E.M. van Bueren
Please Note
28 records found
1
Integrating flood risk in real estate management strategies
Real Estate Management in owner-occupied corporate and public contexts
To answer the research question, this research follows a multimethod approach, qualitative and exploratory. This study combines desk research, empirical research, and a synthesis. The desk research, a literature study, focuses on exploring different concepts and their interrelationships. Concepts covered include (corporate) real estate management, risk management, flood risks, flood risk assessment, asset management, and business operational management. Its purpose is to identify flood risks in the real estate sector and examine their impact on real estate management, both strategically and operationally, at the asset and operational level. The empirical research includes exploratory interviews, three case studies, in-depth interviews, and a cross case analysis. The purpose is to gain empirical insight into how flood risk is managed in REM and create practical knowledge to integrate flood risks into real estate management strategies. In the synthesis, the knowledge gathered in the desk research and the empirical research is combined.
This research aims to gain knowledge about the impact of flooding on real estate, integrating flood risks in REM, and to explore how owner-occupiers of real estate can start integrating flood risks into REM strategies. The practical deliverable following the academic insights delivered in this thesis is a theoretically informed roadmap that can be used to guide the integration of flood risk into real estate management strategies for owner-occupiers of corporate and public organisations. ...
To answer the research question, this research follows a multimethod approach, qualitative and exploratory. This study combines desk research, empirical research, and a synthesis. The desk research, a literature study, focuses on exploring different concepts and their interrelationships. Concepts covered include (corporate) real estate management, risk management, flood risks, flood risk assessment, asset management, and business operational management. Its purpose is to identify flood risks in the real estate sector and examine their impact on real estate management, both strategically and operationally, at the asset and operational level. The empirical research includes exploratory interviews, three case studies, in-depth interviews, and a cross case analysis. The purpose is to gain empirical insight into how flood risk is managed in REM and create practical knowledge to integrate flood risks into real estate management strategies. In the synthesis, the knowledge gathered in the desk research and the empirical research is combined.
This research aims to gain knowledge about the impact of flooding on real estate, integrating flood risks in REM, and to explore how owner-occupiers of real estate can start integrating flood risks into REM strategies. The practical deliverable following the academic insights delivered in this thesis is a theoretically informed roadmap that can be used to guide the integration of flood risk into real estate management strategies for owner-occupiers of corporate and public organisations.
Designing for a Flow
Co-creative Approach to Adaptable and Resilient Housing
...
Cultivating Change
Investigating Landscape Transformation in Shared Residential Gardens
Grounded in long-term, on-site research, the dissertation approaches shared residential gardens as residential commons: spaces shaped by design intentions, everyday use, care, and collective governance. Adopting an ethnographic perspective within landscape architecture, it attends to small-scale transformations, incremental adjustments, and moments of negotiation through which gardens are continuously reinterpreted and reshaped by human and non-human actors alike.
Using landscape transformation as an analytical lens, the research examines how spatial composition, social-ecological practices, and governance arrangements interact over time. Shared gardens are treated as landscape laboratories in which patterns of change can be observed, traced, and reflected upon, revealing how design and governance co-evolve in practice. The study is based on fourteen shared gardens in the EVA-Lanxmeer neighbourhood in Culemborg, the Netherlands, and is complemented by two comparative cases: De Kersentuin in Leidsche Rijn, Utrecht, and Vrijburcht on Steigereiland, Amsterdam, totalling twenty-three shared gardens.
The findings show that the long-term quality of shared residential gardens depends less on fixed design solutions than on the capacity of spatial frameworks and collectively negotiated rules to accommodate change. Rather than treating design and governance as separate domains, this book understands them as interrelated and reflective practices that continually inform and reshape one another. In doing so, it positions landscape architecture as a time-based and relational discipline, offering insights for researchers and practitioners engaged with collective spaces and everyday landscapes. ...
Grounded in long-term, on-site research, the dissertation approaches shared residential gardens as residential commons: spaces shaped by design intentions, everyday use, care, and collective governance. Adopting an ethnographic perspective within landscape architecture, it attends to small-scale transformations, incremental adjustments, and moments of negotiation through which gardens are continuously reinterpreted and reshaped by human and non-human actors alike.
Using landscape transformation as an analytical lens, the research examines how spatial composition, social-ecological practices, and governance arrangements interact over time. Shared gardens are treated as landscape laboratories in which patterns of change can be observed, traced, and reflected upon, revealing how design and governance co-evolve in practice. The study is based on fourteen shared gardens in the EVA-Lanxmeer neighbourhood in Culemborg, the Netherlands, and is complemented by two comparative cases: De Kersentuin in Leidsche Rijn, Utrecht, and Vrijburcht on Steigereiland, Amsterdam, totalling twenty-three shared gardens.
