hosted on the git-hub (https://edu.nl/gmarp) for applications and further development.
...
This thesis aims to design a clustering-based analysis method and Python package (MGA analysis package) based on the designed method to analyze the results of the MGA based optimization model using machine learning algorithms. The package is developed for energy analysts and users of the MGA optimization method to simplify the analysis of results. MGA analysis package clusters the solution space and identifies representative solutions for each cluster. Along with that, it provides a regional equality index to assess the distribution of energy infrastructure. An interactive dashboard is designed to use the MGA analysis package with three to four user inputs and provides information graphically and in text format. The MGA analysis package is hosted on the git-hub (https://edu.nl/gmarp) for applications and further development.
The main case study uses 27 input scenarios with varying outcomes for grid electricity price, solar yield and energy consumption to provide insight in a 100 household neighbourhood energy system with heating, cooling, electricity and hydrogen as energy carriers. With 1377 (near-)optimal solutions, a novel approach in analysis and post processing is used to provide 52 useful configuration options that each have their strengths and weaknesses to different political, economical, social and technical drivers. These configurations are tested for cost, security of supply, CO2 emissions and grid dependency. Those results are visualised through ridge plots and statistical tables to provide a clear overview between each configuration’s trade-offs. An example is included to show how those results can be used for improving energy system design in practice.
This thesis shows that two methods can successfully be combined into one universal one, while providing valuable design insights for energy systems under uncertainty. Furthermore, this method can be applied to a wide variety of energy systems, as long as its possible components, their technical aspects and their allowed interactions are known beforehand. As many future energy system aspects are uncertain, it should be seen as a vital tool to help speed up the decarbonization. ...
The main case study uses 27 input scenarios with varying outcomes for grid electricity price, solar yield and energy consumption to provide insight in a 100 household neighbourhood energy system with heating, cooling, electricity and hydrogen as energy carriers. With 1377 (near-)optimal solutions, a novel approach in analysis and post processing is used to provide 52 useful configuration options that each have their strengths and weaknesses to different political, economical, social and technical drivers. These configurations are tested for cost, security of supply, CO2 emissions and grid dependency. Those results are visualised through ridge plots and statistical tables to provide a clear overview between each configuration’s trade-offs. An example is included to show how those results can be used for improving energy system design in practice.
This thesis shows that two methods can successfully be combined into one universal one, while providing valuable design insights for energy systems under uncertainty. Furthermore, this method can be applied to a wide variety of energy systems, as long as its possible components, their technical aspects and their allowed interactions are known beforehand. As many future energy system aspects are uncertain, it should be seen as a vital tool to help speed up the decarbonization.