The findings show that the long-term quality of shared residential gardens depends less on fixed design solutions than on the capacity of spatial frameworks and collectively negotiated rules to accommodate change. Rather than treating design and governance as separate domains, this book understands them as interrelated and reflective practices that continually inform and reshape one another. In doing so, it positions landscape architecture as a time-based and relational discipline, offering insights for researchers and practitioners engaged with collective spaces and everyday landscapes.
Exploring Pilot Potential
Rethinking Amsterdam's Municipal Engagement in Collaborative Governance
Municipalities are expected to take an important role in pilot projects, connecting experimental initiatives to long-term strategies and public responsibilities. This role is demanding, as municipalities are large organisations with many tasks and internal layers. Coordinating across departments while working with external partners makes pilots an important but also challenging instrument. Research often describes how collaboration between public, private, civic and academic actors takes shape. Less is known about how the public actor navigates these collaborations and how their position influences the way pilots function.
This thesis explores that through the Horizon 2020 project ATELIER in Amsterdam, which develops Positive Energy Districts in collaboration between public, private, academic and civic actors. The study investigates how coordination was organised and how the municipality engaged with and recognised the knowledge produced during the project.
The research is based on a qualitative single-case study design. It combines three sources of data: project documents, semi-structured interviews with municipal officials and consortium partners, and observations during an internship at the Municipality of Amsterdam. This combination made it possible to do a qualitative analysis of how coordination and learning were experienced in practice. The analysis draws on 2 main theories. The first is the collaboration dynamics from the Collaborative Governance Regime framework from Emerson et al. (2012), which looks at how collaboration is sustained through engagement, trust and joint capacity, and the second is absorptive capacity’s first step on how organisations recognise and take up external knowledge. Together, these concepts were used to examine both the organisation of coordination and the conditions for municipal learning.
The results show that Amsterdam’s role in ATELIER lacked clear institutional anchoring. Responsibilities were unclear, leadership improvised, and coordination often relied on informal arrangements and motivated individuals. Engagement was inconsistent, staff turnover disrupted continuity, and mechanisms for transferring knowledge across departments were absent. As a result, lessons on collaboration and governance risk staying within the consortium and can’t easily reach the performances of municipality of Amsterdam.
The thesis concludes that municipal readiness is a decisive condition for effective participation in pilots. Clear purpose, defined responsibilities, and internal structures are necessary for municipalities to translate pilot lessons into practice. The study exposes the fragility of pilot scalability and provides a checklist of organisational conditions that can strengthen the role of public actors in future collaborative projects. The theoretical contribution is that, while current frameworks mainly emphasise relational factors of collaboration, this research shows the need to also account for the readiness of public actors. ...
Municipalities are expected to take an important role in pilot projects, connecting experimental initiatives to long-term strategies and public responsibilities. This role is demanding, as municipalities are large organisations with many tasks and internal layers. Coordinating across departments while working with external partners makes pilots an important but also challenging instrument. Research often describes how collaboration between public, private, civic and academic actors takes shape. Less is known about how the public actor navigates these collaborations and how their position influences the way pilots function.
This thesis explores that through the Horizon 2020 project ATELIER in Amsterdam, which develops Positive Energy Districts in collaboration between public, private, academic and civic actors. The study investigates how coordination was organised and how the municipality engaged with and recognised the knowledge produced during the project.
The research is based on a qualitative single-case study design. It combines three sources of data: project documents, semi-structured interviews with municipal officials and consortium partners, and observations during an internship at the Municipality of Amsterdam. This combination made it possible to do a qualitative analysis of how coordination and learning were experienced in practice. The analysis draws on 2 main theories. The first is the collaboration dynamics from the Collaborative Governance Regime framework from Emerson et al. (2012), which looks at how collaboration is sustained through engagement, trust and joint capacity, and the second is absorptive capacity’s first step on how organisations recognise and take up external knowledge. Together, these concepts were used to examine both the organisation of coordination and the conditions for municipal learning.
The results show that Amsterdam’s role in ATELIER lacked clear institutional anchoring. Responsibilities were unclear, leadership improvised, and coordination often relied on informal arrangements and motivated individuals. Engagement was inconsistent, staff turnover disrupted continuity, and mechanisms for transferring knowledge across departments were absent. As a result, lessons on collaboration and governance risk staying within the consortium and can’t easily reach the performances of municipality of Amsterdam.
The thesis concludes that municipal readiness is a decisive condition for effective participation in pilots. Clear purpose, defined responsibilities, and internal structures are necessary for municipalities to translate pilot lessons into practice. The study exposes the fragility of pilot scalability and provides a checklist of organisational conditions that can strengthen the role of public actors in future collaborative projects. The theoretical contribution is that, while current frameworks mainly emphasise relational factors of collaboration, this research shows the need to also account for the readiness of public actors.
The challenge of collaboration in urban design
Co-designing resilient public spaces in Chile
Sustainability transitions in urban basic infrastructure services
Organising principles from Southern cities
Reconfiguration of Practices towards a Circular Economy in the Architecture, Engineering, and Construction sector
Change throughout a Persistent System
emissions and resource consumption. In response, the Netherlands aims to make the sector 50% circular by 2030 and fully circular by 2050. However, the transition from a linear to a circular economy is complex due to technical, organisational, and cultural barriers. This dissertation explores how interorganisational behaviour and routinised practices within and beyond construction projects influence the realisation of circular ambitions. This research highlights the importance of top-down support, equal partnerships, shared goals, and intrinsically motivated individuals in construction projects. Trust, transparency, flexibility, and a shared team identity further foster the redefinition of traditional roles so as to drive innovation. However, factors such as focus on short-term cost and risk aversion often hinder progress. The dissertation further combines Sustainability Transitions Research (STR) and Social Practice Theory (SPT) into crossover frameworks that capture both systemic change and everyday practices. These are used to analyse (mis)alignments in the system-of-practices around construction projects. It was found that using secondary materials often clashes with notions of quality, safety, and aesthetics. Increasingly, Circular Building Hubs (CBHs) are brought forward as answer to this problem. This research shows that these hubs can be accelerators in the transition, though they are seen as temporary rather than permanent solutions. Ultimately, no single intervention will enable the shift to circularity. Instead, multiple coordinated changes in practices are needed. This dissertation provides tools for researchers and practitioners to navigate this complexity and encourages learning, experimentation, and a systemic approach to support sector-wide transitioning. ...
emissions and resource consumption. In response, the Netherlands aims to make the sector 50% circular by 2030 and fully circular by 2050. However, the transition from a linear to a circular economy is complex due to technical, organisational, and cultural barriers. This dissertation explores how interorganisational behaviour and routinised practices within and beyond construction projects influence the realisation of circular ambitions. This research highlights the importance of top-down support, equal partnerships, shared goals, and intrinsically motivated individuals in construction projects. Trust, transparency, flexibility, and a shared team identity further foster the redefinition of traditional roles so as to drive innovation. However, factors such as focus on short-term cost and risk aversion often hinder progress. The dissertation further combines Sustainability Transitions Research (STR) and Social Practice Theory (SPT) into crossover frameworks that capture both systemic change and everyday practices. These are used to analyse (mis)alignments in the system-of-practices around construction projects. It was found that using secondary materials often clashes with notions of quality, safety, and aesthetics. Increasingly, Circular Building Hubs (CBHs) are brought forward as answer to this problem. This research shows that these hubs can be accelerators in the transition, though they are seen as temporary rather than permanent solutions. Ultimately, no single intervention will enable the shift to circularity. Instead, multiple coordinated changes in practices are needed. This dissertation provides tools for researchers and practitioners to navigate this complexity and encourages learning, experimentation, and a systemic approach to support sector-wide transitioning.
Improving policy coherence for circular cities
Evaluating circular built environment policies of London and Amsterdam
The concept of a circular city is inspired by biological metabolic systems and aims to implement circular economy principles in various aspects of urban functioning, i.e. to minimise the consumption of primary resources and energy, thereby reducing environmental impacts such as waste and emissions. This approach involves redefining urban processes to close, narrow and slow down material and energy flows.
The built environment is included as an area of intervention in most European circular city policies following it is a major resource consumer and polluter through construction and demolition. These policies generally promote a circular built environment by replacing primary raw materials with at least secondary ones, standardising circular practices in design, construction and deconstruction, creating markets for secondary resources and sharing knowledge to integrate circular practices into construction value chains.
However, there are two issues that make the evaluation of circular city policies, and those specific to the built environment, difficult. On the one hand, there is the issue of process: most circular city policies have been in place for less than a decade, and the scale of the built environment makes any policy aimed at changing it a long-term one, making ex-post evaluation impractical today. On the other hand, there is the issue of content: the lack of clear and commonly used conceptualisations of circular cities hampers policy (evaluation) frameworks. Therefore, the aim of this dissertation is to explore the extent to which circular built environment policies contribute to the policy ambitions formulated by cities. This leads to the main research question:
To what extent do circular built environment policies contribute to policy ambitions as formulated by cities?
To answer this research question this dissertation is structured as five independent, but related academic studies.
The first study explores the recent conceptualisation of circular cities as found in the academic literature. It introduces the concept of circular economy and the application of circularity at different levels of the built environment. It then provides a historical narrative from the study of urban metabolism as the dominant analytical lens to the more recently developed understanding of a circular city. Existing perspectives and conceptualisations of the circular city as well as current bibliometric trends are presented.
The second study presents the relationship between a circular built environment and the policy instruments for its implementation as discussed in the academic literature. This is done through a systematic literature review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. It analyses over 140 articles in terms of circular urban development policies (i.e. circularity, ecological regeneration and adaptation) and policy instruments (i.e. regulatory, economic and information).
The third study proposes the ex-ante circular city policy coherence framework. The framework, resulting from the combination of two existing frameworks for policy coherence analysis and circular city development, is tested using the case study of the Delft University of Technology campus development as an urban development proxy.
Based on document analysis of spatial development and circular economy policies, the fourth study uses the ex-ante circular city policy coherence framework to evaluate the policy coherence - or (mis)alignment and potential synergies - of circular built environment policies in Greater London. The Greater London Authority (GLA) presents an interesting case for examining policy coherence of circular built environment policies due to its authority, governance structure, scale and the notable gap in governance research that has not been fully explored.
The fifth and last study examines an ex-ante policy evaluation of timber construction in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, given its decade-long circular city policy and recent ambitions for mass timber construction. This is done in two steps. Firstly, policy instruments from different policy documents in Amsterdam were identified and analysed in terms of how they aim to contribute to a more circular built environment. Secondly, an agent-based model was built as a tool for policy makers to simulate the emergent interactions and outcomes of selected policy instruments in increasing timber construction in Amsterdam.
Conclusions and implications
This dissertation concludes that the current understanding of a circular built environment does not see the city for the buildings. By advancing a perspective on circularity in the built environment based on the concept of circular cities, this dissertation proposes that while circular built environment policies have improved their overall coherence, particularly through business-led optimisations in construction practices, they fall short of fully realising a circular city as envisioned by the circular city policy coherence framework. The circular built environment policies of London and Amsterdam are increasingly designed to mitigate issues such as resource depletion and waste generation. However, their policies largely overlook a broader, more systemic approach, particularly in terms of assessing the need for new buildings, maintaining and adapting the existing building stock, and involving residents and communities in the development of a circular city.
The main contribution of this dissertation is to problematise circular built environment policies in relation to circular cities, with a pioneering evaluation of such policies in London and Amsterdam. It positions the built environment as a key component of circular cities, highlighting the influence of policy decisions on the design of the built environment. The work includes the first systematic literature review of policy instruments for circular built environments, identifying a technocratic trend and a focus on looping measures. It also presents an ex-ante policy evaluation framework for circular cities, tested in Amsterdam and London, which allows the assessment of policy coherence and potential impacts, complemented by an agent-based model to visualise interactions and emergent properties between policy instruments.
The circular city policy coherence framework is currently the only one (to the best of the author's knowledge at the time of writing) that not only integrates both process and content aspects within circular city policies, but also allows for the analysis of policy alignment and synergies between different urban policy areas.
Policy makers could use this framework to design more ambitious and well-rounded policies that include all three circularity actions. The policy coherence factors would provide the necessary justification to refine existing policy objectives and instruments or to propose new ones for future implementation, as well as to detect where or how a more systemic perspective of a circular city can improve its policy development.
...
The concept of a circular city is inspired by biological metabolic systems and aims to implement circular economy principles in various aspects of urban functioning, i.e. to minimise the consumption of primary resources and energy, thereby reducing environmental impacts such as waste and emissions. This approach involves redefining urban processes to close, narrow and slow down material and energy flows.
The built environment is included as an area of intervention in most European circular city policies following it is a major resource consumer and polluter through construction and demolition. These policies generally promote a circular built environment by replacing primary raw materials with at least secondary ones, standardising circular practices in design, construction and deconstruction, creating markets for secondary resources and sharing knowledge to integrate circular practices into construction value chains.
However, there are two issues that make the evaluation of circular city policies, and those specific to the built environment, difficult. On the one hand, there is the issue of process: most circular city policies have been in place for less than a decade, and the scale of the built environment makes any policy aimed at changing it a long-term one, making ex-post evaluation impractical today. On the other hand, there is the issue of content: the lack of clear and commonly used conceptualisations of circular cities hampers policy (evaluation) frameworks. Therefore, the aim of this dissertation is to explore the extent to which circular built environment policies contribute to the policy ambitions formulated by cities. This leads to the main research question:
To what extent do circular built environment policies contribute to policy ambitions as formulated by cities?
To answer this research question this dissertation is structured as five independent, but related academic studies.
The first study explores the recent conceptualisation of circular cities as found in the academic literature. It introduces the concept of circular economy and the application of circularity at different levels of the built environment. It then provides a historical narrative from the study of urban metabolism as the dominant analytical lens to the more recently developed understanding of a circular city. Existing perspectives and conceptualisations of the circular city as well as current bibliometric trends are presented.
The second study presents the relationship between a circular built environment and the policy instruments for its implementation as discussed in the academic literature. This is done through a systematic literature review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. It analyses over 140 articles in terms of circular urban development policies (i.e. circularity, ecological regeneration and adaptation) and policy instruments (i.e. regulatory, economic and information).
The third study proposes the ex-ante circular city policy coherence framework. The framework, resulting from the combination of two existing frameworks for policy coherence analysis and circular city development, is tested using the case study of the Delft University of Technology campus development as an urban development proxy.
Based on document analysis of spatial development and circular economy policies, the fourth study uses the ex-ante circular city policy coherence framework to evaluate the policy coherence - or (mis)alignment and potential synergies - of circular built environment policies in Greater London. The Greater London Authority (GLA) presents an interesting case for examining policy coherence of circular built environment policies due to its authority, governance structure, scale and the notable gap in governance research that has not been fully explored.
The fifth and last study examines an ex-ante policy evaluation of timber construction in Amsterdam, the Netherlands, given its decade-long circular city policy and recent ambitions for mass timber construction. This is done in two steps. Firstly, policy instruments from different policy documents in Amsterdam were identified and analysed in terms of how they aim to contribute to a more circular built environment. Secondly, an agent-based model was built as a tool for policy makers to simulate the emergent interactions and outcomes of selected policy instruments in increasing timber construction in Amsterdam.
Conclusions and implications
This dissertation concludes that the current understanding of a circular built environment does not see the city for the buildings. By advancing a perspective on circularity in the built environment based on the concept of circular cities, this dissertation proposes that while circular built environment policies have improved their overall coherence, particularly through business-led optimisations in construction practices, they fall short of fully realising a circular city as envisioned by the circular city policy coherence framework. The circular built environment policies of London and Amsterdam are increasingly designed to mitigate issues such as resource depletion and waste generation. However, their policies largely overlook a broader, more systemic approach, particularly in terms of assessing the need for new buildings, maintaining and adapting the existing building stock, and involving residents and communities in the development of a circular city.
The main contribution of this dissertation is to problematise circular built environment policies in relation to circular cities, with a pioneering evaluation of such policies in London and Amsterdam. It positions the built environment as a key component of circular cities, highlighting the influence of policy decisions on the design of the built environment. The work includes the first systematic literature review of policy instruments for circular built environments, identifying a technocratic trend and a focus on looping measures. It also presents an ex-ante policy evaluation framework for circular cities, tested in Amsterdam and London, which allows the assessment of policy coherence and potential impacts, complemented by an agent-based model to visualise interactions and emergent properties between policy instruments.
The circular city policy coherence framework is currently the only one (to the best of the author's knowledge at the time of writing) that not only integrates both process and content aspects within circular city policies, but also allows for the analysis of policy alignment and synergies between different urban policy areas.
Policy makers could use this framework to design more ambitious and well-rounded policies that include all three circularity actions. The policy coherence factors would provide the necessary justification to refine existing policy objectives and instruments or to propose new ones for future implementation, as well as to detect where or how a more systemic perspective of a circular city can improve its policy development.
Participation activities areoften dominated by individuals who are easy to recruit, vocal, and comfortablein public arenas. As a result, white, older, higher-educated, and male citizenstend to overshadow other citizens, which can lead to a misinterpretation of thetrue community interests. This leaves underrepresented groups – such as ethnicminorities, youth, women, and lower-educated citizens – with a lack of voice orpower. This research examines how public participation processes of projects inthe urban environment in disadvantaged neighbourhoods can be improved to betterrepresent the voices of these vulnerable groups.
The study involved a policydocument analysis and semi-structured interviews with ten experts and thirteencitizens from two disadvantaged neighbourhoods, Feijenoord and Meerwijk.Through this secondary and empirical data, this research found that expertsemploy various strategies in the following areas: accessibility, communication,existing networks, human aspect, location, and rewards. This study alsoformulated a definition of disadvantaged neighbourhoods based on literature andthrough the perspective of the experts. Next, experts formulated multiplechallenges they experienced during participation processes in terms ofengagement, expectations, outside influence, participation design,representation, and understanding the neighbourhood. Lastly, the barriers andmotivators of residents of disadvantaged neighbourhoods to participate arediscussed. The thesis concludes with eleven recommendations for policy andpractice aimed at improving inclusivity and effectiveness in publicparticipation for disadvantaged communities. ...
Participation activities areoften dominated by individuals who are easy to recruit, vocal, and comfortablein public arenas. As a result, white, older, higher-educated, and male citizenstend to overshadow other citizens, which can lead to a misinterpretation of thetrue community interests. This leaves underrepresented groups – such as ethnicminorities, youth, women, and lower-educated citizens – with a lack of voice orpower. This research examines how public participation processes of projects inthe urban environment in disadvantaged neighbourhoods can be improved to betterrepresent the voices of these vulnerable groups.
The study involved a policydocument analysis and semi-structured interviews with ten experts and thirteencitizens from two disadvantaged neighbourhoods, Feijenoord and Meerwijk.Through this secondary and empirical data, this research found that expertsemploy various strategies in the following areas: accessibility, communication,existing networks, human aspect, location, and rewards. This study alsoformulated a definition of disadvantaged neighbourhoods based on literature andthrough the perspective of the experts. Next, experts formulated multiplechallenges they experienced during participation processes in terms ofengagement, expectations, outside influence, participation design,representation, and understanding the neighbourhood. Lastly, the barriers andmotivators of residents of disadvantaged neighbourhoods to participate arediscussed. The thesis concludes with eleven recommendations for policy andpractice aimed at improving inclusivity and effectiveness in publicparticipation for disadvantaged communities.
Educating Uncertainty
How students and teachers deal with uncertainty in transdisciplinary courses on urban sustainability
Until now, little research has informed teachers and students how to deal with uncertainty. The central question in this research is therefore: How can transdisciplinary education be designed so that students learn to deal with uncertainty in sustainability challenges? The purpose of this dissertation is twofold: (1) to further refine the theoretical understanding of uncertainty in transdisciplinary education and learn to deal with it; and (2) to highlight principles for designing education that empowers both students and teachers to navigate uncertainty effectively. The research approach is based on Educational Design Research (EDR), which aims to combine scientific research findings with practical experiences from people involved in education.
The research highlights how learning to deal with uncertainty is an uncomfortable struggle for students and teachers. The conclusion suggests six design principles to help transform this struggle into a well-guided learning experience. These design principles focus on defining transdisciplinary learning objectives, making uncertainty attitudes explicit, and emphasizing personal development and emotional awareness in future sustainability education. ...
Until now, little research has informed teachers and students how to deal with uncertainty. The central question in this research is therefore: How can transdisciplinary education be designed so that students learn to deal with uncertainty in sustainability challenges? The purpose of this dissertation is twofold: (1) to further refine the theoretical understanding of uncertainty in transdisciplinary education and learn to deal with it; and (2) to highlight principles for designing education that empowers both students and teachers to navigate uncertainty effectively. The research approach is based on Educational Design Research (EDR), which aims to combine scientific research findings with practical experiences from people involved in education.
The research highlights how learning to deal with uncertainty is an uncomfortable struggle for students and teachers. The conclusion suggests six design principles to help transform this struggle into a well-guided learning experience. These design principles focus on defining transdisciplinary learning objectives, making uncertainty attitudes explicit, and emphasizing personal development and emotional awareness in future sustainability education.
Revitalizing the urban life
Design a three-dimensional public space system by combining top-down and bottom-up approaches through serious gaming in Mong Kok, Hong Kong, China
A combination of quantitative and qualitative methods was employed throughout this study to answer the primary research question. First, state-of-the-art models for examining the effect of floods were explained through a literature review. Second, a framework was constructed to define flood vulnerability, including socio-economic status, disaster-bearing capabilities, and flood exposure. This enabled the quantification of flood vulnerability levels of neighborhoods in the case study. Third, qualitative methods in the form of a literature review and exploratory semi-structured interviews with stakeholders were utilized to understand their barriers, drivers, and enablers and the ensuing opportunities to contribute to maintaining the stability of real estate values.
The results indicated that the definition and usage of the parameters are vital to assess the effects of flood risks on residential real estate values. In addition, the results showed significant effects on flood vulnerability when including a subset of indicators besides flood exposure. When constructing a more accessible tool for all stakeholders, employing a more integral definition of flood vulnerability may thus be more socially just. Stakeholders may contribute to the stability of real estate values by actively adapting and incentivizing each other to similar behavior.
In addition, organized irresponsibility (i.e., stakeholders contributing to an issue without wanting to take responsibility for the caused risks) and pillarization appear to be embedded within the system in the Netherlands. Through cooperation, division of responsibilities, and taking ownership, devaluation risks may be diminished and the phenomenon of organized irresponsibility reduced. Moreover, by prolonged engagement of initiating stakeholders, a shift from short-term profit to long-term real estate values may be stimulated, potentially contributing to the prevention of enlarged social injustice due to flood risks. Within the shift towards organized responsibility, this research hints towards a vital role for both the government and insurers. ...
A combination of quantitative and qualitative methods was employed throughout this study to answer the primary research question. First, state-of-the-art models for examining the effect of floods were explained through a literature review. Second, a framework was constructed to define flood vulnerability, including socio-economic status, disaster-bearing capabilities, and flood exposure. This enabled the quantification of flood vulnerability levels of neighborhoods in the case study. Third, qualitative methods in the form of a literature review and exploratory semi-structured interviews with stakeholders were utilized to understand their barriers, drivers, and enablers and the ensuing opportunities to contribute to maintaining the stability of real estate values.
The results indicated that the definition and usage of the parameters are vital to assess the effects of flood risks on residential real estate values. In addition, the results showed significant effects on flood vulnerability when including a subset of indicators besides flood exposure. When constructing a more accessible tool for all stakeholders, employing a more integral definition of flood vulnerability may thus be more socially just. Stakeholders may contribute to the stability of real estate values by actively adapting and incentivizing each other to similar behavior.
In addition, organized irresponsibility (i.e., stakeholders contributing to an issue without wanting to take responsibility for the caused risks) and pillarization appear to be embedded within the system in the Netherlands. Through cooperation, division of responsibilities, and taking ownership, devaluation risks may be diminished and the phenomenon of organized irresponsibility reduced. Moreover, by prolonged engagement of initiating stakeholders, a shift from short-term profit to long-term real estate values may be stimulated, potentially contributing to the prevention of enlarged social injustice due to flood risks. Within the shift towards organized responsibility, this research hints towards a vital role for both the government and insurers.
For evaluation methods, multi-criteria analysis (MCA) emerged as a suitable tool for decision-making in unembanked area development, considering social values and intangible criteria. Combining MCA with cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) or a form of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) proved effective in balancing quantitative and qualitative criteria, facilitating inclusive decision-making. The research emphasizes the extensive involvement of various stakeholders and identifies barriers related to legal aspects, risk awareness, and communication. Stakeholders call for well-defined guidelines, legal regulations, and collaboration between private and public entities. The study recommends establishing principles for unembanked area development and translating them into MCA criteria, addressing both social values and local characteristics. Further research is suggested to address legal assurance for climate-adaptive construction, increase awareness, enhance flood risk assessment methods and communication, and strengthen collaboration between private and public stakeholders in flood risk management and spatial planning. ...
For evaluation methods, multi-criteria analysis (MCA) emerged as a suitable tool for decision-making in unembanked area development, considering social values and intangible criteria. Combining MCA with cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) or a form of cost-benefit analysis (CBA) proved effective in balancing quantitative and qualitative criteria, facilitating inclusive decision-making. The research emphasizes the extensive involvement of various stakeholders and identifies barriers related to legal aspects, risk awareness, and communication. Stakeholders call for well-defined guidelines, legal regulations, and collaboration between private and public entities. The study recommends establishing principles for unembanked area development and translating them into MCA criteria, addressing both social values and local characteristics. Further research is suggested to address legal assurance for climate-adaptive construction, increase awareness, enhance flood risk assessment methods and communication, and strengthen collaboration between private and public stakeholders in flood risk management and spatial planning.
Climate Adaptation in the Built Environment
A hollistic approach to barriers in the climate adaptation process
Despite having numerous documents at all levels of government, the Netherlands struggles with the slow implementation of climate adaptation strategies. As a result of the “Maatlat groene klimaatadaptieve gebouwde omgeving” and the National Adaptation Strategy (NAS) falling short of expectations, the national government must take more proactive measures and engage in long-term planning. The country is still in the understanding and planning stages, with little implementation. Effective climate adaptation depends on including multiple stakeholders throughout the process, as well as on government involvement.
The identified barriers to effective climate adaptation implementation include insufficient signal detection, limited interest and focus, knowledge gaps, and feasibility thresholds. Challenges also arise in developing and agreeing on viable options that align with established goals, inadequate resources, and legal and procedural obstacles inherent in non-binding climate adaptation policies. However, the study highlights enablers tied to some barriers, such as the motivating effects of climate change, dedicated policy employees driving interest, and cost competitiveness of certain measures compared to non-adaptive alternatives.
Building on these insights, the thesis provides a practical roadmap, addressing the central question: “How can climate adaptation policies be implemented in the Netherlands?” This roadmap serves as a valuable guide for municipalities, offering a systematic approach that considers stakeholders, contextual factors, and potential barriers. Particularly beneficial for collaborative efforts, the roadmap fosters a shared language for knowledge exchange and coordinated policy creation across different government levels. With this tool, municipalities are empowered to efficiently accelerate the implementation of climate adaptation measures in an organized and collaborative manner. ...
Despite having numerous documents at all levels of government, the Netherlands struggles with the slow implementation of climate adaptation strategies. As a result of the “Maatlat groene klimaatadaptieve gebouwde omgeving” and the National Adaptation Strategy (NAS) falling short of expectations, the national government must take more proactive measures and engage in long-term planning. The country is still in the understanding and planning stages, with little implementation. Effective climate adaptation depends on including multiple stakeholders throughout the process, as well as on government involvement.
The identified barriers to effective climate adaptation implementation include insufficient signal detection, limited interest and focus, knowledge gaps, and feasibility thresholds. Challenges also arise in developing and agreeing on viable options that align with established goals, inadequate resources, and legal and procedural obstacles inherent in non-binding climate adaptation policies. However, the study highlights enablers tied to some barriers, such as the motivating effects of climate change, dedicated policy employees driving interest, and cost competitiveness of certain measures compared to non-adaptive alternatives.
Building on these insights, the thesis provides a practical roadmap, addressing the central question: “How can climate adaptation policies be implemented in the Netherlands?” This roadmap serves as a valuable guide for municipalities, offering a systematic approach that considers stakeholders, contextual factors, and potential barriers. Particularly beneficial for collaborative efforts, the roadmap fosters a shared language for knowledge exchange and coordinated policy creation across different government levels. With this tool, municipalities are empowered to efficiently accelerate the implementation of climate adaptation measures in an organized and collaborative manner.
Time for timber
A research on policy instruments for a successful timber transition in the Metropole region of Amsterdam
Using the concept design evaluation matrix, the real estate developer and other relevant stakeholders are encouraged to 1) carefully determine what they consider important for the specific real estate development project, taking into account the site-specific characteristics, prior to the evaluation and decision-making process. 2) By subsequently focusing on these priorities during the location/market investigation and concept design process (for example by focusing on identifying any uncertainties and/or risks related to environmental factors such as noise pollution), the expert panel expects that the developer 3) can better steer the process because the different interests are clear and the developer can better evaluate the results with stakeholders by using the analysis results and ranking scores of the different parameters in negotiations/discussions. The expectation is that the evaluation matrix combined with the use of AI powered generative design tooling will decrease the uncertainty regarding the feasibility of the real estate development project, and will provide the developer with a handle to ultimately achieve an even better real estate development result.
...
Using the concept design evaluation matrix, the real estate developer and other relevant stakeholders are encouraged to 1) carefully determine what they consider important for the specific real estate development project, taking into account the site-specific characteristics, prior to the evaluation and decision-making process. 2) By subsequently focusing on these priorities during the location/market investigation and concept design process (for example by focusing on identifying any uncertainties and/or risks related to environmental factors such as noise pollution), the expert panel expects that the developer 3) can better steer the process because the different interests are clear and the developer can better evaluate the results with stakeholders by using the analysis results and ranking scores of the different parameters in negotiations/discussions. The expectation is that the evaluation matrix combined with the use of AI powered generative design tooling will decrease the uncertainty regarding the feasibility of the real estate development project, and will provide the developer with a handle to ultimately achieve an even better real estate development result.
Regionale gebiedsontwikkeling
De invloed van de provincie op ruimtelijke planning in tussenstedelijke gebieden
In het proefschrift is gezocht naar de invloed van de provincie als regionale gebiedsautoriteit in een omgeving waarin diverse publieke en private partijen samenwerken en maatschappelijke organisaties hun stem laten horen. Het onderzoek is gericht op gebieden tussen grote steden waar een aanmerkelijke verstedelijking, ingebed in groen- en waterstructuren, was voorzien. Plannen en planprocessen zijn geanalyseerd, net als het handelen van de provincie in drie regio’s: de regio Rotterdam-Zoetermeer-Gouda, het gebied tussen Arnhem en Nijmegen en de regio Eindhoven-Helmond.
Het proefschrift laat onder meer zien dat planologische sturing een zwakker instrument is dan financiële sturing. Na de decentralisatie van ruimtelijke ordening en landinrichting is de invloed van de rijksoverheid op regionale gebiedsontwikkeling groot gebleven. Voorts blijkt dat planconcepten in de praktijk flexibel zijn. Als de uitvoering aan de orde komt neemt het risico toe dat het planconcept uit elkaar valt. Het onderzoek toont aan dat de provincie haar rol als regionale gebiedsregisseur actiever zou kunnen invullen. De Omgevingswet zou dat mogelijk moeten maken.
...
In het proefschrift is gezocht naar de invloed van de provincie als regionale gebiedsautoriteit in een omgeving waarin diverse publieke en private partijen samenwerken en maatschappelijke organisaties hun stem laten horen. Het onderzoek is gericht op gebieden tussen grote steden waar een aanmerkelijke verstedelijking, ingebed in groen- en waterstructuren, was voorzien. Plannen en planprocessen zijn geanalyseerd, net als het handelen van de provincie in drie regio’s: de regio Rotterdam-Zoetermeer-Gouda, het gebied tussen Arnhem en Nijmegen en de regio Eindhoven-Helmond.
Het proefschrift laat onder meer zien dat planologische sturing een zwakker instrument is dan financiële sturing. Na de decentralisatie van ruimtelijke ordening en landinrichting is de invloed van de rijksoverheid op regionale gebiedsontwikkeling groot gebleven. Voorts blijkt dat planconcepten in de praktijk flexibel zijn. Als de uitvoering aan de orde komt neemt het risico toe dat het planconcept uit elkaar valt. Het onderzoek toont aan dat de provincie haar rol als regionale gebiedsregisseur actiever zou kunnen invullen. De Omgevingswet zou dat mogelijk moeten maken.
Municipal Circular Land Tenders
How do they affect real estate developers?